Study confirms there's no innate difference in aptitude between boys and girls in math
Classroom teaching may be driving a gender gap in math performance, and the effect starts from the moment children begin school, a new study finds.
The study, published July 11 in the journal Nature, included data on the math skills of more than 2.5 million first-grade children in France. It revealed that, while girls and boys started school with a similar level of math skills, within four months, boys performed significantly better than girls. That gap quadrupled in size by the end of the first year of formal education.
Gender gaps in math performance have been documented the world over, and the origin of this disparity has long been blamed on supposedly inherent differences between the genders — "boys are better at math" and "girls are better at language" — that are actually just stereotypes without scientific backing.
But the new study — and previous studies conducted in the U.S. — throw a wrench in those ideas, and instead suggest that something about formal math education spurs the gap to form.
"I was very surprised, not by the fact that there was a gender gap, but that it emerges at the time when formal math instruction in school begins," study coauthor Elizabeth Spelke, a professor of psychology at Harvard University, told Live Science.
Formal education widens gaps
The new study leveraged an initiative by the French Ministry of Education to boost national math standards, which was launched after several years of disappointing performances in international assessments and uncovered the disturbing extent of the math skills gender gap in the country.
Related: Is there really a difference between male and female brains? Emerging science is revealing the answer.
With the aid of cognitive scientists and educators, the French government implemented a universal program of testing for all French children to help teachers better understand the needs of each class and inform updated national standards. Since 2018, every child's math and language skills have been assessed upon entry into first grade, the first mandatory year of schooling in France. They were tested again after four months of formal education and then after one complete year of learning.
These tests revealed no notable differences between girls' and boys' mathematical ability when starting school. However, within four months, a sizable gap opened up between them, placing boys ahead, and that gap only grew as schooling progressed, suggesting that classroom activities had created the disparity, the study authors proposed.
Spelke and her team's analysis covered four national cohorts whose data were collected between 2018 and 2022, and included demographic data to probe the role of external social factors — such as family structure and socioeconomic status (SES) — on school performance. But they found that the emergence of the math gender gap was universal and transcended every parameter investigated: regardless of SES, family structure or type of school, on average, boys performed substantially better in the third assessment than did girls.
This bolstered the hypothesis that an aspect of the schooling itself was to blame. And that idea was further supported by data from the cohort impacted by COVID-related school closures, Spelke added.
"When schools were closed during the pandemic, the gender gap got narrower and then they reopened and it got bigger again," she said. "So there are lots of reasons to think that the gender gap is linked in some way that we don't understand to the onset and progress of formal math instruction."
Causes of the math performance gap
For Jenefer Golding, a pedagogy specialist at University College London who was not involved in the study, the research raises worrying questions about attitudes or behaviors in the classroom that could be creating this disparity.
"Gendered patterns are widespread but they're not inevitable," Golding told Live Science. "It's about equity of opportunity. We need to be quite sure that we're not putting avoidable obstacles in the way of young people who might thrive in these fields." However, separating these educational factors from possible social or biological contributors remains a complex issue, she said.
As a purely observational study, the research does not allow any firm conclusions to be drawn about why this gender gap becomes so pronounced upon starting school. But the alarming findings are already prompting discussion among educational experts.
Educational analyst Sabine Meinck of the International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement drew on her own research, noting that "our data suggest early gendered patterns in parental engagement, [so] gender stereotypes may begin to take root through early childhood play."
RELATED STORIES
—'Let's just study males and keep it simple': How excluding female animals from research held neuroscience back, and could do so again
—When was math invented?
—Parents who have this gene may be more likely to have a girl
For example, "parents report engaging girls significantly more in early literacy activities, while boys are more often involved with building blocks and construction toys," she told Live Science in an email. That may be laying a foundation for how kids engage with reading and math learning in school. These differences in early childhood play have previously correlated with differing levels of scholastic achievement down the line.
The next step requires more research in classrooms, Spelke said, where researchers should gather data to develop interventions that could be useful to students, then test them. "And when we find that something is working, then it can be implemented across the board."
