
What the culture war over Superman gets wrong
Superman. Of all symbols.
I've read reactionary thinkpieces, rage-filled quote tweets and screeds about the legal status of a fictional alien – enough to lose count. This particular episode of American Fragility kicked off because James Gunn had the audacity to call Superman 'the story of America'. An immigrant, by definition, as he was always meant to be.
What set things off wasn't just the sentiment – it was who said it, and how plainly. Gunn, now headlining DC's cinematic future, told the Sunday Times that Superman was 'an immigrant who came from other places and populated the country'. He spoke of Superman's inherent kindness as a political statement in itself, noting that the film would play differently in some parts of America before adding, bluntly, that 'there are some jerks out there who are just not kind and will take it as offensive just because it is about kindness'. 'But screw them,' he added. It was that line – less the immigrant metaphor, more the unapologetic framing – that sent the usual outrage machine into motion.
Enter Dean Cain, a former TV Superman. Cain accused Gunn of politicizing the character, which is remarkably foolish, considering Superman's been swatting at fascism since 1941. Meanwhile, over at Fox News, it's been a full meltdown over the idea that Superman, canonically not of this Earth, might be played as … not of this Earth. Liberal brainwashing, they suggested. Identity politics in a cape.
But have they actually looked at David Corenswet? The man looks like he was made to sell oat milk in a Ralph Lauren ad. All cheekbones and cleft chin. If this is the foreign body in question, no wonder middle America has historically shrugged over Supes being an immigrant by definition.
Even still, there's something telling about any collective gasp over a white, blue-eyed man with an immigrant backstory. The scramble to defend him says more than intended. For all the hand-wringing over Superman's alienness, what rarely gets named is how meticulously his story was crafted to cushion the unease of the topic at hand: otherness itself – the very thing people pretend was always central to his character.
There are plenty of ways to frame the ridiculousness of this argument, clever ways to connect the dots, but the real fracture in Superman's myth hits, oddly enough, during a quiet scene in Tarantino's meditation on vengeance, Kill Bill: Vol. 2.
In the scene, the villain, Bill (David Carradine) unpacks what makes Superman different from every other hero.
'What Kent wears – the glasses, the business suit – that's the costume,' Bill says. 'That's the costume Superman wears to blend in with us. Clark Kent is how Superman views us.'
It's one hell of a tell – the kind of observation that pulls back the curtain on how Superman was engineered to understand the world, and how the world, in turn, reinforced how he should fit within it.
From the start, Superman was never meant to be an outsider. His creators, Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster – sons of Jewish immigrants – didn't craft him as a symbol of difference but as a projection of pure Americanness. They gave him a midwestern upbringing, an Anglo name in Clark Kent, and that square-jawed charm.
Siegel and Shuster were working against the backdrop of unchecked antisemitism, at a time when Jewish immigrants faced hostility. But instead of exploring immigrant 'otherness', the artists imagined a version of America where that alienness could be easily discarded via an outfit change. Superman wasn't an outsider – he was the ideal immigrant, effortlessly slipping into a world that required no resistance. His story wasn't about struggling to belong, but about the fantasy of belonging, with the privilege of choosing whether or not to fight for it.
That projection of safe, silent Americanness hasn't remained confined to the pages of comic books. Today's immigration politics run on the same fantasy. The myth of the 'good' immigrant – quiet, grateful, easy to assimilate – still runs wild. It's the same story that fuels the strange spectacle of politicians praising white South African farmers as victims of racial persecution, all while demonizing migrants from Latin America, the Middle East or sub-Saharan Africa.
The notion of who deserves to stay has always been racialized, selective and violent. Tom Homan, Trump's border czar, has said that a person's physical appearance could be a factor in the decision to question them. He later said it could not be 'the sole reason'. But in April, Juan Carlos Lopez-Gomez, a US-born citizen from Georgia, was detained in Florida even after his mother showed authorities his birth certificate. In New York, Elzon Lemus, an electrician, was stopped because he 'looked like someone' agents were after. Maybe he didn't wear his suit and glasses that day.
Superman, the immigrant who makes people comfortable, has never been just a comic book character. He's been a metaphor and living testament to the kind of 'other' that wealthy nations have always preferred: those who blend in, assimilate and rarely challenge the systems that demand their silence.
If you're still not convinced that Superman's assimilationist fantasy is alive and well, just look at a White House meme from 10 July 2025: Trump dressed as Superman, with the words 'Truth. Justice. The American Way.' It's a glaring example of how cultural symbols are repurposed – hijacked, really – to serve a narrow and self-congratulatory vision of America. That's the trick of Superman: he's been a blank canvas of a both-sides heroism, which makes everyone feel seen.
You don't even need to like or dislike Superman for the Maga debate to pull you in, as it was always meant to. The culture war still appointed a celebrity to govern the most powerful nation on Earth. It still turned a corporate diversity initiative into a national crisis. And it took a serious conversation about immigration and made a polished, all-American character its face. The culture war distorts, and it continues, relentless as ever.
Noel Ransome is a Toronto-based freelance writer
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mail
4 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
The real reason why Travis Kelce went Instagram official with Taylor Swift after Chiefs star's smitten photo dump
Travis Kelce finally posted Taylor Swift on social media this week to show how serious their relationship has become, an insider has claimed. The Kansas City Chiefs legend finally went Instagram official with Swift on Thursday after sharing a photo dump of their 'offseason adventures' together. And a source has told People that Kelce providing a rare glimpse of their romance 'wasn't random'. 'It was intentional,' they said about his Instagram post. 'They've been private in their own way, but this was his way of showing how serious things have become.' The insider then added: 'They're in a really solid place and more in sync than ever.' More to follow.


