Scopa launches inquiry into RAF misconduct claims
The Standing Committee on Public Accounts (Scopa) will investigate serious allegations of mismanagement, governance failures and financial misconduct at the Road Accident Fund (RAF).
Scopa announced on Tuesday that it has resolved to initiate a comprehensive inquiry into allegations of maladministration, financial mismanagement, wasteful and reckless expenditure, and related financial misconduct at the RAF.
The committee said the decision comes after months of several unsuccessful attempts by Scopa to obtain truthful, complete information from the RAF Board and executive management.
RAF board failed to cooperate and disclose key information – Scopa
'The committee cannot perform its work effectively if state entities do not provide it with complete and truthful information with adequate context and supporting information,' the chairperson said in a statement.
Among the committee's concerns are insufficient background checks on executive and senior management appointments who are entrusted with access to and oversight of substantial public funds.
ALSO READ: RAF and its comms head found to have defamed Sunshine Hospital
This is despite having a troubling employment and disciplinary record that includes accusations of making careless financial management decisions.
The committee is also concerned about the subsequent refusal by the RAF to disclose to them where such funds are kept and for what purpose.
Scopa is additionally troubled by the prolonged failure to appoint essential officials, including a chief claims officer, head of claims operations, head of legal, chief corporate support officer, and head of people management.
Prolonged failure to appoint essential officials
This comes as the RAF faces significant financial losses—either due to action being taken when it shouldn't be, or inaction when action is needed.
Some of the issues also include failures of governance with a direct impact on the rule of law and the authority and powers of parliament, as well as Chapter 9 institutions tasked with performing oversight on behalf of the South African people.
ALSO READ: State capture allegations come back to haunt RAF acting CIO
The committee also expressed concern over numerous whistleblower reports alleging supply chain irregularities involving more than R1 billion, noting that internal management appears to be failing to apply proper controls.
The committee said these allegations point to failure by the RAF Board to properly oversee management's decisions and actions in line with its statutory mandate.
The chairperson of Scopa, Songezo Zibi, said an inquiry will give everyone involved or implicated an opportunity to state their case under oath and receive a fair hearing before the committee draws its conclusion.
Inquiry will take place after August recess
'The volume of complaints and related documentary disclosures to the committee about the RAF make it necessary to examine them thoroughly and make such recommendations as may be necessary to ensure that the institution does its work within legal and constitutional prescripts and serves the public interest as intended,' Zibi said.
The committee will approve the terms of reference on 1 July 2025, and the inquiry will take place after the August recess.
ALSO READ: Two law firms get lion's share of RAF's R103m legal services spend
The Association for the Protection of Road Accident Victims (APRAV) has welcomed Scopa's decision to initiate a full parliamentary inquiry after 'years of concern' about systemic mismanagement, growing dysfunction, and serious questions regarding financial and ethical oversight at the fund.
'This is a massive victory — not just for APRAV, but for every victim who has suffered silently under a broken and unaccountable RAF system,' said Pieter de Bruyn, speaking on behalf of APRAV.
'It is a long-overdue reckoning with a system that has failed too many for too long.'
'This is a massive victory' – APRAV
As the inquiry process begins, APRAV called on victims, legal practitioners, former RAF employees and whistleblowers to come forward and share their evidence and experiences.
'Let this be the beginning of a new chapter for the RAF — one rooted in truth, accountability, and the collective will to do better,' said de Bruyn.
