From a Lygon era: Why I can't cop a Silvagni at Collingwood
Carlton lost the great Alex Jesaulenko to St Kilda as a consequence of a political storm after the 1979 premiership, the season after another celebrated Blue and future coach, Robert Walls, crossed to Fitzroy.
Four-time Carlton premiership hero David 'Swan' McKay was a teammate of Jezza and Walls in those glorious and tumultuous times. In his view, the defection of a third generation Silvagni to Collingwood would be worse than the Blues losing his more decorated teammates.
'It was bad enough to see Wallsy end up at Fitzroy and Jezza at St Kilda,' said McKay, who played alongside Jack Silvagni's late grandfather, family patriarch Sergio Silvagni, in the fabled 1970 premiership.
'To have a Silvagni ending up at Collingwood would be even worse.'
Would it really be worse? Not so – Jezza leaving was as wrenching as Ron Barassi's exit from Melbourne. But I share McKay's perspective that it would be jarring – read, flat-out wrong – to see Jack Silvagni running around for the Pies.
The Silvagnis are not merely 'another' Carlton family. They are the clan most identified with Carlton, whose history on the field – and in supporting roles at the club – is deeper and longer than others. They also have been crucial in fostering the bonds between Lygon Street/the Italian community and the Blues.
Today, it's a safe assumption that more Carlton fans – certainly Millennials and Gen Z – would fret about the prospect of seeing Charlie Curnow in another club's jumper than watching the son of SOS in the despised black-and-white stripes.
Curnow is arguably Carlton's premier player, a rare forward who gets people up and out of their seats when he's firing. To lose him would be terrible – unless, of course, the Blues could prise someone younger of similar value in return, e.g. Max Holmes, Errol Gulden or Hugh McCluggage, which is about as feasible as Joe Daniher coming out of retirement to play for Melbourne.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Advertiser
20 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Dog and Dogga all smiles as Sean Darcy hits his straps
Fremantle ruckman Sean Darcy is finally pain free and ready to hit the tail end of the season with a bang - and his dog couldn't be happier. The Dockers (13-6) have won nine of their past 10 matches to put themselves in the mix to nab a top-four berth with just four games will start as hot favourites in Sunday's clash with Carlton at Optus Stadium, and follow-up wins against Port Adelaide (away), Brisbane (home) and the Bulldogs (away) would almost certainly net them a prized double chance come finals endured soft tissue injuries to go with knee and ankle complaints across 2023 and 2024, and there were more questions about his durability following a slow start this year. But the 27-year-old has built nicely over recent weeks, and importantly is now pulling up well from games."It wasn't great before," Darcy said of his next-day soreness following matches. "My dog didn't like me too much the next day after games. I wasn't taking him for walks too much. "I'm pulling up a lot better now, and that's a credit to our rehab staff and our strength and conditioning staff." The ruck combination of Darcy and Luke "Dogga" Jackson, which has come under heavy scrutiny in the past, is starting to pay big dividends. The evolving nature of the relationship means that when Darcy is in the ruck, Jackson often spends time as a big-bodied midfielder, giving Fremantle an X-factor. "I love the big fella. We're quite close off field as well, which makes it a bit easier," Darcy said. "We're pretty selfless, both of us." One quandary Darcy has encountered this year is the big question of who he should hit it to when he's competing for a ruck tap. Hayden Young, Andrew Brayshaw, Caleb Serong and Shai Bolton are all A-grade midfielders, and Jackson is just as hungry to receive the ball when he's part of the engine room. "I've got to keep them all happy - that's half the battle," Darcy said with a laugh. "But no, we're a pretty selfless group. If we're winning, that's the main thing." Young, playing just his second match back from hamstring surgery, won the Glendinning-Allan medal as best afield for his 23-disposal, three-goal display against West Coast last week. "I had some chats with him in rehab, and that's a pretty dark place when you have multiple surgeries or multiple repeat injuries," Darcy said. "He put his head down, and he worked, and you saw what kind of player he is." Fremantle ruckman Sean Darcy is finally pain free and ready to hit the tail end of the season with a bang - and his dog