Judge orders detained Tufts student Rumeysa Öztürk to be transferred back to Vermont
Judge William K. Sessions III stayed his order for four days to give the government a chance to appeal.
Rumeysa Öztürk, a 30-year-old Turkish national in the United States on a visa, is being held at an Immigration and Customs Enforcement detention center in Louisiana.
In Friday's ruling, the judge refused efforts by the government to dismiss her habeas petition.
He found that Öztürk 'has raised significant constitutional concerns with her arrest and detention.'
The Tufts doctoral student was arrested March 25 in Somerville, Massachusetts, and the Department of Homeland Security has accused her of engaging 'in activities in support of Hamas.'
She co-wrote an opinion essay in 2024 for the student newspaper that called on Tufts to 'acknowledge the Palestinian genocide,' which the undergraduate student government had demanded in a resolution.
The essay criticized university leadership for its response to the student government's resolutions that it 'disclose its investments and divest from companies with direct or indirect ties to Israel.'
'A university op-ed advocating for human rights and freedom for the Palestinian people should not lead to imprisonment,' one of her attorneys, Mahsa Khanbabai, said Friday. 'Our immigration laws should not be manipulated to rip people away from their homes and their loved ones.'
Öztürk's attorneys called Friday's ruling a victory, and said that the federal government was trying to manipulate where her case would be heard so that it could try for its preferred outcome.
Friday's ruling allows Öztürk to remain in ICE custody in Vermont while her habeas petition, which challenges her detainment, proceeds in federal court, as well as her removal case in immigration court in Louisiana.
The Department of Justice declined to comment Friday.
Öztürk is one of a number of international students in the U.S. on visas who the Trump administration is trying to deport for their actions protesting the conduct of Israel in its war against Hamas in Gaza, which it launched after the Hamas attacks on Israel on Oct. 7, 2023.
Tufts University has defended Öztürk and has petitioned that she be released from custody. The university said the opinion essay did not violate its policies and was in accordance with its position on free speech.
"The University has no further information suggesting that she has acted in a manner that would constitute a violation of the University's understanding of the Immigration and Naturalization Act," the university leadership said in a declaration earlier this month.This article was originally published on NBCNews.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
8 minutes ago
- New York Post
Palestinian extremist freed in hostage exchange set to discuss ‘struggle in Zionist prisons' at Detroit conference
A Palestinian extremist once jailed for attempted murder is slated to speak at the Detroit People's Conference for Palestine later this month about 'prisoners' struggle in Zionist prisons.' Hussam Shaheen, 53, is among two former prisoners who will attend the event starting on Aug. 29, with the man set to discuss his two decades in Israeli jail following his 2004 conviction for attempted murder. Shaheen was released on Feb. 1 as part of a prisoner swap in exchange for living and dead hostages of the Oct. 7 terror attack. Advertisement 3 Hussam Shaheen, 53, is set to discuss his two decades in Israeli jail following his 2004 conviction for attempted murder at the People's Conference for Palestine. People's Conference for Palestine Along with Shaheen, the People's Conference for Palestine also invited Omar Assaf, 75, a former official of the left-wing Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine group, the Jerusalem Post reported. The event, in its second year, is billed as a way for people to 'hear directly about the prisoners' struggle in Zionist prisons.' Shaheen was accused in 2002 of establishing an al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigade extremist cell in Jebl Mukaber, with four of its members claiming that he recruited them and supplied them with weapons for an attack on Jerusalem that fell through. Advertisement Shaheen was arrested in 2004 in the West Bank and sentenced to 27 years in prison for attempted murder and conspiracy to commit murder, according to Israel's Justice Ministry. 3 Shaheen was released on Feb.1 during a prisoner swap. Facebook He was one of the hundreds of prisoners freed on Feb. 1 in the exchange for some of the hostages taken by Hamas. Advertisement Assaf was arrested in the West Bank during a raid in Ofer following the Oct. 7, 2023, terrorist attack, with Israel holding the 74-year-old for six months without charge. Assaf was described as an official with the Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine (DFLP), a Marxist organization seeking to reform the Palestine Liberation Organization. Assaf is now the coordinator of the executive committees of the Palestinian Popular Conference, which had previously praised the Oct. 7 terrorist attack and called for violence against the Zionist Israeli enemy,' according to the Jerusalem Post. Advertisement 3 According to Israel's Justice Ministry, Shaheen was initially sentenced to 27 years in prison for the attempted murder before his early release in the prisoner swap. AFP via Getty Images Since his release in April 2024, Assaf has repeatedly spoken out about the alleged torture and regular beatings of Palestinian prisoners in Israeli prisons. The People's Conference for Palestine has previously invited controversial guests to their events, with last year's conference in Detroit including Wisam Rafeedie, a member of the PFLP terror group and Sana Daqa'a, the wife of PFLP terrorist Walid Daqu'a, who was convicted of commanding an operation that kidnapped and killed an Israeli soldier in 1984.
