Bird Strike, Engine Failure Or Flap Error? Experts List Possible Causes Of Ahmedabad Air India Crash
Last Updated:
Ahmedabad Plane Crash: Speaking to CNN-News18, Captain Steve, an international aviation expert, pointed to the possibility of a bird strike.
As authorities probe the tragic crash of Air India Flight AI171, which claimed over 200 lives shortly after takeoff from Ahmedabad, aviation experts reflected on the probable causes that may have caused the Boeing 787 Dreamliner to go down. The aircraft was headed to London Gatwick and crashed into a doctors' hostel, killing passengers and several people on the ground.
Bird Strike Possible, But Unlikely Alone
Speaking to CNN-News18, Captain Steve, an international aviation expert, pointed to the possibility of a bird strike. However, he stressed that it would likely require 'a large number of birds" to cripple such a modern aircraft. 'Bird hit may be a possibility, but then it has to be lots of birds," he said.
Flap Retraction Or Pilot Error?
Captain Steve raised concerns about flap mismanagement. If the flaps were retracted prematurely during takeoff, the plane could have lost lift, he said, adding, 'Another plausible theory is that the co-pilot could have raised the flap too early."
That loss of lift at low altitude could explain the aircraft's inability to gain height, he said.
Loss Of Power In Both Engines?
Aviation analyst Devesh Agarwal underlined the significance of the incident, especially as it involves the Boeing 787 Dreamliner, one of the most widely trusted aircraft models. He told ANI, 'This 787 Dreamliner is Boeing's most modern plane. All its safety systems are intact, and it uses reliable engines trusted by airlines and regulators across the world."
He explained, 'Accidents never happen due to a single point of reason. There are always a series of failures or factors that align. That's why it is important to investigate this matter deeply. The whole world has its eyes on this accident."
What Next?
The Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) has initiated a formal inquiry into the crash, in line with ICAO protocols. The government has also constituted a high-level committee of experts to examine the incident and recommend future safety enhancements.
First Published:
June 13, 2025, 18:37 IST
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
14 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
U.S. officials survey Air India crash site, families continue to wait for bodies
AHMEDABAD, India, - Officials from the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board surveyed the site of Air India plane crash that killed at least 271 people, sources said on Sunday, with families continuing to wait for DNA profiling results to identify charred bodies. Along with the NTSB, officials from the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration were in Ahmedabad in western India's Gujarat state surveying the crash site, said one source with direct knowledge. The Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner with 242 people on board bound for Gatwick Airport south of London began losing height seconds after take-off in Ahmedabad on Thursday, and erupted in a huge fireball as it hit buildings below. All but one on board were declared dead in the world's worst aviation disaster in a decade. Around 30 people died on the ground. Air India and the Indian government were looking at several aspects of the crash including issues linked to its engine thrust, flaps, and why the landing gear remained open as the plane took off and then came down. The secretary of the U.S. Department of Transport, Sean Duffy, said on Friday he was in the process of deploying a team from the FAA and the NTSB to India. Boeing and GE, whose engines were used in the plane, were also sending teams. "We'll take action should any recommendations come forward from the NTSB's investigation," Duffy said. The FAA and NSTB did not immediately respond to Reuters queries outside regular business hours. The FAA has said India will lead the investigation, but the NTSB is the official U.S. representative for providing assistance, while the FAA provides technical support. Boeing officials will also look at various parameters in their inspections, including the angle of landing, as they investigate the matter, said the first source. In all, around 10 officials were present at the site on Sunday, including from the NTSB, said the second source. India's aviation regulator has ordered all Boeing 787s being operated by local carriers to be inspected. The crash brings a fresh challenge for both Air India which has for years being trying to revamp its fleet, and Boeing, which is trying to rebuild public trust following a series of safety and production crises. In Ahmedabad, doctors were struggling to identify bodies that were charred in the incident, resorting to dental samples and DNA profiling. DNA samples of 32 victims from the crash have been successfully matched, Rajnish Patel, additional superintendent at the city's main hospital, said on Sunday. "The bodies for which DNA samples have been matched are being handed over to the families with due respect," he said.
