Flint catholic super-school funded by taxpayer will be owned by church
Plans to create an all-through catholic super-school in Flint for pupils aged 3-18 are currently preparing to go into consultation amid opposition from parents' groups.
The proposal requires the closure of four schools in Flintshire, the catholic primary schools of St David's in Mold, St Anthony's in Saltney and St Mary's in Flint plus the closure of St Richard Gwyn Catholic High School.
According to the plans 85% of the cost of the new super-school - £46.75 million - would come from the Welsh Government's Sustainable Communities for Learning Programme with the remaining 15% coming from the Diocese of Wrexham.
Parents groups at two of the four schools - St Anthony's and St David's - actively oppose the plans. St David's School Action Group held a protest march last weekend to campaign against the proposals.
But at this week's Education, Youth & Culture Overview & Scrutiny Committee, the leader of Flintshire's Liberal Democrat group Cllr Andrew Parkhurst asked who would own the super-school building once completed.
"I understand school buildings are owned by the Diocese," he said. "If the new building goes ahead with Welsh Government money then who owns the building?
"Is it the council or is it the church? Are we in effect giving away millions to the church?"
"It's not always clear-cut but as a rule of thumb the council usually owns the playing fields while the Diocese owns buildings and the land beneath them," said Jennie Williams, Senior Manager, School Planning and
Provision for Flintshire County Council.
"Once we've built the school we will have to hand back the building. That's how the legal framework of voluntary aided schools runs."
Now Welsh Government has confirmed that once taxpayers have funded the school, it would transfer into the ownership of the Diocese.
"In the case of voluntary aided schools, the school buildings and land are usually owned by trustees typically the Diocesan," said a Senedd spokesperson.
"The Sustainable Communities for Learning Programme supports investment in education infrastructure across Voluntary Aided, Voluntary Controlled and Local Authority maintained schools. In all cases, the asset remains in the ownership of delivery partners following the investment."
Read more:
WATCH: Supporters of Mold catholic school turn out in force to oppose closure
Date set for Flintshire catholic school closure consultation
'Senseless' - Flintshire parents slam catholic super-school report
It has also been confirmed that the consultation, which was supposed to open this month, will now be opened no later than Tuesday, June 3.
A council spokesperson said: 'The council can confirm that the consultation is scheduled to go live on or before June 3, 2025 and finish before the start of the school summer holidays, subject to the finalisation of the necessary documentation and approvals.'
After Flintshire County Council twice postponed the opening of the consultation, parents campaigning to save their schools fear further delaying the timeline restricts their opportunity to make their case.
Martina Crocombe is one of the leading advocates to save St Anthony's in Saltney. She has two children art the school, which is scheduled to be the first to close under the plan in September 2026.
"These delays have caused yet more uncertainty and show that once again, Flintshire County Council and Wrexham Diocese can't seem to get it right," she said.
"There have now been three delays and the reasons for them have not been made clear to the public. These repeated delays raise serious questions about the efficiency and reliability of both the council and the diocese.
"The proposed super school idea, which the majority oppose, needs to be scrapped. The parents and community of Saltney will continue to fight this ridiculous idea."
Sarah Cunningham, from the St David's School Action Group, said making people wait was making parents anxious.
"Waiting longer for the consultation to open causes great concern as we believe it's a deliberate attempt to let all the noise pass and it brings the dates exceedingly close to the summer holidays," she said.
