‘We painted, sang songs': the Russian woman found living in Indian cave with daughters
Buried deep in the forests of Gokarna, a coastal town in southern India, they had woken 'up with the sun, swam in rivers and lived in nature'.
'I cooked on a fire or gas cylinder, depending on the season, and got groceries from a nearby village. We painted, sang songs, read books and lived peacefully,' Kutina said, according to Indian media reports.
Then the police arrived.
The story of how the 40-year-old Russian woman and her daughters, aged six and four, came to be living in a damp cave in the state of Karnataka has gripped the country.
The family was discovered by police on 9 July during a patrol of the hilly forest area, which is popular with tourists, when officers spied a curtain of red saris hanging in the trees. Moving closer, they realised it was covering the entrance of a cave.
A statue of a Hindu god was visible, as were scattered items of clothing. Then a blond child emerged. Behind her, the police were astonished to find Kutina, asleep with another child by her side.
Kutina told officers she had moved to the cave for meditation and prayer, and to get herself and her children away from modern urban life and into nature.
She had cooked vegetable curries and roti on a small gas stove and they had bathed in waterfalls and slept on plastic mats.
Police believe she had been there for at least a week when they found her and had spent several stints living in the cave over the past nine months.
Kutina dismissed the officers' warnings that it was a highly dangerous place to live, especially during the monsoon, telling police that 'animals and snakes are our friends' and that it was only humans who were dangerous.
Despite her objections, police insisted on removing the family from the cave and taking them back to the town, where they were placed in a shelter after Kutina had a hospital checkup. M Narayana, a local superintendent of police, said Kutina appeared 'deeply disillusioned with human society, yet still compassionate and spiritually grounded'.
Kutina messaged a friend after being taken from her 'big and beautiful cave', saying her family had been 'placed in a prison without sky, without grass, without a waterfall, with an icy hard floor on which we now sleep for 'protection from rain and snakes'…. Once again, evil has won.'
According to immigration records cited by Indian officials, Kutina first travelled to India in 2016, ending up in Arambol Beach, in Goa, a destination popular with Russian travellers. A year later, she had begun a relationship with an Israeli man, Dror Goldstein. After overstaying her visa in 2018, Kutina was deported to Russia and travelled to Ukraine, where she had their first daughter. She already had two older sons from a previous relationship.
In 2020, Kutina returned to India with her children. She reunited with Goldstein in Goa and became pregnant again, making money as an art and language teacher.
According to Goldstein, who spoke to Indian media, Kutina began withdrawing from him and would disappear for long periods with their two daughters. Then, in October last year, her eldest son, 21, was killed in a motorcycle crash in India. After Goldstein travelled to Nepal to renew his visa, he returned to Goa to find Kutina and their daughters had disappeared.
He filed a police report in December but had heard nothing until reports of their discovery emerged this week.
Asked by journalists why she had remained in India without any valid documents, Kutina said there were 'many complicated reasons'.
'First, there were multiple personal losses – not just the death of my son, but also a few other close people. We were constantly dealing with grief, paperwork and other problems,' she said.
Kutina claimed her son's ashes were among the belongings removed from the cave.
