All the times Labour has changed the definition of ‘working people'
The manifesto claimed 'Labour will not increase taxes on working people, which is why we will not increase National Insurance, the basic, higher, or additional rates of Income Tax, or VAT'.
Sir Keir Starmer said on Wednesday that the Government would keep this promise, but a growing hole in the public finances has raised questions over whether this will remain the case, and how the party will define a 'working person'.
Heidi Alexander, the Transport Secretary, on Sunday appeared to suggest that only those on 'modest incomes' would be classed as working people. It was not clear how she defined a 'modest' income.
This is not the first time that the language surrounding 'working people' and how the Labour Party defines them has come under scrutiny.
The Telegraph breaks down how the term 'working people' has changed since Sir Keir first made that promise last year.
Working people do not have savings
Before voters went to the polls, the Labour leader suggested that he did not believe that 'working people' had savings.
Asked what he meant by a working person, Sir Keir told LBC in June: 'People who earn their living, rely on our [public] services and don't really have the ability to write a cheque when they get into trouble.'
The following day, Rachel Reeves, the Chancellor, appeared to contradict him by saying that some working people did have savings.
She claimed on Sky News that her definition was: 'Working people are people who go out to work and work for their incomes.
'Sort of by definition, really, working people are those people who go out and work and earn their money through hard work.'
Ms Reeves added: 'Many other people who go out to work have had to run down their savings.
'But there are people who do have savings, who have been able to save up and those are working people as well.'
People on six figures can be working people
The new Government came under intense scrutiny over its definition of 'working people' ahead of the Chancellor's first Budget in October last year.
Lisa Nandy first suggested that someone on a six-figure salary who goes to work counts as a 'working person'.
In an interview with Sky News, the Culture Secretary said: 'When I think about working people, particularly the challenges they face, I think about the factory workers, I think about people driving the buses in my constituency, working in the public services, working in the private sector, delivery drivers, call centres.'
When asked whether someone on a six-figure salary counted, the minister replied: 'I mean, if they go to work obviously they will be working.'
Landlords and shareholders aren't working people
The following day, the Prime Minister said that he did not believe that landlords or shareholders fell under his definition of a working person.
Asked by Sky News if those who earn income from assets such as shares or property would count as working people in the Budget, Sir Keir said that they 'wouldn't come within my definition'.
The Chancellor went on to announce an increase in capital gains tax at the Budget, but kept property rates the same.
Small business owners might not be working people
Bridget Phillipson, just days before the Government's first fiscal event, refused to say whether a small business owner who earned £13,000 a year was a 'working person' or not.
The Education Secretary told the BBC's Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg that Labour's definition of a working person was someone 'whose main income arises from the fact that they go out to work every day'.
Those paying employers' NI contributions are not working people
When Ms Reeves's first Budget was unveiled on October 30, she announced an increase to employer's NI contributions.
Standing at the despatch box, the Chancellor said that 'people will not see higher taxes in their playslips as a result of the choices that I am making today. That is a promise made and a promise fulfilled'.
Ministers insisted that this did not breach the manifesto promises not to raise taxes on 'working people' because it was employers, rather than employees, paying the increased levy.
But critics, including the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS), disagreed.
Paul Johnson, the then director of the IFS, said ahead of the Budget that the manifesto did not 'specify employee National Insurance' and therefore raising employers' NI would be a breach.
He also warned that the levy ultimately came from employee pay, and therefore an increase could result in 'less pay rises' and 'possibly fewer jobs'.
Working people earn 'modest incomes'
On Sunday, Ms Alexander said that the Government had promised not to put up taxes for 'people on modest incomes'.
