logo
Single photo says it all about the real reason Australians feel so poor right now

Single photo says it all about the real reason Australians feel so poor right now

Daily Mail​6 hours ago
Australia's prohibitively expensive electricity prices and high government spending have been blamed for the nation's productivity crisis.
Nationals senator Matt Canavan has convened an alternative roundtable at Parliament House in Canberra to Treasurer Jim Chalmers ' three-day Economic Reform Roundtable.
Chalmers is trying to find policy solutions to Australia's slipping living standards.
Senator Canavan said: 'There was no mention of a tripling of electricity prices that have occurred in the past 20 years.'
'There's no mention of the government spending that we've seen that is crowding out private investment.'
Canavan, a former economist with the Productivity Commission, noted that from 1990 to 2004, electricity prices had fallen by 19 per cent.
'We actually got in there and made some hard decisions and we lowered the cost of living for Australian people and of course helped Australian businesses compete with the rest of the world,' he said.
'Of course, since then we've lost complete control of electricity prices.'
During the 1990s to the mid-2000s, Australia's productivity - or hourly output per worker - increased by an average annual pace of 2.1 per cent during the first decade of the internet.
That was a far cry from the one per cent plunge in the year to March on Anthony Albanese's watch as Prime Minister.
The Reserve Bank has slashed its growth forecast to just 0.7 per cent a year for the next two years.
Economists have linked Australia's weak productivity growth during the past decade to a reluctance by companies to invest in new technology and machinery that would make businesses more productive.
'We are not, in my view, going to fix our productivity crisis if we cannot lower energy prices in the country, it's as simple as that,' Canavan said.
Gary Banks, a former chairman of the Productivity Commission, said Australia's productivity crisis risked making Australians poorer.
'Productivity ... has become a matter of general concern if not consternation,' he said.
'Even more concerning is the expectation, which is embedded in the Treasury's latest Intergenerational Report, of a much diminished future rate of productivity growth compared to what it was in the past.
'That will bring with it a comparable diminution in income growth and thus living standards in the longer term.'
Chalmers on Wednesday said the second day of his three-day roundtable would focus on addressing Australia's productivity crisis.
'The first day was about resilience, today is about productivity and tomorrow more fundamentally about the Budget,' he said.
'But we all know those three things are very tightly linked.
'Productivity really sits at the core of so much of what we're trying to achieve.
'In the conversations yesterday about attracting more investment, about capital deepening, capital flows in the world and in our own economy.
'Productivity is the central focus of the government, of today's part of the roundtable, but also the work that we will all do in the months and years ahead.
'It was a really deliberate decision by our government to put productivity at the centre of our economic agenda and that's primarily or exclusively because that's how we get those higher living standards that we need to see in our economy.'
Treasury is forecasting a string of deficits for at least the coming decade with government spending as a proportion of the economy at the highest level since 1986, outside of the Covid pandemic.
Shadow treasurer Ted O'Brien told Canavan's summit that workers would end up paying higher income taxes unless government spending was restrained.
'Absolutely key to where the real problem lies, that is, the government has to stop the spending spree because if it doesn't, then it's only going to go after more taxes, and the only tax they are really relying on is income tax increases,' he said.
'That's entirely what they think is going to close the gap of the deficits.'
Income taxes are expected to make up almost 52 per cent of commonwealth revenue during this financial year with neither side of politics committed to raising the GST from 10 per cent or broadening it to cover fresh food, health and education.
Labor is also committed to a net zero by 2050 target and a 43 per cent reduction by 2030.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

AI doom, nature laws and solving the housing problem: five takeaways from day two of economic reform roundtable
AI doom, nature laws and solving the housing problem: five takeaways from day two of economic reform roundtable

The Guardian

time27 minutes ago

  • The Guardian

AI doom, nature laws and solving the housing problem: five takeaways from day two of economic reform roundtable