couldn't be happier. The Dockers (13-6) have won nine of their past 10 matches to put themselves in the mix to nab a top-four berth with just four games will start as hot favourites in Sunday's clash with Carlton at Optus Stadium, and follow-up wins against Port Adelaide (away), Brisbane (home) and the Bulldogs (away) would almost certainly net them a prized double chance come finals endured soft tissue injuries to go with knee and ankle complaints across 2023 and 2024, and there were more questions about his durability following a slow start this year. But the 27-year-old has built nicely over recent weeks, and importantly is now pulling up well from games."It wasn't great before," Darcy said of his next-day soreness following matches. "My dog didn't like me too much the next day after games. I wasn't taking him for walks too much. "I'm pulling up a lot better now, and that's a credit to our rehab staff and our strength and conditioning staff." The ruck combination of Darcy and Luke "Dogga" Jackson, which has come under heavy scrutiny in the past, is starting to pay big dividends. The evolving nature of the relationship means that when Darcy is in the ruck, Jackson often spends time as a big-bodied midfielder, giving Fremantle an X-factor. "I love the big fella. We're quite close off field as well, which makes it a bit easier," Darcy said. "We're pretty selfless, both of us." One quandary Darcy has encountered this year is the big question of who he should hit it to when he's competing for a ruck tap. Hayden Young, Andrew Brayshaw, Caleb Serong and Shai Bolton are all A-grade midfielders, and Jackson is just as hungry to receive the ball when he's part of the engine room. "I've got to keep them all happy - that's half the battle," Darcy said with a laugh. "But no, we're a pretty selfless group. If we're winning, that's the main thing." Young, playing just his second match back from hamstring surgery, won the Glendinning-Allan medal as best afield for his 23-disposal, three-goal display against West Coast last week. "I had some chats with him in rehab, and that's a pretty dark place when you have multiple surgeries or multiple repeat injuries," Darcy said. "He put his head down, and he worked, and you saw what kind of player he is." Fremantle ruckman Sean Darcy is finally pain free and ready to hit the tail end of the season with a bang - and his dog couldn't be happier. The Dockers (13-6) have won nine of their past 10 matches to put themselves in the mix to nab a top-four berth with just four games will start as hot favourites in Sunday's clash with Carlton at Optus Stadium, and follow-up wins against Port Adelaide (away), Brisbane (home) and the Bulldogs (away) would almost certainly net them a prized double chance come finals endured soft tissue injuries to go with knee and ankle complaints across 2023 and 2024, and there were more questions about his durability following a slow start this year. But the 27-year-old has built nicely over recent weeks, and importantly is now pulling up well from games."It wasn't great before," Darcy said of his next-day soreness following matches. "My dog didn't like me too much the next day after games. I wasn't taking him for walks too much. "I'm pulling up a lot better now, and that's a credit to our rehab staff and our strength and conditioning staff." The ruck combination of Darcy and Luke "Dogga" Jackson, which has come under heavy scrutiny in the past, is starting to pay big dividends. The evolving nature of the relationship means that when Darcy is in the ruck, Jackson often spends time as a big-bodied midfielder, giving Fremantle an X-factor. "I love the big fella. We're quite close off field as well, which makes it a bit easier," Darcy said. "We're pretty selfless, both of us." One quandary Darcy has encountered this year is the big question of who he should hit it to when he's competing for a ruck tap. Hayden Young, Andrew Brayshaw, Caleb Serong and Shai Bolton are all A-grade midfielders, and Jackson is just as hungry to receive the ball when he's part of the engine room. "I've got to keep them all happy - that's half the battle," Darcy said with a laugh. "But no, we're a pretty selfless group. If we're winning, that's the main thing." Young, playing just his second match back from hamstring surgery, won the Glendinning-Allan medal as best afield for his 23-disposal, three-goal display against West Coast last week. "I had some chats with him in rehab, and that's a pretty dark place when you have multiple surgeries or multiple repeat injuries," Darcy said. "He put his head down, and he worked, and you saw what kind of player he is."