She told Sky News: 'We made a commitment in our manifesto not to be putting up taxes on people on modest incomes, working people. We have stuck to that.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
.png%3Ftrim%3D0%2C0%2C0%2C0%26width%3D1200%26height%3D800%26crop%3D1200%3A800&w=3840&q=100)
The Independent
32 minutes ago
- The Independent
Who owns the past? Bayeux Tapestry loan reignites Elgin Marbles debate
As cultural treasures criss-cross borders in the name of diplomacy, a deeper debate looms: who really has the right to own the great relics of history? And are temporary loans a diplomatic fix, or a way of dodging the bigger question? President Macron's decision to loan the Bayeux Tapestry – likely stitched in Kent but kept in Normandy for centuries – has also reignited a more contentious debate: whether Britain should return other historic artefacts, most notably the Elgin marbles. Some see striking parallels between the two: cultural icons, created in one place, preserved in another. But others argue it's not so simple. 'That comparison is a huge stretch,' one reader wrote in response to an article by Harry Mount last week. 'It may have been made in England, but it was commissioned by the Normans… Normandy feels like the rightful home of this artefact.' On the other side of the debate, however, another suggested: 'As a born and bred Hastings chap, I'd say it's not returned home until it's been displayed at a Hastings museum.' When it comes to the Parthenon sculptures, the stakes – and emotions – are even higher. Created in ancient Athens and removed in the 19th century, they remain on show at the British Museum in London. Lord Elgin claimed he removed the sculptures with the permission of Ottoman officials, who controlled Athens at the time. However, the legality of his actions – deeply intertwined with the history of the British Empire – has been widely disputed, and Greece has never stopped calling for their return. So what's the answer? Are cultural loans a useful compromise, or just a stalling tactic? Should Britain begin returning historic artefacts to their countries of origin – and if so, where should the line be drawn? We want to hear from you. Share your thoughts in the and vote in the poll below – we'll feature the most compelling responses and discuss the results in the coming days. All you have to do is sign up and register your details – then you can take part in the debate. You can also sign up by clicking 'log in' on the top right-hand corner of the screen.
The Sun
33 minutes ago
- The Sun
Struggling to sell your house? Boost your property price by £46k with 5 features buyers want, from as little as 55p
If your home's stuck on the market, small DIY tweaks could be the key to unlocking serious value – up to £80,000 in some cases – and you don't need a huge budget to get started. Across the UK, homeowners are turning to budget-friendly upgrades to help attract buyers and push up asking prices. From kitchen fixes to kerb appeal, these clever features are proving popular with house-hunters – and small upgrades, like new cupboard handles starting at just 55p, can make a big difference. Kitchens sell homes – and you don't need a full refit to impress. Just swapping out tired cupboard handles or giving walls a lick of paint could work wonders. Upgrade your kitchen Daniel Copley, Consumer Spokesperson at Zoopla, said: "The explosion of DIY trends on TikTok over the past year has undoubtedly led to an increase in people doing budget renovations. "We know kitchens are a key selling point for many buyers – and the centre of activity in many households – so DIY projects are often focussed on this space. "Getting this right can add value and make your home more appealing.' He added in an interview with Magnet: 'Superficial touches, such as replacing broken handles or treating worktops, could give your kitchen a quick update and improve your chances of adding value.' Even updating taps, resealing tiles, or adding stick-on splashbacks can bring your space up to date – and make it stand out in online listings. Swapping out an old kitchen tap can cost as little as £15–£30, depending on the style and finish. Resealing tiles with fresh silicone is another quick win, with sealant tubes priced at around £5–£10 each. For a more noticeable upgrade, stick-on splashbacks – including marble, tile-effect, or stainless steel designs – typically range from £10 to £30, and can completely transform tired kitchen walls in under an hour. Add panelling Panelling is one of the easiest ways to give a room a luxury feel without blowing the budget. Self-adhesive MDF or foam wall panels are widely available and cost between £12 and £60 per wall, depending on size and design. Popular choices include shaker-style and fluted timber-effect panels, often seen in hallways or bedrooms. You'll also need basic tools like a level, saw and adhesive – available from around £5 to £10 – making this one of the most affordable DIY upgrades that adds instant style. Popular in bedrooms and hallways, these DIY kits are now widely available and easy to install. Tool and DIY expert Glen Peskett from Saxton Blades explained: 'We're seeing a big shift toward cosmetic DIY this year, simple jobs