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Forbes
an hour ago
- Forbes
International Resistance To AI In Education Marked In Open Letter
Breaking the techno-ties that bind As the use spreads of computer tools marketed as artificial intelligence, some educators and even entire institutions are embracing the new tech. For example, Ohio State University has anounced a bold AI Fluency initiative to redefine learning and innovation. But some educators are pushing back against the 'inevitable' technology, and open letters are becoming one tool of the resistance. Literary Hub published a letter from authors addressed to publishers. In the Netherlands, over 900 educators have signed a letter entitled 'Stop the Uncritical Adoption of AI Technologies in Academia.' The unfettered introduction of AI technology leads to contravention of the spirit of the EU Al act. It undermines our basic pedagogical values and the principles of scientific integrity. It prevents us from maintaining our standards of independence and transparency. And most concerning, AI use has been shown to hinder learning and deskill critical thought. Earlier in July, another open letter launched 'from educators who refuse the call to adopt GenAI in education.' Melanie Dusseau (University of Findlay) and Miriam Reynoldson (RMIT University) got the petition up and running, and to date over 700 educators have signed on in just two weeks. Dusseau has previously spoken out about AI in education with an article at Inside Higher Ed last November, arguing that resistance is not futile. If you are tired of the drumbeat of inevitability that insists English faculty adopt AI into our teaching practices, I am here to tell you that you are allowed to object. Using an understanding of human writing as a means to allow for-profit technology companies to dismantle the imaginative practice of human writing is abhorrent and unethical. Writing faculty have both the agency and the academic freedom to examine generative AI's dishonest training origins and conclude: There is no path to ethically teach AI skills. The open letter declares that 'Current GenAI technologies represent unacceptable legal, ethical and environmental harms,' that it is 'a threat to student learning and wellbeing,' and that it is "overwhelmingly aimed at automating and replacing human effort.' The open letter includes a series of pledges, including a refusal to use AI to design or evaluate coursework, nor include 'AI literacy' in course design. They also pledge to resist marketing hype, especially that coming from salespeople who are net themselves educators (a problem in education that predates the invention of the computer). Numerous writers tout the 'inevitability' of AI in education {the London School of Science and Technology published a whole post about 'the futility of resisting AI in education'). But there are also voices arguing against any rush to AI adoption. Scott Latham, Ph.D., a professor of strategy at the Manning School of Business at the University of Massachusetts, wrote a 'memo to teachers' at Inside Higher Ed last year, 'AI Is Not Your Friend' And writing educator John Warner mounts a defense of humanity in writing and writing instruction is his new book, More Than Words. Dusseau said via email that she and Reynoldson 'wanted to do something that focused on autonomy and academic freedom in the face of the many ethical concerns surrounding generative AI technology.' What they created was one more sign of international resistance to GenAI.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
How to get the anti-ageing benefits of fasting without having to give up eating
Humans have been practising fasts for millennia. Our bodies are built to fast: 'It is literally the reason we carry body fat,' explains Dr Jason Fung, a nephrologist, fasting expert and the author of The Obesity Code. When the body goes into fasting mode it supports cellular rejuvenation and longevity. However, most of us cannot stick to an extended fast, drinking nothing but water, and still live a normal life. Cue a little known molecule called spermidine, found in everything from blue cheese and mushrooms to wheat germ and soybeans, that is rapidly becoming one of most talked-about topics in longevity research. Some scientists even believe it may be one of the key reasons why some people live longer than others because it helps to rid the body of damaged cells linked to ageing. 'There is no other longevity compound on the market that packs as big a punch as spermidine. By activating the body's vital cell renewal and recycling process – called autophagy (which also occurs when you fast) – it targets ageing at the source. This looks like reduced inflammation, rejuvenated cells and enhanced hair growth, all a result of the cellular clean-up occurring within,' says Leslie Kenny, the founder of Oxford Healthspan and co-founder of the Oxford Longevity Project. 'I make a point of eating spermidine-rich food every day – such as lentils, beans, peas and mushrooms. I also add a food-derived spermidine supplement with the minimum effective daily dose (1mg) shown to improve memory in older adults with subjective cognitive decline,' she says. Recent research backs up what she says. And unlike some other longevity trends, spermidine isn't just for lab mice. Human studies, including a 13-year observational trial and several clinical studies in older adults, have linked higher spermidine intake with better memory, lower blood pressure and even a reduced risk of death. Spermidine is a naturally occurring compound found in a variety of foods, especially those from plant sources and fermented products. Plants, animals and microbes produce spermidine naturally during metabolism. So, any fresh or unprocessed food will contain it to some degree. What makes spermidine stand out is its ability to stimulate a process called autophagy, a kind of internal cellular spring-cleaning that clears out damaged cells and helps cells work more efficiently. As we age, this process slows down, contributing to the development of chronic conditions like cancer, cardiovascular disease and neurodegeneration. But spermidine appears to reactivate autophagy even in older cells, offering a drug-free method of slowing ageing. 