Hawaii families receive payouts for 2021 fuel leak that sickened thousands
A federal judge has awarded more than $680,000 to 17 families who say they were sickened by a leak from a second-world-war era fuel tank into a US Navy drinking water system in Hawaii in 2021.
The bellwether cases set the legal tone for another 7,500 military family members, civilians and service members whose lawsuits are still awaiting resolution.
US district judge Leslie Kobayashi handed down the ruling on Wednesday, awarding from $5,000 to more than $104,000 to each plaintiff. In her order, Kobayashi wrote that it was clear that even though the contaminated water could have caused many of the kinds of medical problems the military families experienced, there wasn't enough evidence to prove a direct link.
The military built the Red Hill fuel tanks into the side of a mountain in the early 1940s to protect them from aerial attack. The site was in the hills above Pearl Harbor and on top of an aquifer equipped with wells that provided drinking water to the navy and to Honolulu's municipal water system.
In 2021, jet fuel gushed from a ruptured pipe in the military-run tank farm, leaking into a well that supplied water to housing and offices in and around the sprawling base. Some 6,000 people suffered nausea, headaches, rashes and other symptoms.
The amount awarded to each of plaintiff was significantly smaller than the roughly $225,000 to $1.25m that their attorney, Kristina Baehr, requested during the two-week trial in federal court in Honolulu.
As bellwether plaintiffs, the 17 were chosen because they were seen as representative of the thousands of other people whose cases are still pending.
Baehr called the damage awards disappointing but said the families 'prevailed against all odds against the US Government'.
'These families can be proud that they helped prove to the world what truly happened when the Navy poisoned the water supply near Pearl Harbor and sickened so many,' Baehr said in a news release. 'The Court rejected the Government's argument that thousands of our clients were just psychosomatic and that there was not enough fuel to make anyone sick.'
Baehr said the legal team was reviewing options for resolving the thousands of remaining cases.
The government admitted liability for the spill before the trial began, but its attorneys disputed whether the plaintiffs were exposed to enough jet fuel to cause the vomiting, rashes and other alleged negative health effects.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
20 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Health snacks loved by young people shockingly linked to risk of sudden strokes, heart attacks
A popular sweetener used in protein bars and sugar-free energy drinks could raise your risk of suffering from a stroke, a study suggests. Researchers at the University of Colorado, Boulder, exposed human cells found in the brain to erythritol in amounts they claimed mirrored a diet soda. The cells showed worrying changes within hours, including a decrease in the amount of clot-busting proteins they released, which is key for preventing strokes. Auburn Berry, a graduate student who led the research, said: 'While erythritol is widely used in sugar-free products marketed as healthier alternatives, more research is needed to fully understand its impact on vascular health. 'In general, people should be conscious of the amount of erythritol they are consuming on a daily basis.' It comes amid a mystery rise in strokes in young people, which have surged almost 15 percent among under-45s since 2011 — according to CDC data. Erythritol is a wildly popular sweetener, used in drinks including Vitaminwater Zero sugar, Monster Zero and Arizona Iced Tea, and in Quest protein bars. It is also found in the sweetener truvia, which is often added to coffee as a sugar replacement. Although the new study was small and used isolated cells, it adds to the growing body of evidence raising concern about the sweetener. A 2023 Cleveland Clinic study tracked 4,000 people found those who consume erythritol were more likely to suffer a heart attack, stroke or early death. The new study was published in the Journal of Applied Physiology. Researchers isolated human cerebral microvascular endothelial cells — cells that line blood vessels in the brain. After exposing them to erythritol for three hours in a lab, the researchers identified several damaging changes. These included the cells producing 75 percent more compounds that can damage them and surrounding tissue. And they also produced about 20 percent less of a compound used to help blood vessels relax, allowing more blood to flow through and minimizing the risk of a clot. Researchers also noted that erythritol decreased the production of a clot-busting protein called t-PA, which can dissolve clots and help prevent strokes. In their conclusion, they said the sweetener 'potentially contributes to [an] increased risk of ischemic stroke'. An ischemic stroke occurs when a blood clot blocks a blood vessel in the brain, preventing blood and oxygen from reaching brain tissue. This can cause brain cells to die within minutes. Limitations of the study include that it was carried out in a lab outside the human body, which may not mirror internal conditions. For example, it was not clear how much of the sweetener is typically absorbed by these cells in people. The study also exposed the cells to the equivalent of 30 grams of erythritol. The researchers claimed this was 'equivalent to the typical amount... in an artificially sweetened beverage.' But the stated amount of sweetener in the beverages typically falls below this threshold. For example, Monster Energy Zero contains about two grams of erythritol — according to consumer website Open Food Facts. Meanwhile Vitaminwater says less than one percent of its 500 milliliter (ml) bottles contain erythritol, or less than five grams. Quest protein bars also contain up to five grams of erythritol each, according to the company's website. Erythritol is about 70 percent as sweet as sugar but contains six percent of the calories. It can be found in small amounts naturally in some foods, but in diet sodas is often made from processing corn. It also isn't easily processed by the body, meaning it is often passed out through urine. Some may, however, be stored in the body — where its effects can build-up overtime. It was approved by the FDA as safe for foods in 2001 The study comes amid a concerning rise in strokes among young Americans, with previous work blaming this on increased stress, a more sedentary lifestyle and higher drug use than past generations. Obesity, high cholesterol and diabetes also play a role — all three are more prevalent in young people today than historically. In previous research from last year, scientists also found that when people are given the sweetener erythritol, cells in their blood that cause clotting become more active. Specifically, they found the sweetener caused platelets in the blood to become activated and stick together, forming clots.
