Are EVs just shifting pollution elsewhere? Zerodha's Nithin Kamath warns EV push may hurt biodiversity hotspots
The green allure of electric vehicles (EVs) may come with a hidden environmental and social price tag, warns Zerodha co-founder and CEO Nithin Kamath. In a post on X (formerly Twitter) earlier today, Nithin Kamath highlighted the unintended consequences of the transition from internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles to EVs.
Kamath questioned whether the world is simply shifting pollution away from cities to remote and vulnerable regions as part of the EV push.
'I'm not sure most people truly understand the cost of transitioning from ICE vehicles to electric vehicles. Are we just moving pollution from city streets to biodiversity hotspots?' he wrote
Kamath pointed out that mining and processing activities required for EV battery production have significant impacts on the environment and communities. He mentioned that Nickel mining in Indonesia — responsible for roughly half of the global supply — is devastating 'paradise islands' through massive strip‑mining operations.
Cobalt extraction in the Democratic Republic of Congo — where over 70% of the world's supply originates — is linked to child labour, dangerous working conditions, and community displacement.
Additionally, China's dominance in mineral processing — wielding control over 90% of rare earths, 75% of lithium, and 80% of tungsten — heavily relies on energy from coal‑powered plants, he noted.
'These environmental costs exist at every step,' Kamath underscored, prompting reflection on whether reduced emissions in cities are simply being outsourced to global supply chains.
Kamath's message resonates with broader concerns that 'clean' technology can mask a darker reality. He cautioned:
'Cleaner streets, yes. But at the cost of dirtier oceans, shattered communities, and forgotten islands?'
His remarks come at a time when EV adoption is increasing rapidly across the globe, driven by goals to reduce carbon emissions and dependence on fossil fuels.
Kamath did not suggest halting the transition to EVs but appeared to call for greater awareness and consideration of the broader environmental impact of the supply chain involved.
Disclaimer: The views and recommendations made above are those of individual analysts or broking companies, and not of Mint. We advise investors to check with certified experts before making any investment decisions.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
NVIDIA share price hits January 2025 high, inches close to record; will it climb to a new peak?
Nvidia shares were trading close to their January 2025 high levels in June 2025, as experts expect sustained momentum from the big tech stock amid easing tensions between Israel and Iran after the raging conflict. Earlier this week, Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang also sold 1,00,000 shares worth nearly $15 million of the company stock on Friday and Monday, part of the executives' larger plan to sell as much as 6 million shares by the end of 2025. A stock market analyst highlighted that the shares of the big tech firm, Nvidia Corp., witnessed a rally in the last few months. The shares surpassed their Janaury level and the shares are now indicating a sustained momentum. 'Nvidia share price has witnessed a stellar rally over the past couple of months, surging from around $90 to above $145. Throughout this uptrend, minor dips have been consistently bought into, with the 20-day EMA providing immediate support. The stock has now surpassed its January swing high, indicating sustained momentum,' a technical analyst told Mint. The analyst also estimates that the Nvidia share price is expected to have a key support level at $133 level, with the next potential resistance at $165 mark. Nvidia Corp. share price closed 2.59% higher at $147.90 after Tuesday's Wall Street session, compared to $144.17 at the previous stock market close. Shares of the big tech giant were trading 0.72% higher at $148.95 in the premarket trading session at 7:04 a.m. (EDT) on Nasdaq ahead of the US stock market open on Wednesday, 25 June 2025, according to Marketwatch data. Nvidia shares have given US stock market investors more than 1,516% returns on their investment in the last five years, and over 17% returns in the last one-year period. On a year-to-date (YTD) basis, the shares of the big tech giant have gained 6.93% in 2025, and are trading 2.39% higher in the last five Wall Street sessions. The shares hit their 52-week high level at $153.13, while the 52-week low level was at $86.62. Nvidia's market capitalisation (M-Cap) was at $3.61 trillion ahead of the US market open on Wednesday, 25 June 2025. Read all stories by Anubhav Mukherjee Disclaimer: This story is for educational purposes only. The views and recommendations above are those of individual analysts or broking companies, not Mint. We advise investors to check with certified experts before making any investment decisions.