that make your home feel more stylish, secure and ready to sell. I turned a derelict, rotten garage that people used as a loo into a stunning two-bedroom home "Many people are surprised how far a small spend can go when you've got the right tools and materials to do it yourself.'pan It's not just for the experts either. Many panels come pre-cut and self-adhesive, meaning you don't need power tools or professional help. Just a spirit level and a spare afternoon. Swap out light switches They're small, but buyers notice them. Old, yellowing switches can instantly date a home, while sleek flatplate alternatives make it feel more modern and put-together. Updating your light switches is a quick, low-effort job with high visual impact. Flatplate designs in black, brushed steel or brass start from just £4–£10 per switch, and are widely stocked by retailers like Toolstation and B&Q. Replacing a handful of tired switches throughout the home can give it a polished, contemporary edge that buyers instantly notice. Glen Peskett continued: "A quick aesthetic win. Swapping out dated white switches for flatplate, black or brushed brass alternatives instantly modernises interiors. "You'd be amazed how much sleeker a space feels with updated switches. It's the kind of detail buyers notice.' This is a quick fix that takes minutes and can be done room-by-room, keeping costs down while freshening up your interiors. EV charging points With more drivers going electric, homes with a charging point are increasingly attractive to buyers. The typical cost to install an electric car charger at home in the UK ranges from £800 to £1200, and whilst the upfront cost might seem steep, the potential payoff is worth it, especially in suburban or commuter areas. A 7kW charger is most common for households, with faster 22kW options costing more. Government grants may also be available to help with installation, depending on your location. Adding an EV point doesn't just future-proof your property – it makes it more desirable to eco-conscious and tech-savvy buyers. Up front cost: £800-1200 House price boost: £3,000 to £5,000 according to the National Association of Property Buyers. Boost curb appeal Cleaning windows, repainting your front door, and adding greenery with potted plants or hanging baskets can make your home more inviting from the moment buyers arrive. Curb appeal, or how your home looks from the street, can increase value by as much as 11 per cent, according to property experts. And you don't need a gardener – even just trimming hedges and clearing the path can make a noticeable difference. In competitive markets, a well-kept exterior can tip the scales in your favour and secure a quicker sale. With the average cost of moving house rising and the market still unpredictable, homeowners are getting creative. These simple, affordable improvements don't just add polish – they could also make or break your sale. And while you don't need to splash out on all five at once, even picking one or two could help your home stand out from the crowd. 2
The Sun
33 minutes ago
- The Sun
What happens to your equity release plan when you die?
IF you're looking to supplement your income in later life, equity release may be an option. But what happens to your plan when you die? Equity release can come in two forms, either as a lifetime mortgage or a home reversion plan. Get your FREE equity release calculation FIND HERE The most common form of equity release is a lifetime mortgage, which is a loan secured against your property. Whereas a home reversion plan allows homeowners to sell a portion of their home in exchange for a lump sum or a regular income, while still living there, typically rent-free. While structured differently, these types of equity release do share a few characteristics. For example, it's only available to homeowners over a certain age, the money you receive is tax free, and the plan finishes when the last person dies or moves into long-term care, at which point any outstanding balance would be repaid. That means taking out equity release will reduce the value of your estate - or in other words, it will leave less for an inheritance to your loved ones. So, below we explain what happens when your plan comes to an end. How does equity release work when you die or move into long-term care? Usually, for a lifetime mortgage, your home will need to be sold, and the proceeds from that sale will be used to repay any outstanding debt. This is the original capital borrowed plus any rolled-up interest. Similarly, for home reversion plans, the provider will be repaid when you die. But since these lenders own all or a portion of your home, the amount they'll be repaid depends on the percentage they own and the sale price of the property. So if your home has increased in value, the provider will benefit from the increase when your property is sold. Companies that are members of the Equity Release Council need to adhere to a strict set of rules, one of which states that plans come with a No Negative Equity Guarantee. This means your estate will never owe more than your property is worth when it is sold. This is an important feature if you're considering a lifetime mortgage. That's because if your home