The Sun
27 minutes ago
- The Sun
The signs of killer cancer you've NEVER heard of that's rising in young people, from waist size clue to bloating
CANCER is typically thought of as a disease of old age. But doctors are increasingly finding that certain types, particularly bowel cancer, are hitting younger people far more than they used to. 2 In a new report, published in the Annals of Internal Medicine, scientists have found that appendiceal cancer - a very rare form of the disease - is also on the rise. An analysis of over 4000 people in the US, found that compared with older generations, rates of the condition, also called appendix cancer, have tripled among Gen X and quadrupled among millennials. 'There is a disproportionate burden of appendix cancer among young individuals,' said the study's lead author, Andreana Holowatyj, from Vanderbilt University Medical Center, in the US, told NBC News. The researchers suggest that environmental, lifestyle and genetic factors that intensified after the second-world war may explain the concerning increase in appendix cancer rates. They point to dietary habits, gut bacteria changes, greater prevalence of conditions inflaming the gastrointestinal tract in particular. 'Similar trends have been reported for other gastrointestinal cancers, suggestive of potential shared cause contributing to this increasing cancer burden across generations,' the study noted. Although the new study, published yesterday, did not include individuals from the UK, a study published in 2022 did, revealing a similar trend. The research, published in BJS Open, showed that cases of the disease in the UK have more than quadrupled in the UK. There were a total of 949 cases between 1995 and 2001, which jumped to 4132 total cases between 2010 and 2016. Still, appendix cancers are extremely rare. The 4 signs of bowel cancer that mean it's 'too late' - as doctor reveals cause of surge in young people being diagnosed According to the National Cancer Institute, they occur at a rate of 1 to 2 cases per million people annually in the US. Meanwhile, in the UK, where the population is smaller, around 640 people are diagnosed with the disease each year. The appendix is a small pouch of tissue that hangs off the abdomen. It is part of the intestines and bowel, which absorb nutrients and remove waste from the body. Experts do not know what the appendix does, but it may help the immune system. There are two main types of appendiceal cancer: epithelial appendiceal cancer and neuroendocrine appendiceal cancer. The symptoms of appendiceal cancer can vary but may include abdominal pain, bloating, the presence of a lump in the tummy, nausea, and feeling full quickly after eating.
The Independent
35 minutes ago
- The Independent
White House says it will spare some Aids programs that were on the chopping block
The White House is trying to reassure House Republicans that Donald Trump's plans to slash funding to Aids projects around the world will spare a number of key prevention programs. House Speaker Mike Johnson and his fellow GOP leaders in the lower chamber of Congress are racing to shore up support ahead of a vote on a $9.4bn package of spending cuts Thursday. Congressional Republicans have expressed particular concern over planned cuts to former commander-in-chief George W Bush 's signature President's Emergency Plan for Aids Relief (PEPFAR), which has been credited with saving millions of lives across the globe since 2003. As part of an effort to allay those worries and rally the troops, the House GOP leadership has vowed to retain treatments offered under PEPFAR as well as a number of other prevention schemes, according to Capitol Hill sources cited by Politico. Speaker Johnson's whip team reportedly spent Monday evening frantically texting Republicans and calculating probable votes for the 'rescissions' package, which, in addition to cutting hundreds of millions of dollars in foreign Aids funding, also targets public broadcasters like NPR and PBS, both of whom are currently suing Trump's administration over the withdrawal of federal funding. Russell Vought, Director of the Office of Management and Budget, told appropriators last week that the administration is seeking to take 'an analytical look' at Aids prevention and instead prioritize funding for 'life-saving treatment' for sufferers as part of its scaling back of PEPFAR. 'It is something that our budget will be very trim on,' he said of prevention funding. 'We believe that many of these nonprofits are not geared towards the viewpoints of the administration. And we're $37 trillion in debt. So at some point, the continent of Africa needs to absorb more of the burden of providing this healthcare.' Trump's cuts to Aids prevention funding, enacted under an executive order he signed within hours of returning to the Oval Office in January, have been forecast to have disastrous results. A crisis that had been on course to be brought under control by 2030 will now be extended at the cost of an estimated 4m more lives, according to forecasts from the United Nations Aids agency. The disruption to global HIV programmes by the U.S. is also projected to lead to more than 3m more Aids orphans than was previously anticipated by the end of the decade. But the president himself has insisted that it is Europe that needs to step up and invest more to help the nations worst-hit by the disease. 'Nobody does anything but the United States… Other countries should be helping us with that,' he told reporters onboard Air Force One last month. 'We're the only country. Where are the others? Where is France? Where is Germany? We've spent billions and billions of dollars.' documentary investigation by The Independent, which includes reporting from remote areas in Uganda and Zimbabwe, has recently demonstrated that Trump's brutal severing of aid – and abrupt halt in medication – is already tearing lives apart. Earlier this year The Independent revealed Trump's slashing of foreign aid has derailed the projected end of the Aids pandemic and could lead to four million extra deaths by 2030. Figures show the number of Aids-related deaths could jump from six million to 10 million in the next five years unless funding is reinstated, according to forecasts from the UN Aids agency (UNAIDS). The unprecedented disruption to global HIV programs by the U.S. is also projected to lead to more than three million more Aids orphans than previously expected by the end of the decade.
