Why a vacant plot of land next to a new children's hospice has sparked outrage as a state politician attempts to take it away from a 'foolish' council
A Perth council has come under fire for opposing plans to build a park outside a hospital for terminally ill children.
The City of Nedlands pushed back against a proposal to transform the plot of land next to a new children's hospice that is set to open in Swanbourne mid next year.
In a statement, the council said the community had expressed concerns the 3,000sq metre park lay in a bushfire zone.
'The community have expressed concern regarding the bushfire zone and ensuring public access through Allen Park to the beach at all times,' they wrote.
'The city hopes these matters will be considered in the final plan and welcomes the opening of the hospice, which will provide valuable support and care for sick children and their families.'
Western Australian Lands Minister John Carey blasted the decision and announced plans to excise the 3,000sq metres from the council so the park could be built.
He announced the proposal on Saturday, aiming to transfer the beachfront site to the state government when the motion goes before parliament next week.
Mr Carey said overruling the council was 'the right decision'.
'I've not seen anything like it, I think Nedlands is one of the worst councils in Western Australia,' Mr Carey told Nine News.
'It is a damning indictment of the Nedlands council and their opposition to both the hospice and now this park.'
The Perth Children's Hospital Foundation (PCHF) will build the hospice.
The hospice is expected to be open to take on terminally ill children from mid next year.
PCHF chair Ian Campbell said the City of Nedland's council had 'made absolute fools of themselves'.
'We are delighted that the City of Nedlands has been made irrelevant and we can get on with building a beautiful native bushland,' he said.
'We're going to go out to the whole community and say here this is our master plan, this is what we're looking at doing, come up with better ideas, we want the community to own this project,' Mr Campbell told the ABC.
The Allen Park plot had been neglected, he said.
'It's a priceless jewel that the City of Nedlands has treated like absolute rubbish.'
In a statement, Mr Carey said the park would be an 'oasis for children and families at the most difficult point in their lives'.
'The decision to excise this land will allow the Perth Children's Hospital Foundation to invest in a park for hospice patients, families and the wider community,' he said.
'The Cook Government is continuing to back Boodja Mia, despite opposition from the City of Nedlands.'
The planning minister will lay the motion before parliament in eight days.
After two weeks before the chambers, if there are no disagreements, ownership of the land will change hands to the state.
The opposition has reportedly indicated their support for the motion.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
I finally found a rental in the crazy property market. Then my son started getting nosebleeds... and I realised our problems were far from over
A single mum and her young son are at a crossroads after their health deteriorated from black mould they found growing in the carpets of their rental. Genevieve, 35, and her 10-year-old son moved into the property in north Brisbane in 2023. About a year into the lease, they both began suffering strange symptoms. 'My son already has asthma but his respiratory problems have gotten worse and he's begun getting nosebleeds,' Genevieve told Daily Mail Australia. 'I have had allergy symptoms like watery eyes, difficulty catching my breath.' Genevieve then made a shocking discovery. Her carpets contained black mould - a fungus that grows in warm, damp areas that can trigger allergic reactions, respiratory problems and even chronic illnesses. Genevieve immediately emailed her real estate agent but said she has received little help in removing it. She found black mould under the carpet (pictured) and later on the walls and her son's belongings and alerted the issue to her landlord - who is now considering his options Despite her best efforts to get rid of the mould herself, it came back with a vengeance, this time contaminating the walls and her son's belongings in his bedroom. 'I sent several emails (to the real estate agent) in March, April and May about the mould and they sent people out to test it,' she said. 'We've had no follow-up since then. The real estate said the landlord is working out his options, but it's been three weeks.' Genevieve said the shortage of affordable homes in Brisbane meant they had decided to stay in the property for now, despite her son's worsening health. 'We're both taking Nasonex, a steroid nasal spray, at night before we go to bed which we were prescribed by the GP,' she said. 'It's specifically for mould allergies - a problem neither of us had before. 'I'm not a doctor but all the health problems seem to be related to the mould spores.' Then, Genevieve received a call from her 'guardian angel'. 'The agent who helped me find this home reached out to me,' she said. 