Afghan refugees stuck in Pakistan as Germany halts entry programme
A visual artist and women's rights advocate, she fled Afghanistan in 2024 after being accepted on to a German humanitarian admission program aimed at Afghans considered at risk under the Taliban.
A year later, Kimia is stuck in limbo.
Thousands of kilometres away in Germany, an election in February where migration dominated public debate and a change of government in May resulted in the gradual suspension of the programme.
Now the new centre-right coalition intends to close it.
The situation echoes that of nearly 1,660 Afghans cleared to settle in the United States, but who then found themselves in limbo in January after U.S. President Donald Trump took office and suspended refugee programmes.
Kimia's interview at the German embassy which she hoped would result in a flight to the country and the right to live there, was abruptly cancelled in April. Meanwhile, Germany pays for her room, meals and medical care in Islamabad.
"All my life comes down to this interview," she told Reuters. She gave only her artist name for fear of reprisal.
"We just want to find a place that is calm and safe," she said of herself and the other women at the guesthouse.
The admission programme began in October 2022, intending to bring up to 1,000 Afghans per month to Germany who were deemed at risk because of their work in human rights, justice, politics or education, or due to their gender, religion or sexual orientation.
However, fewer than 1,600 arrived in over two years due to holdups and the cancellation of flights.
Today, around 2,400 Afghans are waiting to travel to Germany, the German foreign ministry said. Whether they will is unclear. NGOs say 17,000 more are in the early stages of selection and application under the now dormant scheme.
The foreign ministry said entry to Germany through the program was suspended pending a government review, and the government will continue to care for and house those already in the program.
It did not answer Reuters' questions on the number of cancelled interviews, or how long the suspension would last.
Reuters spoke with eight Afghans living in Pakistan and Germany, migration lawyers and advocacy groups, who described the fate of the programme as part of a broader curb on Afghan asylum claims in Germany and an assumption that Sunni men in particular are not at risk under the Taliban.
The German government says there is no specific policy of reducing the number of Afghan migrants. However, approval rates for Afghan asylum applicants dropped to 52% in early 2025, down from 74% in 2024, according to the Federal Migration Office (BAMF).
Kabul fell to the Taliban in August 2021. Since May 2021 Germany has admitted about 36,500 vulnerable Afghans by various pathways including former local staff, the government said.
Thorsten Frei, chief of staff to Germany's new chancellor Friedrich Merz, said humanitarian migration has now reached levels that "exceed the integration capacity of society."
"As long as we have irregular and illegal migration to Germany, we simply cannot implement voluntary admission programs."
The interior ministry said programs like the one for Afghans will be phased out and they are reviewing how to do so.
Several Afghans are suing the government over the suspension. Matthias Lehnert, a lawyer representing them, said Germany could not simply suspend their admissions without certain conditions such as the person no longer being at risk.
Since former chancellor Angela Merkel opened Germany's borders in 2015 to over a million refugees, public sentiment has shifted, partly as a result of several deadly attacks by asylum seekers. The far-right Alternative for Germany party (AfD), capitalising on the anti-migrant sentiment, surged to a historic second-place finish in February's election.
Afghans Reuters spoke with said they feared they were being unfairly associated with the perpetrators, and this was putting their own lives at risk if they had to return to Afghanistan.
"I'm so sorry about those people who are injured or killed ... but it's not our fault," Kimia said.
Afghan Mohammad Mojib Razayee, 30, flew to Germany from Cyprus in March under a European Union voluntary solidarity mechanism, after a year of waiting with 100 other refugees. He said he was at risk after criticising the Taliban. Two weeks after seeking asylum in Berlin, his application was rejected.
He was shocked at the ruling. BAMF found no special protection needs in his case, a spokesperson said.
"It's absurd — but not surprising. The decision-making process is simply about luck, good or bad," said Nicolas Chevreux, a legal advisor with AWO counseling center in Berlin.
Chevreux said he believes Afghan asylum cases have been handled differently since mid-2024, after a mass stabbing at a rally in the city of Mannheim, in which six people were injured and a police officer was killed. An Afghan asylum seeker was charged and is awaiting trial.
Spending most days in her room, surrounded by English and German textbooks, Kimia says returning to Afghanistan is unthinkable. Her art could make her a target.
"If I go back, I can't follow my dreams - I can't work, I can't study. It's like you just breathe, but you don't live."
