‘Wasting everybody's time': AFL Tribunal ‘farce' laid bare
The Blues star walked away from Tuesday night's hearing with a $5,500 fine, a mere $125 closer to the Blues' hoped figure of a five grand figure than the AFL's $6,125. The end sanction was $750 less than he could have received had the league got its way.
FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer.
Speaking on Fox Footy's AFL 360, host and veteran broadcaster Gerard Whateley was pointed in his assessment of the league's handling of a process that required plenty of resources for so such a minuscule outcome.
'I've covered the Tribunal since I was a cub reporter. I've seen high farce, when cases were cooked up in the lifts and the chairman present!' Gerard Whateley began.
'I've seen players blatantly lie and pure themselves. I've heard bio-mechanists invent the most fanciful stories. I have seen character witness, submissions from Prime Ministers to lower penalties...
'Tonight, the AFL has reached new levels of high farce, as they quibbled over $1,250 with a panel of lawyers who will shortly bill for about $30,000.'
The AFL's introduction of a Tribunal hearing for any player who is sanctioned for umpire contact four times in 12 months allows the league leeway to argue for a player's suspension.
MATT ROWELL — 4
GEORGE HEWETT — 4
JACK MACRAE — 4
ZAK BUTTERS — 3
JORDAN DAWSON — 3
HARLEY REID — 3
WILLEM DREW — 3
HUNTER CLARK — 3
Four umpires have been concussed as a result of umpire contact in the last 12 months, which was undoubtedly a big part of the AFL's reason to crack down on the contact as Whateley explained.
'I don't dismiss the broader principal, which is important... (but) it has gone too far. The AFL is duty-bound to its umpires to address it — the only way to do that is to confront players,' continued Whateley.
'But to go into a Tribunal hearing with two lawyers, Jeff Gleeson — who's one of the country's most esteemed — the two members of the jury and the admin staff ... to quibble over $1,250 to set this principal, I don't think they have quite achieved what they wanted to achieve.
'If you wanted to make a stand, and a stand worth making, you had to leave the spectre of suspension on the table — at least for a while, but that was withdrawn immediately.
'This is just wasting everybody's time. If you want to ramp the fines up, just write it into the guidelines and ramp the fines up.'
Cerra will line up for Carlton this Saturday night when the Blues go up against Melbourne.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
26 minutes ago
- ABC News
Three teenagers killed in north Queensland car crash
Three teenagers have died in a car crash in north Queensland overnight. Emergency services were called to Mackay Ring Road in the Mackay suburb of Glenella about 10:30pm after reports of a crash involving multiple vehicles. Police allege three teenagers were travelling in a Mazda sedan when it collided head-on with another car, with a third vehicle also becoming involved. Two teenage boys and a teenage girl were declared dead at the scene. Three other people were assessed for injuries, with one man taken to Mackay Base Hospital with minor leg injuries. The Forensic Crash unit is investigating. Authorities have urged anyone with information or relevant dash-cam footage to contact police.
News.com.au
26 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Detective reveals the subtle clue that gave away Daniel Morcombe's killer Brett Cowan immediately
From the minute retired detective Dennis Martyn drove up the driveway of paedophile Brett Peter Cowan's house just two weeks after the disappearance of 13-year-old Sunshine Coast schoolboy Daniel Morcombe, he knew something was off. 'His house was on the front of the block,' he explains, 'there was a lot of - I wouldn't say kids' toys - but there were a lot of things around in the yard, like little windmills that Cowen had made, all sorts of things he would take to markets and sell. But they were painted in such a way that to me, I thought a kid would want them, you know? There were butterflies on the blades of the windmills and all this sort of stuff.' 'I said to [detective Ken King, Martyn's partner] straight away: 'that's a bit strange, mate. It just looks like a kid's area'. And I knew he didn't have any children at that age.' But it was the conversation Martyn would have with the house's inhabitant that would change everything. From the moment Martyn and King left Cowan's house that day in December 2003, they were convinced he was their suspect. Sitting down with fellow ex-detective Gary Jubelin for an episode of Jubelin's podcast I Catch Killers, Martyn recalled the moment, over 20 years ago, that convinced him Cowan was the perpetrator. It was two weeks since Daniel had last been seen waiting for a bus, on his way to buy Christmas gifts for his family. Martyn, who at the time was working as a senior constable on Task Force Argos, a team responsible for investigating child sex offences, had been handed the file. 'At that time, they gave you a series of folders [full] of convicted, released sex offenders in that area,' he tells Jubelin. 'Our job was to go around and check out their bona fides. If they said, 'I was at the shop at that time', you would spend half the day going to the shop, getting CCTV to verify their alibi. That's how we came up, and one of the people in the file was Brett Peter Cowan.' Martyn was already aware of Cowan's criminal history, most notably his 1993 conviction for the horrific rape of a six-year-old child in the Northern Territory. He was also aware that a white 4WD with a black snorkel had been seen near the underpass where Daniel Morcombe was last seen, which matched the description of Cowan's vehicle. Once they'd arrived at Cowan's house, the two officers began questioning the paedophile about his whereabouts on the day of Daniel's disappearance. After admitting he 'might have gone in and picked something up at Nambour' around the time Daniel was last seen on the Nambour Connection Road, Martyn says Cowan was 'acting cocky.' 'He was a skinny sort of fellow, and every movement was accentuated, that's sort of the way he was,' Martyn recalls. 'He was very cocky and straight away I didn't like him. I said to Ken, 'just keep an eye on this bloke, mate'.' 'I said, 'did you happen to see a little child with black hair on the underpass from the other side near the bus stop?' [Cowan said] 'No, no, no. Not at all. Never saw anybody.' I said, 'well, did you see a white 4WD with a snorkel on it?' 'No.' 