The treasurer, Jim Chalmers, presided over talks about growing the Australian economy on day two of the economic reform roundtable. As proceedings wrapped up, Chalmers said 'there is a real prospect of a useful consensus emerging on a number of key reform areas.' Here are five takeaways from Parliament House: The government is optimistic about efforts to lower spending including on the National Disability Insurance Scheme and the age pension. The social services minister, Tanya Plibersek, on Tuesday announced plans to end the freeze on the deeming rate used to calculate welfare payments. The freeze has cost the budget about $1.8bn. Plibersek said a phased return to pre-Covid settings is appropriate as inflation pain eases for households. Separately, the health minister, Mark Butler, said the 8% growth target for the NDIS was 'simply unsustainable'. Currently growth is closer to 11%. Butler wants it lowered to 5 or 6%. Butler is expected to join a session on efficient and high-quality government services, spending and care at the summit on Thursday. While business leaders and experts talk up the potential of AI, Sally McManus, the ACTU's secretary, backed a worker-centric approach to rolling out the technology. Danielle Wood, the Productivity Commission's chair, said AI could lift the average workers' income by $4,300 per year over the coming decade. While acknowledging AI's potential, McManus said 'we shouldn't just say automatically we are all going to be better off because of AI - we've got to make sure we are'. 'It may boost productivity, it may also just boost profits.' McManus said she wasn't advocating for 'over-regulating' AI. But she said there was a 'doomer' view of the technology that comes with the fear of a 'Trump-billionaire, let-it-rip' approach. 'People have got to trust AI to deliver good outcomes. You are going to get better outcomes if you involve people in the use of it.' A discussion on better regulation and approvals involved the environment minister, Murray Watt, who is in charge of the rewrite of the Howard-era Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act (EPBC). Kelly O'Shanassy, the Australian Conservation Foundation chief, said increased productivity was meaningless if the planet is overheated and natural environment is lost. O'Shanassy has welcomed signs of consensus the establishment of areas for critical developments like housing and renewable energy. However, there was no consensus on the powers of the planned independent environment protection agency. Business has pushed for the federal government to retain approval powers. 'We went into the room a bit worried that people would have a knee jerk reaction of 'just get rid of the EPBC Act', or 'just devolve all the responsibilities to the states' or 'fast track environmental approvals for renewables and housing',' O'Shanassy said. 'None of that was the reality. I think there was support for better, smarter regulation that has increased protections for nature.' With most in agreement that we need to make it easier to build homes, Daniel Mookhey, the New South Wales treasurer, and the Business Council of Australia's chief executive, Bran Black, voiced strong support for a temporary freeze of the national construction code. Mookhey, speaking on the sidelines of the roundtable, said a pause in adding new federal regulations would 'certainly' lead to more homes being built. 'If the national code is frozen it gives us a bit more time to get the interactions between national standards and state standards clear and sorted. But equally, it will give a lot of confidence to people who are looking to build right now.' Black was more circumspect on whether there was widespread support for pausing the NCC, saying 'there isn't agreement on that within the room'. The Australian Council of Social Service boss Cassandra Goldie told the meeting a freeze might be bad for vulnerable people and flexibility was required to improve the standards of housing, including in the rental market. Meanwhile, the former industry minister Ed Husic said he was concerned about the proposed pause to the code. Husic said the former Coalition government had frozen new homebuilding regulations, only to rush through a mass of changes in a short period of time. 'People who've lived in older homes with regulations that weren't as strong understand why livability is such an issue.' The Productivity Commission's Danielle Wood reminded attendees that 'it's productivity that drives improvements in living standards'. Average productivity growth in the decade to 2014 had slumped to a 60-year low of 0.4%, she said. According to slides obtained by Guardian Australia, she blamed the slowdown on the waning boost from technology, low rates of business investment, a less dynamic economy, and a disinterest in pro-growth policy reforms. The shift to more labour-intensive services industries, such as the care sector, has also played its part in the productivity decline. The PC boss then ran through the commission's 'five pillar' interim reports. She highlighted smarter regulation is needed for approvals for building homes and green energy projects. 'Australia needs 10,000kms of new transmission lines and a six-fold increase in grid-scale renewable energy to reach net zero by 2050,' her presentation slides noted. But the average time for a decision under the EPBC for clean energy projects was over 500 days, while 45 projects from 2018 to 2022 still had no decision by November 2024. It was a similar story in housing, where Wood said actual building is a small fraction of the time it takes to build a home. 'An apartment complex that takes seven to 10 years to develop can be built in one to two years.'

