France's top court annuls arrest warrant against Syria's Assad
The Court of Cassation ruled there were no exceptions to presidential immunity, even for alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity.
But its presiding judge, Christophe Soulard, added that, as Assad was no longer president after an Islamist-led group toppled him in December, "new arrest warrants can have been, or can be, issued against him" and as such the investigation into the case could continue.
Human rights advocates had hoped the court would rule that immunity did not apply because of the severity of the allegations, which would have set a major precedent in international law towards holding accused war criminals to account.
They said that, in this regard, it was a missed opportunity.
"This ruling represents a setback for the global fight against impunity for the most serious crimes under international law," said Mazen Darwish, the head of the Syrian Center for Media and Freedom of Expression, a civil party to the case.
French authorities issued the warrant against Assad in November 2023 over his alleged role in the chain of command for a sarin gas attack that killed more than 1,000 people, according to US intelligence, on August 4 and 5, 2013 in Adra and Douma outside Damascus.
Assad is accused of complicity in war crimes and crimes against humanity in the case. Syrian authorities at the time denied involvement and blamed rebels.
UNIVERSAL JURISDICTION
The French judiciary tackled the case under the principle of universal jurisdiction, whereby a court may prosecute individuals for serious crimes committed in other countries.
An investigation - based on testimonies of survivors and military defectors, as well as photos and video footage - led to warrants for the arrest of Assad, his brother Maher who headed an elite army unit, and two generals.
Public prosecutors approved three of the warrants, but issued an appeal against the one targeting Assad, arguing he should have immunity as a head of state.
The Paris Court of Appeal in June last year however upheld it, and prosecutors again appealed.
But in December, Assad's circumstances changed.
He and his family fled to Russia, according to Russian authorities, after Islamist-led fighters seized power from him.
In January, French investigating magistrates issued a second arrest warrant against Assad for suspected complicity in war crimes for a bombing in the Syrian city of Deraa in 2017 that killed a French-Syrian civilian.
'GREAT VICTORY'
The Court of Cassation said Assad's so-called "personal immunity", granted because of his office, meant he could not be targeted by arrest warrants until his ouster.
But it ruled that "functional immunity", which is granted to people who perform certain functions of state, could be lifted in the case of accusations of severe crimes.
Thus it upheld the French judiciary's indictment in another case against ex-governor of the Central Bank of Syria and former finance minister, Adib Mayaleh.
He has been accused of complicity in war crimes and crimes against humanity over alleged funding of the Assad government during Syria's civil war.
Mayaleh obtained French nationality in 1993, and goes by the name Andre Mayard on his French passport.
Darwish, the Syrian lawyer, said that part of the court's ruling was however a "great victory".
"It establishes the principle that no agent of a foreign state, regardless of the position they hold, can invoke their immunity when international crimes are at stake," he said.
Syria's war has killed more than half a million people and displaced millions from their homes since its eruption in 2011 with the then-government's brutal crackdown on anti-Assad protests.
Assad's fall on 8 December 2024 ended his family's five-decade rule.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
TimesLIVE
an hour ago
- TimesLIVE
Indian state refiners pause Russian oil purchases, say sources
Indian state refiners have stopped buying Russian oil in the past week as discounts narrowed this month and US President Donald Trump warned countries not to purchase oil from Moscow, say industry sources. India, the world's third-largest oil importer, is the biggest buyer of seaborne Russian crude, a vital revenue earner for Russia as it wages war in Ukraine for a fourth year. The country's state refiners — Indian Oil Corp, Hindustan Petroleum Corp, Bharat Petroleum Corp and Mangalore Refinery Petrochemical Ltd — have not sought Russian crude in the past week or so, four sources familiar with the refiners' purchase plans told Reuters. IOC, BPCL, HPCL, MRPL and the federal oil ministry did not immediately respond to Reuters' requests for comment. The four refiners regularly buy Russian oil on a delivered basis and have turned to spot markets for replacement supply — mostly Middle Eastern grades such as Abu Dhabi's Murban crude and West African oil, sources said. Private refiners Reliance Industries and Nayara Energy, majority owned by Russian entities including oil major Rosneft, have annual deals with Moscow and are the biggest Russian oil buyers in India.