West Australian
21 hours ago
- West Australian
Fremantle Dockers remain unchanged for pivotal clash with Carlton at Optus Stadium
Fremantle will take an unchanged team into their clash with Carlton in a pivotal weekend for the club's finals pursuit. In a round where much of the competition's top eight play each other, the Dockers have the chance to earn a place in the top five with a win over the Blues at Optus Stadium. The Western Bulldogs have already done the men in purple a favour, belting the Giants by 88 points to lift Fremantle into seventh on percentage, while they could also jump Hawthorn and Brisbane should those two sides lose to Adelaide and Collingwood, respectively. Hayden Young will likely play increased minutes after being subbed out in his Glendinning-Allan Medal-winning performance in the western derby as the three-pronged attack of Josh Treacy, Pat Voss and Jye Amiss will put pressure on Carlton's struggling defence. The Blues are missing Charlie Curnow, whose season is over after knee surgery, as well as former Docker Adam Cerra. Sam Docherty retired after last week's clash with Hawthorn. Fremantle will need to overcome a poor record against the Blues, having won just one of their past five meetings, with Carlton claiming their last clash at Adelaide Oval in 2024 by 10 points. Alex Pearce will miss a fourth consecutive game. However, Justin Longmuir said he was confident the key defender would be ready to play a significant role in the last month of the season after battling shin splints. 'We've probably been a little bit more conservative this time. So that should hold him in good stead,' Longmuir said. Fremantle resisted the urge to bring dual Brownlow medallist Nat Fyfe straight back into the seniors as a sub, opting to instead give him a run in the WAFL with Peel Thunder. Sunday, Optus Stadium, 3.10pm DOCKERS B: L Ryan B Cox O McDonald HB: H Chapman K Worner J Clark C: J O'Meara H Young N O'Driscoll HF: S Switkowski P Voss S Bolton F: M Frederick J Treacy J Amiss FOLL: L Jackson C Serong A Brayshaw I/C: S Darcy M Reid B Banfield N Erasmus I Dudley EMG: B Walker W Brodie J Draper BLUES B: A Saad J Weitering M Carroll HB: L Cowan H O'Farrell N Haynes C: B Acres P Cripps C Lord HF: Z Williams J Motlop O Hollands F: L Fogarty H McKay W White FOLL: T De Koning G Hewett A Moir I/C: M Pittonet F Young L Young F Evans C Durdin EMG: J Binns J Boyd H O'Keeffe
Perth Now
21 hours ago
- Perth Now
Dockers take unchanged team into pivotal Carlton clash
Hear what Eagles and Dockers fans had to say after Saturday's western derby Fremantle will take an unchanged team into their clash with Carlton in a pivotal weekend for the club's finals pursuit. In a round where much of the competition's top eight play each other, the Dockers have the chance to earn a place in the top five with a win over the Blues at Optus Stadium. The Western Bulldogs have already done the men in purple a favour, belting the Giants by 88 points to lift Fremantle into seventh on percentage, while they could also jump Hawthorn and Brisbane should those two sides lose to Adelaide and Collingwood, respectively. Hayden Young will likely play increased minutes after being subbed out in his Glendinning-Allan Medal-winning performance in the western derby as the three-pronged attack of Josh Treacy, Pat Voss and Jye Amiss will put pressure on Carlton's struggling defence. The Blues are missing Charlie Curnow, whose season is over after knee surgery, as well as former Docker Adam Cerra. Sam Docherty retired after last week's clash with Hawthorn. Fremantle will need to overcome a poor record against the Blues, having won just one of their past five meetings, with Carlton claiming their last clash at Adelaide Oval in 2024 by 10 points. Alex Pearce will miss a fourth consecutive game. However, Justin Longmuir said he was confident the key defender would be ready to play a significant role in the last month of the season after battling shin splints. 'We've probably been a little bit more conservative this time. So that should hold him in good stead,' Longmuir said. Fremantle resisted the urge to bring dual Brownlow medallist Nat Fyfe straight back into the seniors as a sub, opting to instead give him a run in the WAFL with Peel Thunder. Sunday, Optus Stadium, 3.10pm DOCKERS B: L Ryan B Cox O McDonald HB: H Chapman K Worner J Clark C: J O'Meara H Young N O'Driscoll HF: S Switkowski P Voss S Bolton F: M Frederick J Treacy J Amiss FOLL: L Jackson C Serong A Brayshaw I/C: S Darcy M Reid B Banfield N Erasmus I Dudley EMG: B Walker W Brodie J Draper BLUES B: A Saad J Weitering M Carroll HB: L Cowan H O'Farrell N Haynes C: B Acres P Cripps C Lord HF: Z Williams J Motlop O Hollands F: L Fogarty H McKay W White FOLL: T De Koning G Hewett A Moir I/C: M Pittonet F Young L Young F Evans C Durdin EMG: J Binns J Boyd H O'Keeffe