NOW READ: RAF 'deliberately withholding' information from Scopa
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
37 minutes ago
- The Star
Ramaphosa unaware of SANDF chief's controversial Iran visit
Mayibongwe Maqhina | Published 5 hours ago The Presidency on Thursday night said President Cyril Ramaphosa was unaware of the 'ill-advised' visit by South African National Defence Force (SANDF) Chief Rudzani Maphwanywa to Iran. Addressing the media, Ramaphosa's spokesperson Vincent Magwenya said Ramaphosa did not sanction Maphwanya's visit. He stated that it was Defence Minister Angie Motshekga, not Ramaphosa, who approved Maphwanya's travel. 'As much as the president is the appointing authority and the commander-in-chief, he does not get involved in supervising the general's travel. That process sits with the minister. So the president did not know.' Maphwanya was quoted by Iranian media as pledging 'common goals' with Iran and said his trip carried 'a political message'. Magwenya said there was a concern about Maphwanya's trip. 'At this period of heightened geopolitical tensions as well as conflict in the Middle East, one can say the visit was ill advised and more so the expectation is that the general should have been a lot more circumspect with the comments he makes, which delve into the area of foreign policy that only the president, as well as the Department of International Relations, are responsible for.' Maphwanya's trip took place amid tensions between South Africa and the US President Donald Trump imposed 30% tariffs on South African goods, which were implemented this month. Magwenya said South Africa was in a process of resetting diplomatic and political relations with the United States, as well as balancing the trade relationship in a mutually beneficial manner between the two countries. 'Of resolving the relationship or resolving issues around the relationship with the US, you then have senior government or military officials in statements that will further inflame the situation. It is not helpful at all,' he said. Both the Department of International Relations and Cooperation (DIRCO) and the Defence have distanced themselves from Maphwanya's remarks, citing that Ramaphosa and DIRCO were custodians of foreign policy. Magwenya said Ramaphosa will meet Maphwanya within the next week regarding his 'ill-advised' trip. 'I can't say when that meeting will happen, but there will be an engagement between the president and the general. So it's still early to say what the outcome of that engagement will be.' He would not comment on the possible consequence, if there was to be any, for the defence's chief amid calls by the DA for him to be hauled before a court martial. 'It is also difficult to speak to. One must consider what constitutes the grave nature of charges or accusations that would require a court-martial ,' Magwenya said. Deputy Defence Minister Bantu Holomisa told Newzroom Afrika that he was unaware of the visit. 'I don't know what the purpose of his visit was. It is only the minister who will be in the know. If he did not ask for permission to leave from the minister, then he will have to swim in his stew,' he said. Holomisa also said such visits outside the country were authorised by Motshekga. 'The last word has been said by the Presidency, and the Presidency is the custodian of our foreign policy. There is nothing one can contest on that, but what we should be waiting for is either to hear the minister herself addressing this issue or alternatively wait for General Maphwanya to come back and tell the nation how he went there, what was the purpose.' He said since the matter was in the open, Maphwanya should be allowed to respond openly and be transparent about it. Holomisa added that it was too early to say what would happen to Maphwanya. 'If he went abroad without permission from the president or the minister, he will have to face the music and explain on what basis he had to utter such words, which are creating controversy,' he said. [email protected]
Daily Maverick
an hour ago
- Daily Maverick
Aslina Wines challenges Western culture through winemaking
At Aslina Wines, KwaZulu-Natal's Ntsiki Biyela pays homage to her grandmother, Aslina, and to Zulu tradition, through a cultural wine brand rooted in heritage. The Cape Winelands are fertile grounds for innovation and promotion of industrial-scale wine production. In the largest wine-producing region in South Africa, the Western Cape is home to winemakers, wine brands and wine lovers. As much as 70% of the wine sold in South Africa comes from this region and continues to entice tourists and empower locals to support the vineyards vying for international recognition. While wine tasters sip to strengthen the local economy, winemakers are behind the scenes building the beloved brands. KwaZulu-Natal's Ntsiki Biyela is the founder of Aslina Wines. After the passing of her grandmother and her newfound interest in wine, Biyela wanted to pay homage to her grandmother, Aslina, and Zulu tradition, creating a cultural wine brand rooted in heritage. Her bottles and brand not only represent her commitment to culture but to curated selections. The established winemaker was not exposed to wine growing up, yet learnt about the fermented drink business during her studies. Since 2016 Biyela has been on a mission to share her premium South African wine brand with her