Dismay as UN talks fail to agree on treaty to tackle plastic pollution
The final hours saw entrenched positions over key areas – specifically plastic production caps, which had been a key issue that boiled over from last year's failed talks in Korea.
"It's very clear that we did not arrive where we wanted to arrive," UN Environment Programme executive director Inger Andersen told the media on Friday. "People want a deal. Everyone has to understand that this work will not stop, because plastic pollution will not stop."
The Geneva talks were the most high-stakes round yet in a process launched in 2022 to forge a global treaty addressing the full life cycle of plastic.
A draft "chair's text" tabled earlier this week aimed to unify positions, but major producing countries reportedly resisted language that would mandate reductions in plastic output, favouring recycling initiatives instead.
However, Ms Andersen acknowledged that while delegates did not reach a final agreement, some progress was made in clarifying negotiating positions.
Red lines drawn
"Red lines were clarified," she said. "Progress is made because people are demanding a treaty. Now there's a lot of hard work ahead."
Several countries expressed disappointment and frustration at the lack of agreement on a treaty.
A closing statement submitted by Barbados highlighted that more needed to be done to fully recognise the circumstances of Small Island Developing states (SIDS), which face unique sustainable development challenges.
"Unfortunately there was no consensus on the two texts you have placed on the table," the statement from Barbados read. "Both lacked critical elements of importance."
Meanwhile, representatives from Cuba argued that a treaty cannot be effective without establishing a "sufficient, stable, and predictable financing mechanism".
"Developing countries need resources to effectively address plastic pollution," a statement from the Cuban delegation said.
Farah Al Hattab, Lead Plastics Campaigner and Greenpeace Mena's delegate at the talks, told The National: 'The governments' collective inability to reach an agreement in Geneva must be a wakeup call for the world: delay comes at a cost for people and the planet."
For the region, Ms Hattab said "this outcome is not just disappointing; it is dangerous. From coral reefs in the Red Sea to coastlines, cities, and rural communities across our region, plastic pollution is accelerating, with devastating impacts on ecosystems and communities.'
What happens next?
For now, Ms Andersen said that while she "will not settle" until there is a pathway forward, "it is important that everyone takes time to reflect on what they have heard," with a session to reconvene expected at a later date.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
9 hours ago
- The National
Belgium's foreign minister urges Palestine recognition 'before there is nothing left'
Belgium's foreign minister told parliament that Belgium must quickly recognise the state of Palestine. Maxime Prevot spoke at an emergency debate on Thursday to address the worsening humanitarian crisis in Gaza. He expressed his concerns that no decision on recognition had been taken yet, despite an agreement to do so after the coalition government was formed in February. 'If Belgium does not make progress towards official recognition in September, there will soon be nothing left to recognise,' he said. 'Moreover, Belgium will lose all credibility in speaking about a two-state solution.' He also called for economic sanctions on Israel, and for Israeli far-right ministers Itamar Ben Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich to be on a 'blacklist' in Belgium that would forbid them from entering. The UK and Norway, alongside three other countries, sanctioned the two Israeli ministers in June. 'History shows that the introduction of targeted sanctions can be an effective lever for moving situations marked by serious violence towards a dynamic of peace and sustainable conflict resolution,' he said. 'We must therefore raise our tone and be firmer, and deploy an assumed and progressive strategy of sanctions.' The debate broke the summer break time, and Mr Prevot urged for a plan to recognise Palestine in time for the UN General Assembly in September, alongside France. Prime Minister Bart De Wever, of the right wing Flemish party N-VA, did not call a cabinet meeting about the deteriorating situation in Gaza, frustrating his coalition partners, including Mr Prevot's centrist party, Les Engages. Les Engages, alongside CD&V and Vooruit, support a rapid recognition of Palestine, whereas liberal MR and the right wing N-VA oppose it, arguing that the conditions to do so have not been met, and that sanctions would be ineffective without US backing. Mr De Wever is currently on holiday in South Africa and no decision on the issue is expected to be made yet. Mr Prevot pledged to mobilise allies within the coalition to gain support. 'This is not an ideological debate, it is about respecting the law,' Mr Prevot said, pledging to mobilise allies within the coalition. 'The government must not miss its appointment with history, with our conscience, and with our moral and legal obligations,' he said. 'It is essential that we continue to act to ensure international justice and maintain Belgium's reputation as a defender of human rights.' He feared that failure to do so would 'isolate' Belgium alongside a 'minority' of other European Union countries. 'We would join the minority of EU member states (and countries around the world) that have not recognised Palestine, isolating us a little more from others and sinking us into our contradictions,' he said. He rejected accusations that recognising Palestine was rewarding Hamas. 'Recognition is a 'bonus' for the Palestinain Authority, not for Hamas. It strengthens the peaceful struggle. 'The recognition of a state is neither a reward nor a weapon,' he said. Mr Prevot announced he had also sent the draft of a Royal Decree, that would tighten Belgium's existing ban on arms sales to Israel and Palestine, which came into effect in 2009. The draft decree would prohibit arms being shipped to Israel or Palestine to cross Belgian airspace. 'will thus even cover the overflight of our airspace, and therefore a fortiori any transit,' he said. Yet Mr Prevot feared that these measures, and others taken in the government's first six months, would be undermined by a failure to recognise. Nearly 800 Belgian nationals and recognised refugees in Gaza had been evacuated by Belgium, he said, praising the diplomats who co-ordinated the 'extremely complicated' process. 'I want to take my hat off to all our diplomats and other personnel mobilised,' he said. 'One must imagine the chaotic situation on the ground in order to find the people concerned in a war zone, to ensure their correct identity, to carry out the required analyses, to identify the routes of exfiltration, to secure these corridors, to organise transport and repatriation without further endangerment,' he said.
