27 Actors Who Were Supposed To Be Hollywood's Next Big Star, But Faded Away Instead
Recently, Reddit user CreepyYogurtcloset39 posed the question, "Who was supposed to be Hollywood's next big star but faded away?" to the people of r/moviecritic. Here are their top responses:
1. "Carl Weathers should have been what Sly and Arnold were. He oozed charisma and had an amazing presence on the big screen."
— Bubzszs
"Carl was so good they specifically cast him in Predator to mentor Arnold in his first actual acting role (the Conan stuff required no acting)"
— PrimalNumber
2. "Michael Biehn. To be fair, not many actors have such an iconic resume — Aliens, The Terminator, The Abyss, Tombstone, Navy Seals, The Rock. Not only are they all great films, he's great in them."
— ohnofluffy
"I didn't know much about Michael Biehn but I def remember him as Johnny Ringo. His Wiki page says: James Cameron suggested that 'what held Michael back was that he didn't like playing the Hollywood game — schmoozing people and all that. For him it was all about the work.' Biehn has never hired a publicist and was reportedly never interested in the 'fame aspect of the business, even though his agent — and Cameron — both believed he had what it took to be a major star.' I prefer this version of why he didn't become a 'superstar.'"
— CriscoMelon
3. "Stuart Townsend. He was replaced by Viggo Mortensen in The Lord of the Rings trilogy."
4. "Biggest star that never became a star? I'd say Aaron Eckhart. The guy has it all, just never became a big headliner."
5. " Hayden Christensen. He co-starred in Life is a House with Kevin Kline years ago, but that's kind of it (other than playing Anakin again in the Obi-Wan Kenobi show). He actually can act, but he was just never going to escape that role."
— Nearby-Cod6310
"It's a shame because Star Wars fans (most of them at least) have really come to love him and his portrayal of Anakin. It's just sad that he had to endure so much hate for his acting and the dialogue to the point it tanked his career."
— ReservedRainbow
6. "Mickey Rourke had immense talent, but his off-screen antics overshadowed his performances."
7. "Jonathan Rhys Meyers. Bro was rolling off The Tudors and an acclaimed performance in Match Point. Then addiction got him, and now he's doing B-movies with Bruce Willis and John Travolta."
8. "Casper van Dien. He didn't need to do anything else. He peaked with Starship Troopers and has never come off that throne."
9. "Chris O'Donnell. I remember he did Scent of a Woman, The Three Musketeers, and Batman Forever, and thinking he was going to be huge."
10. "Nikolaj Coster-Waldau, he's got it all but never really launched into stardom after Game of Thrones."
11. "Taylor Kitsch. I mean, don't get me wrong, he has a very respectable career and is a talented actor. I just mean that his career hasn't lived up to the early trade hype about him, blame for which I don't attribute to the actors themselves."
12. "Skeet Ulrich. He was so good in Scream. Like hybrid Johnny Depp/Jack Nicolson, that is good. Then nothing..."
13. "I like Anna Farris, and I feel like she never got a big-time shot at her moments because of her involvement with the Scary Movie series. She's in a lot of B movies, and they're okay, but the writing is bad in most of them since she's cast as the ditzy blonde in 99% of things she was in."
14. "Shia LaBeouf. I mean, he did Disturbia and then the Transformers movie, which I absolutely loved — that movie made me feel like a kid again for a few hours. Then Spielberg made him Indy's son and hinted at a future with him in that role. And then he faded away, I know he had issues, but so many were able to come back. Wonder what was different about him."
15. "Sam Worthington. He's set for life with his Avatar gigs. But back in 2009, people, especially people in Australia, were expecting him to become the next Heath Ledger."
16. "Rutger Hauer. He's my fave; I love his movies, even the cheesiest of them, but after Blade Runner, it seemed like he'd be one to watch out for but ended up fading into cult status."
17. "Deep cut from the women's side: Alison Lohman. Big Fish and Matchstick Men in the same year. She was so good in both."
18. "Nick Stahl comes to mind. I'm still salty about Carnivale 's cancellation."
19. "Jason Patric. Although, let's be honest, Speed 2 was never going to launch him... I mean, it's kind of hard to follow Keanu in a franchise, and even more so when the movie is just plain awful."
20. "Bruce Campbell. Ash vs Evil Dead is hands down a hidden gem of a show and Bruce gets to go full ham in it as Ash. I wish it had been more popular."
21. "Ron Livingston had such a great shot after Office Space, but he kinda faded back into obscurity."
22. "Dougray Scott. Was originally cast as Wolverine, but he was filming Mission: Impossible 2, and filming ran long. So he had to back out of X-Men."
23. "Gretchen Mol. She had a 'New IT Girl' Vanity Fair cover and did a few things here and there, but she didn't want to play the game. Apparently, she refused to travel away from NYC because of her young kids, etc. She said in Cookie Magazine, 'I told my agent I didn't want to work in L.A., even if it was the greatest job in the world. I didn't want to compromise.' You gotta strike while the iron is hot. I was happy to see her in Broadwalk Empire and Yellowstone, though."
