Janaagraha gives Greater Bengaluru Governance Act the thumbs down
For the assessment, Janaagraha, compared the GBGA with the Brand Bengaluru Committee- GBG Bill, the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP) Act 202, and the Karnataka Municipal Corporations Act, 1976.
The teams analysed the GBGA on 33 parameters and noted that it scored barely half as effective as the other Acts and bills.
They noted that the GBGA makes some advances in municipal finance and staffing, but fails on critical aspects of planning, political leadership and citizen participation. They also chalked out a roadmap for the government to follow, highlighting three pathways.
The list of suggestions in the road map included, establishing city corporations, completing the ward delimitation and reservations by March 2026, creation of the Bengaluru Metropolitan Planning Committee and selection of mayors, ward committee members and detailing their functioning, mandating area sabhas for neighbourhood-level engagement and ensuring financial and administrative autonomy of city corporations.
Srikanth Viswanathan, Chief Executive Officer, Janaagraha, said the GBA is a net positive move, but the GBGA is poorly drafted. The original draft of the Brand Bengaluru committee was better. 'We have recommended 46 specific actions to make the GBGA work for Bengaluru's citizens. The Karnataka government has a golden opportunity to pioneer metropolitan governance in India, along with decentralised participatory governance. Its handling of the GBGA and its recent track record do not inspire confidence. Civil society, business and academia in Bengaluru should mobilise into a collective and ensure this opportunity is not lost,' he said.
Adding to this, Santosh Nargund, Director, Policy Engagement, Janaagraha, said that Bengaluru has been without an elected local government for nearly five years and this prolonged vacuum is denting the city's stature as a global metropolis.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
5 hours ago
- The Hindu
Tunnel road will be another Yettinahole project: BJP
The Opposition BJP on Wednesday said the proposed 17-km tunnel road in the city will be 'another Yettinahole project' and urged the Congress government to withdraw it. Speaking on the debate initiated by the Opposition on the halting of development works in the State, Leader of the Opposition R. Ashok said the cost of the Yettinahole project has tripled from ₹8,000 crore in 2011 to ₹25,000 crore in 2025. The project was initiated during the tenure of D.V. Sadananda Gowda for catering to the drinking water needs of the drought-prone districts of the southern part of the State. Even after spending ₹25,000 crore on the project, the water has not reached Kolar and other districts, Mr. Ashok said. C.N. Ashwath Narayana (BJP) said that during the S.M. Krishna government, the civic body, Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike, mortgaged properties and buildings to raise loans. Now, the government has decided to raise ₹8,000 crore loans from Housing and Urban Development Corporation Limited (HUDCO) by mortgaging government buildings and properties.
Hans India
12 hours ago
- Hans India
LoP slams Congress over pothole-ridden roads
Bengaluru: Leader of the Opposition in the Legislative Assembly, R. Ashoka, launched a sharp attack on the Congress-led state government over the alarming condition of Bengaluru's roads, riddled with potholes that have become a nightmare for commuters. Citing a media report, Ashoka posted on social media platform 'X', calling the city 'Broken Bengaluru, not Brand Bengaluru.' He ridiculed the government's claims of development while citizens continue to struggle on unsafe roads. 'Potholes everywhere, but dreams of tunnels underground—this is Congress' concept of Brand Bengaluru,' Ashoka remarked, accusing the ruling party of neglecting basic civic responsibilities. He pointed out that rains, coupled with BBMP's inefficiency, have turned the roads into 'death traps.' According to him, there is not a single pothole-free road in the city. 'Under the Agara flyover, you cannot even spot the road. Bus stops, offices, and residential complexes are all surrounded by damaged roads,' he said. Highlighting the risks, Ashoka alleged that accidents have become routine in the city, with motorists losing balance, patients facing difficulties, and residents suffering from back pain due to poor road conditions. 'Daily travel has become torture,' he added. Targeting Deputy Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar, Ashoka asked: 'What is the self-proclaimed creator of Brand Bengaluru doing? Instead of fixing potholes, he is dreaming about underground tunnel roads.' Taking a dig, he quipped that Shivakumar perhaps wants people to live underground since the surface roads are filled with craters. Ashoka urged the government to focus on ensuring safe, motorable roads instead of making hollow promises. 'This is not Brand Bengaluru. This is Congress' Broken Bengaluru,' he concluded.
New Indian Express
14 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Assembly nod for Bill to clarify GBA's authority over new corporations
BENGALURU: The Karnataka Assembly on Tuesday passed the Greater Bengaluru Governance (Amendment) Bill, 2025, to clarify that the newly formed Greater Bengaluru Authority (GBA) would not interfere with the functioning of the proposed five new corporations. Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar, who also holds the Bengaluru Development portfolio, said that though the Greater Bengaluru Governance Act was passed, some people filed a PIL in the court. 'Hence, this amendment has been brought, stressing to clarify the point that the Greater Bengaluru Authority would not interfere in the functioning of the corporations,' Shivakumar said. According to the existing Act, GBA shall exercise such authority and discharge such functions as per the provisions of this Act, including with respect to the corporations created, he said. 'We have removed it... we will not interfere. Corporations are separate. We don't want to interfere in their functioning,' Shivakumar added. Discussing the matter, Dasarahalli MLA Muniraju (BJP) lamented that his constituency will be divided between the proposed Bengaluru City North Corporation and Bengaluru City West Corporation.