Josh Willie named new Tasmanian Labor leader after party officially concedes election defeat
Josh Willie named new Tasmanian Labor leader after party officially concedes election defeat

The Guardian

time27 minutes ago

  • The Guardian

Josh Willie named new Tasmanian Labor leader after party officially concedes election defeat

Tasmanian Labor has replaced Dean Winter as parliamentary leader, with Josh Willie elected unopposed to serve as the state's new opposition leader. The party, which has been in opposition for 11 years, met for more than seven hours on Wednesday before announcing Willie's appointment. 'Tasmanian Labor has a proud history and I look forward to giving this role everything I've got to return Labor to government,' he said in a statement. It came a day after Winter's bid to take power via a no-confidence motion in parliament fell spectacularly flat. Sign up: AU Breaking News email Neither the incumbent Liberal government (14 seats) nor Labor (10) got the 18 seats needed for majority at a snap poll on 19 July, meaning both parties had spent the past month courting the 11-member crossbench in an attempt to form government. Tasmania's governor had declared that in the absence of a confidence and supply agreement, Jeremy Rockliff would remain premier as the incumbent, but Winter had flagged a motion of no confidence in the Liberals on the first day of the new parliament. None of the crossbench, made up of up five Greens, five independents and one Shooters, Fishers and Farmers MP, backed Winter's bid on Tuesday. The result meant the election was declared officially lost by Labor, with party rules meaning the leadership was automatically spilled as a result. Winter was criticised by several crossbench MPs on Tuesday for failing to compromise during policy negotiations. The Liberals made a number of concessions to the largely left-leaning crossbench, including a pledge to ban greyhound racing and review salmon farming. Labor suffered a 3% swing against it at the election and picked up 25.9% of the primary vote, the party's worst election result in more than a century. Winter, who assumed the Labor leadership 16 months ago, said he took 'full responsibility' for the election result and it was 'understandable' for the party to have a new leader. He accused Rockliff of selling out workers by shifting positions. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion 'Some say that politics is the art of compromise, but compromise does not and should not mean capitulation,' said Winter, who will continue as an MP for the seat of Franklin. Willie, from the party's left faction, was a teacher before entering politics and spent eight years in the upper house before being elected in the lower house in 2024. Janie Finlay has been elected as deputy leader, replacing Anita Dow. The Greens and several independents said they lacked faith in the Liberals, but had less faith that Labor could form a workable government. Rockliff said it was time to 'get on with the job' and policy shifts were a recognition of a minority scenario. Tasmania's fourth election in seven years was triggered after Rockliff lost a no-confidence motion in June that criticised the state's ballooning budget debt.

Australia's peak Jewish group condemns Netanyahu's ‘clumsy' attack on Albanese and calls for end to ‘spat'
Australia's peak Jewish group condemns Netanyahu's ‘clumsy' attack on Albanese and calls for end to ‘spat'

The Guardian

time27 minutes ago

  • The Guardian

Australia's peak Jewish group condemns Netanyahu's ‘clumsy' attack on Albanese and calls for end to ‘spat'