24. "Joseph Gordon-Levitt. I am 100% still waiting for a Robin movie!"
25. "David Duchovny. He didn't fade away after leaving the X-Files, but every industry rag predicted he'd be the next Hollywood leading man following his departure. He obviously found success in TV again, and he's had a few film roles, including Return to Me with Minnie Driver, which I really liked. His career isn't a failure, but he's not the 'George Clooney Version 2' many were expecting."
26. "Edward Furlong. Typical child actor story. I think Cameron had more to do with Furlong's success in T2 than Eddie himself did, and he probably wasn't playing a role that was deeply different from himself, so he didn't need to do a lot of real character work."
27. Finally, "Djimon Hounsou. LOVE HIM! I definitely think this is a case of Hollywood not writing interesting and compelling roles for an actor like him. Hollywood has a very narrow view of Black actors (which is stupid and shameful and hopefully something audiences can change), and he's not a Will Smith or Denzel Washington-type."
What do you think? Do you agree with what the people above said, or is there anyone you'd add to the list? Tell us your thoughts in the comments below or via the anonymous form here:
Note: Some responses have been edited for length and/or clarity.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
A Killer New 'Predator' Movie Is Quietly Releasing This Week. Here's How To Watch
If you love the 1987 action/horror classic Predator, there's some very good news. While the next live action movie, Predator: Badlands, won't hit theaters until November 7, this week, there's another new Predator movie sneakily coming to streaming. Directed by Dan Trachtenberg, the same guy who brought us Prey in 2022, a new animated movie called Predator: Killer of Killers is hitting Hulu this Friday. Here's what to know about the plot, the trailers, and when to stream the newest Predator Killer of Killers will hit Hulu on Friday, June 5, 2025. If you have Disney+ with a Hulu add-on, you can stream it that way, too. There have been two major trailers for Killer of Killers, one that reveals the basic premise of the movie, and another, a behind-the-scenes video detailing how this animated movie tries to take striking concept art and bring it to life. Unlike other Predator movies, Killer of Killers is an anthology concept, meaning the roughly 90-minute film has three sections, each depicting people battling Predators in different historical periods. The movie starts with ancient Vikings, moves to feudal Japan, and eventually, depicts Predators attacking WWII fighter planes. There is a method to this madness, though. All three stories are linked, and by the end of the movie, you'll see why. If the concept of Predators battling humans in historical settings sounds familiar, it should. In 2022, Trachtenberg's film Prey depicted a Comanche woman named Naru (Amber Midthunder) battling a Predator in 1719. The vibe of Killer of Killers very much follows the mood of Prey, and if you're paying attention, there's even some pretty big Easter eggs connected to that movie. Presumably, all of this is setting up the next big movie, Predator: Badlands. Starring Elle Fanning, that sci-fi action flick hits theaters on November 7. A Killer New 'Predator' Movie Is Quietly Releasing This Week. Here's How To Watch first appeared on Men's Journal on Jun 4, 2025
UPI
9 hours ago
- UPI
Movie review: 'Predator: Killer of Killers' a visceral animated trio
1 of 5 | The animated "Predator: Killer of Killers," on Hulu Friday, features new Predators. Photo courtesy of 20th Century Studios LOS ANGELES, June 5 (UPI) -- Predator: Killer of Killers, on Hulu Friday, is a worthy addition to the Predator franchise. The animated film takes advantage of the format to explore aspects only hinted at in the live-action movies. Killer of Killers is an anthology of three stories in different time periods. In 841, the Viking queen Ursa (voice of Lindsay LaVanchy) encounters a Predator during a battle against an enemy clan, while in 1629 Japan, two samurai brothers come across a Predator in a mostly dialogue-free segment. Later, in 1942, World War II mechanic John Torres (Rick Gonzalez) leads a dogfight against a Predator ship. Predator 2 seeded the idea that the Predators have been visiting Earth throughout human history, but it wasn't until 2022's Prey that the live-action franchise explored the past. While live-action period pieces would be welcome, a single period piece is cost-prohibitive, let alone three in one movie. The animation directed by Dan Trachtenberg, director of the live-action Prey and upcoming Predator: Badlands, feels like a legitimate Predator movie from the moment the score plays. The Predator's invisible ship ripples against the backdrop, and the creature turns on heat vision to stalk its prey. The Predator that Ursa faces is taller and more hulking than any of the human actors who wore the suit, even the late 7-foot-2 Kevin Peter Hall in the first two films. The Japanese brothers face a leaner Predator, and the WWII Predator, sitting in his cockpit, has interesting horns and scars. Details show the thought put into crafting an alien encounter, such as a leaf sticking to an invisible Predator or a spark from a fire rippling the Predator's invisible cloak. The humans prove as vicious as the Predators, committing graphic decapitations. The setup has always been that the Predators sought the most worthy warriors, hence elite soldiers in the original, Native American warriors in Prey and even the xenomorph in the Alien vs. Predator films. The dynamic action shows the steadiness of a long take is as effective in animation as live action, letting the viewer absorb extended, unedited combat. Recognizable and more obscure Easter eggs add connections to the rest of the Predator series. The three stories connect in surprising ways that make it more than just an anthology. Still, Killer of Killers would already be cool as a collection of Predator minisodes. Fred Topel, who attended film school at Ithaca College, is a UPI entertainment writer based in Los Angeles. He has been a professional film critic since 1999, a Rotten Tomatoes critic since 2001, and a member of the Television Critics Association since 2012 and the Critics Choice Association since 2023. Read more of his work in Entertainment.
