America's foreign student fiasco
Harvard University's graduation day takes place amid escalating tensions between the university and the Trump administration.
Photo:
Getty via AFP
One of the world's best universities, a magnet for the globe's brightest brains, is under attack by the Trump administration.
And while Harvard is fighting various funding restrictions and bans on foreign student visas, harsher policies on America's borders are
creating fear from returning students
that they could be arrested by immigration officers and jailed or deported.
International students are big money-makers for universities worldwide - in New Zealand they pay four times the amount in fees as domestic students.
"We could be doing well while doing good," says the chief economist at the policy think-tank The New Zealand Initiative, Dr Eric Crampton.
"It's amazing that America's throwing all this away.
"We aren't the destination market for the best students in the world. But if the place that is the destination for the best students in the world suddenly says 'we don't want them any more' - my God we'd better be ready for that," he tells
The Detail
.
Crampton is Canadian, but spent time in the US on a student visa so knows what it's like to study there. He's also taught at Canterbury University and has experience with exchange students.
He says the American administration has now basically put every student visa under threat, with erratic threats coming from the President, whether over funding or threats to Chinese students on the basis that "they're all spies or something".
Trump's move to bar international students from Harvard by blocking their visas has itself now been
blocked by a court order
, but the situation remains uncertain. At the same time foreign students are getting nervous about leaving the country and trying to get back in, with reports about people randomly getting arrested at the border.
The hit to the US economy is expected to cost billions in revenue, and has been described as an "anti-intellectual spree".
"When you live in America on something like a student visa, every interaction with the state you're reminded that you're less than an American. Even in 2002 it was very clear that you are there by their sufferance.
"It would be awful being there now on a student visa because just imagine it ... you'd be paying $US50,000 per year in international tuition fees, maybe you've already paid for two years of study and you're coming towards the end of it ... and you've got two more years ahead of you ... if they cancel your visa you've wasted $100,000 and two years.
"If you're at a place like Harvard, people wouldn't hold it against you, you could continue your studies elsewhere. People would say 'well, he was admitted to Harvard, he must be really good', but if you're at a mid-tier US university - which is still better than anything New Zealand has - you'll have sunk two years' worth of study and $100,000 worth of cost, and you won't be able to finish your degree.
"It feels like the kind of spot where New Zealand could help. We've always been able to accommodate students on international exchange. We could make it really easy for students to come in that way."
Universities New Zealand chief executive Chris Whelan says New Zealand is
nearly back up to pre-Covid numbers
of foreign students, with our eight universities having about 20 thousand full time equivalent students between them.
"International students help, but they're just one of a number of different mechanisms that universities are looking to for making payroll and keeping lights on," he says.
"We don't want to grow too far ... we want international education to be a genuinely quality and value proposition for both domestic students - giving them the ability to rub shoulders with people from different cultures - but also for the international students, to give them a genuine international experience.
"But if any student did want to, or was forced to, discontinue their studies in the US, there are places like New Zealand that I think would welcome them and would make it as easy as possible for them to get here."
Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail
here
.
You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on
Facebook
or following us on
Twitter
.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Home loan rates fall again
Photo: AFP Westpac is cutting some of its home loan rates and slightly increasing one other. The bank said it would reduce its one-year rate to 4.89 percent, a drop of six basis points. Its three-year rate will lift by four basis points to 4.99 percent. The six-month rate drops by 20 basis points to 5.29 percent. The bank's general manager of product, sustainability and marketing, Sarah Hearn, said the rates would be available on Friday. The one-year rate is the joint lowest in the market, tied with Kiwibank. ANZ, ASB and BNZ are offering 4.89 percent for 18 months, while Westpac is still offering 4.95 percent for that term. Swap rates have fallen significantly from the start of the year, although they have started to lift a little more recently, on expectations that the Reserve Bank might be near the bottom of its official cash rate cutting cycle. BNZ chief economist Mike Jones said the fact that the decision this time went to a vote was one factor that illustrated that. One member of the monetary policy committee voted against the decision to cut the official cash rate at the most recent update. "The fact you had one committee member wanting to pause for a meeting - you've got to add that to some of the comments from [committee] members at or after the decision around where we might be in relation to the cycle as a whole. "It does tend to guide us to we're probably on the home stretch, whether it's one more, two more or even three more cuts, the messaging there tends to suggest we've had some big cuts to date and based on everything we know now we're getting towards the end - although there's always that optionality to respond to changing conditions and conditions are changing really rapidly at the moment." He said BNZ's official forecast was still for two more cuts to an OCR low of 2.75 percent. "When we look at the language from the bank combined with some of the data that has come in a bit firmer than we might have expected, that lead us to the risk of maybe just one but we still expect two. If that's right that means in terms of market interest rates, it's just the floating rates and the shorter term rates that have that much further to fall from here. We might getting close to or at the bottom for some of those longer term interest rates."
