Fact check: Which EU country returns the most irregular immigrants?
Minister of the Presidency of Portugal António Leitão Amaro, of the ruling centre-right Social Democratic Party, recently said that the Socialist Party failed to tackle illegal immigration during its roughly eight years in government between 2015 and 2024.
He said that Portugal is "one of the countries that returns the fewest illegal immigrants", but how do its return figures compare to those of other EU countries?
To find out, we took a look at official Eurostat statistics, which log the third country nationals returned following an order to leave each EU country every quarter.
And yes, Portugal is consistently ranked as one of the countries with the lowest return rates.
For example, the most recent dataset including every EU member is Q3 2024, which shows that Slovakia returned the fewest irregular migrants, having sent back 55 people, followed by Slovenia with 80 and then Portugal with 85.
On the other side of the spectrum was France, having returned nearly 4,000 people, followed by Germany and Spain with just over 3,000 people each.
It's a similar story every year: in Q1 2025, France, Germany and this time Cyprus returned the most irregular immigrants, according to Eurostat, with Luxembourg, Slovenia and Slovakia bringing up the rear.
The Portuguese figures for this quarter aren't yet available on Eurostat, but the country has generally been at the bottom end of the table every quarter since 2022.
The same is true for the number of orders to leave the EU which each member state has handed out, without necessarily having carried them out yet.
Eurostat figures show that Slovakia gave the fewest orders to leave to irregular migrants in Q3 2024 (80), followed by Portugal (120) and Estonia (135).
France was way ahead of the pack with 30,800, but Germany (13,660) and Spain (13,645) once again rounded out the top three.
Figures indicate the EU as a whole is ramping up efforts to clamp down on irregular immigration.
New figures released on Monday reveal that in the first quarter of 2025, 123,905 non-EU citizens were ordered to leave an EU country, and 28,475 people were returned to third countries following an order to leave.
Compared with Q1 2024, the number of non-EU citizens ordered to leave went up by 18.4% and the number of people returned to third countries was up by 6.4%.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
37 minutes ago
- France 24
Macron urges Putin to accept Ukraine ceasefire in first phone call since 2022
In a two-hour call with Russia 's President Vladimir Putin, French President Emmanuel Macron on Tuesday called for a ceasefire in Ukraine and the start of negotiations on ending the conflict, the French president's office said on Tuesday. The pair, who had not spoken since September 2022, according to the Élysée presidential palace. Macron "emphasised France's unwavering support for Ukraine's sovereignty and territorial integrity" and "called for the establishment, as soon as possible, of a ceasefire and the launch of negotiations between Ukraine and Russia for a solid and lasting settlement of the conflict", the French presidential office said. Putin blamed the West for the Ukraine conflict in his telephone conversation and said any peace deal should be "long-term", said the Kremlin readout of the call. "Vladimir Putin reminded [Macron] that the Ukrainian conflict is a direct consequence of the policy of Western states," the Kremlin said in a statement. Putin added that Western states had "for many years ignored Russia's security interests" and "created an anti-Russian bridgehead in Ukraine". The Kremlin said Putin told the French president that any peace deal should be "comprehensive and long-term, provide for the elimination of the root causes of the Ukrainian crisis and be based on new territorial realities". Putin has previously said Ukraine must accept Russia's annexation of swathes of its territory as part of any peace deal. Macron seeks diplomatic solution to Iran's nuclear programme, missiles Macron's office said the French president also stressed the need for Iran to comply with its obligations under the UN's Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) and to cooperate fully with the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). The French president expressed his "determination" to seek a diplomatic solution that would allow for a lasting settlement of the nuclear issue, the question of Iran's missiles and its role in the region. Putin told Macron that Iran has a "right" to develop a "peaceful" nuclear programme, said the Kremlin. The two leaders agreed to coordinate their efforts and to speak again soon, the Élysée statement said. Attempts at high-level contact between France and Russia The French leader tried in a series of phone calls in 2022 to warn Putin against invading Ukraine and travelled to Moscow early that year. He kept up phone contact with Putin after the invasion but talks then ceased, with the last call between the presidents dating back to September 2022. Macron has over the last year toughened his line against Russia, saying its expansionism is a threat to all of Europe. The French president has also refused to rule out putting troops on the ground in Ukraine. In April 2024, Russia's then defence minister Sergei Shoigu and French counterpart Sebastien Lecornu, a close confidant of Macron, held talks focused on security in the run-up to the Olympic Games in Paris. That was the last official high-level contact between the two countries.
