Why surrendering a key eastern region would be hard for Ukraine
An aerial shot of Donbas, whose industrial cities have stood as a shield protecting Ukraine.
KYIV - After President Donald Trump announced that he would meet with President Vladimir Putin of Russia on Aug 15, the American leader suggested that the end of the war would involve 'some swopping of territories' between Russia and Ukraine.
It is not clear what, if any, occupied territory Russia would be prepared to give up as part of a swop. But Russia wants Ukraine to unilaterally withdraw from the entire eastern region known as the Donbas, according to European officials who have spoken with Trump administration officials about their discussions with Mr Putin.
Ukrainian officials say they will not hand over land for a vague promise of peace that they would not trust Russia to abide by. That stance reflects not just fundamental principles of territorial sovereignty, but also military, humanitarian and political considerations that make a surrender of the Donbas hard to imagine for Ukrainians.
Here is a look at the Donbas, whose industrial cities have stood as a shield protecting Ukraine, one that thousands of Ukrainians have fought and died to sustain.
Military significance
The Donbas region shaped some of the most brutal battles of World War II and continues to define the fiercely contested front today.
In the current war, in places such as Bakhmut and Avdiivka, Ukrainians held the line for years, forcing the Russians to pay a high price for every mile they moved forward. The two cities are the only major ones that the Russians have taken since the first year of the war.
The cities still under Ukrainian control are connected by one road running north to south, forming a defensive line that prevents Russian forces from sweeping across the country.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
World US trade team will meet Chinese officials in two or three months, Bessent says
Singapore From survivable to liveable: The making of a green city
Asia DPM Gan kicks off India visit in Mumbai as Singapore firms ink investment agreements
World Ukraine, sidelined in Trump-Putin summit, fights Russian grab for more territory
Asia South Korea's former first lady arrested after court issues warrant, Yonhap reports
Opinion Singpass use in dating apps raises difficult questions
Singapore Man who stalked woman blasted by judge on appeal for asking scandalous questions in court
Singapore SG60: Many hands behind Singapore's success story
Giving up any of those cities 'would effectively mean the collapse of this entire defensive line', said Mr Serhii Kuzan, the chair of the Ukrainian Security and Cooperation Centre.
Handing over the region would also give Russia control of fortifications that Ukraine spent tens of millions of dollars constructing, as well as vital railway infrastructure and land rich in minerals and coal.
Beyond the dense industrial cities lies wide, open terrain that is a gateway to Ukraine's heartland.
Surrendering the Donbas without a fight would position Russian forces to renew their attacks and push to the west, according to the Institute for the Study of War, a Washington-based research group.
Humanitarian issues
A humanitarian disaster could follow a Russian takeover of the region if hundreds of thousands of people were forced to flee their homes or risk suffering under occupation.
Media organisations, human rights organisations and UN investigators have documented widespread and systematic human rights abuses in Russian-occupied territories, including arbitrary detention, torture, ill treatment and enforced disappearances.
More than 200,000 civilians live in the Ukrainian-controlled corner of the Donetsk region, part of the Donbas. Out of 1,298 settlements in the region, 847 are occupied by Russian forces, including 447 that have been occupied since Russia annexed Crimea and sent troops into eastern Ukraine in 2014. The Russians control about two-thirds of the region in all.
Ms Kateryna Arisoy, who is originally from Bakhmut and runs a charity dedicated to helping others escape fighting, said people living under occupation faced a grim future, including severe abuse for those who oppose the occupation authorities.
'I say that there is no life in the occupied territories – people there are simply surviving,' she said.
Political reality
While neither the White House nor the Kremlin has publicly put forward a specific proposal regarding 'land swops', the quick rejection of the idea by President Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine reflected an underlying reality often missed in the West, said Mr Yaroslav Hrytsak, a Ukrainian historian.
Ukrainian identity, he said, centres on the principle 'nothing about us without us' – a core concept that dates to the Cossacks.
'If you want to resolve some Ukrainian issue without Ukrainians, in a sense, it's denying Ukrainian identity, which is very central to Ukrainians, especially now,' he said.
That helps explain why Mr Zelensky, despite his sagging poll numbers, has found broad support for his rejection of any land swop. He has noted that he has no authority under the country's Constitution to bargain away parts of the country.
More than three-quarters of Ukrainians oppose trading land for a promise of peace. Crucially, inside the military, 'that figure is much, much higher', said Mr Kuzan, of the Ukrainian Security and Cooperation Centre.
'The units, brigades and commanders we have been in contact with since 2014 are categorically opposed to Putin's ultimatum,' he said.
