Las Vegas resorts defeat hotel rate price-fixing class action in US appeal
Affirming, opens new tab a lower court decision, a three-judge panel of the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said it wasn't enough for the consumers to show that the rival resorts used the same revenue-management service provider amid an alleged rise in room rental rates.
The plaintiffs had accused the resort companies of colluding to overcharge guests by feeding sensitive internal information to a shared software platform operated by Cendyn that offered pricing recommendations. They appealed after a judge in Nevada dismissed the lawsuit in May.
The 9th Circuit panel said the consumers had not shown there was any agreement among the hotels to follow Cendyn's pricing recommendations. The court also said that hotels' independent use of the same software did not restrain their abilities to rent hotel rooms.
'Rather than eliminating competition, pricing one's hotel rooms in a manner calculated to maximize profits is how one competes,' wrote Circuit Judge Carlos Bea, joined by Circuit Judge Ana de Alba and U.S. District Court Judge Jeffrey Brown.
A lead attorney for the consumers did not immediately respond to a request for comment, and neither did the lawyer who argued for the defendants.
Cendyn said it welcomed the court's order. Wynn declined to comment. Caesars and Treasure Island did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
The hotels and software provider Cendyn have denied any wrongdoing.
U.S. courts are facing an increasing number of lawsuits claiming hotels and other industries unlawfully use revenue maximization platforms to fix prices.
Last October, a group of major casino-hotel operators in Atlantic City defeated a proposed consumer class action accusing them and a revenue management platform of overcharging for room rentals.
In dismissing the lawsuit in Las Vegas, Chief U.S. District Judge Miranda Du said the system generated pricing recommendations that hotels were not bound to follow.
The consumers in their appeal countered that even non-binding guidelines such as price recommendations can be considered an 'unreasonable' restraint within a competitive market.
The case is Richard Gibson et al v. Cendyn Group et al, 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 24-3576.
For plaintiffs: Steve Berman of Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro
For defendants: Melissa Sherry of Latham & Watkins
Read more:
US proposes settlement with Greystar to end alleged rental price collusion
US Justice Dept backs consumers in Las Vegas hotel pricing case
Consumers seek second chance in Las Vegas hotel price-fixing lawsuit
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
The 'King of American Coins' is found in 'grandpa's closet' after 70 years... and is set to fetch $5million
Where James A. Stack Sr. acquired it is a mystery that may never be solved - but for more than 70 years, one of the rarest coins in American history sat quietly in his family's collection. Stack, a prominent New York banker and one of the most discerning coin collectors of the 20th century, began building his collection in the late 1930s with a bold goal: to assemble the most complete and highest-quality cabinet of U.S. coins possible. He pored over landmark sales, forged relationships with top dealers, and handpicked pieces not just for rarity, but for their pristine condition and impeccable provenance. By the time of his death in 1951, Stack's holdings spanned everything from early American copper to spectacular gold issues, along with rarities in U.S. paper money, ancient coins, and world currency. His collection included some of the greatest trophies in American numismatics - an 1802 half dime, an 1894-S dime, an 1838-O half dollar, the 1815 half eagle, and the finest known 1870-S silver dollar. Even the notorious 1933 double eagle once sat in his albums before being surrendered to the Secret Service, leaving behind only his wry note: 'Secret Service has mine.' One of his most elusive prizes - an 1804 silver dollar known as the 'King of American Coins' - has remained hidden since the 1940s. Just 16 examples are known to exist, and this one is considered the finest of the so-called 'Class III' type in private hands. It will be seen publicly for the first time next week at the American Numismatic Association's World's Fair of Money in Oklahoma City before going under the hammer on December 9, where it's expected to fetch up to $5 million. John Kraljevich, numismatic historian with Stack's Bowers Galleries, which is handling the sale told Daily Mail: 'It certainly has the upshot of making some people who thought they knew everything about everything, or at least everything about this coin, second guess. 'There's always another collection sitting in grandpa's closet. That's why we do what we do - the joy of discovery and the hunt for hidden treasure.' Despite its date, no silver dollars were actually struck in 1804. 'None of the silver dollars made in 1804 were actually dated 1804,' Kraljevich explains. 'In 1834 they wanted diplomatic gifts for heads of state, so they made new dies and put 1804 on them.' Those first pieces went to rulers such as the King of Siam and the Sultan of Muscat - instantly making them rarities. Later, in the late 1860s and early 1870s, Mint employees struck a few more off the books for collectors. This newly surfaced piece is one of those so-called 'Class III' examples. 'It's high grade, it's beautiful, and it's the only one among all the Class Threes in private hands with that kind of caliber,' Kraljevich says. 'Among the Class Threes, this is far and away the best one any collector will have a chance to bid on,' he added. Stack's Bowers Galleries in New York will auction the newly discovered legendary rare coin on December 9 The 'King of American Coins' nickname dates back to 1941. 'That was marketing talk from another numismatic auctioneer… a Lithuanian immigrant named B. Max Mehl, sort of the PT Barnum of the coin industry,' Kraljevich says. 'He spent hundreds of thousands of Depression-era dollars on marketing, got everyone looking for rare coins in their change, and really helped coin collecting blossom.' Where Stack Sr. acquired the coin remains a mystery. 'We have no backstory,' says Kraljevich. 'The collector bought this between the late 1930s and 1951 in New York… where it was sourced before that is anybody's guess.' Kraljevich believes the coin's pristine state and fresh-to-market appeal could drive bidding sky-high. 'We're thinking probably four to five million… but anything could happen. People love new discoveries and stories of hidden treasure. You get two wealthy individuals who decide they just have to have it, and records will be set.' So why does the king still reign? 'Everybody loves a controversy,' Kraljevich says. Vendor Warren Mills is seen at a previous gathering of the American Numismatic Association's World Fair of Money 'You've got government officials behaving badly, early U.S. diplomacy, colorful collectors, and just enough conspiracy to keep people talking. 'None of these coins are what they seem - they all have a little bit of a secret side. 'Owning one automatically elevates a collection and the collector's place in history.' Only seven or eight examples of the 1804 dollar are in private hands today. The last one sold - the famed Sultan of Muscat specimen - fetched $7.68 million in 2021.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
