Our elders deserve dignity and the Government has a duty to protect its citizens – shock RTE programme showed failing
It exposed multiple failings at Residence
Advertisement
3
A new RTE investigation uncovered how residents were being treated in the nursing home
Credit: Getty Images - Getty
3
Natasha Newsome Drennan has urged the government to take action to protect its citizens
Credit: Wikipedia
The Health and Information Quality Authority (HIQA) is now reviewing all EMEIS homes, but it is a terrible indictment of the industry and not the first time abuse has been uncovered in
EMEIS has apologised and said the findings were 'deeply distressing, wholly unjustifiable, and entirely unacceptable'. It has also launched a review.
The HIQA investigation will hopefully unvcover the extent of the abuse but it is clear a lot needs to change.
Older people should be treated with dignity and respect in their later years and their
Advertisement
READ MORE OPINION
Here
IRELAND'S older people deserve dignity – and the highest-quality care.
What we have witnessed in the
But sadly, this is not the first time we have seen scandals in the care sector. We have had the Emily Case, Brandan Case, Grace Case, Áras Attracta and many more.
Advertisement
Most read in The Irish Sun
Exclusive
Breaking
For over a decade, professional bodies, experts and advocates have pointed to weak regulation, failures in standards and an absence of safeguarding, all on the watch of
This programme points to the need for better regulation of nursing homes and the need for adult safeguarding legislation. The Irish Association of Social Workers has demanded this for years, as has Sinn Fein.
We need mandatory reporting of abuse and neglect, and a legal right of entry for social care teams to investigate individual complaints.
BROKEN PROMISE
Sinn Fein is committed to empowering older people to live independently, building a
Advertisement
We have advocated for a comprehensive social care policy to support independent living for people and groups with identified additional needs, including targeted funding to tackle loneliness and isolation, particularly among older people and people living alone.
People deserve to live in their own
But waiting lists for home support are growing and the promised statutory home-care scheme never materialised.
Another broken promise by Fianna Fail and Fine Gael.
Advertisement
The State should support older people to 'age in place', through home support and adaptation grants. Long-term residential care should be available for those who want or need it, but it should not be the default option.
Long-term residential care will, however, always be the appropriate care setting for some. Our ambition must be to provide assessable, afford-able, safe and quality care.
REALISTIC PROPOSALS
Sinn Fein has set out realistic, deliverable proposals to improve access to care for all our citizens.
We proposed to mandate the Commission on Care to future-proof the model of care for aging. We would support family carers, as outlined in our Charter for Carers, and invest in day services for older people.
Advertisement
We would also support specific programmes for those with dementia,
We also point to weaknesses in regulation which have led to a failure in standards in some care settings, and instances of neglect and abuse. This is intolerable — and it is a scandal that this
Sinn Fein would urgently enact adult safeguarding legislation.
This would provide a legal framework to support safeguarding, additional power for social workers and relevant social care professionals — and an agency, separate from the
Advertisement
We would legislate to provide a legal right of entry to any designated care centre for relevant social workers and social care professionals.
We would also legislate for a care partner scheme similar to that which operates in the north of
WAKE-UP CALL
This scheme was highly successful at reducing isolation and improving health outcomes during the
It gives a right to a family or friends acting as care partners to combat isolation and, during public health emergencies, assist in care-giving in residential facilities.
HIQA regulation is not enough. We cannot dismiss abuse or neglect or adopt an out-of-sight, out-of-mind approach. Our elderly citizens deserve to receive the highest quality of care and to be kept safe from harm.
Advertisement
We also need to invest in public nursing home capacity.
Over 70 per cent of nursing home capacity is now private. But privatisation of nursing home care is wrong.
We need to tip the balance back in favour of public capacity, with robust regulations and appropriate safeguarding.
It is the duty of any Government to keep all citizens safe and protected from harm.
Advertisement
The Prime Time program is another wake-up call.
We can no longer accept or tolerate sub-standard care or abuse and neglect of our elderly citizens.
They deserve so much better.
