Frontbencher proposes alternative to quotas as Liberal party agonises over gender imbalance
Party insiders in New South Wales say support for quotas is building, but any major reform to match Labor's rules first introduced in the mid-1990s is likely to take years.
McIntosh, the shadow women's minister, wrote to the NSW Women's Council president, Berenice Walker, this week, urging the discussion not be reduced to a yes or no on quotas.
'Strong systems help open the door, but it is the party's culture that determines whether women stay, thrive, and reach the heights of leadership and success,' McIntosh wrote.
She said she was open to quotas or some other mechanism for change, but warned addressing the party's culture needed to come first.
'A structural re-design might consider gender-balanced candidate pools to ensure equality of opportunity – consistent with our values – rather than prescribing outcomes.
'We should also examine leadership pipelines, mentorship initiatives, and other evidence-based mechanisms that reflect our principles. Culture and structure must evolve together.'
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
A candidate pool model would be similar to the 'A-list' of candidates for preselections introduced in Britain's Conservative party by the former prime minister David Cameron.
Cameron put a freeze on candidate selection and introduced a priority list, with half of the list to be female and a large number to be from minority backgrounds.
At Wednesday's meeting the council did not settle on a model for change or next steps, but participants said there was majority support for quotas and other significant changes.
The NSW Young Liberals have called for a candidate pool model, and reiterated their support for it at their last meeting in May, following the federal election.
Before this week's meeting, Walker said there would be an 'open discussion' of quotas.
Those in the meeting said a majority of the participants, diverse in age, were in favour of quotas, with only a few speaking against them.
One senior party member said there was 'no rush' to put forward a model.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
They said it was unlikely that quotas, which would need to be added to the NSW Liberal constitution, and voted on by its state council, would be in place by the next state election in 2027.
'We're a long way away from it, because the structure is difficult,' they said.
The federal leader, Sussan Ley, has said she is 'agnostic' on the party's approach to change, but told the National Press Club in June she was a 'zealot' on recruiting more women.
The frontbencher Angus Taylor, who Ley defeated for the leadership, has publicly opposed quotas, and said it would 'subvert democratic processes', pointing instead towards more mentorship within the party.
Vocal supporters for quotas, including the NSW senator Maria Kovacic, have called for more immediate action.
Kovacic said she would support temporary quotas with a sunset period, and firm expiry date, to get more Liberal members over the line.
'Achieving this goal will likely take two election cycles … Once that balance is reached, we can return to the existing system with confidence that equity has been successfully embedded,' she said.
'A sunset clause would be an appropriate mechanism to ensure the temporary nature of a quota system.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
20 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Use of AI could worsen racism and sexism in Australia, human rights commissioner warns
AI risks entrenching racism and sexism in Australia, the human rights commissioner has warned, amid internal Labor debate about how to respond to the emerging technology. Lorraine Finlay says the pursuit of productivity gains from AI should not come at the expense of discrimination if the technology is not properly regulated. Finlay's comments follow Labor senator Michelle Ananda-Rajah breaking ranks to call for all Australian data to be 'freed' to tech companies to prevent AI perpetuating overseas biases and reflect Australian life and culture. Ananda-Rajah is opposed to a dedicated AI act but believes content creators should be paid for their work. Sign up: AU Breaking News email Productivity gains from AI will be discussed next week at the federal government's economic summit, as unions and industry bodies raise concerns about copyright and privacy protections. Media and arts groups have warned of 'rampant theft' of intellectual property if big tech companies can take their content to train AI models. Finlay said a lack of transparency in what datasets AI tools are being trained on makes it difficult to identify which biases it may contain. 'Algorithmic bias means that bias and unfairness is built into the tools that we're using, and so the decisions that result will reflect that bias,' she said. 'When you combine algorithmic bias with automation bias – which is where humans are more likely to rely on the decisions of machines and almost replace their own thinking – there's a real risk that what we're actually creating is discrimination and bias in a form where it's so entrenched, we're perhaps not even aware that it's occurring.' The Human Rights Commission has consistently advocated for an AI act, bolstering existing legislation, including the Privacy Act, and rigorous testing for bias in AI tools. Finlay said the government should urgently establish new legislative guardrails. 'Bias testing and auditing, ensuring proper human oversight review, you [do] need those variety of different measures in place,' she said. There is growing evidence that there is bias in AI tools in Australia and overseas, in areas such as medicine and job recruitment. An Australian study published in May found job candidates being interviewed by AI recruiters risked being discriminated against if they spoke with an accent or were living with a disability. Ananda-Rajah, who was a medical doctor and researcher in AI before entering parliament, said it was important for AI tools to be trained on Australian data, or risk perpetuating overseas biases. While the government has stressed the need for protecting intellectual property, she warned that not opening up domestic data would mean Australia would be 'forever renting [AI] models from tech behemoths overseas' with no oversight or insight into their models or platforms. 'AI must be trained on as much data as possible from as wide a population as possible or it will amplify biases, potentially harming the very people it is meant to serve,' Ananda-Rajah said. 