Gizmodo
9 hours ago
- Gizmodo
‘Predator: Killer of Killers' Just Rules
After two divisive and ultimately failed attempts to revitalize the Predator franchise in the 2010s, 20th Century Studios found its stride with 2022's Prey. While sadly locked to Hulu as a result of the Disney-Fox merger, that film was met with such a strong reception that it gave the sci-fi horror franchise the boost it'd been needing. Now, the studio is keeping that momentum going with two projects in 2025: Predator: Badlands in November, and this week's animated Killer of Killers. Beyond their being linked by returning Prey director Dan Trachtenberg (co-directing here with Josh Wassung, and working off a script by Micho Robert Rutale from a story by Rutale and Trachtenberg), this future trilogy seems to have been made with the intent of bringing a specific set of ideas and concepts for the Predator franchise to fruition. On its own, that's not surprising, as the franchise tried this before with its 2018 film, and its sibling series Alien also recently made this same play with 2024's Alien: Romulus. What makes all the difference is how much Trachtenberg, Wassung, and Rutare make an earnest effort to let Killer of Killers function as its own work that's informed by, but not reliant on, its predecessor, even as the two can't help but be in conversation with one another. And as with Prey, the end result is a project that succeeds at nearly everything it sets out to do, so much that it's a shame it can't get the full, theatrical rollout something as fun and sublime as this almost definitely deserves. Like prior films, Killer focuses on a cast of humans enacting violence on their fellow man just before a technologically superior alien from another world suddenly arrives looking to shed some blood. Whereas Prey took its time showing how Naru and its Predator both moved through the space of the 1719 Great Plains, Killer is more fast-paced. This is a movie that prioritizes action and gore over tension, but that's not as much of a betrayal as it sounds. That action can often be tense, both in how viscerally violent it is and in how relentless the Predators are in pursuit of their targets. It helps that co-directors Trachtenberg and Wassung have brought over a key part of what made that previous film such a delight: the continuously shifting power dynamics between the hunters and the poor souls they've set their sights on. Each of the three stories—841 AD's 'The Shield;' 'The Sword,' set in 1629 Japan; and 'The Bullet,' set in WWII's North Pacific—run 20 minutes and play out more or less as you'd expect based on their setting. That predictability and narrative slightness ends up working in Killer of Killers' favor, since main characters Ursa (Lindsay LaVanchy), ninja Kenji (Louis Ozawa), and pilot John Torres (Rick Gonzalez) get just enough backstory to inform their personal plights and make them compelling even before their respective Predators enter the picture. Ursa and Kenji's tales are more somber, not entirely unlike Naru's in Prey. Conversely, Torres is a considerably chattier character, and his story has more humorous beats. That has the potential to feeling like too sharp a contrast, but by the time his story comes, the film's earned enough goodwill that it doesn't undermine things, and the eventual payoff for what everything has built up to is satisfying and fun in its own right. What unites the trio thematically is their ability to outwit the aliens looking to add some new spines to their collections. Predator movies have always been considered slashers where the victims are just as capable as they are helpless, and that through line continues in Killers. The film takes full advantage of its individual settings to show how the humans come to understand and quickly adapt to the Predators' bag of tricks, and the solutions they each come up with to turn the tide of battle (or even just to get a breather) are pretty clever. The Predators themselves are a nice, diverse bunch, and while not as characterized as Prey's Feral hunter, they have a similar curiosity and mean streak that imbues them with just enough personality. Visually, Killer is a pretty nice movie to look at, made more impressive by this being the series' first full foray into animation. The CG/3D art style is reminiscent of Arcane, but animated at a frame rate similar to Ninja Turtles: Mutant Mayhem, giving individual movements a particular weight. For a movie with a lot of action, 20th Century Animation and Third Floor have come up with several impressive battle scenes that'll feel familiar but are pulled off with an impressive amount of flourish and gore that it won't matter. (A long take involving Ursa and her raiders is just one of several fist-pumping highlights throughout.) And when it's not showing off how bloody fights with the Predator can be, the film is showing off impressive vistas and providing such scale that it's again a shame this can't ever come to the big screen. The strength of its individual stories would make Killer of Killers worthwhile on its own, but its final act brings things home with one fun beat after another that feels like the team wanted to get everything they could into this project. By the time it's laid down all the cards and revealed what everything's all been building up to and where it could go next, it's easy to come away impressed at how self-assured and confident it carries itself the entire time. Live-action franchises can stumble when they take exotic vacations to the world of animation, but that's not the case here—this film's more than got the goods and is a fine addition to the Predator's recent resurgence. Also starring Michael Biehn, Predator: Killer of Killers arrives June 6 on Hulu.