With no valid documents to remain, the family were moved to a detention centre and police are arranging for Kutina's deportation to Russia.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
2 minutes ago
- BBC News
Mumbai train bombings: India court pauses acquittal of 12 men convicted in the case
India's Supreme Court has stayed a recent court verdict which acquitted 12 men who had been convicted for the 2006 Mumbai train Bombay High Court had freed the men on Monday, overturning a 2015 special court verdict which gave death penalty to five of the accused and life imprisonment to the remaining high court said the prosecution had "utterly failed" to establish that the men had committed the crimes they had been convicted Tuesday, the Maharashtra government appealed against their acquittal. The train bombings had killed 187 and injured more than 800 people. While pausing the high court order on Thursday, a two-judge bench of the Supreme Court said the men were not required to go back to judges said that some of the observations made by the high court in its order could impact pending cases under the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act (MCOCA), the Live Law website 12 men had been convicted in 2015 by a MCOCA court - a special court set up to try cases that fall under the particular 11 July 2006, seven blasts ripped through busy commuter trains during the evening rush hour in one of India's deadliest bombs, packed into seven pressure cookers and put in bags, detonated within six minutes of each blasts took place in the areas of Matunga, Khar, Mahim, Jogeshwari, Borivali and Mira Road, with most on moving trains and two at security agencies blamed the attack on Islamist militants backed by Pakistan, an allegation Islamabad accused, who were arrested shortly after the blasts, have been in jail since then. One of them, Kamal Ansari, who had been sentenced to death, died of Covid in MCOCA court convicted the men of murder, conspiracy and waging war against the country. The prosecution appealed to confirm the death sentences, while the defence sought July 2024, the Bombay High Court formed the two-judge bench to expedite the say that over the next six months, the court conducted more than 75 sittings and examined 92 prosecution witnesses and over 50 defence the 667-page order on Monday, the court noted that the defence had questioned the credibility of the witnesses produced by the prosecution, as well as the confessional statements made by the also acknowledged the defence's contention that the recovered evidence was not maintained in a "sealed condition throughout".
Daily Mirror
32 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Exactly what sparked horror Thailand-Cambodia feud as 12 confirmed dead at border
Thailand officials say at least 12 civilians have died amid fresh clashes in multiple contested border areas with Cambodia. It comes after the nations downgraded their diplomatic relations Thailand and Cambodia have exchanged fire on the border in a sharp escalation of a conflict that has killed at least 12 civilians. The Thai army said the most casualties occurred in Si Sa Ket province, where six people were killed after shots were fired at a fuel station. At least 14 people were injured in three border provinces, according to Thai authorities. Relations between the Southeast Asian neighbours have deteriorated rapidly since an armed confrontation in May that killed a Cambodian soldier. Nationalist passions on both sides have inflamed the situation. The Thai army confirmed it had launched airstrikes on ground targets within Cambodia. In response, the Cambodian Defence Ministry claimed that Thailand 's army used jets to drop bombs on a road near the ancient Preah Vihear temple. Surasant Kongsiri, a spokesperson for the Thai Defence Ministry, said that three civilians, including a 5 year old boy, were seriously injured after Cambodia fired shots into a residential area in Thailand's Surin province. Groundbreaking discovery of 29,000-year-old human skeleton in remote cave Missing Russian plane UPDATES: Wreckage found after plane vanished before landing Clashes are currently ongoing in at least six areas along the border, according to Surasant. The first clash on Thursday morning occurred near the ancient Ta Muen Thom temple along the border of Surin and Cambodia's Oddar Meanchey province. Both nations have accused each other of initiating the gunfire. A livestream video from Thailand's side showed people fleeing their homes and seeking shelter in a concrete bunker on Thursday morning as explosions could be heard. Cambodia's Prime Minister Hun Manet alleged that Thailand attacked Cambodian army positions at Ta Muen Thom temple and Ta Krabey temple in Oddar Meanchey and expanded to the area along Cambodia's Preah Vihear province and Th. Tensions have escalated in Thailand's Ubon Ratchathani province. "Cambodia has always maintained a position of peaceful resolution of problems, but in this case, we have no choice but to respond with armed force against armed aggression," stated a representative. Earlier on Thursday, Cambodia announced it was downgrading diplomatic relations with Thailand to their lowest level, expelling the Thai ambassador and recalling all Cambodian staff from its embassy in Bangkok. This move was in response to Thailand closing its northeastern border crossings with Cambodia, withdrawing its ambassador