Elon Musk's Mars plan is a dangerous illusion, warns astrophysicist Adam Becker
Mars
has come under sharp criticism from renowned astrophysicist and author Adam Becker, who calls it "the stupidest thing" one could pursue. In a recent interview and in his new book More Everything Forever, Becker argues that efforts by billionaires like Musk and Jeff Bezos to settle Mars are nothing more than 'sci-fi fantasies' detached from scientific and ethical realities. Despite Musk's framing of Mars as a backup plan for humanity in the event of a global catastrophe, Becker insists that even a damaged Earth would remain far more habitable than the red planet. He believes these grandiose space ambitions are more about escaping fears than solving real problems.
Elon Musk's Mars vision: 'Stupidest thing' says Becker
Becker takes a blunt stance on Musk's idea of Mars as a 'lifeboat' for humanity. 'We could get hit with an asteroid, detonate every nuclear weapon, or see the worst-case scenario for climate change, and Earth would still be more habitable than Mars,' he told Rolling Stone. He cites the planet's lack of breathable air, radiation exposure, and extreme conditions as insurmountable barriers. His critique also targets the illusion that technology alone can make Mars livable. 'Any cursory examination of facts about Mars makes it clear, it's not a place for humans,' Becker asserts.
Childhood wonder meets scientific reality
Once a strong believer in space colonization, Becker admits that his views changed as he studied the harsh truths of space environments. 'As I got older, I realized, 'Oh, that's not happening.' We're not going to go to space, and certainly not to make things better,' he told The Harvard Gazette. He accuses tech billionaires of pouring resources into escapist dreams instead of addressing problems on Earth. According to him, their space crusades reflect deep-seated fears rather than rational strategy.
Scientists warn of risks in billionaire space ambitions
Becker isn't the only critic. Fellow astrophysicist Lawrence Krauss has also denounced Musk's Mars plan, calling it 'logistically ludicrous' and 'scientifically and politically dangerous.' Despite these warnings, Musk remains committed to his goal of building a Mars colony with at least one million people, positioning SpaceX as the spearhead of this vision. Yet experts argue that such ambitions, if rushed or poorly planned, could have disastrous consequences both scientifically and socially.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
an hour ago
- News18
Elon Musk Launches Global Online School Where The Fee For 1 Hour Is Over Rs 1 Lakh
Last Updated: The school focuses on practical, hands-on learning, combining academics with sports and interactive activities to keep students engaged and make education more meaningful Elon Musk, the billionaire entrepreneur behind SpaceX and social media platform X, has now entered the education sector with the launch of Astra Nova School — an experimental institution that breaks away from traditional learning models. The school focuses on practical, hands-on education, blending academics with sports and interactive activities to keep students engaged. Astra Nova School, accessible to children globally, operates entirely online, creating a unique lab-type environment despite its virtual mode. Studying at Astra Nova School could come with a hefty price tag, potentially requiring a loan. The fee for just one hour of class is $2,200 — which amounts to over Rs 1.88 lakh in Indian currency. What Makes Elon Musk's Astra Nova School Unique? If the goal is to move beyond rote learning and bring children closer to real-world problem solving, Elon Musk's Astra Nova School stands out with its practical, experimental approach. Here are its key features: How Much Does It Cost To Study At Elon Musk's School? The fees at Astra Nova School are well beyond the reach of most households. However, according to the school's official website financial assistance is available through scholarships and other support options. More details regarding admission, course structure, and financial aid can be found on the school's official website. view comments First Published: Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
United News of India
8 hours ago
- United News of India
Post ISS mission, Shux in good health