'We need to free our own data in order to train the models so that they better represent us. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion 'I'm keen to monetise content creators while freeing the data. I think we can present an alternative to the pillage and plunder of overseas.' Ananda-Rajah raised skin cancer screening by AI as an example where the tools used for testing have been shown to have algorithmic bias. Ananda-Rajah said the way to overcome any bias or discrimination against certain patients would be to train 'these models on as much diverse data from Australia as possible', with appropriate protections for sensitive data. Finlay said any release of Australian data should be done in a fair way but she believes the focus should be on regulation. 'Having diverse and representative data is absolutely a good thing … but it's only one part of the solution,' she said. 'We need to make sure that this technology is put in place in a way that's fair to everybody and actually recognises the work and the contributions that humans are making.' An AI expert at La Trobe university and former data researcher at an AI company, Judith Bishop, said freeing up more Australian data could help train AI tools more appropriately – while warning AI tools developed overseas using international data may not reflect the needs of Australians – but that it was a small part of the solution. 'We have to be careful that a system that was initially developed in other contexts is actually applicable for the [Australian] population, that we're not relying on US models which have been trained on US data,' Bishop said. The eSafety commissioner, Julie Inman Grant, is also concerned by the lack of transparency around the data AI tools use. In a statement, she said tech companies should be transparent about their training data, develop reporting tools and must use diverse, accurate and representative data in their products. 'The opacity of generative AI development and deployment is deeply problematic,' Inman Grant said. 'This raises important questions about the extent to which LLMs [large language models] could amplify, even accelerate, harmful biases – including narrow or harmful gender norms and racial prejudices. 'With the development of these systems concentrated in the hands of a few companies, there's a real risk that certain bodies of evidence, voices and perspectives could be overshadowed or sidelined in generative outputs.'
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Is Australia's worst-case housing scenario about to hit? Grim warning issued - despite Albanese's optimism
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has embraced the RBA's recent rate cut despite experts raising fears the decision will price more Aussies out of the property market. On Tuesday, the Reserve Bank of Australia decided to cut the cash rate for the third time this year, bringing it down 25 basis points to 3.60 per cent. Within an hour, Mr Albanese praised the decision as the result of his government's efforts to tackle the cost-of-living crisis. 'Interest rates have just been cut again. It will mean Australians paying less on their mortgages,' he said. 'We're working hard to help families with the cost of living. There's more to do and that's what we're focused on every day.' The announcement fell on deaf ears, with a number of Australians pointing out the decision will drive up demand for housing, ultimately pushing up prices. 'Historically, every time interest rates have been cut, home prices tend to increase,' Mr van Onselen told the Daily Mail. 'Cutting interest rates is a band-aid. It can increase your borrowing capacity and it can reduce your monthly mortgage payments - so if you already have a mortgage, it's great if you're looking to buy again. 'It can lower your payments on a new home loan because you've got to pay less monthly. 'But as that lower interest rate gets capitalised into higher prices, it then reduces affordability going ahead. So, it makes affordability structurally worse down the road.' Mr Van Onselen says the root cause of the housing crisis was rising immigration. 'We've grown by 8.7million people in less than 25 years - 46 per cent population growth - and you wonder why we don't have enough housing, we don't have enough infrastructure. 'We've run one of the biggest immigration programs in the world, and we haven't built enough houses, enough infrastructure, enough anything, to cope with it.' According to his analysis, if Australia's population growth slowed by 15 per cent over the next five years, the country would end up with a surplus of 40,000 homes. 'That was buried at the back of the NHSAC's report and what that tells you is that the solution to this mess is to cut immigration,' Mr van Onselen said. The Albanese government has committed to shoring up Australia's housing supply, with a target of 1.2 million new homes in the next five years. Meanwhile, the National Housing Supply and Affordability Council predicted in May the government will fall short of its goal by at least 250,000. Even if it were to reach its goal, Mr van Onselen said rising demand fuelled by government policy would keep accessibility out of reach. 'It's a government policy failure - we've got the supply issues but it won't get better until the government stops pumping demand with things like its five per cent deposit scheme and mass immigration,' he said. Despite the government's efforts to address the supply issue, NSHAC predicted Australia's housing shortage will worsen over the next five years. According to Loan Market, home loan pre-approvals spiked across the country last month as homebuyers scrambled to secure financing ahead of an expected rate cut. Loan pre-approvals were 53 per cent higher in July compared to the same time last year, with an 80 per cent spike in the Northern Territory and South Australia. Pre-approvals were up 79 per cent in Western Australia while the eastern states all recorded upticks of nearly 50 per cent. Loan Market chief executive David McQueen said a tight housing stock was forcing homebuyers to test their borrowing capacity ahead of the Spring rush. 'Market listings are sitting at a three-year low, which is making it tough for buyers,' Mr McQueen said. 'They're looking for every edge and that starts with knowing exactly what they can borrow and afford to repay. 'Buyers want to walk into an auction with confidence or put forward strong private treaty terms that help them stand out.'
