Judge increases 'unduly lenient' sentences of two child rapists after appeal
Lord Beckett made the observations in a judgment in which prosecutors succeeded in their bids to increase the jail terms given to two sex offenders.
The Lord Justice Clerk – Scotland's second most senior judge – sat with his colleagues Lord Matthews and Lord Armstrong in a case brought against Andrew McMahon, 69, and Christian Lambert, 22.
McMahon was given a five-year jail term by Judge Alison Stirling following proceedings at the High Court in Edinburgh in March 2025. Lambert was given three years and four months after two hearings at the same court in the Scottish capital.
A jury heard how McMahon raped a 12-year-old girl in a wooded area in Edinburgh and told her not to tell others about what happened to her.
Lambert, a former boarding school pupil, pleaded guilty to raping another 12-year-old girl in Slateford, Edinburgh, in March 2024.
Judge Lord Summers heard how Lambert told a court-appointed social worker that he felt 'aroused' when he was choking his victim.
Prosecutor Paul Harvey went to the Court of Criminal Appeal in Edinburgh earlier this year to argue that the sentences given to the pair were unduly lenient and should have been longer.
He said the judges didn't properly consider the exact circumstances of the attacks and the impact that they would have had on the victims.
The court heard that even McMahon thought the sentence given to him was unduly lenient.
Mr Harvey told the appeal judges that the sentences given to the two men should have been longer.
In a written judgement published by the court on Tuesday, Lord Beckett writes of how Mr Harvey also invited him and his colleagues to find that rapists convicted under section 18 of the Sexual Offences Scotland Act 2009 – the rape of a young child – should receive longer sentences.
He said their sentences should be longer than ones given to rapists prosecuted under section one of the legislation – the rape of an adult.
Mr Harvey's submissions succeeded. McMahon's sentence was increased to 11 years – he will also be supervised by the authorities for two years after his release from jail.
Lambert's jail term was also increased to five years and three months, with a three-year-long supervision order put in place for his immediate post-release life.
In the judgment, Lord Beckett wrote: 'The crime of rape generally is a particularly serious offence. It is apparent that in England, the guidelines have a higher starting point for rape of a young child than for an older person.
'Rape of a young child will generally be more culpable than rape of an older person, serious though both crimes are.
'It is also likely that there will be a higher level of harm. Courts in both England and Scotland have recognised that sexual exploitation of a young child may be comparatively easy to commit given the physical and intellectual advantages of an adult over a young child.
'Both individual and general deterrence is an important sentencing objective.
'Whilst there can be exceptional cases with exceptional circumstances, in general in the absence of exceptional circumstances, the appropriate sentence for rape of a child under 18 will be significantly higher than for rape under s1.'
McMahon subjected his victim to sexual assaults on two occasions in Edinburgh in the summer of 2023.
During the first attack at a house in the Granton area of the city, he subjected the girl to an oral rape on an occasion between March 28 and August 17 in 2023.
McMahon then raped a second victim on August 18 that year in the Niddrie area when he attacked her outdoors and grabbed her, pulled her and pushed her to the ground.
The rapist told his child victim not to tell anyone and threatened her after subjecting her to the sexual abuse.
After a jury returned guilty verdicts against the sex offender, Judge Alison Stirling told jurors that it was 'a difficult and anxious case'.
Meanwhile, the court heard how Lambert pretended to be a teenager in order to sexually assault the child whom he encountered whilst using the Snapchat messaging app.
The High Court in Edinburgh heard how the attack took place at a house in the city's Slateford area in March last year. The child thought she was going to meet a boy who was a couple of years older than she was.
When Lambert, also of Edinburgh, appeared before Judge Lord Summers for sentencing, the court heard how Lambert was assessed as being at 'high risk' of further sexual offending.
The court also heard how Lambert had choked the girl as he raped her.
This prompted Lord Summers to send Lambert to jail for three years and four months for the attack.
On Tuesday, the appeal concluded that the sentences given to the two men were 'unduly lenient'.