Chennai, July 17 (UNI) The health condition of decorated piot Shubhanshu Shukla, who became the first Indian astronaut to travel to International Space Station and returned after a 18-day stay, was stable and in good health, ISRO said today. After Gaganyatri Shubhanshu Shukla was extracted by SpaceX's recovery teams on July 15, 2025, preliminary health checks were carried out at recovery ship. Initial health assessments indicated that Gaganyatri Shukla was in stable condition with no immediate concerns reported. He was airlifted by helicopter from the recovery ship to the mainland for further medical evaluations and debriefing sessions. Later, Shubhanshu Shukla was flown to Houston for a week-long rehabilitation program to mitigate any adverse effect of microgravity. This is being administered by Axiom's flight surgeon and ISRO's flight surgeon is also participating in this program. This includes a series of medical checks especially cardiovascular assessments, musculoskeletal tests psychological debrief. The rehabilitation activities of Gaganyatri focus on monitoring physical and mental health, addressing any effects of microgravity, and preparing him for a return to normal activities. Shux and three other crew members from US, Hungary and Poland, took off for ISS on June 25 and docked the next day after a 28 hr flight journey. After an extended 18 day stay, during which Shux conducted seven microgravity experiments of iSRO, undocked from ISS on July 14 and the Dragon spacecraft splashed down off California coast after a 22.5 hr journey the next day. Shux was the second Indian to travel to space after a gap of 41 years when Rakesh Sharma travelled in 1984. UNI GV 1515
Time of India
9 hours ago
- Time of India
Elon Musk confirms next SpaceX Starship test flight coming soon after recent setbacks
SpaceX founder and CEO Elon Musk has confirmed that the company plans to launch the next test flight of its massive Starship rocket in 'about three weeks.' The announcement came via a post on X (formerly Twitter) on July 14, 2025. If the timeline holds, it would mark the 10th test flight of Starship, the largest and most powerful rocket ever built, and its fourth mission this year. The flight follows a string of technical setbacks, including the explosion of a Ship upper stage during a test and the loss of control in previous flights. Despite these hurdles, SpaceX remains committed to advancing Starship's goal of enabling interplanetary travel and rapid, reusable orbital missions. SpaceX Starship's recent failures The upcoming launch follows a bumpy path for SpaceX's Starship program. On June 18, the upper stage (referred to as "Ship") originally slated for Flight 10 exploded on a test stand at the company's Starbase facility in South Texas. Investigations pointed to a failed pressurized nitrogen tank in the vehicle's nosecone. SpaceX has since begun preparing a replacement Ship vehicle for the mission. This incident adds to previous in-flight failures: Flights 7, 8, and 9—all launched in 2025—ended with the vehicle being lost during or after ascent. Super heavy booster shows promise by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Why seniors are rushing to get this Internet box – here's why! Techno Mag Learn More Undo While the ship has encountered repeated issues, the Super Heavy booster—the rocket's massive first stage—has delivered more consistent performance. During Flights 7 and 8, the booster successfully returned to Starbase and was even caught by the launch tower's mechanical 'chopstick' arms. Flight 9 also featured the first-ever reuse of a Super Heavy booster. However, during reentry, that reused booster broke apart over the Gulf of Mexico shortly after initiating its landing burn. What's next for Starship Flight 10 Flight 10 will be the 10th fully integrated launch of the Starship-Super Heavy system. If successful, it will help SpaceX demonstrate improved reusability and system reliability, key to the company's ambitions of using Starship for lunar missions, space station resupply, and eventually Mars colonization . SpaceX has not yet disclosed a specific target date, but if preparations go as planned, the launch could occur by early August 2025. Long-term vision: Moon, Mars, and beyond SpaceX's ultimate goal for Starship is to serve as a fully reusable transport system for large payloads and humans to the Moon, Mars, and beyond. The rocket stands nearly 400 feet tall when fully stacked and is powered by Raptor engines fueled by liquid methane and liquid oxygen. With each launch, the company collects valuable data to refine the vehicle's design and operations. Despite recent failures, Musk has reiterated that iterative testing and rapid development are central to SpaceX's approach. Starbase, SpaceX's sprawling launch site in Boca Chica, Texas, continues to be a key hub for Starship development. The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) is closely monitoring the program and will need to approve the upcoming launch. Local and international space enthusiasts are watching closely, eager to see if Starship can deliver on its promise of revolutionizing space travel.