Under Taliban rule, women are banned from most public life, face harassment by morality police if unaccompanied by a male guardian, and must follow strict dress codes, including face coverings. When security forces raided homes, Kimia said, she would frantically hide her artwork.
The Taliban say they respect women's rights in accordance with their interpretation of Islamic law and local culture and that they are not targeting former foes.
Hasseina, is a 35-year-old journalist and women's rights activist from Kabul who fled to Pakistan and was accepted as an applicant on to the German programme.
Divorced and under threat from both the Taliban and her ex-husband's family, who she says have threatened to kill her and take her daughter, she said returning is not an option.
The women are particularly alarmed as Pakistan is intensifying efforts to forcibly return Afghans. The country says its crackdown targets all undocumented foreigners for security reasons. Pakistan's foreign ministry did not respond to request for comment on how this affects Afghans awaiting German approval.
The German foreign ministry has said it is aware of two families promised admission to Germany who were detained for deportation, and it was working with Pakistan authorities to stop this.
Marina, 25, fled Afghanistan after being separated from her family. Her mother, a human rights lawyer, was able to get to Germany. Marina has been waiting in Pakistan to follow her for nearly two years with her baby.
"My life is stuck, I want to go to Germany, I want to work, I want to contribute. Here I am feeling so useless," she said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
10 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Over half of Germans would not fight for their country
Nearly two-thirds of Germans would 'probably not' defend their homeland from invaders, a survey has found, in a blow to the government's rearmament plans. In a survey carried out for RND, a German broadcaster, 59 per cent of respondents said they were 'probably' or 'definitely' unwilling to defend the country from an attack. Only 16 per cent of Germans were 'definitely' willing to take up arms to defend Germany, while 22 per cent said they would 'probably' do it. The new figures are a headache for Boris Pistorius, the German defence minister, as he leads efforts to rearm Germany and turn it into a serious European security power, following decades of under-investment in the army. In July, Mr Pistorius unveiled plans to recruit 40,000 young adults per year into the Bundeswehr, the German armed forces, by 2031 as part of a new military service scheme. The same scheme plans to send out compulsory questionnaires to young male Germans to fill in once they turn 18, and could be followed by compulsory health screenings of young men to check their suitability for the army. Bundeswehr officials say that the overall size of the army needs to grow from 182,000 soldiers to at least 260,000 by 2035. The Bundeswehr reserve forces also need to be increased from 60,000 to 200,000 people. The German military has struggled for decades with recruitment, partly due to Germans' wartime guilt and a widely held view that their country no longer needed an army. Conscription in Germany, which was deeply unpopular, ended in 2011. But the Russian invasion of Ukraine has prompted a major rethink on security in Berlin, known as the 'Zeitenwende', or turning of the times. Friedrich Merz, the German chancellor, declared that 'Germany is back' after his election victory in February, as he vowed to stand up to Russian president Vladimir Putin. The centre-Right Christian Democrats [CDU] party leader has introduced historic debt reforms, which allow potentially unlimited government defence spending on projects costing more than 1 per cent of GDP. The Merz government has also created a 500bn euro (£435bn) special infrastructure fund, which will rebuild the country's crumbling road and rail networks. The fund is a crucial part of Nato's wider security planning for a potential war with Russia, as Germany would serve as a transit zone for troops and tanks en route to the eastern front. Germany is not the only country having difficulties drumming up recruits: in Italy, a similar survey also found that only 16 per cent of citizens were willing to defend their nation - despite defence spending increasing by 46 per cent over the past decade. In Britain, the army and navy have missed nearly every annual recruitment target since 2010, according to government statistics. The shortfall has been blamed on stagnant pay, poor military housing, a wider downward trend in young people being interested in fighting for their country.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Pakistan resumes forced expulsions of 1.4 million Afghan refugees despite UN concerns
Authorities in Pakistan have resumed the forced deportations of Afghan refugees after the federal government declined to extend a key deadline for their stay, officials said Monday. The decision affects approximately 1.4 million Afghans holding Proof of Registration cards, whose legal status expired at the end of June. Many had hoped for a one-year extension to settle personal affairs, such as selling property or concluding business, before returning to Afghanistan. In addition to PoR card holders, around 800,000 Afghans hold Afghan Citizen Cards. Police say they also are living in the country illegally and being detained prior to deportations in the eastern Punjab, southwestern Balochistan and southern Sindh province. Monday's decision drew criticism from the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, the U.N. refugee agency. At least 1.2 million Afghans have been forced to return from Iran and Pakistan this year, according to a June UNHCR report. Repatriations on such a massive scale have the potential to destabilize the fragile situation in Afghanistan, where the Taliban government came into power in 2021. A July 31 government notification seen by The Associated Press confirms Pakistan's decision to repatriate all Afghan nationals holding expired PoR cards. It states Afghans without valid passports and Pakistani visas are in the country illegally and must return to their homeland under Pakistani immigration laws. Police across Pakistan are detaining Afghans to transport them to border crossings, according to two government and security officials who spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to speak publicly. They said there are no mass arrests and police were told to go to house-to-house and make random checks to detain foreigners living in the country illegally. 