Khaleej Times
11 hours ago
- Khaleej Times
Trump says 'not here to negotiate for Ukraine' at Alaska meeting with Putin
US President Donald Trump said he would not negotiate on behalf of Ukraine in his Friday meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin and would let Kyiv decide whether to engage in territorial swaps with Russia. Trump said his goal was to get the two sides to start a negotiation, with any territorial swaps to be addressed then. "They'll be discussed, but I've got to let Ukraine make that decision, and I think they'll make a proper decision. But I'm not here to negotiate for Ukraine, I'm here to get them at a table," Trump told reporters aboard Air Force One. Trump's remarks are likely to offer some assurance to Ukraine, which is worried that the US-Russia talks could freeze the conflict at Ukraine's expense. Trump said the Russian offensive in Ukraine was likely aimed at helping to strengthen Putin's hand in any negotiations to end the war. "I think they're trying to negotiate. He's trying to set a stage. In his mind that helps him make a better deal. It actually hurts him, but in his mind that helps him make a better deal if they can continue the killing," he said. The US President said he expected his meeting with Putin to produce results, given the stakes involved and weakness in the Russian economy. "He's a smart guy, been doing it for a long time but so have I ... we get along, there's a good respect level on both sides, and I think, you know, something's going to come of it," he said. Trump said it was a good sign that Putin was bringing business executives with him from Russia, but said no deals could be made until the war was settled. "I like that 'cause they want to do business, but they're not doing business until we get the war settled," he said.
The National
14 hours ago
- The National
Dismay as UN talks fail to agree on treaty to tackle plastic pollution
Negotiations to establish the first global plastics treaty faltered in Geneva on Friday, as delegates failed to reach consensus on critical treaty provisions to tackle pollution. The final hours saw entrenched positions over key areas – specifically plastic production caps, which had been a key issue that boiled over from last year's failed talks in Korea. "It's very clear that we did not arrive where we wanted to arrive," UN Environment Programme executive director Inger Andersen told the media on Friday. "People want a deal. Everyone has to understand that this work will not stop, because plastic pollution will not stop." The Geneva talks were the most high-stakes round yet in a process launched in 2022 to forge a global treaty addressing the full life cycle of plastic. A draft "chair's text" tabled earlier this week aimed to unify positions, but major producing countries reportedly resisted language that would mandate reductions in plastic output, favouring recycling initiatives instead. However, Ms Andersen acknowledged that while delegates did not reach a final agreement, some progress was made in clarifying negotiating positions. Red lines drawn "Red lines were clarified," she said. "Progress is made because people are demanding a treaty. Now there's a lot of hard work ahead." Several countries expressed disappointment and frustration at the lack of agreement on a treaty. A closing statement submitted by Barbados highlighted that more needed to be done to fully recognise the circumstances of Small Island Developing states (SIDS), which face unique sustainable development challenges. "Unfortunately there was no consensus on the two texts you have placed on the table," the statement from Barbados read. "Both lacked critical elements of importance." Meanwhile, representatives from Cuba argued that a treaty cannot be effective without establishing a "sufficient, stable, and predictable financing mechanism". "Developing countries need resources to effectively address plastic pollution," a statement from the Cuban delegation said. Farah Al Hattab, Lead Plastics Campaigner and Greenpeace Mena's delegate at the talks, told The National: 'The governments' collective inability to reach an agreement in Geneva must be a wakeup call for the world: delay comes at a cost for people and the planet." For the region, Ms Hattab said "this outcome is not just disappointing; it is dangerous. From coral reefs in the Red Sea to coastlines, cities, and rural communities across our region, plastic pollution is accelerating, with devastating impacts on ecosystems and communities.' What happens next? For now, Ms Andersen said that while she "will not settle" until there is a pathway forward, "it is important that everyone takes time to reflect on what they have heard," with a session to reconvene expected at a later date.