"For St Anthony's this could most certainly be seen as tactical as they will have even less time to prepare for the possible closure of the school."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Rhyl Journal
a day ago
- Rhyl Journal
Plans to rebuild Llanerch Bridge scrapped despite £1.5m spent
The cabinet yesterday (Tuesday) considered a report on rebuilding Llanerch Bridge after the original structure was destroyed during Storm Christoph in January 2021, when the River Clwyd burst its banks. Council officers warned that if they drilled into the riverbed, it could contaminate a water supply to 85,000 homes. That's because the old bridge was above a vital freshwater aquifer that Dwr Cymru Welsh Water use to supply drinking water to residents. Councillors heard how drilling into sandstone layers could create fissures, contaminating the lake. MORE: Rhyl man 'who just wanted to get home from Chester' fined for drunken abuse Paul Jacksons, the council's head of highways and environmental services. said: 'There's not been a design solution that has been found that completely removes the risk to that water asset. 'Therefore, the detailed design stage has concluded that it is not possible to construct a new bridge without the required foundations penetrating the weathered section of sandstone and putting a potential fissure in the aquifer, and again, interrupting that water supply. 'Welsh Water has stated that drilling into the aquifer would ultimately create a pathway for the risk of the water supply being contaminated, and that could lead to several factors, including risk and safeguarding their customers. 'It is a public health risk, and Welsh Water has stated that should the risk come to fruition, rectifying the issues created by drilling into the ground would be far from straightforward and extremely costly to resolve. It may not even be feasible to repair if we drill a physical pathway into the aquifer.' MORE: Rhyl mum and daughter create detailed post box topper in tribute to Mike Peters He added: 'They consider this to be extremely high risk, and they would suggest we don't go ahead with this project.' Mr Jackson said every design possible had been considered. Last week, backbench councillors Chris Evans and James Elson argued about the inconvenience and extra cost to residents, raising the solution of a temporary bridge. The pair said not building a bridge drastically affected the lives of residents in Tremeirchion, Rhuallt, Bodfari, Cwm, as well as those in Trefnant, Denbigh, Henllan, and Ruthin, particularly with the rise in the cost of fuel. £1.5 million of Welsh Government funds has already been spent on the design work of the project. Speaking at the meeting, Cllr Alan James also raised the matter of building a temporary bridge. But Mr Jackson said a temporary bridge would still require the same foundations, so the risk would remain, arguing the proposal was unfeasible. Leader Cllr Jason McLellan warned the cabinet: 'If we go ahead and start construction, knowing the risk to the damage to the aquifer, we essentially owe a duty of care to Welsh Water's customers that their water supply won't be affected, and quite clearly the advice is that it might be, so that chain of events would mean that we would be negligent and liable. 'We haven't got insurance, so we wouldn't be able to go through the insurance route. We would be liable, and it could potentially be millions. You think what the number of days without water looks like, without the ability to run a tap, boil the kettle, flush your toilet, have a shower. What does that look like for 85,000 homes after two days, three days, four days a week. Our liability would be off the scale.' Mr Jackson said the council would improve the road network, with £950,000 already secured from Welsh Government to upgrade 'alterative routes' and the diversion to make it 'more pleasurable for commuters'. But Cllr James Elson said the council had promised the residents a bridge. 'We must deliver on that promise,' he said. He added there must be a solution such as a single-track bridge or a temporary 'pre-fabricated' bridge set on benches without drilling. He said the cost of such a bridge would be less than the £1.5m Denbighshire had already spent, claiming he had been given a quote by a construction company two years ago. Mr Jackson reiterated a temporary bridge wasn't possible, explaining a bridge without foundations could present a danger to 'life and limb' during a flood. Cllr Chris Evans then echoed Cllr Elson's comments. 'There has been very little engagement from Denbighshire Council, which has had a detriment to this project,' he said. 'This again has had a massive impact on residents, feeling the bridge is not going to get built. It has been gone for four-odd years, and we have spent, or Welsh Government have spent, £1.5m to get to a set of drawings. I think that issue alone needs to be taken to the audit and governance committee.' Cllr Evans then claimed that a local building contractor had indicated to him a bridge was possible. 'We have not looked with conviction at the temporary bridge,' he said. 'I don't mean to be disrespectful, but Jones Brothers builds motorways. He is the person that does the job. He is the knowledgeable chap that has looked at that.' He added: 'The residents want a crossing.' Cllr Evans added residents and businesses were suffering and children couldn't get to school. He asked the cabinet to defer the decision so the matter could go to full council. But Cllr McLellan said that would put Denbighshire in the 'line of fire' for future litigation. Corporate director Tony Ward said officers couldn't win, having been criticised for spending £1.5m on designs, with it also being suggested they hadn't done enough. Cllr Gwyneth Ellis questioned whether a smaller bridge would need the same foundations, but Mr Jackson explained the foundations needed were due to the water pressure, not the weight on any bridge. The cabinet voted unanimously in favour of ceasing work on the project.
