Nvidia takes EU antitrust regulators to court for probing AI startup Run:ai bid
BRUSSELS, Feb 24 (Reuters) - U.S. chipmaker Nvidia (NVDA.O), opens new tab has sued EU antitrust regulators for accepting an Italian request last year to scrutinise its acquisition of AI startup Run:ai, saying they had flouted an earlier court ruling restricting their merger powers on minor deals.
While the case does not have any impact on the Run:ai deal which was eventually approved by the EU competition watchdog in December last year, a ruling favouring Nvidia may further curb the regulator's merger power.
Businesses have been concerned in recent years with the European Commission flexing a rarely-used power called Article 22 to assess small deals even though these are below the EU's merger revenue threshold.
The EU executive says it is concerned about killer acquisitions in which big companies buy startups to shut them down, but companies criticise such moves as regulatory over-reach.
Europe's highest court, however, in a landmark ruling in September last year said the Commission cannot encourage or accept referrals of deals without a European dimension from national enforcers when the latter do not have the powers to examine such deals under their own national laws.
Nvidia cited the ruling in its lawsuit filed with the Luxembourg-based General Court, Europe's second-highest, according to a filing on the court website.
"The decision unlawfully accepted a referral request from the Italian Autorità Garante della Concorrenza (AGCM), regarding a transaction that fell below the EU Merger Regulation and member state merger control thresholds, based on the AGCM's exercise of loosely defined, ex post, discretionary call-in powers," Nvidia said.
It said regulators' decision to take up the Italian request breaches principles of institutional balance, legal certainty, proportionality and equal treatment.
The case is T-15/25 Nvidia v Commission.
Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles., opens new tab
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Leader Live
32 minutes ago
- Leader Live
UK ministers confident post-Brexit trade friction will be eased by deal
The movement of trade was one of the main discussions at the first meeting of the East-West Council to take place in Northern Ireland on Thursday, which was also attended by members of Intertrade UK. Earlier this month the UK Government said border checks on fruit and vegetables imported from the EU will be scrapped, to ease trade, ahead of its new sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) deal with the EU. Secretary of State Hilary Benn, Northern Ireland Office minister Fleur Anderson and Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster Pat McFadden held discussions with First Minister Michelle O'Neill and deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly at the Custom House in Belfast on Thursday. Speaking after the meeting, Mr McFadden said the main topics were ensuring smooth trade between Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and the new Connect Fund to support community groups. He said he believed the recent agreement between the UK and EU will 'go a long way' to reducing friction and restoring the free flow of trade. Mr Benn also expressed confidence the flow of trade will be smoothed. 'It comes after a very busy period with the negotiation of the new relationship with the European Union, and one of the issues we discussed was the beneficial impact an SPS deal will have on the flow of the agrifood and plant products from GB to Northern Ireland,' he said. He added: 'The new Government was elected in July, we came in and said we want to build a closer, better relationship with the EU and you saw the result of that in the agreement that was reached at the summit a few weeks ago. 'And for Northern Ireland the single most important part of that agreement was to work together to get an SPS agreement in place because that would deal with a lot of the things that people are having to cope with at the moment in respect of agri food products and plants moving from Great Britain to Northern Ireland. 'I hope that will give businesses real hope for the future, and we want to get on and put that new SPS scheme in place as quickly as possible.' Meanwhile Ms Anderson announced the Connect Fund, which will provide awards from a funding pot of up to £1 million to support groups working in sectors which directly affect Northern Ireland communities. It will be open to groups seeking to strengthening east-west connections, with bids are invited for between £300 and £50,000. Ms Anderson said it will 'support better connections between community groups and individuals of all ages between Northern Ireland and Great Britain'.'I ran a community centre before I was an MP and so I know the value that this funding will bring,' she said. 'I urge local community and voluntary groups in Northern Ireland to apply to take part in this great opportunity, and look forward to the positive changes which this fund will bring to communities in the coming years.'