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Dee Development Engineers surges 6% after winning $10 million international order for piping fabrication
Shares of Dee Development Engineers rallied 6 percent in intraday trade on Wednesday, June 25, 2025, after the company announced the receipt of a large international order worth $10 million. The development sparked optimism among investors, reaffirming the company's growing stature as a global leader in piping fabrication and engineering solutions. In a stock exchange filing, the company disclosed that the order was awarded by an international client, whose identity remains confidential due to commercial reasons. Nonetheless, the size and scope of the contract signal Dee Development Engineers' growing footprint in overseas markets, especially in the high-specification engineering services domain. According to the disclosure, the contract includes piping fabrication work on a material-supplied basis. The scope involves sophisticated engineering processes such as piping spool fabrication, Non-Destructive Testing (NDT), Post Weld Heat Treatment (PWHT), blasting and painting, as well as packing and transportation to a Free on Board (FOB) port. This suggests that the company will oversee both manufacturing and logistical aspects up to the port dispatch stage. The order is expected to be executed by February 28, 2026, providing the company with a two-year execution window. Notably, the order was classified as a non-related party transaction and does not involve any promoter or promoter group entities. This indicates the order was received at arm's length from an external international entity, reinforcing transparency and governance practices in line with regulatory expectations. This contract win, especially amid global economic uncertainties, reflects the strong operational capabilities and credibility Dee Development Engineers enjoys in the international market. It also underscores the company's ability to secure technically demanding projects and meet complex execution standards. Following the announcement, the stock soared to an intraday high of ₹ 322.10, marking a 6 percent jump. The stock is currently trading over 19 percent below its 52-week high of ₹ 400.00, which it had touched in July 2024. However, it has rebounded sharply from its 52-week low of ₹ 166.60 in February 2025, rallying more than 93 percent since then. Investor sentiment has remained broadly positive over the past few months. In June alone, the stock has added 8.5 percent, following a robust 30 percent surge in May. This comes after a temporary correction in April when the stock slipped 7.5 percent. March was another strong month, with the scrip registering a 21 percent gain. However, the stock did face selling pressure earlier in the year, declining 7.5 percent in January and plunging 29 percent in February. Disclaimer: The views and recommendations made above are those of individual analysts or broking companies, and not of Mint. We advise investors to check with certified experts before making any investment decisions.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Tata Motors' strategy to mitigate geopolitical headwinds
New Delhi: Following China's restrictions on rare earth magnet exports, auto major Tata Motors said it is working with the government and is also taking steps to procure magnets from alternate sources. These elements are critical to the production of ICE as well as electric vehicle (EV) components. Speaking to the media on Tuesday, Group CFO PB Balaji said there is no immediate concern. 'No panic buttons are being pressed at this stage,' he said. Commenting on the broader geopolitical risks , including the Israel-Iran conflict, he noted that the semiconductor crisis of 2022–23 served as a critical stress test for the automotive ecosystem, which led companies to internalise key lessons and significantly strengthen their supply chain resilience. The automaker stated that it will 'not change any of the product launch plans' at this stage. However, it added that if the situation worsens significantly, a reassessment may be necessary. The company recently launched the Harrier EV, with dispatches scheduled to begin next month, and confirmed that the Sierra EV rollout remains on track. Shailesh Chandra, MD at Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles and Tata Passenger Electric Mobility, added that the company is 'comfortable from a stock perspective for the next few months.' However, he acknowledged the strategic need to diversify sourcing in the medium to long term. 'We have identified seven high-impact rare earth elements out of 17 that are most critical to our components. We are closely tracking how to reduce the constitution or mix of these into the components in which it gets into,' Chandra said. He added that while short-term dependency will continue, there are clear pathways to significantly reduce and eventually eliminate this dependence over the long term. Union Steel and Heavy Industries Minister HD Kumaraswamy on Tuesday said the government is likely to decide on a subsidy scheme for domestic production of rare earth magnets within 15–20 days. While actual production is expected to take about two years, interim sourcing alternatives including Japan and Vietnam are being explored. Tariff impact on JLR Tata Motors anticipates a tariff-related impact on its British subsidiary Jaguar Land Rover (JLR), with EBITDA expected to decline to the 5–7 per cent range, down from its earlier 10 per cent EBIT trajectory. Further, he acknowledged that exports from the company's Slovakia plant to the US remain subject to tariffs, resulting in a cost impact. To mitigate this, the company is rolling out a "cost-out programme over the next 12–18 months." Meanwhile, Balaji confirmed that JLR will commence completely knocked down (CKD) operations at its Ranipet, Tamil Nadu plant in India by early 2026, gradually transitioning from its current Pune base. JLR plans to invest ₹9,000 crore in Ranipet plant over five years, as part of a broader strategy to expand its presence and manufacturing capabilities in the country. He noted that the proposed UK-India trade agreement could ease market entry for future models without requiring CKD scale initially. Hybrids on the cards? When asked about plans to introduce hybrid models by 2030, Chandra said that while the company currently categorises hybrids under the petrol segment, it remains open to the technology. 'If competitiveness requires us to introduce hybrids in certain segments, we will do so– not just for emission compliance, but also for performance-driven reasons,' he noted. However, reiterating its stance on incentivising hybrid vehicles, Tata Motors stated that the company does not view them as a long-term solution deserving of government incentives. 'We are absolutely fine supplying hybrids if that's what the customer wants. But our concern lies with incentivising hybrids. These are not destination technologies, they are transitional, meant to be used for managing CAFE norms by others,' Balaji said. According to him, hybrids are essentially enhanced ICE powertrains, and if they are to be incentivised, then CNG should logically receive similar support. Tata Motors' internal powertrain forecast in the near-term projects 30 per cent of volumes from EVs, 27 per cent from CNG, and around 6–10 per cent from diesel, with the remaining share comprising petrol including hybrids. It may be noted that the automaker's Avinya brand for EVs, which was initially aimed to launch within two and a half years from mid-2022, has been deferred to late 2026 due to 'feasibility challenges in certain subsystems', which required architectural revisions and prolonged engineering cycles. Demerger completion targeted by year-end Tata Motors' proposed demerger process is progressing smoothly, with July 1 this year set as the 'appointed date' for accounting purposes and October 1 as the 'effective date' when the commercial vehicle (CV) and passenger vehicle (PV) businesses begin operating as separate entities. Balaji noted that while the shareholder approval has already been secured, the company is now filing with the NCLT, after which it expects to receive inputs from the ROC and other regulators before final approval. Once the NCLT ruling is received, the company will proceed to operationalise the demerger. Post the demerger, the existing listed entity will become the PV business. The spun-out CV entity, which is set to be renamed Tata Motors, will be listed separately within 45–60 days of the effective date. Tata Motors anticipates the full process, including listing of both entities, to be completed by November–December 2025 period.
