Mike Lynch estate and business partner must pay £740m to HP Enterprise, court rules
In a long-awaited ruling on Tuesday, Mr Justice Hildyard determined that HPE was owed £740 million (€852 million) from Lynch's estate and his former business partner Sushovan Hussain in connection with the disastrous 2011 acquisition of their software company Autonomy.
The judge had found in 2022 that the FTSE 100 company's 'true financial position and performance had not been properly and accurately disclosed' when it was sold to the then Hewlett-Packard 14 years ago for $11.7 billion.
HPE had originally sought at least $4.55 billion in damages, a figure that the judge described in Tuesday's ruling as 'substantially exaggerated'.
The Lynch family is considering whether to appeal against the ruling. The estate is estimated to be worth about £500 million and so would be bankrupted if the figure was upheld, according to a person familiar with the matter.
Lynch died aged 59 last year alongside his 18-year-old daughter and five others when his family's Bayesian superyacht sank off the coast of Sicily. They had been celebrating his acquittal on US fraud charges related to the Autonomy sale. Fifteen people, including Lynch's wife, Angela Bacares, survived.
HPE pressed ahead with a civil claim in England, with chief executive Antonio Neri describing it as a 'difficult' decision but one that was 'in the best interest of shareholders'.
HPE was formed out of the 2015 split of Hewlett-Packard, which sued Lynch after it took an $8.8 billion (€7.5 billion) writedown on Autonomy, accusing him of falsely inflating the company's revenues.
Hildyard said Autonomy executives had engaged in 'a fraudulent acceleration of revenue at the expense of future revenue flows'.
However, the judge said HP's original claim was 'always substantially exaggerated', adding there was 'more than a grain of truth' in Lynch's argument that HP's estimate of the cost of the alleged fraud 'was not based on detailed analysis'.
A spokesperson for the Lynch family said that the ruling showed HPE's original claim of damages was 'a wild overstatement... misleading shareholders'. In a statement the family said that Lynch had prepared before his death, the late tech entrepreneur said: 'This result exposes HP's failure and makes clear that the immense damage to Autonomy was down to HP's own errors and actions.'
Lynch also complained in the statement that the English civil case had 'included hearsay evidence from the US, and we were never able to question or cross-examine those witnesses... When in the US criminal trial we were able to cross examine the relevant witnesses, a very different story emerged. Why is the English legal system so trusting?'
The ruling does not resolve how much interest should be paid, which is to be determined at a subsequent hearing.
HPE said in May that it had reached a settlement with Hussain for an undisclosed sum.
It said in a statement: 'We are pleased that this decision brings us a step closer to the resolution of this dispute. We look forward to the further hearing at which the final amount of HPE's damages will be determined.' – Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Brittany Ferries increasing Rosslare-Cherbourg services as passenger volumes up 40% and freight units double
Brittany Ferries is increasing its presence at Rosslare Europort after confirming on Tuesday it will increase sailings to Cherbourg following Stena Line's decision to leave the service. Brittany Ferries, which is long established in Cork, will increase both capacity and frequency of sailings from Rosslare to the French port from the end of September, with departures rising from five to seven every week. Brittany Ferries launched their Rosslare to Cherbourg service in 2021 in a post-Brexit response to demand from hauliers, to obviate the need to cross the UK-landbridge when moving freight between Ireland and France. Passenger volumes have soared nearly 40% this year while freight units have doubled. Brittany Ferries says the increased service can ensure business continuity for Irish hauliers, as well as offering more choice to holidaymakers. 'News that our competitor was stepping back, started the firing pistol in a concerted effort to secure port slots and better serve customers in Ireland and France," said Brittany Ferries chief executive Christophe Mathieu. 'It means greater choice for holidaymakers and even more opportunity for freight operators seeking to by-pass the UK entirely, cutting down on bureaucracy and delays at the UK border. Our new train connection in Cherbourg only adds further strings to the multimodal bow.' The company's first train is being rolled out, which will utilise rail line links from Cherbourg and Bayonne, carrying unaccompanied trailers over 970km of the French rail network. Glenn Carr, director of commercial business units for Iarnród Éireann Irish Rail-Port Authority for Rosslare Europort said since Brexit, direct sailings between Rosslare Europort and the European continent have increased six-fold. "Our priority has been to ensure we maintain that capacity and choice for industry and tourism alike." Stena announced its decision to withdraw its existing three-day Rosslare-Cherbourg service after "an extensive review" with the intention of strengthening the company's investment in the Irish Sea, where it said it will strengthen its Irish Sea network. "We have recently announced investments of almost £40m in our Liverpool and Belfast terminals, as well as the upgrading of the Fishguard port infrastructure. We will also be increasing capacity across the Irish Sea with two new freight vessels planned for the Belfast–Heysham route and an additional freight vessel for the Dublin–Liverpool route," said Stena trade director Johan Edelman.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Diageo forecasts flat annual sales growth, raises cost-savings target
Guinness-maker Diageo said it expects muted sales growth in this fiscal year, as the drinks maker seeks to recover from a challenging period including the sudden exit of its chief executive officer. The company said organic sales growth will likely only match the 1.7 per cent uplift of last year, when the drinks maker grappled with US President Donald Trump's tariff war, volatile demand and management upheaval. That growth was slightly more than analysts expected. The world's biggest spirits maker is looking for a new chief and finance head to turn around its financial and share performance, and guide it through a plan announced in May to cut $500 million in costs and make substantial asset sales by 2028. 'Macroeconomic uncertainty and the resulting pressure on consumers continues to weigh on the spirits sector,' Diageo said in its first set of results under interim chief executive Nik Jhangiani. READ MORE Diageo said it expects organic sales to fall slightly in the first half of 2026, with growth more weighted towards the second half. The board of Diageo is moving quickly to find a permanent chief executive officer and will likely make a decision by the end of October, Mr Jhangiani said on a media call. Former chief executive, Debra Crew, stepped down last month after two years in the role. - Reuters, Bloomberg