'Think of it as a molecular amplifier for health,' says Nektarios Tavernarakis, the author of a study in Nature Cell Biology into the health effects of spermidine. 'It helps cells tidy themselves, boosting resilience, energy production and potentially warding off disease.' His research identified spermidine as essential to the longevity benefits of fasting. Fasting naturally increases autophagy, the body's cellular 'clean-up' process, and spermidine mimics and enhances this effect by promoting the same pathways. This cellular renewal helps reduce age-related damage and inflammation. Spermidine and brain health Cognitive decline is one of the most feared consequences of ageing, but spermidine could offer hope. A clinical trial published in Alzheimer's & Dementia found that three months of spermidine supplementation improved memory in older adults with mild cognitive impairment. The SmartAge trial, published in GeroScience, also found improvements in memory and reductions in inflammatory markers in participants aged 60 to 90. So, how does it work? 'Spermidine stimulates autophagy, which breaks down faulty proteins that otherwise accumulate in the brain and are linked to Alzheimer's disease,' explains Tavernarakis. This 'cellular housekeeping' clears the way for neurons to function better. Andrew Steele, who worked at the Francis Crick Institute decoding DNA and author of Ageless: The New Science of Getting Older Without Getting Old, is cautiously optimistic: 'It's likely spermidine provides a general slowing of biological ageing. That may benefit the brain just as much as the heart or gut.' He adds: 'In animal studies, it's helped restore cognitive and motor function. And in humans, we've seen memory improvements.' 'Evidence suggests those consuming more spermidine, mostly in a Mediterranean diet, have better brain (function) and higher life expectancy,' says Dr Stefan Kiechl, a professor of neurology at Innsbruck University, Austria, and one of the world's leading researchers into the health effects of spermidine. How spermidine improves heart health Heart disease remains the world's leading cause of death. New research suggests spermidine could also protect your heart. In aged mice, spermidine supplementation has been shown to enhance heart elasticity, reduce fibrosis (stiffening) and improve mitochondrial function, which supports energy production within cells. 'It mimics some of the benefits of exercise and caloric restriction,' says Tavernarakis, who has studied spermidine's effects on cardiometabolic health. 'People with high spermidine intake tend to have lower blood pressure and a reduced risk of cardiovascular disease,' he says. A study from Nutrients (2024), using UK Biobank data, reported not only fewer heart attacks but a significant reduction in all-cause mortality for those with high dietary spermidine. 'In our population studies, individuals with higher spermidine consumption, primarily from Mediterranean diets, had better heart health,' notes Kiechl. 'And the anti-inflammatory effects may also play a key role.' Other studies support his claim and a 2024 UK Biobank study also linked higher polyamine intake with fewer heart problems and an 18 per cent reduction in early death. Spermidine and cancer Emerging research highlights spermidine's potential in cancer prevention through several mechanisms. By triggering autophagy, spermidine can lower the chance of cells turning cancerous. A 2018 review in Nature Reviews Cancer found how autophagy can prevent the initiation of tumours by maintaining healthy cells in the body. Spermidine also supports immune function, particularly by rejuvenating T cells, which are crucial for identifying and eliminating cancer cells. A 2020 study published in Nature Communications demonstrated that spermidine supplementation restored T cell function in aged mice, improving immune surveillance against tumours. Spermidine and gut health Another area where spermidine shows promise is the gut, particularly through its influence on the gut microbiome. The gut plays a dual role when it comes to spermidine. It is where spermidine from food gets absorbed into the body. But also many of the beneficial microbes in your digestive system, especially in the colon, naturally produce spermidine as part of their normal activity. 'Because it boosts autophagy, spermidine supports the gut barrier and helps maintain healthy microbial balance,' says Steele. 