Daily Maverick
an hour ago
- Daily Maverick
Chad's struggle for democracy is far from over as it steadily takes an authoritarian turn
Barely a year after restoring constitutional order and dominating elections, Chad's government is doubling down against opposition and free speech. Chad emerged from its political transition in January following presidential and parliamentary elections. The country underwent regime change in 2021 when Mahamat Déby took office after the death of his father and long-time president. The election results saw the ruling party, the Mouvement Patriotique du Salut (MPS), and transition president Déby dominate the political scene. This was unsurprising given that the MPS controlled the process from start to finish, and most of the opposition boycotted and contested the polls. Despite the electoral system's flaws, the MPS has used its election win to legitimise its resistance to dialogue with the political opposition. Since January, the crackdown on civic space has been reinforced by a campaign of legal pressure on all dissenting voices, including the media, the political opposition and civil society. These tactics are reminiscent of the previous regime. Although he came to power promising democratisation, the late former president Idriss Déby Itno's administration was characterised by the dominance of his family and political circles. Over three decades his reign undermined the foundations of democracy, triggering rebellions, deadly confrontations and weakening national cohesion and stability. In 2021, his son took charge of a fragmented and unstable country. The transition promised dialogue, reconciliation, inclusion and building a strong nation. But protests, friction and bloody repression cast doubt on the authenticity of the transition agenda. The legitimisation of Déby and his party through controlled elections reinforces the trend under his father of a single camp dominating public life. In one year of rule, the MPS system has gradually strengthened its grip on Chadian politics. The judiciary is politicised, and dissenting voices are silenced through arrests and trials widely regarded as biased. Independent media, opposition parties and civil society are also being targeted. Journalists are threatened and arrested while doing their job, with six detained for several months since January. In February, the head of an online media outlet was arrested for publishing an article about a financial scandal. In March, four journalists were detained on charges of 'intelligence with agents of a foreign power' – referring to the Russian group Wagner. Their lawyers deny the accusations and believe the trial represents the weaponisation of the justice system to restrict press freedom. After five months in jail, the journalists were acquitted. Pressure on the media remains constant. In June, N'Djamena's public prosecutor threatened imprisonment for journalists and human rights organisations who visited a conflict scene in the south of the country. The judicial system is also being used against prominent MPS opponents, such as Succès Masra, leader of the Les Transformateurs' party and former prime minister, who was arrested on 16 May. He is currently languishing in prison, accused of instigating a conflict in May 2025 despite evidence deemed fallacious by his defence team and much of the public. Constant pressure is exerted on opposition parties and their leaders, such as the opposition collective Groupe de concertation des acteurs politiques. Tactics involve intimidation, surveillance and the poaching of activists. The Ministry of Territorial Administration and Decentralisation has cracked down on four civil society organisations, banning them from all activities nationwide. Demonstrations and public protests remain prohibited unless authorised by the ministry. But for more than two years all applications have been systematically rejected. Meanwhile, Chad lacks real political alternatives. In the national assembly, 124 of 188 members (66%) belong to the ruling party. The remaining seats are split between parties allied to the MPS, undercutting any chance of real debate in parliament. Similarly, 44 of the senate's 46 elected representatives are MPS members. The constitution allows the president to appoint another 23 senators, all of whom are part of Déby's inner circle. The upper and lower houses of parliament are almost all under the MPS banner, raising fears of a drift to de facto one-party rule. Chad's precarious democratic project is in danger. Less than a year after returning to constitutional order, the country is steadily taking an authoritarian turn, returning to conditions that weakened national cohesion and fuelled instability under the previous regime. To take the political dialogue forward, former transitional prime minister Saleh Kebzabo has been appointed national mediator between the government and the opposition. He should advocate for the protection of citizens rather than their harassment and arbitrary arrest, and for the independence of the judiciary to be respected. At the regional level, the Economic Community of Central African States needs to re-engage with the Chad issue via its chosen mediator, Democratic Republic of the Congo President Félix Tshisekedi. His mediation previously facilitated the Kinshasa Agreement, which allowed the exiled Les Transformateurs party to return to the country and contest the presidential election. Considering that the domestic political and governance challenges Tshisekedi faces may hinder his legitimacy, other international actors, including the African Union through its Peace and Security Council, must also support the dialogue efforts. DM
TimesLIVE
7 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Modi faces opposition fury after Trump's 25% tariff threat
Indian opposition parties criticised the government on Thursday, describing US President Donald Trump's threat of a 25% tariff as a diplomatic failure for New Delhi, while the rupee tumbled and equity indices slid in response to the news. The 25% rate would single out India more harshly than other major trading partners and threatens to unravel months of talks, undermining one of Washington's strategic partners in the region, viewed as a counterbalance to China. Trump said the tariff on goods imports from India would start from Friday, in addition to an unspecified penalty for Russian dealings and involvement in the Brics grouping of nations, but added later that trade talks continued. In response, the government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi said it was studying the implications of Trump's remarks and was dedicated to securing a fair trade deal. 'This development reflects a broader collapse of foreign policy under the Modi government,' a legislator of the main opposition Congress said in a notice asking for a discussion of the matter in the lower house. The debate would focus on the 'government's economic and diplomatic failure in preventing the imposition of 25% US tariffs plus penalties on Indian exports,' it added. Commerce minister Piyush Goyal is expected to brief the lower house later on Thursday, TV news channels said. Economists warned the steep tariff could hurt India's manufacturing ambitions and trim up to 40 basis points from economic growth in the financial year to March 2026. India's benchmark equity indices, the Nifty 50 and BSE Sensex, fell about 0.6% each, while the rupee declined to 87.74, its lowest in more than five months, before paring losses. India has received a 'raw deal', said Priyanka Kishore, an economist at Asia Decoded. 'While further trade talks may bring the tariff rate down, it appears unlikely that India will secure a significantly better outcome than its eastern neighbours,' she added.