Despite all the obstacles, Mr Hrytsak, the historian, did not rule out a grand bargain. But he said it would have to include something as sweeping as an agreement by Russia to leave all of southern Ukraine.
And even that might not be enough, he said. Ukrainians see the territories as more than just land.
'First and foremost, people live there,' Ms Arisoy said. 'I also lived in a city that is now destroyed and occupied, and therefore I do not see it as just a piece of land.' NYTIMES
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
19 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Nowhere to run: Why Singapore needs to start protecting its coasts now
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox By 2100, Singapore's sea level is projected to rise by up to 1.15m. That is more than 70 years away, but the Republic is starting to take action today to protect its coastlines. Singapore is a maritime hub and critical infrastructure also dots the country's coastline. SINGAPORE – In one of the most climate-threatened corners of the planet lies a small island nation, its shores being eaten away by rising sea levels. Home to some 10,000 people, Tuvalu – located between Hawaii and Australia – is dealing with sea-level rise by building seawalls and reclaiming land. But it is also moving its people elsewhere. More than 80 per cent of its population has applied to move to Australia under a landmark climate visa designed to help people escape rising sea levels, reported France 24 in July. As a small island nation, Singapore is also not spared from sea-level rise. But the concept of managed retreat, where people are moved away from the coast so the sea is allowed to swallow up land, is unimaginable for Singapore, home to over six million people. Critical infrastructure also dots the country's coastline – from an expanding airport to power plants, military bases and reservoirs. These are things that Singapore, a city that has to accommodate the needs of an entire country, cannot afford to relinquish to the sea. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Ong Beng Seng fined $30k in case linked to ex-minister Iswaran after judge cites judicial mercy Singapore Why was Ong Beng Seng fined instead of jailed? Key points from the case Singapore ICA to review Ong Beng Seng's PR status after he is fined for abetting obstruction of justice Singapore Drug trafficker gets death sentence commuted after President Tharman grants clemency Asia Former China envoy to Singapore Sun Haiyan reappears after reported questioning Life Founder of Singapore Symphony Orchestra Choo Hoey dies at 90 Singapore Hawkers at Bukit Canberra Hawker Centre will not need to provide free meals under new contracts Programmes like climate visas should be seen as a last resort, said Mr Bryce Rudyk, legal adviser to the chair of the Alliance of Small Island States, which Singapore and Tuvalu are part of. 'I think all small islands would prefer not to move elsewhere. While Singapore has some adaptation capacity, if seas rise by 2m, 4m, it will become so incredibly expensive that it can drag down the rest of the economy.' In places like Emao Island in the Pacific nation Vanuatu, residents are forced to abandon their homes and move to higher ground at financial, cultural and emotional costs. 'Unlike cyclones or floods that bring immediate and visible destruction, sea-level rise creeps forward quietly, year after year,' said Dr Christopher Bartlett, special climate adviser at Vanuatu's Ministry of Climate Change. Not a problem for the future By 2100, Singapore's sea level is projected to rise by up to 1.15m. When combined with extreme events such as high tides and storm surges, sea levels could potentially rise up to 5m. But about 30 per cent of Singapore is less than 5m above mean sea level. Doing nothing would mean coastal flooding events could severely impact homes and businesses, and disrupt daily lives. Singaporeans got a taste of this in January. Parts of Jalan Seaview in Mountbatten were inundated for nearly three hours, leaving some vehicles stranded, and the premises of a nearby house flooded. The flooding event was due to a confluence of factors – a high tide, heavy rain and a storm surge, when storms offshore cause tides to go up higher than usual. A car passing through a flooded low-lying section of Mountbatten Road connecting Jalan Seaview on Jan 10. PHOTO: ST FILE Assistant Professor Elisa Ang from the Singapore Institute of Technology's (SIT) engineering cluster, said storm surges have brought abnormal sea levels as high as 0.75m to the country in 1999. When mean sea levels are higher due to melting ice sheets, such 'triple whammy' flooding events could become more common. Associate Professor Tay Zhi Yung from the same SIT cluster said: 'Storm surges can temporarily raise sea levels significantly, pushing seawater inland. When this is combined with high tides or heavy rainfall causing flash floods, (the) drainage systems might overflow causing these low-lying zones to face a compounded threat of inundation.' Climate change first shot to the top of the national agenda in 2019, when then Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong said in his National Day Rally speech – considered one of the most important political speeches of the year – that Singapore's coastal defences were as existential for the country as its armed forces. Climate change defences should be treated like the Singapore Armed Forces – with utmost seriousness, said Mr Lee then. 