‘Walk to Safeguard Judicial Independence' should have taken place much earlier — Hafiz Hassan
That was in March 2017.
More than a year later, eminent constitutional law expert, Prof Dr Shad Faruqi wrote in his column in The Star:
'The provision of the Federal Constitution's Article 125(1) on retirement age (66 years plus six months of possible extension) seriously hinders the ongoing internal effort to reform the judiciary.
'It is therefore recommended that in line with many other countries, the age of retirement of our superior court judges should be extended. The most extreme case is the US Supreme Court, where the appointment is for life. Canada imposes the age of 75. The United Kingdom, Australia, Holland, South Africa, the Philippines and Indonesia observe the age of 70.'
The article was republished on the Malaysian Bar website.
In April this year, the eminent expert said it again: the retirement age of judges should be extended to 70 by amending Article 125(1).
In the preceding years, it is noteworthy that the call to extend or increase the retirement age of judges was also made by Karen Cheah, then president of the Malaysian Bar.
According to Cheah, Malaysia should allow its judges to retire at the later age of 70.
She noted that many other countries have set the retirement age for judges at 70 years old, and that some countries have proposed for the retirement age to be increased to 75 or even 80 years old.
'Another important reform which the Malaysian Bar believes will strengthen the judiciary and retain the nation's talent is to increase the age of retirement of judges to 70,' she said in her speech at the Opening of the Legal Year 2023 at the Putrajaya International Convention Centre.
'The Malaysian Bar urges the government to make constitutional amendments to give effect to this important reform,' she added.
So, what happened to the call made in the name of the Malaysian Bar?
Deputy law minister Mas Ermieyati Samsudin (left) holding up the memorandum she received from Bar president Karen Cheah (right) during Walk for Judicial Independence at Padang Merbok in Kuala Lumpur June 17, 2022. — Picture by Yusof Mat Isa
If the call had been pursued vigorously, without fear or favour, the peaceful 2.6km march for judicial independence in Putrajaya, aimed at handing over a memorandum to the Prime Minister's Office, should have taken place following the call by Karen Cheah.
The 'Walk to Safeguard Judicial Independence' starting at the main entrance of the Palace of Justice (POJ) – the very heart of the judicial system, from where justice is dispensed – would have long demonstrated the commitment of the Malaysian Bar to judicial independence and integrity.
* This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Deputy minister: Putrajaya maintains 7.3pc profit cap for TNB under current regulatory period, with excess returned to consumers
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 13 — Putrajaya said today it has maintained a profit cap of 7.3 per cent for Tenaga Nasional Berhad (TNB) for a three-year period under Regulatory Period 4 (RP4), a rate unchanged since 2018. According to Deputy Energy Transition and Water Transformation Minister Akmal Nasrullah Mohd Nasir, any profit exceeding this limit will be returned to consumers through the Electricity Industry Funds (KWIE). 'The capped profit rate has been in place since RP2 in 2018, and any excess earnings will be channelled back to the people through KWIE,' he told the Dewan Rakyat here. He explained that the capped profit is benchmarked against TNB's investment needs, including upgrading and strengthening the national grid to support the Asean Power Grid, building and maintaining power plants, installing smart meters, digitalising the energy system, and accommodating greater integration of renewable energy in line with Malaysia's energy transition agenda. He also said government-linked investment companies such as Khazanah Nasional Berhad, the Retirement Fund (KWAP), and the Employee's Provident Fund are among TNB's main shareholders, with these entities receiving a total of RM15.75 billion in dividends from 2018 to 2023. 'The profit cap is intended to ensure TNB remains stable as a utility company capable of delivering quality services to consumers while providing reasonable returns to its main shareholders, which include the government-linked investment companies,' he added. Akmal was responding to a question from Bagan MP Lim Guan Eng on TNB's annual profit and the additional revenue it could gain after the electricity tariff hike for the commercial sector on July 1. Replying to a supplementary question from Padang Besar MP Rushdan Rusmi on whether the ministry would consider introducing a 'reserve tariff' or 'returnable tariff' mechanism to return profits beyond a set threshold directly to consumers as bill rebates rather than through company dividends or CSR initiatives, Akmal said such returns were already in place. 'For example, those using less than 600 kWh will receive energy efficiency incentives starting now. Secondly, to further assist groups that use energy efficiently, retail costs do not need to be paid,' he added. He said the government is rebalancing the tariff so that more funds go towards infrastructure, instead of the previous structure where nearly 90 per cent covered energy costs and only 9 per cent went to infrastructure. He added that they are aiming to keep energy costs at around 40 to 50 per cent, pending confirmation of the exact figures. 'In principle, protection and returning benefits to the people have been implemented from the start. We have planned that for the next three years, users below the mentioned threshold will not be affected by automatic fuel adjustment 'Under this plan, if examined closely, 85 per cent of TNB's users, especially domestic ones, are already enjoying reductions when using electricity at the same consumption level because these incentives were provided earlier,' he added.