'Yes, the Afghan refugees living in Pakistan illegally are being sent back in a dignified way,' said Shakeel Khan, commissioner for Afghan refugees in the northwestern Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province. The latest operation is the most significant step yet under orders from federal government in Islamabad, he said. Rehmat Ullah, 35, an Afghan, said his family migrated to Pakistan's northwestern Peshawar city decades ago and now is preparing to return home. 'I have five children and my concern is that they will miss their education,' he said. 'I was born here, my children were born here and now we are going back,' he said. Millions have fled to Pakistan over the past four decades to escape war, political unrest and economic hardship. The renewed deportation drive follows a nationwide crackdown launched in 2023 targeting foreigners living illegally in Pakistan. The Interior Ministry, which oversees the campaign, did not immediately comment. Qaiser Khan Afridi, a spokesperson for the U.N. refugee agency, expressed deep concern over the government's recent actions. 'Sending people back in this manner is tantamount to refoulement and a breach of a state's international obligations,' Afridi said in a statement, urging Pakistan to adopt a 'humane approach to ensure voluntary, gradual, and dignified return of Afghans' and praised the country for hosting millions of Afghan refugees for more than 40 years. 'We call on the government to halt the forcible return and ensure a gradual, voluntary and dignified repatriation process,' Afridi said. 'Such massive and hasty return could jeopardize the lives and freedom of Afghan refugees, while also risking instability not only in Afghanistan but across the region.'
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Germany sees number of asylum seeker arrivals HALVE in six months following tough new migration policies
The German government says a dip in the number of people seeking asylum is proof that its strict migration policies are working. According to figures, the number of people applying for asylum in Germany for the first time fell by more than half in the first six months of the year. There were just over 70,000 applications between January and July, compared to nearly 141,000 during the same period last year. Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt said: 'We have massively reduced the number of initial asylum applications compared to last year.' The drop has been seen as a big success for Chancellor Friedrich Merz's conservative government, which promised to crack down on illegal immigration and speed up deportations. The coalition is putting pressure on the EU to bring in stricter rules, including fewer appeal options for failed asylum seekers and faster returns to their home countries. Dobrindt told the Bild am Sonntag newspaper: 'We want procedures at the EU's external borders, faster decisions and consistent returns.' 'We are declaring an even tougher fight against the smugglers, because the state must regulate who comes into our country, not the criminal smuggling gangs.' But the government's policies have come under scrutiny, with some critics saying it breaks European Union rules and puts pressure on the bloc's visa-free travel zone. EU data shows Spain has now overtaken Germany as the most popular destination for asylum seekers. That change is partly due to fewer Syrians applying for refuge, following the collapse of the Assad regime. In Germany alone, overall asylum claims dropped to 9,900 in May, compared to 18,700 during the same month last year. A major reason for the decline has been the introduction of tough new border controls. Asylum seekers without valid entry papers can now be turned away at the German border. The policy was one of Merz's key election promises and was introduced as one of the first changes under his new government earlier this year. But the new checks have sparked controversy across Europe, as they go against the rules of the Schengen area, which makes way for passport-free travel across much of the EU. Germany is now carrying out border checks with Poland, Switzerland, Austria, France, the Czech Republic, Denmark, and the Netherlands. On Sunday, Poland said it would extend its own border checks until October. The measures were first brought in this July, following pressure from far-right vigilante groups that began stopping migrants at illegal checkpoints. Across the EU, illegal migration has become one of the most divisive conversations. In Germany, the hard-right party Alternative for Germany (AfD) continues to enjoy a rise in polling. The party is known for its hardline stance on migration and has promised mass deportations if it comes to power. A new poll published showed it's now at 25 percent, just behind Merz's Christian Democratic Union on 27 percent. Support for the chancellor's coalition has dropped to 42 percent. Germany, Italy and Denmark are all pushing the EU to make it easier to deport people whose asylum claims are rejected.