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Breakingviews - Mediobanca great escape has more twists ahead
LONDON, June 12 (Reuters Breakingviews) - Judging by the Mediobanca ( opens new tab stock price, CEO Alberto Nagel has pulled off an M&A defence coup. His move to snap up a rival wealth group has helped boost the 16-billion-euro Italian bank's shares, taking their price above the level of a hostile offer from Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena ( opens new tab (MPS). Yet Nagel can't sit easy: key votes and his own investors complicate matters. After MPS made an unsolicited offer for Mediobanca in January, the Milan-based group's boss put together an alternative path with a 6-billion-euro plan to buy Banca Generali ( opens new tab, a wealth manager owned by insurer Assicurazioni Generali ( opens new tab. By moving to create a large money-management business, Nagel has boosted his stock. Mediobanca now trades around 9% above the value of the all-share MPS offer. One interpretation is that investors are excited about the prospect of an enlarged wealth player if the Banca Generali deal goes through. One complicating factor, however, is that some of Nagel's biggest shareholders are not yet endorsing the Banca Generali purchase, which requires 50% approval at a June 16 Mediobanca shareholder meeting. Billionaire Francesco Gaetano Caltagirone, who owns 10% of Mediobanca and 5% of MPS, has said that Nagel's deal lacks industrial logic. He has also been buying stock ahead of the meeting, which may partly explain why Mediobanca's shares have risen. Then there's Delfin, which owns nearly 20% of Mediobanca and a tenth of MPS. If that vehicle and Caltagirone oppose the Banca Generali acquisition, Nagel would need a minimum 60% vote turnout and the support of most other shareholders to carry the day. He may feel OK about that risk, since other shareholders have backed the deal. But the next question is whether the insurer Assicurazioni Generali, which owns 50% of the similarly named wealth manager, will agree to sell to Mediobanca and at what price. The slim current 9% premium versus Banca Generali's undisturbed price, and the fact that Nagel is offering to pay in kind through Mediobanca's shares in Generali, make the deal vulnerable to a cash counteroffer from a rival suitor. And Generali cannot be seen to give a sweet deal to Mediobanca, its biggest shareholder. The third challenge is MPS itself. True, CEO Luigi Lovaglio seems to be in a tight spot. Just to get its offer up to the current value of Mediobanca, MPS might need to raise its 15-billion-euro bid by over 1 billion euros. Yet by paying much more for his larger rival, Lovaglio risks chasing his tail: his own share price would probably fall, depressing the value of the bid. Yet Lovaglio has other options. He currently wants two-thirds of investors to accept his soon-to-be-launched tender offer, a level that would allow him to merge the two banks and enjoy all the deal benefits. But he could settle for a lower threshold of 50%, or below. And if Delfin and Caltagirone backed him, he would already be at 30%. Such a move would be sub-optimal. With a lower take-up, Lovaglio would be under pressure to buy the rest, and might not get some or even most of the deal's synergies, which include 300 million euros of cost savings as well as tax benefits. Yet he could still exert control over his target. Mediobanca, meanwhile, would get the disruption of a takeover, and a more complex governance. Nagel's great escape is not yet complete. Follow @Unmack1, opens new tab on X
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
US says China's Huawei can't make more than 200,000 AI chips in 2025
WASHINGTON, June 12 (Reuters) - China's Huawei Technologies [RIC:RIC: is capable of producing no more than 200,000 advanced artificial intelligence chips in 2025, a top U.S. exports controls official told lawmakers on Thursday, warning that though the number is below the company's demand, China is quickly catching up to U.S. capabilities. Since 2019, a slew of U.S. export rules aimed at curbing China's technological and military advancements have limited access by Huawei and other Chinese firms to high-end U.S. chips and the equipment needed to produce them. The issue has become a flashpoint in U.S.-China relations. Facing those restrictions, Huawei aims to ship its Ascend 910C AI chips to Chinese customers as an alternative to those made by the United States' Nvidia (NVDA.O), opens new tab, the global leader. "Our assessment is that Huawei Ascend chip production capacity for 2025 will be at or below 200,000 and we project that most or all of that will be delivered to companies within China," Jeffrey Kessler, Under Secretary of Commerce for Industry and Security at the Commerce Department, told a congressional hearing. Kessler said that the U.S. should not take comfort in the figure. "China is investing huge amounts to increase its AI chip production, as well as the capabilities of the chips that it produces. So, it's critical for us not to have a false sense of security, to understand that China is catching up quickly," he told the House of Representatives Foreign Affairs South and Central Asia subcommittee. White House AI Czar David Sacks said on Tuesday that China was only 3-6 months behind the U.S. in AI. The White House later said he was referring to China's AI models, adding that Chinese AI chips are one to two years behind their U.S. counterparts. Huawei's CEO Ren Zhengfei told Chinese state media on Tuesday that the company's chips were a generation behind those of U.S. competitors, but that it invests more than $25 billion annually to improve performance. Nvidia's AI chips are more powerful than Huawei's but Washington's export controls on its most sophisticated chips have caused it to lose market share. The U.S. and China reached a tentative trade truce at talks in London this week after a previous agreement faltered over China's continued curbs on minerals exports. That prompted the Trump administration to apply additional export controls on shipments of semiconductor design software, jet engines for Chinese-made planes and other goods. Democratic Representative Greg Meeks expressed concern that the Trump administration had conflated U.S. exports controls with broader discussions on trade. "What I will say is export controls have been strong and I'm confident that they will remain strong," Kessler said. Kessler said he was not planning any immediate new restrictions on U.S. semiconductors sold to China, but that the Commerce Department will "remain active in this space." "It's a constantly evolving landscape, and we need to make sure that our controls remain effective," he said.