is sold after your death and it's worth less than your outstanding balance, your family won't be required to make up the shortfall. Find out how much you may be able to release FIND HERE Will my partner need to repay my lifetime mortgage when I die? Lifetime mortgages can be sold as joint policies, and in these instances, your surviving partner can continue to live in your home until they either die or move into long-term care. The plan will stay in place; however, the interest will continue to roll up. Some lenders do allow a 'Significant Life Event exemption' clause in your plan, which means you have the option to repay the mortgage without incurring early repayment charges if your spouse dies first. If it's not a joint policy with your partner, then they'll have the option to repay the outstanding balance or sell the home and move elsewhere. If you find a new partner after taking out equity release, then speak to an equity release advisor about adding them to your policy. Dangers of equity release EQUITY release can be a good way to unlock cash in retirement - but there are some dangers to consider, according to The Sun's Tara Evans. Interest rates on lifetime mortgages are around 5.5%, with some topping 8%. This means they can be more expensive than a traditional mortgage and you should always consider downsizing first. You could end up owing more than you borrowed, although it will never be more than the value of your home. Using equity release to take cash from your home will reduce the assets you have to pass on to loved ones when you die. It is a long-term commitment and you may be charged an early redemption fee that can be as high as 25% if you want to pay it off. Be aware that equity release could affect or stop your benefits. Always seek advice from a qualified equity release adviser. What happens if I move into full-time care? If the last policyholder moves into full-time care, then your equity release plan will need to be repaid. Once your home is sold and the proceeds are used to repay the lender, you can use the remaining balance to fund your care. If you don't have enough to afford the care you need, then you'll need to get in touch with your local authorities to investigate funding options. How long is there to repay the equity release lender after death? Equity release providers normally require the final bill to be settled no more than 12 months after your death. Your lender expects that the money released and any accrued interest will be repaid through the sale of your home, so it naturally allows time to market and negotiate the sale of the property. If the sale of your home is taking longer than expected, and whoever handles your estate is afraid of missing the deadline, they will need to get in touch with your lender to discuss options. Get your equity release calculation in seconds FIND HERE Does equity release interest stop on death? No, interest will continue to be charged on a lifetime mortgage until the outstanding balance is repaid to your lender. Will my house need to be sold to pay back my lifetime mortgage? In some instances, your beneficiary may decide they want to inherit your home and, as such, they would need to repay the outstanding balance via alternative means. However, this option will need to be discussed with your lender. Will there be any money left for inheritance? If leaving behind an inheritance for your loved ones is important, you can ring-fence a percentage of the equity in your home to be passed on to your beneficiaries when you pass away. In effect, this makes your home less valuable to your lender, and it does reduce the amount you can borrow. If this is important to you, make sure that your adviser knows to include it as a feature of your plan. Without it, the amount that is passed on to your beneficiaries will be impacted. What happens if house prices fall? A fall in house prices isn't good news for anyone with an equity release plan. For a lifetime mortgage, the amount you owe your lender doesn't change in line with any change in the house price. This means that after you have repaid the lender, if the house price has fallen, there will be less equity left over for your beneficiaries. For home reversion plans, things are different. If the house price falls, the percentage of equity in the home that you and the lender own will both drop in value. Can equity release be paid back before death? Equity release can be repaid early. Some plans allow you to make voluntary payments to stop the roll-up of interest and repay some of the capital; however, payments are subject to certain limits. Early repayment charges may apply above a set value, so if you do decide to repay the plan early, it's important to factor those charges into your decision. Sometimes, continuing to keep up with the interest repayments and repaying the outstanding balance when moving to long-term care or when you die is a better solution for you. Age Partnership is a trading name of Age Partnership Limited, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. FCA registered number 425432. Company registered in England and Wales No. 5265969. VAT registration number 162 9355 92. Registered address, 2200 Century Way, Thorpe Park, Leeds, LS15 8ZB.