'She called me because I'd applied for another property and she wanted to check how we were doing and if we needed any help. 'She's a remarkable human and incredibly compassionate which is really rare in the property world.' The woman was able to find a new home for Genevieve and her son. 'It's all been renovated and it's a very beautiful, freestanding, two-bedroom rental but the rent is almost $100 more than I pay here,' Genevieve explained. The single mum is worried her landlord will withhold her bond to remove the mould and pay for new carpets, despite her complaints early on in the lease. Without that safety net, Genevieve will struggle to pay the bond for her new home, especially considering she will need to pick up extra shifts to cover the higher rent. Queensland's Rental Tenancies Authority states the burden of who pays for cleaning mould and fixing any damage 'depends on how the mould appeared in the first place'. 'If mould is a result of problems with the property - for example, a leaking roof, or water damage caused by leaking pipework, it is the property manager/owner's responsibility to address the mould and make any necessary repairs,' it said. 'If the tenant has caused the mould to appear - for example, by allowing steam to build up in a bathroom without proper ventilation and/or regular cleaning, they are responsible for cleaning it and paying for any damages that the mould has caused.' A friend recommended Genevieve start a GoFundMe to help with the upcoming costs. In a post on the fundraiser, Genevieve described her new home as 'a fresh start we deeply need - one with light, space, and safety'. 'Moving, as you know, comes with costs: rental bond, upfront rent, moving expenses. 'I'm not in a position to access credit or loans, and asking for financial help is not something I do easily. I've carried shame around this. But I also believe in the power of community and vulnerability. 'If you feel moved to support us, any amount - big or small - would mean the world. Your donation will go directly toward our bond and moving costs to help us settle into a healthy, stable home where we can continue our healing.' The fundraiser has already received more than $2,600 from 35 donors, which Genevieve and her son are grateful for.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Why a vacant plot of land next to a new children's hospice has sparked outrage as a state politician attempts to take it away from a 'foolish' council
A Perth council has come under fire for opposing plans to build a park outside a hospital for terminally ill children. The City of Nedlands pushed back against a proposal to transform the plot of land next to a new children's hospice that is set to open in Swanbourne mid next year. In a statement, the council said the community had expressed concerns the 3,000sq metre park lay in a bushfire zone. 'The community have expressed concern regarding the bushfire zone and ensuring public access through Allen Park to the beach at all times,' they wrote. 'The city hopes these matters will be considered in the final plan and welcomes the opening of the hospice, which will provide valuable support and care for sick children and their families.' Western Australian Lands Minister John Carey blasted the decision and announced plans to excise the 3,000sq metres from the council so the park could be built. He announced the proposal on Saturday, aiming to transfer the beachfront site to the state government when the motion goes before parliament next week. Mr Carey said overruling the council was 'the right decision'. 'I've not seen anything like it, I think Nedlands is one of the worst councils in Western Australia,' Mr Carey told Nine News. 'It is a damning indictment of the Nedlands council and their opposition to both the hospice and now this park.' The Perth Children's Hospital Foundation (PCHF) will build the hospice. The hospice is expected to be open to take on terminally ill children from mid next year. PCHF chair Ian Campbell said the City of Nedland's council had 'made absolute fools of themselves'. 'We are delighted that the City of Nedlands has been made irrelevant and we can get on with building a beautiful native bushland,' he said. 'We're going to go out to the whole community and say here this is our master plan, this is what we're looking at doing, come up with better ideas, we want the community to own this project,' Mr Campbell told the ABC. The Allen Park plot had been neglected, he said. 'It's a priceless jewel that the City of Nedlands has treated like absolute rubbish.' In a statement, Mr Carey said the park would be an 'oasis for children and families at the most difficult point in their lives'. 'The decision to excise this land will allow the Perth Children's Hospital Foundation to invest in a park for hospice patients, families and the wider community,' he said. 'The Cook Government is continuing to back Boodja Mia, despite opposition from the City of Nedlands.' The planning minister will lay the motion before parliament in eight days. After two weeks before the chambers, if there are no disagreements, ownership of the land will change hands to the state. The opposition has reportedly indicated their support for the motion.