'These are life and death matters. Everything else must bend at the knee to safeguard the existence of our island nation,' he said. Since then, Singapore has moved to act on climate change on multiple fronts. Coastal protection and tackling flooding have been a large pillar of the country's efforts. These include widening drains, building underground tanks to hold stormwater, and studying the sea level risks faced by each corner of the coastline. 'Coastal protection works require careful planning and are a significant undertaking,' said Ms Hazel Khoo, director of the coastal protection department at national water agency PUB. 'We need to take into consideration several factors, such as the effectiveness of measures, existing and potential land uses, environmental impact and cost. Trade-offs are therefore inevitable,' she said. Reclaiming land offshore to protect the East Coast area, for example, can impact the marine environment. A costly endeavour In August, the small island nation of Nauru in the Pacific Ocean sold its first passports as part of a programme to fund climate action, including retreating from rising sea levels. Each applicant has to contribute US$105,000 (S$135,500) to the fund to be eligible for Nauru citizenship. Coastal protection efforts can be costly. Singapore has estimated that coastal protection efforts could cost $100 billion over the next 100 years, due to significant construction works. To protect the East Coast, it is looking to reclaim around 800ha of land offshore – about twice the size of Marina Bay – with a new reservoir in between. PUB has also since 2023 been studying the feasibility of installing large barriers to protect the south-western coastline – including Jurong Island, Pasir Panjang Terminal and Tuas shipyards – from extreme events like storm surges. But as flood risk expert Matthijs Bos puts it: 'Luckily enough, Singapore is a very wealthy country, and that gives it the capacity to adapt.' The Coastal and Flood Protection Fund, established in 2020, is one way Singapore will fund long-term investments in coastal protection, said Ms Khoo. To date, the authorities have dipped into the $10 billion pot for drainage projects including the Syed Alwi Pumping Station, Alkaff Lake and upgrading works at a section of Bukit Timah Canal. Ms Khoo added: 'This is in addition to long-term borrowing via Singa bonds, and the use of past reserves to fund land reclamation.' Singa bonds are government securities used to finance long-term infrastructure. Ms Khoo said that the high costs of coastal protection works mean that Singapore would need to stage its coastal protection planning and construction in phases, to ensure a sustainable pace. Singapore has divided its coastline into eight sections to determine the most suitable ways to protect each stretch. There are four ongoing site-specific studies, she said, with plans to commence two new studies at Singapore's south-west coast and Sentosa by 2026. The first study commenced in the city-east coast stretch of Singapore's coastline in 2021, and Long Island is expected to protect much of the stretch. Ms Khoo said PUB will be sharing the proposed coastal protection scheme for the two ends of the stretch – the Greater Southern Waterfront and Changi – at the first coastal protection exhibition to be held at VivoCity from Aug 28 to 31. Mr James Lam, Surbana Jurong's executive director for coastal engineering, said the studies for different sites will also help the country decide on the best and most cost-effective solutions for each stretch, given their differing characteristics and tolerance to floods. The global urban and infrastructure consulting firm has been appointed to study two of the eight sections – Jurong Island and the north-west coast, which runs from Tuas Checkpoint to Lim Chu Kang jetty. Its Jurong Island study is done together with consulting firm Jacobs. 'The north-west is more natural and less built up. The measures we are considering will likely blend with the ecosystems. For Jurong Island, home to many petrochemical companies, the measures will consider their operations and the assets to protect,' he said. Not just hard infrastructure The construction of some coastal defences is expected to start from the 2030s. While the authorities will armour up most of the country's shoreline, there are seaside businesses and private properties that will need to become the second line of defence. To pave the way for that, a law on coastal protection will be tabled by the first half of 2026. 'This legislation will define the roles and responsibilities of the relevant stakeholders, safeguard land needed for coastal protection measures, and ensure that coastal protection requirements are met and sustained over time,' said Ms Khoo. Mr Lim Peng Hong, managing director of engineering firm PH Consulting, said: 'It is not useful to remind the public continuously about being flood-resilient without providing possible solutions.' Mr Lim is helping to put together a PUB-backed guidebook of solutions that is slated to be published by mid-2026. Mr Lim, who is also president of the Professional Engineers Board, added that property owners should also budget for the cost of being flood-resilient, like how they do for repair and maintenance. 'The rising seawater level will not be a sudden event and the investment made by the property owners, whether individuals or small and medium enterprises, will span over many years, even decades,' he said.