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
David Koch 'makes move to SACK ex-Channel Nine star from AFL club' after he was accused of standing by disturbing conspiracy theories
Power chairman David Koch is reportedly set to make a 'negative call' on board member and premiership captain Warren Tredrea following disturbing comments made by a guest on his podcast. Tredrea's position has reportedly been under threat while Port performs a 'formal governance review' into the 46-year-old. Port's move comes after The Jewish Council of Australia objected to an Instagram post from Tredrea related to comments about Israel from a guest on the retired footballer's Ballsy Show podcast. '(The council) is deeply disturbed by the amplification of far-right ... conspiracy theories in this Instagram post and podcast episode,' executive officer Max Kaiser said in a statement. On Tuesday night, AFL journalist Caroline Wilson gave an update on the drama at Port Adelaide, suggesting that the board will ultimately sack Tredrea. 'David Koch and his team, I'm told, has decided... they just want to dot every i and cross every t before they make what I believe will be a negative call on Warren Tredrea's ability to serve on that board,' Wilson said on Seven's The Agenda Setters. 'That is my belief, but no one at the board will talk to me about this.' Last month, Koch said the club maintained 'comprehensive governance standards'. 'Directors and officials of the club are entitled to their personal views, however there are concerns that recent content published is in breach of these standards,' Koch said in a statement. 'The club is committed to upholding the professional standards our members, partners and the community expect and deserve.' In a podcast segment posted to Tredrea's social media, he hosted a man claiming to be a former soldier, who put forward the conspiracy theories. Tredrea wrote a response to public criticisms on his own Instagram account about the issue. 'I unequivocally condemn war and genocide, and seek only to share other perspectives of what has been a very one-way reported narrative in the mainstream media,' he wrote. 'I am not in any way, shape, or form, an anti-Semite, and consider it defamatory for anyone to accuse me as such. Tredrea, who retired as a player in 2010, is Port's all-time leading goalkicker and captained the team to the 2004 AFL premiership 'The purpose of my podcast has been not to shine a light on my own personal views and opinions, but rather to provide a platform for others to present their views and opinions in an unfiltered forum.' Tredrea and Koch have butted heads in the past, with the former champion centre half forward branding Port coach Ken Hinkley's position 'untenable' in 2023 after poor performances. Koch hit back by claiming Tredrea only said that because he has 'a new podcast to promote', prompting a furious response. 'I can't ignore multiple times now he's gaslighting,' Tredrea shot back on radio station FIVEaa. 'When I went to the board he told me - not to me - that 'you need to learn about Port Adelaide'. 'I was like, OK, I'll let that go, but then yesterday he's said it's to get podcast downloads. 'Telling people to get involved in the club and learn about the club, and it's for a podcast, give us a spell.' Tredrea added that he and Koch haven't spoken for years and insisted he wanted to join the board to support the club - but said he knew he might not be wanted because 'I've been outspoken'. Tredrea is revered and considered among Port's greatest AFL players. He is a four-time All Australian and captained the club to their only premiership in 2004. Tredrea moved into the media in Adelaide after a decorated 255-game playing career between 1997 and 2010. He was dismissed in 2021 for refusing the company's Covid vaccine edict and lost a court appeal seeking $6million in lost wages. The case was dismissed in the Federal Court last year after Nine argued his contract was not up for renewal.