Euronews
2 hours ago
- Euronews
Will new animal welfare law curb illegal trade?
The upcoming legislation sets minimum rules for the entire EU, such as mandatory microchipping and registration of dogs and cats born in or imported into the bloc. Pet registration is already mandatory in 24 of the 27 EU Member States, but the systems are fragmented. A future common online data base should tackle the problem said Tilly Metz, an MEP from the Green group and shadow rapporteur for the regulation. "It is now the responsibility of the European Commission to implement a system that works in all member states, so that we can guarantee interoperability and real traceability of the animal throughout Europe," Metz told Euronews. The EU dog and cat trade is worth 1.3 billion euros annually. Around 60% of owners purchase them online, which has led to opacity regarding the origin of the animals, their health and whether they are vaccinated. According to a study by the European Commission, the main countries of origin for the illegal animal trade are Romania and Hungary, both EU members, and the third countries Russia, Belarus, Serbia and Turkey. "That's why we also want the animal to be registered as quickly as possible when it enters the European Union and we have been advocating that this should happen at the border," the MEP added. End 'animal mills' The European Parliament also defends a ban on the sale of dogs and cats in pet shops in an amended proposal to the law approved this month. Inappropriate practices in the breeding of these pets are also being addressed, by imposing limits on the number of litters a female can have. "The maximum is three litters in a two-year period, followed by a one-year break. This is because frequent pregnancies lead to malnutrition or weakening of the immune system," said Gerardo Fortuna, a Euronews reporter who has been covering the new law. "It is one of the ways to curb the phenomenon of puppy mills, that has both support of the Council and Parliament," he added. To avoid consanguinity, the crossbreeding between parents and children, grandparents and grandchildren, as well as between siblings and half-siblings will be prohibited. Although cats and dogs make up 90% of Europeans' pets, the law could be soon enough extended to other companion animals, with the permitted species to be defined in a so-called "Positive List", an idea proposed by the European Parliament. Watch the video here! Journalist: Isabel Marques da Silva Content production: Pilar Montero López Video production: Zacharia Vigneron Graphism: Loredana Dumitru Editorial coordination: Ana Lázaro Bosch and Jeremy Fleming-Jones
LeMonde
3 hours ago
- LeMonde
French diplomat visits two French nationals detained in Iran
A French diplomat on Tuesday, July 1, visited two French nationals detained in Iran, Cécile Kohler and Jacques Paris, the foreign minister said, after their families demanded proof that they were alive after Israeli strikes. The fates of Kohler and Paris had been unknown since Israel targeted Iran's Evin prison in an air strike last week, before a US-proposed ceasefire between the belligerent parties came into force. "We obtained a visit today from our chargé d'affaires in Iran," Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot told lawmakers. A French Foreign Ministry spokeswoman confirmed the visit had taken place earlier in the day. However, the ministry did not specify where the visit occurred, amid uncertainty over the couple's whereabouts. Iran's judiciary has said the Israeli strike on the prison had killed at least 79 people. It also said that the Iranian prison authority transferred inmates out of Evin prison, without specifying their number or identifying them. Several women prisoners have been transferred to Qarchak prison for women outside Tehran, which has a notorious reputation for its conditions. Around 20 European nationals detained On Friday, the families of Kohler and Paris demanded "proof of life," while a lawyer denounced their "forced disappearance." Kohler, 40, and Paris, her 72-year-old partner, have been held in Iran since May 2022 on espionage charges that their families reject. Iran is believed to be detaining around 20 European nationals, many of whose cases have never been publicized, in what some Western governments, including France, describe as a strategy of hostage-taking aimed at extracting concessions from the West. Three Europeans, who have not been identified, have also been arrested in the wake of the current conflict, two of whom stand accused of spying for Israel, according to the authorities.