'I said, 'do you think it is a coincidence that you drive a white car with a snorkel on, and it's a four wheel drive, and someone's saying they saw something similar on that side of the road?'' Martyn decided it was time to apply more pressure. 'I said, 'you're a paedophile. A bad one by the sounds of it. And Daniel is in your [preferred] age group'. And he goes: 'well, he looked it.'' 'I said, 'did he? That's strange. I thought you said you didn't see anyone,' [and he said], 'oh, well I might have pulled over.'' 'I said: 'so now we've established two things. First, you've pulled over and you reckon you've seen Daniel, and [second] you're a liar. But we all know you're a liar, because paedophiles are liars.' And then he started to get cranky.' In spite of this, and the officers' conviction that Cowan was responsible for Daniel's abduction, it would be another eight harrowing years for the Morcombe family before their son's remains were found, and Cowan apprehended after a lengthy undercover sting operation which became the subject of the 2022 Netflix film The Stranger, starring Joel Edgerton. But it wasn't for Martyn and King's lack of trying. 'Ken briefed the major incident room the next day,' Martyn explains. 'And that was it. It was quietly dismissed.' 'So that people understand the working of a strike force, whether it be in Queensland or down here,' explains Jubelin, 'all that information comes in at briefings. As you said, Ken briefed the major incident team and said, 'OK, this is our take on it'. You've done the report, submitted that, and you would think that there would be some priority given to what needs to be done.' 'At that point in time, our report dictated that that should have been the case,' agrees Martyn. 'My reports are reasonably concise and very clear and accurate in relation to what recommendations should and should not be done. 'The recommendations on that report were very clear - basically, he's your main suspect. If he's not, he should be, and everything should be done to rule him in rather than trying to rule him out … but they never even went and seized his computers.' Brett Peter Cowan is currently serving a life sentence for the murder of Daniel Morcombe and will be eligible for parole in 2031.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Siblings who discovered the body of Rosemary Brown 25 years ago speak publicly for the first time
It was a crisp winter's day on July 2, 2000, when Sarah and James Fidock went fishing with their father on Garden Island in Adelaide's north-west. Sarah was 10 years old, while James was eight. They quickly grew bored of waiting for a fish to bite, so they started to explore the shoreline in search of rock crabs. The tide was out as the pair walked through the dense mangroves with their buckets in hand. What the siblings were about to find would stay with them for the rest of their lives. The body of 33-year-old Rosemary Brown was lying face down submerged in thick mud. She and her 15-year-old daughter Melissa Trussell had been missing for seven weeks. James found the body first and was shocked by what he had stumbled across. "She was lying there, fairly decomposed at that point. I think some of the sea creatures must have gotten to her at that point too," he said. His older sister Sarah was terrified. She still remembers the moment vividly. "I was really scared, my mind went to automatically, you know, the [alleged] killer could still be out here, we've got to get out of here ... That's where my mind went as a 10-year-old," she said. The pair ran back to find their father, who was still fishing on the jetty. He took them straight to the Port Adelaide Police Station to report what they had found. Sarah said police officers asked the children if they could have mistaken the body for a doll or mannequin. "I could describe what she was wearing, she was wearing black tracksuit pants," she said. "They had the elastic bands at her ankles, she was wearing sneakers and she was wearing a flannelette top, and she had long hair, and she was face down." The sun had set and the tide had come in by the time the Fidock family returned to the island with detectives. It took police about half an hour to locate Rosemary's body in the dark as Sarah led the way. "She was probably 150 metres from the shore and so I've had to walk — put the big police gumboots on to walk — through water and sludge and everything else," she said. It's now 25 later and Rosemary's daughter, Melissa, has still not been found. Police believe the teenager and her mother were murdered but detectives have no motive and no one has ever been charged in relation to their disappearance. Police launched a new appeal this month to help solve the 25-year-old cold case, and police divers spent Friday searching the waters and coast of Garden Island in an area not previously explored. SA Police suspended the search on Friday afternoon and said a vehicle had been located in the area, with further inquiries to be undertaken to determine whether it is connected to the case. They are also forensically re-testing evidence with new technology that was unavailable 25 years ago. Until now, the Fidock siblings have never spoken publicly about their discovery. Sarah has not been able to return to Garden Island, she doesn't go to the beach, and has never gone fishing again. She said she always hoped Melissa was still alive and has decided to finally speak to shed light on the case. "But for her to still be lost out there, and there's a family that don't know where she is and who need her home, if I can do just a little something, then it's about time that I do it." James, now 33, feels the same, and said Rosemary and Melissa's family deserve to know what happened. "Coming up yearly and seeing that the family hasn't had closure still does affect me and my sister to this day," he said. "I hope it's done as soon as possible, they deserve closure, everyone deserves closure for it." Both Sarah and James, who now have young children of their own, have praised SA Police for how their family were supported after finding Rosemary's body. Police have offered a reward of up to $1,000,000 for information and assistance that leads to the conviction of those responsible for the suspected murder of Melissa, while a reward of up to $200,000 has been on offer for the same in Rosemary's case. The Fidock siblings have joined renewed calls from police and family members for any information on the case. "I'm sorry that, you know, we found her — that also makes me feel guilty," Sarah said. "We didn't do anything, but knowing that we were a part of them [the family] having their hearts broken, that also hurts us.