Hindustan Times
15 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
'Mayday! Mayday!' Air India pilot's final radio message before deadly Ahmedabad plane crash
Ill-fated Air India aircraft's pilot Captain Sumeet Sabharwal's last radio message to Ahmedabad air traffic control was a 'Mayday' call. As per aviation authorities, flight AI 171 crashed seconds after Sabharwal's message to the ATC in Ahmedabad on Thursday, June 12. Speaking to reporters on Saturday, SK Sinha, the Aviation Ministry Secretary, said that the pilots made the distress call to ATC when the plane failed to rise above 650 feet after takeoff. Seconds after the distress call, ATC responded but the plane had crashed by then, killing 241 people on board. A British national seated in 11A has been identified as the sole survivor of the incident. "Thrust not achieved... falling... Mayday! Mayday! Mayday!," was the pilot's last message to ATC as reported by TOI. As per aviation authorities, the plane took off at 1:39 PM and a few seconds after, started sinking after reaching a height of 650 feet. "The plane took off at 1.39 pm and, within a few seconds, after reaching a height of about 650 feet, it started sinking, i.e., it started losing height. The pilot informed Ahmedabad ATC that it was a 'mayday', i.e., a full emergency. When ATC tried to contact, it did not receive a response," Sinha said in a press conference. "After exactly a minute, the plane crashed in Meghaninagar, which is two kilometres from the airport. The Captain was Sumeet Sabharwal and the First Officer was Clive Sundar," the aviation secretary added further. Thursday's plane crash in Ahmedabad has killed a total of 270 people. This includes 241 people who were on board the London-bound flight and the 29 people who were killed after the plane crashed into the hostel of B.J. Medical College. The Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner was bound for London's Gatwick when it crashed. Of the 242 people on board, only one passenger survived the crash. The black box of the plane was recovered by officials during the rescue and relief operations. As per Union Minister of Civil Aviation Ram Mohan Naidu, the data from the black box will help identify the exact cause of the deadly plane crash.
News18
22 minutes ago
- News18
Chaotic Scenes As Kin Of Air India Crash Victims Refuse Partial Remains: '2 Heads In One Bag'
Last Updated: In a particularly tough situation, two heads were discovered in a body bag, resulting in the need to redo the entire DNA testing process. Chaotic scenes were witnessed at Ahmedabad's Civil Hospital as family members of the Air India plane crash victims have been making rounds in hope of at least finding the mortal remains of their loved ones. The authorities are facing unforeseen challenges in the process of victim identification as the deadly crash spared only one passenger. Relatives of passengers were seen gathering at an emergency centre on Friday to give DNA samples so their loved ones could be identified. In a particularly tough situation, two heads were discovered in a body bag, resulting in the need to redo the entire DNA testing process, which takes approximately 72 hours. A report in Times of India quoted a senior official at the Civil Hospital as saying, 'This will require the DNA sampling process to be repeated as the parts belong to two victims and shouldn't be in the same bag." A man on Saturday was seen urging officials to give him all the remains of his family members for the last rites. However, he was told that this request was not feasible. 'It was hard to convince him," the official was quoted. Outside the postmortem room of the 1,200-bed Civil Hospital, where health department staff have stored body bags for DNA analysis, distressed relatives cling to hope that the officials will manage to recover all the remains of each victim. 'We have an established clinical protocol which includes placing the remains in body bags, transferring them to cold storage, conducting analysis and finally handing over the identified remains in coffins to the families. We cannot assure the families of retrieval of complete body parts of the victims as the remains are charred," TOI further quoted the official. The authorities at Ahmedabad's Civil Hospital on Saturday issued a checklist of 'dos and don'ts" for the relatives of the deceased. It also mentioned 'quick procedure' of the handover of the mortal remains. • The relative who provided the DNA sample is recommended to be present for the handover of the mortal remains. • If that is not feasible, close family members of the individual should come. • If unavoidable situations arise, they can authorize others to handle procedures on their behalf by issuing an authority letter. • For the handover, you need to provide an Aadhaar card or any government-issued photo identification document. • They should also bring the deceased's documents, such as an Aadhaar card, passport, or voter ID card (either original or duplicate). • They should bring a document that verifies their relationship to the deceased. And mobile number given when the DNA sample was provided. • The hospital will provide a file containing the postmortem report, death certificate, and other legal documents. • If there is no document related to relationship, the relatives can approach mamlatdar, collector office. • Air India will assist in transporting the bodies by flight. Coordination for this is necessary. • Free transport will be provided for those who wish to take the mortal remains by road.