Australia's peak Jewish group has lambasted Benjamin Netanyahu's attack on Anthony Albanese as 'inflammatory and provocative', adding that the 'clumsy intervention' showed a 'woeful lack of understanding of social and political conditions in Australia' – notwithstanding what the group describes as 'unseemly' conduct from Australia's leader. The concerned intervention by the Executive Council of Australian Jewry came as Australia and Israel entered the third day of a diplomatic tit-for-tat prompted by Australia's visa cancellation of far-right Israeli politician, Simcha Rothman, on Monday. ECAJ's president, Daniel Aghion, sent separate letters to both leaders on Wednesday afternoon. In the letter to Australia's prime minister, he criticised Albanese's previous comments accusing Netanyahu of being 'in denial' as as 'excessive and gratuitously insulting'. He echoed this criticism in his letter to Israel's prime minister, saying it was 'unseemly for an Australian Prime Minister to depart from diplomatic norms'. But he also dressed down Netanyahu for labelling Albanese 'a weak politician who betrayed Israel and abandoned Australia's Jews'. 'These comments have played straight into the hands of opponents of Israel and antisemites, to the detriment of the Australian Jewish community,' Aghion wrote. 'Had we been consulted, we would have warned against such a clumsy intervention into Australia's domestic politics. The charge of antisemitism, whether made directly or indirectly, is a serious one and never to be made lightly. 'Doing so only invites scepticism, and undermines the efforts we and the government have been making to combat this pernicious phenomenon.' Alex Ryvchin, ECAJ's co-chief executive, also expressed reservations about the wording of Netanyahu's attack. 'We've never used that sort of language and if we believed it, we would have said it along the way,' he said on Wednesday. 'We've expressed concerns for nearly two years now about some of the government's rhetoric and policies and handling of the antisemitism crisis. We've had serious misgivings and we've made them known, but we've never felt abandoned. We've always felt like we can speak to government and speak to the public of this country.' He appealed for 'both governments to remember what's at stake to ensure that calm heads prevail and to conduct their matters of state privately, diplomatically'. In the Wednesday letters, ECAJ warned both leaders that Australia's Jewish community 'will not be left to deal with the fallout of a spat between two leaders who are playing to their respective domestic audiences'. 'We are now calling on both [of] you … to address the policy differences between the two governments in the usual way through diplomacy rather than public posturing,' Aghion wrote. 'If things need to be said publicly, they should be said using measured and seemly language befitting national leaders. Australia and Israel are mature democracies and their governments need to act accordingly.' Earlier on Wednesday, Albanese, when asked to respond to Netanyahu's latest criticism of him, told reporters he did not 'take these things personally'. 'I treat leaders of other countries with respect. I engage with them in a diplomatic way,' he said. The home affairs minister, Tony Burke, had earlier accused the Israeli prime minister of 'lashing out' against Australia over its decision to recognise a Palestinian state. 'Strength is not measured by how many people you can blow up or how many children you can leave hungry,' Burke told ABC on Wednesday morning. 'Strength is much better measured by exactly what prime minister Anthony Albanese has done, which is when there's a decision that we know Israel won't like, he goes straight to Benjamin Netanyahu.' The ECAJ president told both Albanese and Netanyahu he had been appalled by Burke's 'incendiary and irresponsible' comments. Australia's acting foreign affairs minister, Tim Ayres, told ABC the government would not retaliate further with public statements against Netanyahu. The former science minister, Ed Husic, one of the more outspoken pro-Palestinian supporters within the Albanese government, said Australia should ramp up sanctions against Israelis over the aid and humanitarian crisis in Gaza. 'When Prime Minister Netanyahu talks about betrayal, the betrayal is of humanitarian law, kids and innocent Palestinians,' he said. 'We have 60,000 innocent Palestinians killed, half of which are women and children. And I would suggest respectfully to Prime Minister Netanyahu, the bigger focus should be to stop seeing kids being killed or starved.' Husic was followed by Ophir Falk, a foreign policy advisor to Netanyahu, who claimed to the ABC that Australia's decision to recognise a Palestinian state had been 'a huge reward for Hamas'. 'The fact of the matter is that the Australian government is morally bankrupt,' Falk said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store