'This could be important for preventing chronic gut inflammation and related disorders like inflammatory bowel disease or metabolic syndrome.' Although research is still in the early stages, some studies suggest that spermidine may help keep the lining of the gut strong and intact, preventing harmful substances, like toxins, bacteria and partially digested food particles, from leaking into the body and triggering inflammation. There is also evidence that it helps gut-residing immune cells function better, which could be especially beneficial as we age. Adding spermidine to your diet One of the easiest and safest ways to get more spermidine is through your diet. Aged cheese, mushrooms, soy products, whole grains and legumes are all good sources. Wheat germ is especially high in spermidine, which you can sprinkle on your yogurt or cereal at breakfast. A tablespoon of wheat germ provides around 1.2 milligrams of spermidine, and 100g of mushrooms or cheddar can offer up to 10mg. Studies suggest that a daily intake of 5mg to 10mg may support health benefits, which can be achieved through a balanced mix of these foods consumed regularly throughout the week.A large US study found that people with the highest spermidine intake from foods like cereals, vegetables, legumes and cheese had significantly lower risks of cardiovascular disease and all-cause mortality. Kiechl advises a measured approach for now. 'Evidence is strong but there are no 'gold standard' large-scale intervention trials which are necessary for standard medical recommendations,' he says. As spermidine is naturally found in a wide range of everyday foods, it should be easy to boost intake if you don't want to use supplements. That said, for those who prefer a more targeted approach, there are now a number of spermidine supplements on the market that are specifically tested for purity, safety and consistency. These supplement options provide a potential alternative for those who want to explore spermidine's health benefits in a measured, evidence-aware way, while science continues to catch up. Kenny says spermidine has had a dramatic impact on her health, after she was diagnosed with lupus, rheumatoid arthritis and Hashimoto's thyroiditis in her late 30s. 'The biggest area has been in my hsCRP (high-sensitivity C-reactive protein), a biomarker of systemic inflammation in the body. Mine is 0.3 – the same as a healthy teenager. In addition, my biological age, as measured by the GlycanAge test, which measures many other inflammatory markers, shows my biological age as 21. This matters because at 39, I was told inflammation in my body was so out of control, I had only five years left to live. 'Other places I notice are my hair quality and colour – I am 60 and don't dye my hair, or need any hair treatments, because my hair, lashes and brows are all healthy and growing as they would when I was younger. I also get consistently strong deep-sleep scores (60-plus minutes) on my Oura Ring when I take it before bed. This is important because it's only during deep sleep that the glymphatic system, the brain's 'washing machine', gets to work to remove the rubbish that piles up during the day that is associated with dementia.' Spermidine supplements Primeadine Original spermidine, from Oxford Healthspan, co-founded by Leslie Kenny, is developed in Japan from non-GMO wheat germ and is third-party laboratory tested. Longevity Box offers a plant-based spermidine supplement aimed at supporting cellular renewal and healthy ageing. UK-based Youth & Earth also offers a well-regarded spermidine supplement made from high-grade wheat germ extract. Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.


Gizmodo
an hour ago
- Gizmodo
Neptune Dances in Sync With a Rare Distant Object, Astronomers Find
For lovers of newly identified space objects, July has indeed been an exciting month. Last week, astronomers described Ammonite, a potential dwarf planet beyond Pluto. Yesterday, astronomers announced the existence of BetelBuddy, a small companion star orbiting Betelgeuse. And now we have another exciting discovery to share. In a Planetary Science Journal paper published earlier this month, astronomers with the Large inclination Distant Objects (LiDO) survey reported the discovery of 2020 VN40, a rare distant object that orbits the Sun once for every ten orbits Neptune completes. Astronomers have classified 2020 VN40 as a trans-Neptunian object—a class of small objects and dwarf planets that orbit the Sun at a greater distance than Neptune. The small object sports a peculiar, tilted orbit that places it in orbital resonance with Neptune at a ratio of 10:1. This means the two celestial bodies affect each other's motion, locking them into a clean, neat ratio of orbital periods. 'This is a big step in understanding the outer solar system,' Rosemary Pike, lead researcher from the Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian, said in a statement. 'It shows that even very distant regions influenced by Neptune can contain objects, and it gives us new clues about how the solar system evolved.' Spotting an oddball object in the solar system is always a cause for celebration, but 2020 VN40 stands out for a couple of reasons. First, it supports the idea that Neptune's gravity can pull distant objects into the inner solar system—something astronomers have documented with other distant objects. What's more, 2020 VN40 features a strange, tilted orbit that brings it closer to the Sun when it's nearest to Neptune—the opposite of how most similar objects behave. This tilt is what's causing the observed orbital sync between Neptune and 2020 VN40, in which the smaller object approaches the Sun once for every ten orbits Neptune completes, according to the study authors. This means that, for 2020 VN, one year is equal to 1,650 Earth years! 'This new motion is like finding a hidden rhythm in a song we thought we knew,' said study co-author Ruth Murray-Clay, an astronomer at the University of California, Santa Cruz. 'It could change how we think about the way distant objects move.' 'This is just the beginning,' said Kathryn Volk of the Planetary Science Institute. 'We're opening a new window into the solar system's past.'