Wales Online
2 days ago
- Wales Online
New rules affecting roads and drivers across Wales planned
New rules affecting roads and drivers across Wales planned The Welsh Government has proposed changes to help the transition to a new future A new rule for driveways in England came into force this Thursday (May 29) and something similar looks on the way for Wales (Image: InYourArea ) A new law coming into force in England could soon be repeated in Wales. From this week, people in England will no longer need to submit planning applications in order to install electric vehicle chargers, a law which will effect every household in England. The Labour government hopes that this new law will streamline the process of installing EV chargers and therefore reduce months of delays and possibly saving drivers £1,100 a year. They say it will give drivers more chargepoints, with less red tape. In April this year, the Welsh Government published a consultation which proposes to change the development rules around EV charging infrastructure. The proposals would bring Wales further in line with provisions in Scotland and England by removing the 2m from a highway restriction and, in certain instances, increasing the height limit of chargers to 2.7m. The Welsh Government said: "The number of EV charging points across Wales needs to increase to support the anticipated growth in electric vehicle usage, and to align with Net Zero Wales targets and UK Government's proposed ban on the sale of new petrol and diesel vehicles by 2030/35. "Reliable and comprehensive charging infrastructure is needed to support this transition. "The changes will further facilitate the roll-out of electric vehicle charge points in line with predicted growth in use of electric vehicles and to ensure sufficient charging infrastructure is available to support zero emission vehicle targets." Other changes to permitted development rights in Wales laid out in the consultation include increased provision for air source heat pumps and increased rights for recreation campsites. The Future of Roads Minister, Lilian Greenwood, called England's move a boost for the "EV revolution". Love dreamy Welsh homes? Sign up to our newsletter here . She added: "We continue to make the switch to EVs easier, cheaper and better by investing over £2.3billion to support drivers and back British carmakers through international trade deals - creating jobs, boosting investment and securing our future as part of our Plan for Change." Osprey Charging Network's operations director, Lewis Gardiner, said changes in England would make a "real difference". He continued: "Removing the need for planning permission for essential electrical infrastructure like substations across the majority of sites will save months of delays, reduce costs and accelerate the delivery of the rapid charging hubs drivers need." Article continues below Research by Autotrader shows that the number of EV chargers in the UK rose from by 30,000 at the end of 2021, to 77,000 as of March 2025. The Welsh Government consultation runs until July 1, 2025. It can be viewed here.
ITV News
3 days ago
- ITV News
Wales' public services face £36m shortfall after National Insurance hikes
The Welsh Government says it won't get enough money from the UK Government to offset all of the impact of higher National Insurance costs for public services. Ministers say there'll be a £36m shortfall even after they've raided reserves. The UK Government says it's 'boosted' the Welsh Government's spending power by lifting limits on use of reserves on top of 'a record £21bn' budget. Employers have been paying more National Insurance Contributions (NICs) since April after the Chancellor announced the increase in her budget last October. The UK Government had said it would ensure funding for the Welsh Government to cover the cost of the increase for public sector organisations such as hospitals, local authorities and schools. Welsh Ministers have been concerned about the method the UK Treasury is using to calculate that amount. It relies on the Barnett Formula - a method used to work out how much funding Wales should get based on spending in England. But because the public sector is bigger here in Wales than across the border, Welsh ministers argued that using the formula in this instance would leave Wales shortchanged. Now the Welsh Government says it's had final confirmation of the figures. It says that the increase in NICS will cost the public sector here in Wales an extra £257m. The UK Government is providing £185m, leaving a shortfall of £72m. The Welsh Government says it will find half of that amount, £36m, from its own reserves. But it says that still leaves a gap of £36m. Finance Secretary, Mark Drakeford, said: "We're protecting our vital public services by using £36m from our reserves to help address the National Insurance shortfall left by UK Government. "The UK Government did provide funding, but this falls short of the actual costs faced by Welsh public services, creating a multi-million-pound gap every year. "We have stepped in to help as much as we can, but the Welsh Government cannot afford to cover the entire shortfall. "The UK Government should treat the public sector the same across the UK and make good on its pledge to fully fund these extra costs." A UK Government source said: "The Welsh Government's spending power has been boosted by the UK Government's decision to waive their reserve draw down limits for 2025-26. "This increased spending power came on top of more than £180m extra to compensate for public sector national insurance contributions, and a record £21bn financial settlement at the Autumn Budget, the largest in the history of devolution. "UK Government did this to help the Welsh Government invest in public services and drive down NHS waiting lists. Together, we are delivering our Plan for Change in Wales by fixing our NHS, creating thousands of well paid jobs, boosting the minimum wage, and investing billions in our high streets and public services." It's another source of tension between the Labour Welsh Government and the Labour UK Government. Earlier this week the First Minister called for the two-child benefit cap to be scrapped. Eluned Morgan told ITV Wales: ''We are really concerned about levels of child poverty in Wales and we have called on the UK Government to lift the two tier child benefit cap. "We think this should be considered in future budgets and we have made that case to the Prime Minister as I did last week in London." Ahead of that meeting, Eluned Morgan told ITV Wales that Keir Starmer should 'start coughing up' to make up for areas where Wales has been shortchanged. She added: "I'll obviously be taking that opportunity to really push the case for those things that I outlined in my Red Welsh Way speech, making sure that we get a fairer deal on things like the railways and coal tips and other issues that are absolutely top of my agenda, where we think we've been hard done by in the past and we want them to make up for it." Is a cash boost for railways coming down the tracks? There have been reports today that there will be significant extra funding for at least one of those demands: railways. The Chancellor Rachel Reeves will set out long-term spending plans in her Spending Review on June 11th. The Politico website says it's been told that the plans will include capital funding for Wales which is aimed at improving rail infrastructure. UK Government sources have dismissed the report as 'speculation' but say that rail spending in Wales is a top priority for the UK Government as has been repeatedly highlighted by the Welsh Secretary Jo Stevens.