3
It points to the need for better regulation of nursing homes and the need for adult safeguarding legislation
Credit: Getty Images - Getty
Advertisement
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
a day ago
- The Irish Sun
Major blow for Irish families as Laya to hike health insurance prices in weeks with some plans scrapped
Premiums are set to increase by an average of 4.5 per cent PRICE HIKES Major blow for Irish families as Laya to hike health insurance prices in weeks with some plans scrapped HEALTH insurers Laya Healthcare are set to raise their prices in weeks - with some families facing hikes of over 700. Premiums are set to increase by an average of 4.5 per cent on a number plans from October. 2 Laya healthcare is increasing rates on a number of plans Credit: Laya These increases will only apply to new policies and renewals from October and existing policyholders unaffected. Advertisement The health insurer is also retiring 10 of its existing policies. Any customers with these existing plans will automatically be switched to an equivalent plan on their renewal date. Laya will legally need to contact these customers and offer alternative options with similar benefits. Health Insurance Expert Dermot Goode said the hikes were 'expected as they're following previous trends' of increasing rates twice per year - in April and October. Advertisement The previous increase was an average 6.6 per cent which occurred in April 2025. Mr Goode said: 'This average of this latest increase is 4.5 per cent. However, members need to be wary of these average figures as the actual increase on their plan may be significantly higher 'The reason for the increase is the rising cost of claims, especially from the private hospital sector. 'It appears that all insurers are still struggling to contain these costs especially as members want access to the new emerging treatments, drug therapies and technology.' Advertisement The insurance pro said some plans will not be increasing at all such as Assure Protect, Inspire and Inspire Plus. He said: 'The Signify Care scheme will increase by c. €54 per adult or €80 for a typical family, in line with the average. 'Other plans such as Simply Connect Plus will see a much higher increase, i.e. €289 for an adult or €716 for a family (12 per cent). 'Another plan, Momentum will increase by €283 or 10 per cent for a single adult.' Mr Goode said the advice to all consumers now is to 'never just accept these increases' and 'don't allow your cover to auto-renew'. Advertisement He continued: 'Members have six weeks now to engage with the insurer to source alternative, better value, cover. 'Always disclose your budget and challenge the insurer to find you a similar cover that fits this.' OPTIONS All insurers including Laya will be launching a range of lower cost options to help consumers who will struggle to afford these hikes. Mr Goode added: 'Unfortunately more increases are expected as insurers look to review their rates in advance of the peak renewal period when half the market or c. 1.25 million members look to renew their cover 'These latest increases may be less for families as Laya is introducing some discounted offers for children under 18.' Advertisement Managing Director of Laya healthcare D.O O'Connor told RTE that the cost of delivering healthcare is "going up across the world, and Ireland is no exception". He said: "Demand for health services is at an all-time high, particularly in the private and hi-tech hospital settings where we're seeing a 14.8 per cent increase in 2025 claim costs (year-to-date) when compared to last year. "While advances in medical technology and new therapies are delivering welcome improvements in health outcomes for our members, this comes at the highest cost we've seen in over 25 years. "Our product review aims to strike a careful balance between delivering fast access to healthcare while safeguarding affordability of cover for our members. " 2 Laya Healthcare will introduce the new dates from October 1 Credit: Laya Healthcare
The Journal
a day ago
- The Journal
HIQA confirmed two new children's care homes on same day it said operator breached standards
THE OPERATOR OF a number of private care homes for children with disabilities was given permission to open two new homes on the same day that a report detailed a number of breaches of standards at an existing site. Inspectors at a care home for children with disabilities in April said Irish company Lotus Care Ltd was not compliant with a number of care standards and that development plans for residents were not properly completed. The firm, who owns and operates a number of centres in the midlands, had previously been told to make improvements to a child's timetable at a different facility earlier this year, after inspectors found it repeated for months on end – except for one trip to the zoo . The Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa), the agency in charge of inspecting and monitoring residential care centres for children, did not explain why it approved two new sites owned by Lotus Care Ltd when asked by The Journal. An inspection report at Lime Tree Lodge in Co Offaly, published on 18 July, detailed that staff had no received proper training in a number of skills. It also highlighted governance failures in respect of this oversight. A Lotus Care spokesperson has said it welcomed Hiqa's review of Lime Tree Lodge and 'fully accepts the findings of the inspection report'. The firm noted that the majority of the inspector's findings were 'overwhelmingly positive'. On the same day the report was uploaded to Hiqa's website, the authority also published documentation showing that it had approved two new sites operated by Lotus Care, Willow Brook in Co Laois and Cedar Lodge in Offaly. Willow Brook was approved exactly three months after the unannounced inspection at Lime Tree Lodge and Cedar Lodge was fully registered the day before the review was made public. A spokesperson for Hiqa said that providers are obliged to apply to register all new centres with the authority, adding that an operator's fitness and ability to comply with standards is also examined prior to approval. Advertisement Hiqa's Chief Inspector of Social Services Finbarr Colfer, who has the responsibility to approve new centres, recently told the Oireachtas that meeting and being compliant with care requirements are the basic standards for all providers . The Ombudsman for Children's office told The Journal that the state has a 'duty' to protect the rights of children with disabilities who are cared for outside their homes, in respect of education, healthcare and participation in society. 