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Owen Doyle: Dan Sheehan should have got a red card and a longer ban for dangerous strike
'Feral' was one word a pundit used to describe what we were watching. The dictionary explains its meaning: 'of, or characteristic of, wild animals; ferocious; brutal'. It is, of course, a dreadful descriptor, but hard to think of a more telling word. The third Test was indeed all of those things, and also troubling to observe. Four failed brain injury assessments, including James Ryan being knocked senseless for several very worrying minutes. It was accidental, but it's another concussion for the stalwart secondrow. There was a very intemperate undercurrent throughout. Both teams wanted desperately to win, and at times nasty stuff surfaced. The leading Australian protagonists were Will Skelton, the biggest man on the pitch, and Nic White, perhaps the smallest. Both have made a career out of rattling their opponents' cage. The Lions responded in kind, particularly Tom Curry and Dan Sheehan : never a backward step. There was constant sledging, faux-grinning and taunting from the start. Owen Farrell's incensed verbal outburst aimed at Joseph Sualli was an awful look. READ MORE Is all of this really what rugby wants to be? The match was a travesty of the sport. It failed miserably to uphold the game's stated values. Respect for the opposition was nowhere in sight. How sad that was to see. The Lions' objective was to win all three Tests, but they played as if the party had started a week early. Perhaps it had. Sheehan, inexcusably, had a real go at the prone Tom Lynagh. It was an unworthy and disgraceful cheap shot. In marked contrast to Jac Morgan last week , the Lions' hooker entered the breakdown late, targeting his opponent with a very dangerous strike to the head. It was not picked up, a negative mark against the TMO, South Africa's Marius Jonker. Owen Farrell's tackling during the third Test between the Lions and Australia was at times questionable. Photograph:The TMO also called the referee's attention to a completely innocuous incident, which Nika Amashukeli took but a moment to dismiss. A typical Farrell shoulder hit also went unseen; it's been his trademark calling card for far too long. Jonker needed to be better. Until recently, Sheehan would have received a straight red card. Under the global trial, it should have gone to the bunker for upgrading (or not) to the correct colour. At times like this we often hear the excuse of what else could the offending player have done. Well, if that was the player's only option, he should have done nothing, and waited for play to develop. He would have been more useful elsewhere. I had the good fortune to share a pitch with Michael Lynagh, father of Tom, on several occasions. Enjoyable evenings too. He has always been the epitome of modest excellence. He must be horrified to see his son on the receiving end of some appalling hits, this time failing his brain injury assessment. Given the number of times Lynagh gets thumped illegally – at least twice in these three Tests – it's impossible not to think that the replacement red card is involved. Playing just an extra 10 minutes reduced to 14 players is a small price to pay if it gets rid of a key opponent. Sheehan was correctly cited, although he didn't think it was correct or that he had even committed an act of foul play. That viewpoint is as nonsensical as his dangerous action. His non-acceptance of the charge resulted in a lost week of mitigation, and, subject to him completing a coaching intervention course, he will serve a meagre three-match ban , instead of a paltry two. Imagine the furore if Finn Russell had been forced off in similar circumstances, and the perpetrator denied any wrongdoing. The uproar would have been totally justified; as is Australian anger on this occasion. The suspension is once again too light. How often is it necessary to repeat the words – sub-concussive head knocks, concussion, dementia, chronic traumatic encephalopathy – before those sitting at the high table decide that deterrent-level sentences are necessary. Referee Nika Amashukeli has a word with Australia's Will Skelton after the player clashed with James Ryan of the Lions during the third Test. Photograph:It would be good to hear from World Rugby . So far, chief executive Alan Gilpin has indicated their support for Andrea Piardi in the second Test, but hasn't told us whether Morgan's clear out was judged correctly. It would be ridiculous if World Rugby got involved publicly in every controversial decision, but on this one we could all learn a lot if the silence was broken. On a general point, there is a distinct difference in how breakdown side-entry is refereed on either side of the equator. Down south a sanction is as rare as a hen's tooth, while in this neck of the woods the clear and obvious ones are rightly meant to be sanctioned. We saw it across the three tests: Piardi and Amashukeli actually refereed the area, while New Zealander Ben O'Keeffe's approach was very laissez-faire. World Rugby needs to sort it out, it's an extremely unhealthy divide. Amashukeli was a very good choice for the final match of the tour. He is a strong operator, unflappable too. His calm assuredness was essential when dealing with the various flare-ups, and for giving necessary warnings, which he did even-handedly. In all the prevailing circumstances, including horrendous rain, and the stoppage for lightning, it's unlikely that anyone could have done better. In a match that came with a very high degree of difficulty, he can be quietly pleased with his performance. And what of those who were avidly watching this 'feral' match? There is a very serious, existential debate among parents, sometimes in the same household. The motion: 'Is rugby is a suitable sport for my kids?' This match will have spoken very emphatically for those against the motion. At the same time it will have done nothing for those in favour. Absolutely nothing.