The Guardian
7 hours ago
- The Guardian
SBS's Insight accused of betraying people living with chronic fatigue syndrome who appeared on program
People living with chronic fatigue syndrome who appeared on SBS's Insight program have accused the broadcaster of betraying them in the final cut, which presented what they claim is a potentially harmful and unscientific narrative and favoured a person who said she had 'cured herself' by 'listening to her body'. The SBS ombudsman is investigating their individual complaints, as well as one from Emerge Australia, the national advocacy body for patients with myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/CFS). There are hundreds of negative comments about the episode on the program's social media pages. One participant who is a carer for his wife and daughter, Peter McCluskey, has told the SBS ombudsman the final broadcast 'compounded the invalidation and gaslighting that patients and carers endure daily'. McCluskey wrote a first-person piece for SBS about his family's experience, which was published ahead of the episode airing last month. 'The editorial decisions made by Insight undermined what we naively thought was the very purpose of the episode and breached multiple clauses of the SBS code of practice,' he wrote in a complaint seen by Guardian Australia. He accused SBS of '… sidelining science, clinical expertise, and the lived experience of patients – all under the guise of balance'. 'Rather than giving voice to a stigmatised and misunderstood community, the program re-traumatised it.' Sign up to get Guardian Australia's weekly media diary as a free newsletter The chief executive of Emerge Australia, Anne Wilson, accused SBS of presenting what she described as 'a harmful narrative' by giving disproportionate airtime to one person who said she had recovered from ME/CFS, and then to have contracted and recovered from rheumatoid arthritis without medical care. She said she had 'cured herself' by 'listening to her body' and was now running marathons. Wilson accused Insight of undermining decades of scientific research, education and advocacy by not challenging the narrative. 'Scientific evidence states that there is no recovery from rheumatoid arthritis and less than 10% of people with ME/CFS return to pre-illness functioning,' Wilson said. 'Of further concern, this person claimed their recovery was due to attitude alone, implying that recovery is a choice or can be achieved through effort alone. There are no proven treatments for ME/CFS and there is no cure. The small number who recover are the lucky few.' Emerge was approached by Insight producers to provide people to appear on the show and agreed to because of the program's 'positive reputation as well-researched, serious journalism', Wilson said. 'We were pleased the program chose to feature the often-overlooked challenges of living with invisible illnesses such as ME/CFS, long Covid, fibromyalgia and similar conditions. Sign up to Weekly Beast Amanda Meade's weekly diary on the latest in Australian media, free every Friday after newsletter promotion 'We were, however, extremely disappointed by the unbalanced narrative portrayed in the episode. Ironically, the episode accurately reflected the gaslighting experienced by many living with invisible illnesses.' Another participant, Allie Rawlings, said she agreed to be part of the studio discussion because she believed SBS had integrity, but she was disappointed with the edited program which was broadcast. 'The content aired bore little resemblance to the contributions I made during filming, stripping away the nuance, complexity, and intent of my perspective,' she told the ombudsman. Another complainant, Lauren Beasley, said she had hoped the episode would bring clarity and compassion about her illness to the wider public. 'Instead of platforming the full spectrum of experiences, the episode centred disproportionately on a highly individualised recovery narrative – one based on mindset, willpower, and personal agency,' Beasley wrote. A spokesperson for SBS said Insight's remit is to examine topical issues from a variety of perspectives. 'We generally receive a range of feedback, as we did for this topic, and we'll be responding to these audience members in line with our usual practices,' the spokesperson said. 'Like all of our content, Insight is subject to the SBS Code of Practice, which states that SBS will share a diversity of views and perspectives, and requires our news and current affairs programs to provide balanced and impartial coverage. We appreciate the contribution of the participants who shared their lived experiences in the studio and helped to raise awareness of the important issue of invisible illness.'