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Netanyahu to hold emergency meeting on Europe's recognition of a Palestinian state
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will hold a security-political meeting on Monday regarding Israel's response to European countries recognizing a Palestinian state. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will hold a security-political meeting on Monday evening regarding Israel's response to the intentions of European countries to recognize a Palestinian state in September. Smotrich is expected to demand the application of sovereignty over the West Bank and the immediate dismantling of the Palestinian Authority (PA). About three months ago, Smotrich announced the suspension of fund transfers to the PA and his intention not to extend the indemnification for Israeli banks transferring funds to the PA. This was done by canceling the indemnity provided to correspondent banks in relation to banks operating in the Palestinian Authority, his office confirmed on Tuesday. Until that moment, Smotrich had only occasionally delayed the transfer of funds from time to time, but had not ordered a complete halt. European countries to recognize a Palestinian State France and the UK are the two main European countries that plan to recognize a Palestinian State in the UN General Assembly in New York in September, alongside other European and non-European nations. Australia was the last to announce that it would recognize a Palestinian state, while Canada, another important Western ally, will also follow this route. Countries that still have not taken a position in this situation are New Zealand, whose Foreign Minister Winston Peters said he was carefully considering recognition of a Palestinian state, and Denmark, whose Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen said that while her country condemned Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, she did not support recognizing a Palestinian state at this time. Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas is considering unilaterally announcing the transformation of the PA into a state during the upcoming General Assembly, London-based outlet al-Araby al-Jadeed reported. Avraham Bloch, Reuters, and Mathilda Heller contributed to this report. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
How important is Gaza City to Hamas?
Gaza City presents a challenge. In 2024, it was largely cut off from central Gaza because the IDF held the Netzarim corridor. The IDF left that area in January 2025 and never retook it fully. Israel is once again targeting Gaza City in operations in Gaza. For many observers of the war, this might seem like a surprise. Some will wonder, wasn't Gaza City taken from Hamas at the beginning of the war? Others may wonder why it wasn't taken in the past? These are good questions. Why is the capital of Gaza still in the hands of Hamas? Why has Israel spent 22 months chipping away at the periphery, losing hundreds of soldiers, while 50 hostages remain in Gaza, and Hamas apparently has the privilege of controlling Gaza City and other parts of Gaza throughout the war? Hamas likely expected Israel to take Gaza City at the beginning of the war. Instead, what happened was that the IDF cut off Gaza City and northern Gaza from central Gaza in the first days of the ground offensive in late October 2023. Then, the IDF spent a month pushing into neighborhoods and suburbs of Gaza City, but never taking the city itself and holding it. Many of these areas were cleared quickly, and then the tanks and infantry left. This was the raiding strategy and tactic that Israel's commanders apparently believed would work early in the war. By mid-November, reports from the IDF claimed that they had broken through ten of the 24 battalions of Hamas in Gaza. The IDF claimed at the time that it had basically shattered Hamas in northern Gaza and dismantled the Hamas battalions there. However, it appears that the Hamas units were not destroyed. There was a brigade in Gaza City and another brigade in northern Gaza. By November 2024, a year after the battalions were supposedly defeated, the IDF had to enter Jabaliya in Gaza for the third time and clear it. Thousands of Hamas members remain, and 70,000 people had to be evacuated in November and December 2024. During the new operation, Gideon's Chariots launched in May 2025, the IDF once again vowed to retake Gaza. Politicians said that whole areas would be destroyed in this new operation. However, once again, Hamas was left in control of Gaza City as the IDF basically retook areas in Gaza in June and July 2025 that it had taken in 2023 and 2024. What is happening in Gaza now? Reports in Israeli media indicate that tanks have entered the outskirts of Gaza City. These reports speak of operations in the Sabra neighborhood in the southern part of the city. There have also been operations in the Zeitoun area between Gaza City and the Netzarim Corridor. The IDF had already taken this area at least four times since the war began. There have been limited operations in Sabra as well. Israel's political echelon believes that if Hamas is pushed out of Gaza City, then Hamas might finally collapse. However, Hamas has been pushed out of other key areas such as Rafah and Khan Yunis, and it has not collapsed. Evidence shows it has lost almost all of its company, battalion, and brigade commanders, as well as most of its leadership in Gaza. However, it continues to replace its fighters, and it has fought on. Hamas mostly retreats and hides in areas where the IDF operates. In Beit Hanoun, for instance, it hid out for 20 months of war near the Israeli border before finally being defeated. It was only defeated in Beit Hanoun in July 2025 because every house there was demolished. Gaza City symbollically important to Hamas Some believe that Gaza City is of great importance to Hamas. It is symbolically important, to be sure. Militarily, it is less clear. Hamas has strongholds in the Central Camps, areas where its activists have historically grown up. Hamas is more popular among Gazans who are descendants of Arabs who fled Israel in 1948 and ended up in Gaza. The older clans of Gaza are less supportive. These older Gazans tend to live in parts of Gaza City. Will entering their areas lead Hamas to collapse? Gaza City presents a challenge. In 2024, it was largely cut off from central Gaza because the IDF held the Netzarim corridor. The IDF left that area in January 2025 and never retook it fully. How many people are in Gaza City today? Several hundred thousand? Whatever the number, fighting among them will be complex. The IDF has always asked people to leave before it enters an area. This gives Hamas time to leave as well. Will Hamas simply leave Gaza City and wait out this offensive as it has in the past? Solve the daily Crossword