community and beyond. Biyela was born in a rural village in KwaZulu-Natal, Mahlabathini. Young Biyela had fond memories of growing up on a farm, tending to cows with her grandmother. Some of the scents and tastes of her wine are reflections from her childhood, creating a wine brand that challenges the conventions of the wine industry, one grape at a time. While some wine tasters might think of truffles, mushrooms from the Karoo, Biyela was reminded of the dairy aroma of amasi, fermented milk. When she was young, she said, when sniffing wine she used to smell characteristics of forest and manure. After graduating from high school Biyela received a scholarship to study viticulture and oenology at Stellenbosch University to pursue winemaking. Upon graduation she worked at Stellekaya Wines in Stellenbosch as a winemaker for 13 years. Moving from rural KwaZulu-Natal to the suburbs of Stellenbosch marked the beginning of Biyela's promising career. Winemaking wasn't Biyela's initial career choice. Instead, the opportunity to study wine encouraged her to pursue the unfamiliar field. Despite this decision to ultimately study wine, Biyela experienced a culture shock. Biyela, a Black South African woman, became aware of the lack of diversity in the wine industry. 'In this industry, for me the hurdles were culture – cultural difference,' said Biyela. Though the predominantly Afrikaans-speaking school (Stellenbosch) was foreign to Zulu and English speakers, Biyela decided to change her perspective to transform her educational, personal and professional experience at university by learning how to integrate into her new environment. 'I navigated that by really just diving into it – building bridges, making friends and trying to figure out what it was going to be. I didn't have another option, that was it,' said Biyela. Since coming to South Africa, I have had serendipitous sipping experiences with the cultural wine brand that inspired me to interview the winemaker herself. My first experience trying Aslina Wines was at the Africa Food Show in June. I was invited by chef, food security expert and entrepreneur Miles Kubheka after he and I had been conversing on WhatsApp before my arrival. While I have been reporting on diversity in the culinary industry, I am also reporting on spaza shops through the Pulitzer Center Campus Consortium Fellowship. I reached out to Kubheka to interview him based on his knowledge of spaza shops and he kindly invited me to the event. This three-day event connected vendors with distributors, hospitality groups and media to showcase products currently or not yet on the market. Here, I stumbled upon the wine brand that celebrates Zulu culture with the burgundy calabash, a traditional drinking vessel with grapes placed on the top as the logo of the brand, Aslina Wines. Though Biyela wasn't at the event, her two representatives, marketing and brand coordinator Eden Bezuidenhout and sales coordinator Yoliswa Masekwana, were. At the food show, both representatives warmly greeted guests and two bottles from the brand were on display when I arrived – a 2023 Chenin Blanc and a 2023 Chardonnay. As a sweet-wine lover, Masekwana offered me the Chardonnay as a hopeful substitute for my maturing palate. The dry wine was met with buttery notes and had a creamy texture. I watched as other attendees lined up to taste the Zulu-inspired brand. I picked up Masekwana's business card before leaving the event – this surely couldn't be my last experience tasting a bottle from Aslina Wines. The second sip session experience was at EDGE X VUE. My editor, Tony Jackman, friends and I had an evening of tasting cultural cuisine at the restaurant in Cape Town. When our waitress with the colourful hair scarf, Ayanda Peters, proposed three options for the diners to choose from – Aslina Sauvignon Blanc, Marianne Rosé and the Glen Carlou Merlot — I chose the bottle from Biyela without hesitation. I remember putting my lips to the glass and tilting my head back to try the refreshing zest that offered a lingering finish of lemon notes. I remember drafting an email to the marketing representative at the dinner table because I was too eager to interview Biyela. After a few days of correspondence I was scheduled to interview one of the first Black female winemakers in South Africa. On the day of the interview, it was a not-soshocking rainy day in Cape Town. I had just finished dining at AmaZink, a restaurant in the Kayamandi township, before heading to my interview with Ntsiki Biyela. The trip to Alberto Drive in Devonbosch, Stellenbosch, was a short 10-minute drive through the townscape to the semi-rural grounds and greenery. Upon arrival, a barrel that read 'ASLINA by Ntsiki Biyela' was written on the wooden frame with her calabash logo on top of the words. The rain gently pattered on top of the barrel and from the glass doors one table was filled with guests with presumably filled glasses on the table. Inside the tasting room, red couches are paired with beige accent chairs. Posters with different wine bottles from Aslina Wines against a wildlife background with the logo of the brand are hung on the walls. More wine bottles from Aslina are on display, but by the receptionist's desk. Customer service and wine specialist Scarra Wayiza greeted me at the door before I reunited with Bezuidenhout and Masekwana. Our short reunion was soon joined by