$83m cash bonanza as surprise checks sent to residents in red state
Thousands of Americans could soon find surprise checks arriving in their mailboxes thanks to a new state law aimed at reuniting residents with unclaimed money - without them having to lift a finger. Act 114 of 2025, which went into effect last week, allows the Arkansas State Auditor's office to automatically return property valued at less than $5,000 to its rightful owner if they live in the state and the auditor 'reasonably believes' it belongs to them - even if they never filed a claim. State Auditor Dennis Milligan says the change means the agency will start sending out nearly $83 million in unclaimed property to around 360,000 people in the coming months, with the average payout expected to be just over $100. 'The next two or three months is going to be a lot of fun for Arkansans, because the checks will start going out,' Milligan told the MH Observer. 'This program is very, very important to me. You know, $200 might not mean anything to one person, but it may mean the difference between being able to pay a utility bill or … put[ting] some food on the table.' One in four Arkansans has money sitting in the unclaimed property program, which the auditor's office manages alongside its other duties. In total, the office holds around $400 million in unclaimed assets - money that can come from abandoned checking accounts, uncashed rebate checks, insurance adjustments, and even unclaimed wages. Milligan says he's had his own small payday from the program: 'I got 20 bucks here a while back off of some kind of rebate. 'A former employer tried to send you your last check, and they couldn't find you, so they forwarded it to us. It's a multitude of different reasons why we get sent this money.' While much of the unclaimed property is cash, some is far more unusual. The office maintains a catalog of items from abandoned safe deposit boxes, including a World War II-era telegram referencing Gen. Dwight D. Eisenhower, a $10,000 bill, and signed Nolan Ryan baseball cards. Until now, reclaiming any amount - even a few dollars - required filling out paperwork and verifying identity. But Republican Sen. Dave Wallace of Leachville, who sponsored the bill, said Milligan approached him last year with the idea to streamline the process. 'The state has $238 that belongs to either me, or my wife, Karen, from some event a couple years ago. I didn't even know about it,' Wallace told the MH Observer. 'And there's going to be thousands and tens of thousands of Arkansans in that same situation.' The auditor's office will use software to confirm identities and addresses before mailing checks, with letters going out first to alert recipients. As long as the notice isn't returned as undeliverable, the check will follow a few weeks later. 'I mean, who can argue about Arkansans getting their money back?' Milligan said. 'I haven't had anybody complain yet.' The automatic payments only apply to amounts under $5,000. Anyone owed more than that - or with physical property or jointly held assets - will still need to file a claim through the state's unclaimed property database. Milligan still encourages residents to check the online database from time to time, noting that even Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders has unclaimed property listed in her name.
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
How much has Ted Scott earned this year? Scottie Scheffler's caddie's incredible 2025 pay revealed
While Scottie Scheffler continues to dominate the fairways in 2025, it's now been revealed that his caddie Ted Scott has raked in nearly $1.5million along the way. Scheffler, 29, has cemented his place as the undisputed World No.1 with four tour wins already this season - including a fourth Major title at the Open Championship. Much of that success has come with Ted Scott by his side. The veteran caddie, who previously worked with Bubba Watson, joined Scheffler's team in 2021. Since then, the pair have formed one of the most effective partnerships in the modern game and it's proving to pay dividends for both men. GolfMonthly have now estimated - based on the standard PGA Tour arrangements for caddies - that Scott is believed to have pocketed $1.4million this year alone. Caddies are typically entitled to 10 per cent of the winner's cheque, and between 5 to 7 per cent for high finishes throughout the year. This year, things started strongly with Scheffler picking up more than $1.8 million in February thanks to two top-10 finishes and a T25. That early-season run likely earned Scott around $125,000 in bonus pay before the year had really even got going. March saw a a runner-up finish at the Houston Open and two more results inside the top 20. That three-tournament stretch probably netted Scott an extra $93,000. Between tournaments seven and nine of the season, the World No.1 landed two more top-10s and piled up $3.37 million in prize money. For Scott, that likely translated to a further $290,000 in earnings. Scheffler finally broke through with his first win of the year at the CJ Cup Byron Nelson in May. That victory lit the fuse for a run of form that saw him win three times in four starts, including a stunning triumph at the PGA Championship for his third Major title and a $3.42 million payday. He followed it with another win at the Memorial Tournament, where he took home $4 million and between those three victories, Scott is estimated to have collected a $742,000 cut of the spoils. Three more top-10 finishes in the same period saw Scheffler bank around $1.7 million, likely adding another $121,000 or so to Scott's growing total. By the end of June, Scott is believed to have earned $1.4million alongside Scheffler. However, Scheffler will be without his caddie Ted Scott when he tees it up at this week's BMW Championship in a huge blow for golf's world No 1. Scott has been a mainstay in Scheffler's professional career for the past four years, but a family emergency last weekend saw him rush back to his home in Louisiana. The change in circumstance led to Scheffler turning to a chaplain and close friend to help him out with the final round of the FedEx St Jude on Sunday, and now it'll be all change again this week. The recent Open champion and four-time major winner will have Mike Cromie on his bag instead, as he continues his foray into the FedEx Cup playoffs. Scott's personal matter has so far not yet been disclosed, but it is expected Scheffler will field questions about his close friend's absence as the week progresses.
