Targets Trouble Leads To Fake Doctors Appointments
'Correspondence between clinicians shows fake appointments are being made for fake clinics at Nelson Hospital,' Labour health spokesperson Ayesha Verrall said.
'This is a worrying sign that yet again National's targets are leading to perverse incentives. This happened last time, when the system was gamed to make it look like people were having shorter stays in emergency departments.
'This time, clinicians are putting five-minute appointments in the system, when in reality patients are not being seen.
'The goal should always be patient outcomes, not making the books look good so the Minister can boast about meeting arbitrary targets. We said this would happen, now it is.
'The Minister needs a better answer than blaming others – this is a result of his decisions,' Ayesha Verrall said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
5 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Simeon Brown defends rollout of breast cancer screening with 370 women seen – full implementation not until 2029
She said the fact the nationwide rollout would not be complete until 2029 was a 'broken promise'. 'To only have screened a fraction of a percent of the eligible women is a broken promise and shows how incapable this Government is of delivering health services for New Zealanders,' she said. Labour health spokewoman Ayesha Verrall during the Health select committee hearing, Parliament, Wellington, 03 December, 2024. NZME photograph by Mark Mitchell Brown said eligibility was being brought online progressively to avoid overwhelming the system. The Nelson-Marlborough region was the first to deliver the new scheme last October and the nationwide rollout will start in the same month this year. Brown said the programme had begun with women aged 70 and 74 (who had not been screened in the past two years) and did not yet include women aged 71 to 73. This was to target people who had not recently had a screening while ensuring the workforce was not overwhelmed by a large cohort all at once. 'It will be progressively extended to people between 70 and 74 as the rollout expands,' he said. 'The number who are eligible is growing as the rollout is taking place.' Simeon Brown Minister of Health gives a speech and answers questions regarding Health Reform at MinterEllisonRuddWatts offices in downtown Auckland/Tamaki Makaurau. NZME photograph by Alex Burton 07 March 2025 Brown said there were an estimated 1600 women aged 70 or 74 in the Nelson-Marlborough region. He said that up until May, screenings were only being 'offered'. A new computer system means eligible women are being contacted directly to come forward for a screening. 'We've seen a much greater uptake since then. This is about making sure the systems are in place ahead of the national rollout that begins in October,' Brown said. He said expanding the reach of the scheme would follow a similar pattern and would not be completed out until October 2029 because it was important to 'manage demand on the system'. 'There will be further information announced later this year,' he said. Verrall said the phased rollout would mean some people missing out. 'This is a broken promise. Women understood screening would be promised at the election. It now turns out many of those women will never be able to access the screening they were promised,' she said. Verrall, who was Health Minister in the last Government, said Labour had not campaigned on increasing the screening age because officials had told her it would be 'very challenging because of staffing constraints on screening'. 'Nonetheless, the National Party did not change its position – now they are letting women down,' she said.
Scoop
18 hours ago
- Scoop
Targets Trouble Leads To Fake Doctors Appointments
Under National, hospitals are booking ghost appointments to make it look like their targets are being met. 'Correspondence between clinicians shows fake appointments are being made for fake clinics at Nelson Hospital,' Labour health spokesperson Ayesha Verrall said. 'This is a worrying sign that yet again National's targets are leading to perverse incentives. This happened last time, when the system was gamed to make it look like people were having shorter stays in emergency departments. 'This time, clinicians are putting five-minute appointments in the system, when in reality patients are not being seen. 'The goal should always be patient outcomes, not making the books look good so the Minister can boast about meeting arbitrary targets. We said this would happen, now it is. 'The Minister needs a better answer than blaming others – this is a result of his decisions,' Ayesha Verrall said.
Otago Daily Times
a day ago
- Otago Daily Times
‘Marked improvement' in mental health shown
Matt Doocey. PHOTO: ODT FILES The South is showing "marked improvement" in most of its mental health targets, Mental Health Minister Matt Doocey says. But health officials are asking the minister to be careful with the data, and an opposition MP says it does not reflect the feeling of staff. Mr Doocey has set specific targets for mental health delivery, including faster access to primary mental health and addiction services, faster access to specialist mental health and addiction services and shorter mental-health related stays in the emergency department. The Southern district has improved its performance in all three targets, and was successful in faster access to primary mental health and addiction services (91.6%) and shorter mental health and addiction-related stays in EDs (86%), Health New Zealand Te Whatu Ora's most recent quarterly data says. The Southern district was also a shade under the target for access to specialist mental healthcare (78%). Mr Doocey said this was a "marked improvement" from two quarters ago, where Southern was languishing near the bottom of the table. "This government believes when someone is making the brave step of reaching out for help whether it's you, your child, a friend or family member, we are committed to ensuring we have the right support in place to answer that call, no matter where you are in New Zealand. "It is promising to see the third quarter target data show Southern are exceeding two out of three access targets. I have recently been in the Southern region where I met some of our hard-working frontline workers who are on the ground making a real difference in helping those in the region have access to faster mental health support." However, officials have also advised there were still some caveats around the data — particularly in ED presentations, where it "does not account for the complexities of acute presentations, for example people presenting with combinations of physical and mental symptoms, or presentations where the actual problem is not immediately obvious" and "does not reliably identify any addiction-related events". A late January briefing paper, released under the Official Information Act, urged Mr Doocey to be cautious when looking at the quarterly results. "This is the first attempt at this level of reporting on data against the mental health and addiction targets. "Unlike the wider health system targets, the datasets and reporting processes are new and the infrastructure supporting the process is evolving. It is critical to appreciate the preliminary nature of the data as a picture of performance against the mental health addiction targets at this juncture of the implementation and design." Labour MP for Taieri Ingrid Leary said the results did not reflect what she was hearing from frontline workers, who were still under-resourced and stretched. Many young people were waiting several months for mental health assistance, she said. "The caveats in the document might explain the chasm between the reality on the ground and the supposedly good results. "When you have so many waiting for mental healthcare, the results aren't worth the paper they're printed on." Meanwhile, Mr Doocey said yesterday he was pressing ahead with the creation of a Digital Mental Health Hub, which was aimed at improving access to mental health services. "A key component of the hub will be improving digital navigation to connect people with existing mental health services. Unfortunately, many people are unaware of the services already available to them and these navigation systems could be a game changer. "The road map is currently in development, and I am hoping to have more to say over the coming months."