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Rape survivors go head to head with controversial mens' rights group outside Parliament
Members of Justice for Innocent Men Scotland (JIMS), who have been slammed for targeting women speaking out on abuse, are to be met with a counter protest at Holyrood. Rape survivors will go head to head outside the Scottish Parliament with a controversial mens' rights group accused of trolling victims. Members of Justice for Innocent Men Scotland (JIMS), who have been slammed for targeting women speaking out on abuse, are to stage a 'silent protest' outside the Scottish Parliament in the coming weeks - pledging support of 'innocent people caught in broken justice systems'. But the group is set to be met with a counter protest organised by JEMS - Justice for Exploited and Mistreated Survivors - after members hit out over being targeted online by supporters of the group. Ellie Wilson, who says she was labelled an 'attention seeker' for campaigning in the wake of her rapist's conviction, said survivors will stand up to those who seek to blame victims. The 27-year-old said: 'All of us survivors have come together because we've faced targeting by this group. 'They're gathering for their protest so we thought it was important that we show survivors solidarity. 'Our aim is to call out victim blaming and show survivors that we stand with them and stand together. 'We stand against any sort of behaviour that tries to blame them for what happened. 'It's so difficult in this country to get a guilty verdict in the first place. So to go through that then be told this didn't happen to you, in quite a public way as well, just isn't acceptable. 'It's bullying and it's public humiliation. It shouldn't be happening and we believe that the majority of Scotland does stand with survivors and we want to show that.' Ellie's ex-partner Daniel McFarlane was sentenced to five years in prison in 2022 for raping her twice while they were both students at Glasgow University. Ellie bravely waived her right to anonymity to fight for change in the justice system. But she has told how supporters of JIMS accused her of using her experience to 'gain fame' and make money. She said: 'It's obviously really difficult when you're a survivor and you've gone through the trauma of rape and domestic abuse and the justice system to then have people going on the internet saying you're a liar and calling you names. 'It's retraumatising and it's not what people need after going through so much already. 'I've waived my anonymity and other survivors have done the same, but it's almost like people like JIMS think we shouldn't be heard or exist in public life. Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. 'I think people feel more empowered to say or do things online, which is leading to a lot of this horrible behaviour. 'We definitely have lots of interest (in the counter protest), so I think it will be quite likely that we get more numbers than they do.' Scottish Conservative MSP Pam Gosal said: 'The last thing survivors need after enduring heinous abuse is to be trolled when they bravely speak out about their ordeal. 'Abuse victims deserve to be listened to and supported, not have their trauma reignited by misguided activists. 'Survivors deserve to be at the heart of a Scottish justice system which currently panders to offenders rather than victims.' JIMS has publicly denied harassing victims. One of the group's arguments is that crucial evidence is being ignored by parts of the Criminal Procedure Act, which was designed to protect victims from intrusive questioning. In a statement on its social media yesterday, JIMS said it would hold its silent protest on September 9 - International Falsely Accused Day (IFAD). It said: 'IFAD is a global movement that began to support innocent people caught in broken justice systems. It is not just a Scottish issue. Our colleagues in London and international partners at DAVIA will be gathering too. The world will be watching. 'We stand for justice and fairness. We stand with everyone who has been failed by the system and all the people maintaining their innocence, and all we ask for is FAIR TRIALS - nothing more, nothing less. 'Together, we can raise our voices for change.' The Record contacted JIMS for comment.
Times
7 hours ago
- Times
Man who stepped in front of train with toddler jailed for ten years
A suicidal man who attempted to murder a two-year-old boy by walking in front of a train while carrying the child has been jailed for ten years. Frederick Danquah, 28, stepped in front of a train after being told that his former partner had entered into a new relationship. Both the child, who cannot be named for legal reasons, and Danquah were injured in the incident at Garrowhill railway station in Glasgow's east end in July 2023. Garrowhill railway station, in Glasgow, where the incident took place two years ago Danquah denied attempted murder and another charge of culpable and reckless conduct, regarding another incident on the same date, stating his mental condition as a defence, but he was convicted by a jury at the High Court in Glasgow last month. At the same court on Wednesday, the judge said the 'harm was of the greatest kind' and sentenced Danquah to ten years in prison. He also imposed a non-harassment order until the child is 18. The court heard that earlier that day, Danquah had tried to climb over a footbridge above the M8 in Glasgow with the child on his shoulders, after arguing with his former partner who told him she had 'moved on'. After posting a suicidal message on Facebook, he prepared a 'contingency plan' including a note with contact details, the court heard. Danquah collected the child from relatives and took him into Glasgow city centre and met his sister's partner, before he attempted to climb the bridge over the M8. He was spotted by police but 'reassured them', the court heard, before he travelled to Garrowhill station with the child and made an attempt on their lives. British Transport Police said Danquah sustained a broken jaw and fracture to his neck, while the child suffered cuts and bruises but no serious injuries, and the child was discharged from hospital two days later. Danquah sustained a broken jaw and fracture to his neck but the child escaped serious injury BRITISH TRANSPORT POLICE Sentencing, Judge Tony Kelly said: 'You went to the platform, picked up [the child] and walked into the path of a train. You suffered injuries and [the child] was injured. 'To seek to take the life … over some hours is great criminality. I have no doubt about your intentions. You were intent on taking your own life on July 2, 2023.' He said a train driver 'saw you step in the path of a train' and people involved in the rescue were in 'various stages of upset'. The court heard that Danquah had no previous convictions and was involved in a Ghanaian community group. Danquah made further suicide attempts, including in December 2023, the court heard. Gary Allan, for the defence, said it was a 'horrible miracle' and Danquah was receiving psychiatric help since a 'one-off horror story took place at his own hand'. Allan said Danquah had been 'beaten up by other prisoners', and jail 'will be a living nightmare for him'.