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Russia readying nuclear-powered cruise missile test, Ukraine's military intelligence says
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox A satellite view showing equipment at the Pankovo test site in Yuzhny Island, on the Barents Sea archipelago of Novaya Zemlya, Russia, on Aug 7. LONDON/WASHINGTON - Russia is preparing to test its new nuclear-capable, nuclear-powered cruise missile and if successful, plans to use the results to bolster its negotiating position with the West, Ukrainian military intelligence said on Aug 15. Mr Andriy Yusov, a spokesperson for the service, issued the written statement to Reuters just before US President Donald Trump was due to hold talks in Alaska with Russian President Vladimir Putin on ending Moscow's war in Ukraine. He did not give an assessment of the possible timing of the test in the statement, given in response to questions submitted by Reuters for a report published on Aug 12 that Moscow was preparing to test the 9M730 Burevestnik cruise missile. He did not say how his service arrived at its assessment. It has for years received intelligence from the United States and its Nato allies, and it has its own networks inside Russia. Reuters on Aug 12y reported two US researchers and a Western security source as saying that Moscow was readying a test of the Burevestnik at its Pankovo test site on the Barents Sea archipelago of Novaya Zemlya. The researchers said imagery from Planet Labs, a commercial satellite firm, showed extensive activities at the site, increases in personnel and equipment and the presence of ships and aircraft associated with previous tests of the weapon dubbed the SSC-X-9 Skyfall by Nato. The Russian defence ministry, the Pentagon and the CIA declined to comment for that report. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Ong Beng Seng fined $30k in case linked to ex-minister Iswaran after judge cites judicial mercy Singapore Why was Ong Beng Seng fined instead of jailed? Key points from the case Singapore ICA to review Ong Beng Seng's PR status after he is fined for abetting obstruction of justice Singapore Drug trafficker gets death sentence commuted after President Tharman grants clemency Asia Former China envoy to Singapore Sun Haiyan reappears after reported questioning Life Founder of Singapore Symphony Orchestra Choo Hoey dies at 90 Singapore Hawkers at Bukit Canberra Hawker Centre will not need to provide free meals under new contracts The White House did not comment directly on whether a test was being prepared, saying in response to a question about it that Mr Trump wanted peace in Ukraine. Mr Yusov said Moscow, which has threatened to use nuclear weapons over the Ukraine war, saw a test as diplomatic leverage. 'Russia is preparing for another round of tests of the 9M730 Burevestnik,' his statement said. 'The purpose of these tests is to validate scientific and technical solutions implemented by the missile.' 'If successful, Russia will leverage the test results to defend its interests in negotiations with the West,' he continued. Mr Putin has said the weapon is 'invincible' to missile defences, with an almost unlimited range and unpredictable flight path. But many experts say it is unclear if the missile can evade defences, would not give Moscow capabilities it does not already have, and would spew radiation. The Burevestnik has a poor test record, according to the Nuclear Threat Initiative advocacy group, with two partial successes among 13 known tests. REUTERS
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
Trump speaks to Belarus leader ahead of Alaska summit with Putin
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko (centre) welcoming US special envoy Keith Kellogg to Minsk, on June 21. ABOARD AIR FORCE ONE - US President Donald Trump spoke with Belarusian leader Alexander Lukashenko – a close ally of Vladimir Putin – by telephone on Aug 15, hours ahead of the US and Russian leaders' summit in Alaska. Belarus has backed Mr Putin's invasion of Ukraine and allowed Russia's army to use its territory as a launchpad for its first wave of attacks in early 2022. 'We discussed many topics, including President Putin's visit to Alaska,' Mr Trump said in a post on his Truth Social platform, which was sent while he was en route to the talks aboard Air Force One. Mr Trump said that he had thanked Mr Lukashenko for freeing political prisoners and said that the two sides were 'discussing the release of 1,300 additional prisoners'. According to Belarus state news agency Belta, 'Lukashenko invited Trump and his family to visit Belarus, and he agreed.' The leaders also discussed bilateral relations and the war in Ukraine, Belta added. Mr Lukashenko has ruled Belarus since 1994 and has stamped out free media and political opposition in an increasingly authoritarian rule. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Ong Beng Seng fined $30k in case linked to ex-minister Iswaran after judge cites judicial mercy Singapore Why was Ong Beng Seng fined instead of jailed? Key points from the case Singapore ICA to review Ong Beng Seng's PR status after he is fined for abetting obstruction of justice Singapore Drug trafficker gets death sentence commuted after President Tharman grants clemency Asia Former China envoy to Singapore Sun Haiyan reappears after reported questioning Life Founder of Singapore Symphony Orchestra Choo Hoey dies at 90 Singapore Hawkers at Bukit Canberra Hawker Centre will not need to provide free meals under new contracts According to a latest estimate by the Belarusian rights group Viasna, the country has 1,186 political prisoners. Many of them were arrested following widespread protests that gripped the nation in 2020 after Mr Lukashenko claimed victory in an election marred with allegations of fraud.