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
From accident response to crime prevention, Gobind says Malaysia's cloud policy set to transform public services
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 13 — The government today launched the National Cloud Computing Policy (NCCP), which Digital Minister Gobind Singh Deo said will be a key enabler to transform how Malaysia works, lives and delivers public services. Speaking at the launch, Gobind said the NCCP is not just a technology blueprint, but a living national framework to harness cloud computing across all sectors. 'This is something more than just a conversation. My ministry looks at it as an enabler. If you are able to put all of these blocks together, then we will see the country transformed into a nation that invites all its people to partake in this journey of digital transformation,' he said in his speech here. The NCCP places cloud computing at the heart of public service reform, enabling government agencies to store and process data on secure, shared platforms instead of in isolated systems. This would allow ministries, councils and emergency services to work off the same real-time information, from renewing passports online to dispatching ambulances faster. Gobind illustrated how cloud-powered smart cities could transform daily life, saying the technology could change how Malaysia responds to emergencies, manages infrastructure, and delivers services. 'Imagine a country where we have autonomous vehicles, where surveillance systems can show you how cars travel on the roads and, if there's an incident, you can in real time visualise what has happened,' he said. Gobind said cloud-powered systems could access nearby camera footage to quickly determine fault in an incident and decide whether to dispatch police or an ambulance, with smart ambulances providing preliminary treatment en route so the right doctors are ready on arrival. He said the same system could help manage traffic, identify accident-prone areas, and prevent floods using sensors to detect rising water levels. 'If we can send people to look at it beforehand, we can fix the problem before there is a flood. It's the same with security, the cameras can alert police to areas with higher criminal activity so we can act immediately,' he said. Gobind also highlighted cloud-powered healthcare, where encrypted electronic health records could be shared between rural clinics and urban hospitals for faster, more accurate treatment. The NCCP sets five core goals: positioning Malaysia as a leading regional cloud and digital hub by 2030; enhancing public sector efficiency; boosting private sector innovation and competitiveness; enabling a digitally inclusive society; and promoting environmentally sustainable cloud practices. Under the policy, government agencies will adopt a 'cloud-first' approach, with centralised cloud infrastructure, citizen-centric digital services and transparent procurement processes. The private sector will benefit from incentives, support for local cloud providers, sovereign cloud infrastructure, and a certification framework for cloud service providers to meet national security and privacy benchmarks. The NCCP also includes measures to strengthen data sovereignty by ensuring critical data is stored in Malaysia, while allowing cross-border transfers only under strict safeguards. Malaysia has already approved RM114.7 billion in data centre and cloud investments between 2021 and 2023, with global players such as AWS, Microsoft, Google and Oracle committing more than USD16.5 billion to local infrastructure.
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Federal Court grants Najib leave to seek review on purported house arrest order
PUTRAJAYA, Aug 13 — Former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak is now cleared to pursue his legal challenge over an addendum or 'supplementary order' issued by a former King permitting him to serve the remainder of his reduced sentence under house arrest. This follows the Federal Court's three-member bench unanimous decision to dismiss the Attorney General's Chambers' (AGC) appeal against a lower court decision to grant Najib leave to proceed with his court case seeking house arrest. The Federal Court said the addendum order's existence has been previously confirmed following concessions made by the Attorney General in previous hearings despite its validity being inconclusive at this stage. "Its status vis-a-vis its validity or whether its true needs to be ascertained at the substantive judicial review hearing which we do not consider it right or fair for us to express any view on this point at this stage. "It is a point for further investigation on a full interparty basis with all such evidence as is necessary on the facts and all such arguments as is necessary on the law. "Consequently we remit the case to the High Court for the hearing of substantive judicial review proceedings before a new judge," Federal Court judge Datuk Zabariah Mohd Yusof said in delivering the panel's decision. The three-member Federal Court bench was led by Chief Judge of Malaya Tan Sri Hasnah Mohammed Hashim and included Zabariah as well as Datuk Hanipah Farikullah. In a 2-1 majority decision on January 6, a three-member appellate court bench remitted the case on Najib's claim of the existence of an additional document — purportedly allowing him to serve the remainder of his six-year prison sentence under house arrest — to the High Court to be heard on its merits. MORE TO COME