'Standards and inspections are a crucial part of the delivery of high-quality care and ensure the continual improvement in service delivery for children,' it said, adding that the state must also 'ensure they receive high-quality care'. Despite being the watchdog of residential care centres, such as nursing homes, Colfer also told the Oireachtas that Hiqa does not have legislative powers to regulate facilities for children . While HIQA carries out inspections on the facilities, it is unclear which agency regulates them as both the HSE and Tusla have told The Journal they do not. The unannounced inspection at Lime Tree Lodge, carried out in April, found that the two residents living there at the time were relaxed and happy. They also noted that the staff were aware of their needs, preferences and interests. It added, however, that staff members were not properly trained in fire safety, medicine administration or manual handling skills. Inspectors noted governance and managing failures in respect of the scheduling of training for staff. They added that development plans for the two children needed to be improved. Lotus Care said it fully accepts Hiqa's findings. Lotus Care told The Journal that management took 'immediate action' and that all staff received the necessary fire safety training within 48 hours of the inspection's completion. 'Lotus Care is committed to quality improvement and ensuring all in our care receive the opportunity to reach their full potential,' it added. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
The Journal
2 days ago
- The Journal
Sleeping arrangements for IPAS residents affects ‘dignity and privacy'
THE SLEEPING ARRANGEMENTS for residents living at an International Protection facility is impacting upon their dignity and privacy and has the potential to lead to accumulative harm to children, a report has found. The Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) published six inspection reports on permanent International Protection Accommodation Service (IPAS) centres. IPAS centres, formerly known as direct provision centres, provide accommodation for people seeking international protection in Ireland. When inspectors visited a centre in Co Dublin, which accommodates around 231 residents, 60 of whom were children, they observed overcrowding and cramped conditions in some rooms. They found 11 families where parents shared bedrooms with children aged 10 and over. For instance, in one family unit observed, the room was divided by a wardrobe, with one side featuring a bunk bed and a single bed for three teenagers, while the other side contained a double bed for the parents. In addition, the rooms lacked dedicated living areas for families or single residents in shared bedrooms. While all rooms viewed met the minimum space requirements of the national standards, these living arrangements compromised the dignity and privacy of residents, and were not in line with the provisions of the Housing Act of 1966. Privacy and dignity Inspectors found that while families were accommodated together, the privacy and dignity of some families were not adequately protected. It said that the arrangements were not in line with the requirements of the Housing Act of 1966, and impacted upon the dignity and privacy of residents and had a potential to lead to accumulative harm to children. Advertisement The private provider of the IPAS facility had plans to relocate some families to more suitable accommodation within the centre once available and had engaged with the relevant Government department on this issue. Hiqa inspects the quality and safety of permanent IPAS centres against the National Standards for accommodation offered to people in the protection process (2019). The reports were published on Cuirt Uisce Accommodation Centre, Co Galway; Atlantic Lodge, Co Kerry; Davis Lane Apartments, Co Cork; Glenvera Hotel, Co Cork; Ocean View House, Co Waterford; and The Towers, Co Dublin. Hiqa found that four of the centres inspected – Cuirt Uisce Accommodation Centre, Davis Lane Apartments, Glenvera Hotel and Ocean View House — had no non-compliances against the standards. The remaining two centres had varying levels of compliance. Across the inspections conducted, inspectors found examples of good practice such as well-equipped cooking facilities for preparing meals, access to health and social supports, and support for integrating into the community. Atlantic Lodge and the Towers were have found to have breached compliance in areas around governance, accountability and leadership; safeguarding and protection; and accommodation. For example, in one centre, the management team was not aware of its responsibility to notify safeguarding incidents to HIQA. At the Atlantic Lodge, inspectors found that the management team did not have a full understanding of the relevant legislation, regulations, national policies and standards to protect residents living in the accommodation centre. While residents were treated with respect in the centre, the management team were not aware of their responsibilities in terms of notifying safeguarding incidents to Hiqa, the report stated. In accordance with Standard 8:3, the provider had established a process to ensure that adverse events were reported to the relevant body. However, this process was not followed, and an incident was not reported to Hiqa as required by policy and legislation. Where non-compliance with the national standards was identified, providers were required to submit compliance plans to demonstrate how they will make improvements and come into compliance with the national standards.