Daily Mail
9 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Jailed for ten years, man who stepped in front of train holding two-year-old child
A man who attempted to murder a toddler by stepping in front of a moving train while holding the child has been jailed for 10 years. Frederick Danquah assaulted the two-year-old in his care at Glasgow 's Garrowhill train station on July 2, 2023. The 28-year-old had been told his relationship with a former partner was over. He was carrying the youngster on his shoulders as the train struck them. Both were injured but the toddler escaped with minor grazes and has since recovered. It came after police let Danquah leave with the boy after he was spotted trying to pull himself and the child ver a fence on a foot bridge over a motorway. Danquah was previously found guilty of attempted murder at the High Court in Glasgow and was yesterday sentenced to 10 years in prison. He was also convicted of culpable and reckless conduct. Danquah had lodged a special defence that he was unable to appreciate his actions due to a mental illness. The court heard yesterday that he was deemed to have an 'adjustment disorder', but was not at a level which absolved him of being criminally responsible. Yesterday a judge condemned Danquah's attempts to kill the boy, saying: 'You meant to have his mother attend his funeral'. The incident had been described as an apparent 'murder suicide' during a previous hearing. Jurors heard how Danquah had struggled to accept his relationship with his partner was over in 2023. She insisted they would not get back together and that she had since met someone else. He ended up alone with the boy on the day of the murder bid. At one stage, he wrote what appeared to be a suicide note and posted it on Facebook. It included: 'I cannot continue to live in this darkness, I guess this is goodbye.' He was later seen with the child on a footbridge over the M8 in the city centre. He repeatedly tried to pull himself and the boy over a fence. Police went on to speak to Danquah, but were reassured enough that they left him with the boy. However, he went on to make his way to Garrowhill station where what his own lawyer called 'a one-off horror story' occurred. CCTV captured Danquah as he had his boy on his shoulders and then stepped in front of a train pulling into the platform. An off-duty nurse was at the station and she helped calm the chaotic scenes until paramedics arrived. The child miraculously suffered only bruising and swelling to his head, back, face and nose. Danquah, however, had fractures to his spine and jaw. The boy's mother later learned of what happened and raced to hospital to see her son. Recalling his condition, she recalled in court: 'He was lying and could not move his body. 'They did not know at the time if there was anything wrong with him. The nurse said he could hear, but was in shock. He had a lot of bruises.' After the incident, Danquah was initially held at a mental health clinic in Glasgow before being discharged. Gary Allan KC, defending, said Danquah continues to need help with prison 'frightening the living daylights out of him'. The advocate said what happened was 'wholly out of character'. Mr Allan said: 'He has asked me to state how sorry he is that he put the child in the position that he did.' Sentencing, Judge Tony Kelly said he had read an emotional impact statement from the boy's mother. He told Danquah: 'The affect on his mother is profound. She is deeply affected. 'She said she felt overwhelmed. She still suffers constant anxiety.' The judge added: 'You endangered the life of the boy, You intended to take his life. 'You meant to have his mother attend his funeral.' Members of Danquah's family broke down in tears as he was led handcuffed to the cells.