and expelling the Cambodian ambassador on Wednesday following a land mine blast that injured five Thai soldiers. Relations between the Southeast Asian neighbours have been strained since May when a Cambodian soldier was killed in an armed confrontation over disputed territory. The Thai army reported that during Thursday's initial clash, its forces spotted six armed Cambodian soldiers approaching Thailand's station after hearing an unmanned aerial vehicle. Despite attempts by Thai soldiers to defuse the situation, the Cambodian side reportedly opened fire. Cambodia's Defence Ministry claimed that Thailand initiated the armed clash and that Cambodia "acted strictly within the bounds of self-defence, responding to an unprovoked incursion by Thai troops that violated our territorial integrity." Cambodian Senate President Hun Sen urged people not to panic in a post on his Facebook page. Meanwhile, Thai nationals have been urged to maintain faith in their government and the military. The Thai embassy in Phnom Penh announced on Facebook that clashes had erupted across multiple border regions, with the potential for further escalation. It called upon Thai citizens in Cambodia to depart the country where possible and recommended others avoid travelling to Cambodia unless utterly essential. On Wednesday, a landmine explosion close to the frontier injured five Thai soldiers, with one losing a leg. A week prior, a landmine in a separate disputed zone detonated and wounded three Thai troops when one stepped on it, resulting in the loss of a foot. Thai officials have claimed the mines were recently planted along routes that had been mutually agreed as secure corridors. They alleged the explosives were Russian-manufactured and not of a variety used by Thailand's armed forces. Cambodia dismissed Thailand's version as "baseless accusations," highlighting that numerous unexploded mines and other munitions remain from 20th century conflicts and civil unrest. Nationalist fervour on both sides has heightened tensions further. Thailand's prime minister was suspended from office on 1 July pending investigation into potential ethics breaches regarding her management of the border row. Frontier disagreements represent enduring issues that have sparked intermittent tensions between the nations. The most significant and violent confrontations have centred around the 1,000 year old Preah Vihear temple. In 1962, the International Court of Justice granted sovereignty over the temple site to Cambodia, which became a major source of irritation. Cambodia returned to the court in 2011, following several skirmishes between its military and Thai forces which resulted in approximately 20 fatalities and displaced thousands. The court reiterated the ruling in 2013, a decision that continued to unsettle Thailand.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Police arrest man accused of running ‘Westarctica' embassy from rented Delhi building
Indian authorities have arrested a 47-year-old man accused of posing as a diplomat and operating a bogus embassy from a rented bungalow in the suburbs of New Delhi. The property had luxury cars with fake diplomatic plates, doctored photos of the 'fake' diplomat with world leaders, and seals of imaginary nations, police said. The man, identified as Harshvardhan Jain, allegedly conned unsuspecting job seekers by promising overseas employment and lucrative foreign deals under the guise of ambassadorial clout. According to Sushil Ghule, a senior officer with Uttar Pradesh 's Special Task Force (STF), Mr Jain introduced himself as an adviser or ambassador to 'micronations' such as 'Seborga, Lodonia, Poulvia and Westarctica'. Inside the property, police uncovered an elaborate setup: international flags, falsified insignia of India's ministry of external affairs, and nearly three dozen fake seals from various nations. Investigators also seized four luxury vehicles fitted with counterfeit diplomatic number plates, around 4.5m Indian rupees (approximately £38,000) in Indian and foreign currency, and multiple forged documents, according to the Associated Press. Photographs recovered from the scene showed Mr Jain with political leaders, including prime minister Narendra Modi. Police believe the pictures were digitally manipulated. Authorities also accuse Mr Jain of using shell companies overseas to facilitate illegal money transfers and laundering operations. He now faces a range of charges, including impersonation, forgery, and possession of forged documents. According to India Today, he turned a rented bungalow in Ghaziabad's Kavi Nagar into the so-called 'Embassy of Westarctica'. The building had flags marking the micronations, luxury cars bearing fake diplomatic plates, and the interiors mimicked a real consulate. While Seborga is a town in northern Italy with a self-declared prince and a symbolic government, Ladonia is a Swedish nature reserve founded by artist Lars Vilks. Westarctica is an unrecognised Antarctic micronation. Mr Jain is said to have made up the name of Poulvia. Mr Jain was reportedly born into a wealthy marble-trading family in Rajasthan and studied business in India and the UK, according to reports. This wasn't his first run-in with law enforcement. In 2011, he was booked for possessing illegal satellite phones, with a case registered at Ghaziabad's Kavi Nagar police station, said UP Police senior officer Amitabh Yash.