the wine owner herself, Biyela, a woman with beautiful moles and short locks. We shook hands and she immediately offered me a beverage of my choice – a glass of wine or tea. She sensed my shy spirit and chuckled before bringing me a glass – the option that I was too nervous to ask for. The interview I psyched myself out for was a pleasant chat about community, culture and curation. Interviewing Biyela was like talking to one of your favourite aunts. The witty woman effortlessly cracked jokes, shared her wisdom on the wine industry and offered words of encouragement to me as an early-career journalist. While interviewing Biyela, she shared that Absie Pantshwa, co-founder of EDGE X VUE, proudly displays Aslina Wines as an opportunity for local and Black winemakers to be highlighted at the restaurant to uplift the economy and support local businesses. 'Wine is playing a role of matriarching, putting people together, but also wine is playing a role of changing the economic aspect of the country,' said Biyela. As the marketing coordinator, Bezuidenhout understands the role winemakers and buyers have in the wine industry. 'Local owned wine brands put food on people's tables. Not only does Aslina give me a good life that I can live because it supports me, but it also supports the farm workers, the people who do the labelling, the people who do the bottling,' said Bezuidenhout. Biyela's wines include a curated selection to cater and complement cultural cuisine such as her grandmother's chicken curry. In KZN, the Indian influence helps to enhance the flavourful Zulu meals. Biyela challenges Western wine philosophy by experimenting with different cuisine and wines. She remembers her experience in Japan when she and her peers decided to try a glass of Cabernet with spicy noodles. 'The wine is already in the bottle, but it is all about what you are going to do with your food so that it pairs well with your wine,' said Biyela. As a young winemaker, Biyela remembers being told not to pair red wine with spicy food. The bold brand owner did the exact opposite. 'It made the wine sweeter, it made the flavours explode,' said Biyela. Biyela wants to encourage aspiring winemakers to explore different meals with unexpected bottles. 'It must either enhance the flavour profile of the wine or it must match it, but you don't want any of this suppressing each other,' said Biyela. Biyela's brand is more than wine in a bottle, she offers intimate wine tasting room experiences for customers to explore. At Aslina Wines, customers can expect to taste five selected wines: Sauvignon Blanc, Chardonnay, Chenin Blanc, Cabernet Sauvignon and Umsasane, Biyela's grandmother's nickname which translates to 'tree'. The traditional Zulu word means protection. Biyela believes different cultures can enhance the wine industry. 'It helps the industry to bring beautiful structures, beautiful textures, beautiful tastes, and you can't just go one dimensional,' said Biyela. 'Having all of these different cultures is actually a good thing for the wine industry.' While the wine industry continues to transform, Biyela encourages young winemakers to be flexible with their learning and networking. 'Be knowledgeable about it, but also allow yourself to learn, be open to learning, ask questions, talk to people,' said Biyela. Before leaving the tasting space in Stellenbosch, I snapped a couple more photos of the Afrocentric ambience and watched Biyela take a seat with the guests attending the tasting experience, her friendly spirit matching the energetic company of the wine tasters. A month later, I was attending the Local Wine Expo in Johannesburg on Tony's behalf and Aslina Wines was there once again. I proudly snapped a photo and sent it to Tony. It is nearly 10 years since Biyela has decided to start her wine business. The heritage in a bottle wine brand challenges the Western wine industry by mixing traditional ingredients to create her wine brand. 'When we look at the wine industry, the wine has been mostly wine as Western culture, but now… there's a global village. We all have different foods. It is for us to understand, the wines should adjust to what we do,' said Biyela. DM
Eyewitness News
an hour ago
- Eyewitness News
Presidency ‘delighted' that more countries recognising Palestine as a state
JOHANNESBURG - The Presidency said it was "delighted" that more countries were recognising Palestine as a state, saying it was about time. At least 145 countries are now calling for Palestine to be recognised as a state, with Australia, Canada, and France also announcing their intentions to do so later in 2025. The recognition of a Palestinian statehood comes as the Israeli government has announced plans to extend its illegal settlements into Gaza. Speaking at a media briefing in Pretoria on Thursday, Presidency spokesperson, Vincent Magwenya, said this had been long overdue. "It's about time that we get more and more countries recognising the historical reality that Palestinians are deserving of nationhood. They do have a right to exist, to shape and determine their own future, free from occupation and free from constant barrage of military attacks, as well as genocidal attacks, as we have experienced. From the South African point of view, we are delighted that more and more nations that this right needs to be given practical meaning - it can't just be in theory and in words."