Daily Mail
4 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Oscar-nominated horror movie star of 'cursed' blockbuster looks unrecognizable on rare outing
A horror movie icon who shot to fame in a 'cursed' blockbuster which threw her personal life into turmoil was seen on a rare public outing this week. The Oscar nominated star's debut leading role, saw her become a worldwide star but hit with death threats and sensationally accused of promoting Satanic beliefs. Her later career would be blighted by box office flops as she was 'typecast' as a distressed teen. She was famously arrested for drug possession aged 18, and also posed nude on the cover of Playboy five years later. In recent years she has pivoted from acting to a focus on her animal rescue - although did reprise her most iconic role in the film's 2023 sequel. So can you guess who she is? It's The Exorcist star Linda Blair! The actress, now 66, starred as possessed Regan MacNeil in the iconic 1973 film aged just 14. Blair cut a low-key figure in a black tee, straw hat and high waisted trousers as she wheeled her suitcase at LAX. The original movie debuted in December 1973, following Chris MacNeil (Ellen Burstyn) as she enlists the help of two priests (Max Von Sydow and William O'Malley) to exorcise a demon from her daughter Regan. William Friedkin (The French Connection) directed the original, with The Exorcist author William Peter Blatty writing the screenplay adaptation based on his book. Fans who flocked to the sensational film, were shocked at scenes that showed Blair's character involved in terrible violence and profanity. In one gruesome moment Regan is shown masturbating with a crucifix. Other scenes show the character's head-spinning and vomiting over a priest, who was trying to expel the demon from Regan's body. The Exorcist was controversial and subsequently banned or restricted in some countries - and it was even claimed the film was 'cursed' after a mysterious set fire and mishaps during production. Friedkin himself said: 'We were plagued by strange and sinister things from the beginning, it is simply the hardest thing I have ever done in my life.' The film is still considered to be one of the scariest movies of all time, earning $441 million at the box office and earning 10 Oscar nominations, making history as the first horror movie ever to earn a Best Picture nomination. The role earned Blair a Golden Globe for Best Supporting Actress, and an Academy Award nomination for Best Supporting Actress. At the time of the film's release, rumors spread Blair had been killed off during its making. There were other stories that the young star had survived the film, but had come away psychologically damaged after acting out the demonic possession. Blair later reprised her role as Regan in the Exorcist sequel, Exorcist II: The Heretic in 1977 - which was a critical and commercial failure. That same year aged 18 she was charged with conspiracy to commit a felony in the alleged sale and purchase of cocaine. She pleaded guilty to a reduced charge of conspiracy to possess cocaine, in exchange for three years' probation. Blair fractured her spine while thrashing around on a mechanical bed for the film - with the injury developing into scoliosis. Blair would never reach the heights of her The Exorcist performance again. In 1974 she starred as a runaway teenager suffering sexual abuse in controversial TV film Born Innocent. That same year aged 15 she dated Australian singer Rick Springfield, who was 25 at the time. Establishing herself as a Scream Queen, she starred in horror films including Stranger in Our House in 1978, Hell Night in 1981 and and Grotesque in 1988. She was nominated for five Razzie Awards between 1980-1985. On a trip to Australia in 2013, Linda Blair admitted to the Daily Telegraph that the films producers had deliberately spread rumors about her and the movie to stir up controversy. 'There was all this negativity about what I had been through, so I began this world press tour,' she explained. 'I went out to England and Australia and all over the world to talk about the film and to show that I was fine.' In 1982 in an attempt to break free of her horror movie roots, she posed nude for Playboy. In 1996 she made a cameo in Scream and appeared on Broadway the following year in Grease. In 2006, she guest-starred on Supernatural, playing the part of Detective Diana Ballard. In 2010, she appeared as herself on the cable series Pit Boss and Jury Duty. Before The Exorcist: Believer, her last screen role was in ghost drama Landfill in 2021. She reprised her Regan role again in 2023's The Exorcist: Believer.


Reuters
4 minutes ago
- Reuters
Kennedy to oust care task force, WSJ reports; HHS says no decision yet
WASHINGTON, July 25 (Reuters) - U.S. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is planning to remove all the members of an advisory panel that determines what cancer screenings and other preventive health measures insurers must cover, the Wall Street Journal reported on Friday, citing people familiar with the matter. A Department of Health and Human Services spokesperson said on Friday that Kennedy had not yet made a decision regarding the 16-member U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. "No final decision has been made on how the USPSTF can better support HHS' mandate to Make America Healthy Again," the HHS spokesperson said. The Journal said Kennedy planned to dismiss all 16 panel members in what would be the latest in a series of far-reaching actions by Kennedy, a long-time vaccine skeptic, to reshape U.S. regulation of vaccines, food and medicine. In June he fired all 17 members of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, a panel of vaccine experts, replacing them with seven handpicked members, including known vaccine skeptics. The USPSTF includes medical experts serving staggered four-year terms on a volunteer basis. Its role in choosing what services will be covered by insurers was established under the 2010 Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare. The 40-year-old group, whose recommendations provide guidance to doctors, looks at everything from routine breast cancer screening to drugs to prevent HIV infection. The U.S. Supreme Court in June upheld the constitution of the task force and ruled in favor of its recommendation to cover preventive care. Though made up of an independent group of volunteer experts, members are selected by the health secretary without Senate confirmation and it relies on support from the department's Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. A group of 104 health organizations, opens new tab, including the American Medical Association and the American Academy of Pediatrics, in early July sent a letter to Congressional health committees, urging them "to protect the integrity" of the task force. The task force has been criticized by some conservatives, opens new tab as too left-leaning.