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Labour leapfrog National, but coalition keeps power in Taxpayers' Union poll
Both Christopher Luxon and Chris Hipkins saw their leadership numbers decline. Photo: RNZ Labour would be the largest party in Parliament - but the coalition would still cling onto power, according to a new poll. The latest Taxpayers' Union-Curia poll - the first the firm has conducted since the budget - sees Labour leapfrog National in popularity and parties outside parliament making slight gains. Party vote: The centre-right would have a combined 62 seats, down one seat from the previous poll. The centre-left is up two seats to 60. For the minor parties, TOP is on 1.8 percent (up 1.3 percentage point), Outdoors and Freedom is on 1.1 percent (up 0.7 points), New Conservatives are on 0.7 percent (up 0.7 points) and Vision NZ on 0.6 percent (up 0.2 points). Preferred prime minister: In the preferred Prime Minister stakes, both Christopher Luxon and Chris Hipkins have taken hits, with Luxon staying slightly ahead of Hipkins. Luxon is down 4.2 points from last month to 20.3 percent, while Hipkins is down 1.5 points to 18.5 percent. The poll was conducted by Curia Market Research Ltd for the NZ Taxpayers' Union. It is a random poll of 1f000 adult New Zealanders, weighted to the overall adult population. It was conducted by phone (landlines and mobile) and online between Saturday, 7 June and Monday 9 June 2025. It has a maximum margin of error of +/- 3.1%. Curia is a long-running and established pollster in New Zealand, which has resigned its membership from the Research Association New Zealand (RANZ) industry body. Polls compare to the most recent poll by the same polling company, as different polls can use different methologies. They are intended to track trends in voting preferences, showing a snapshot in time, rather than be a completely accurate predictor of the final election result. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Core public service agencies spend $420m on consultants, contractors in 9 months to March
The spend has fallen to 4.5 percent of the total wage bill of 38 core agencies. Photo: Unsplash New figures show core public service agencies spent $420 million on consultants and contractors in a nine-month period to March. The spend has fallen to just 4.5 percent of the total wage bill of 38 core agencies. The [ Public Service Commission] says this is the lowest since measurement began seven years ago. The Education Ministry was far and away the biggest spender for the nine months, shelling out $146m. The spending by the Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment has plummeted from high levels several years ago, to just $24m; the Ministry of Social Development has dropped a lot, too, to $31m, though these two major ministries were still among the biggest spenders in the period to March 2025. Only the core agencies are counted for this, leaving out the likes of big spenders such as Defence and Police. Once those two, and all Crown entities and non-core departments are counted in, the total spend for the nine months was $1.22 billion, split half and half between capital and operating spending. Often, capital spending on contractors is tied up with IT upgrades, while operating spending is on recruitment firms to hire temp workers to plug holes. National pledged in the election to cut $400m a year in operational - not capital - spending on contractors by the end of the 2024-25 financial year - end of June - compared to 2022-23. Halfway there, at the end of 2023-24, it had dropped $274m. In the year to June 2024, the total spend was almost $1b and two years ago it was $1.2b. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
