Ex-Marist brother sexually abused pupil 40 years ago
Cyril Alfred Hughes, 82, was found guilty on Friday of two counts of the since repealed legislation of homosexual intercourse between a teacher and a pupil.
The alleged victim, who cannot be legally named, was sexually abused in Hughes' office at Marist Brothers College in western Sydney in 1985.
Hughes - who was known as Brother Thomas - was found unfit to stand trial in the Parramatta District Court in April because of a constellation of health conditions including non-Hodgkin lymphoma, chronic back pain and kidney failure.
At a three-week special hearing, crown prosecutor Heidi Cantor said the former teacher's conduct escalated from touching - including at a school sports carnival - to massaging the boy's intimate parts and more.
Defence barrister Bill Neild SC said the alleged abuse never occurred, accusing the victim of fabricating his claims for financial gain.
The allegations were also unreliable, having been infected by a controversial therapy called eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing which was known to create false memories, the court was told.
Judge Karen Robinson on Friday found the day student's memories regarding the rape were reliable even though he could not remember specific details of what happened.
"I have no difficulty finding the complainant to have been a forthright and honest witness," she said.
But Hughes was found not guilty of two further counts of indecent assault where he allegedly touched the boy's genitals between November 1982 and February 1984.
The judge found that this claimed abuse stemmed from memories "returning" to him in more detail during a breakdown in 2017.
She said she could not be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the memories were not a "repressed" memory which could be false.
The alleged indecent assault was said to have occurred in the school's teacher's lounge.
However, this lounge was officially opened in March 1984, after the period of the claimed abuse.
The victim watched silently in court as judgment was handed down and declined to comment afterwards.
Hughes did not say anything outside court but shielded his face with a green folder as he left flanked by his solicitor Greg Walsh and a support person.
The 82-year-old will face a sentence hearing on November 7.
1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732)
National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028
A former high school student's recollection of historical molestation by a Catholic brother remained uninfected by a later mental breakdown, a judge has found.
Cyril Alfred Hughes, 82, was found guilty on Friday of two counts of the since repealed legislation of homosexual intercourse between a teacher and a pupil.
The alleged victim, who cannot be legally named, was sexually abused in Hughes' office at Marist Brothers College in western Sydney in 1985.
Hughes - who was known as Brother Thomas - was found unfit to stand trial in the Parramatta District Court in April because of a constellation of health conditions including non-Hodgkin lymphoma, chronic back pain and kidney failure.
At a three-week special hearing, crown prosecutor Heidi Cantor said the former teacher's conduct escalated from touching - including at a school sports carnival - to massaging the boy's intimate parts and more.
Defence barrister Bill Neild SC said the alleged abuse never occurred, accusing the victim of fabricating his claims for financial gain.
The allegations were also unreliable, having been infected by a controversial therapy called eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing which was known to create false memories, the court was told.
Judge Karen Robinson on Friday found the day student's memories regarding the rape were reliable even though he could not remember specific details of what happened.
"I have no difficulty finding the complainant to have been a forthright and honest witness," she said.
But Hughes was found not guilty of two further counts of indecent assault where he allegedly touched the boy's genitals between November 1982 and February 1984.
The judge found that this claimed abuse stemmed from memories "returning" to him in more detail during a breakdown in 2017.
She said she could not be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the memories were not a "repressed" memory which could be false.
The alleged indecent assault was said to have occurred in the school's teacher's lounge.
However, this lounge was officially opened in March 1984, after the period of the claimed abuse.
The victim watched silently in court as judgment was handed down and declined to comment afterwards.
Hughes did not say anything outside court but shielded his face with a green folder as he left flanked by his solicitor Greg Walsh and a support person.
The 82-year-old will face a sentence hearing on November 7.
1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732)
National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028
A former high school student's recollection of historical molestation by a Catholic brother remained uninfected by a later mental breakdown, a judge has found.
Cyril Alfred Hughes, 82, was found guilty on Friday of two counts of the since repealed legislation of homosexual intercourse between a teacher and a pupil.
The alleged victim, who cannot be legally named, was sexually abused in Hughes' office at Marist Brothers College in western Sydney in 1985.
Hughes - who was known as Brother Thomas - was found unfit to stand trial in the Parramatta District Court in April because of a constellation of health conditions including non-Hodgkin lymphoma, chronic back pain and kidney failure.
At a three-week special hearing, crown prosecutor Heidi Cantor said the former teacher's conduct escalated from touching - including at a school sports carnival - to massaging the boy's intimate parts and more.
Defence barrister Bill Neild SC said the alleged abuse never occurred, accusing the victim of fabricating his claims for financial gain.
The allegations were also unreliable, having been infected by a controversial therapy called eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing which was known to create false memories, the court was told.
Judge Karen Robinson on Friday found the day student's memories regarding the rape were reliable even though he could not remember specific details of what happened.
"I have no difficulty finding the complainant to have been a forthright and honest witness," she said.
But Hughes was found not guilty of two further counts of indecent assault where he allegedly touched the boy's genitals between November 1982 and February 1984.
The judge found that this claimed abuse stemmed from memories "returning" to him in more detail during a breakdown in 2017.
She said she could not be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the memories were not a "repressed" memory which could be false.
The alleged indecent assault was said to have occurred in the school's teacher's lounge.
However, this lounge was officially opened in March 1984, after the period of the claimed abuse.
The victim watched silently in court as judgment was handed down and declined to comment afterwards.
Hughes did not say anything outside court but shielded his face with a green folder as he left flanked by his solicitor Greg Walsh and a support person.
The 82-year-old will face a sentence hearing on November 7.
1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732)
National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028
A former high school student's recollection of historical molestation by a Catholic brother remained uninfected by a later mental breakdown, a judge has found.
Cyril Alfred Hughes, 82, was found guilty on Friday of two counts of the since repealed legislation of homosexual intercourse between a teacher and a pupil.
The alleged victim, who cannot be legally named, was sexually abused in Hughes' office at Marist Brothers College in western Sydney in 1985.
Hughes - who was known as Brother Thomas - was found unfit to stand trial in the Parramatta District Court in April because of a constellation of health conditions including non-Hodgkin lymphoma, chronic back pain and kidney failure.
At a three-week special hearing, crown prosecutor Heidi Cantor said the former teacher's conduct escalated from touching - including at a school sports carnival - to massaging the boy's intimate parts and more.
Defence barrister Bill Neild SC said the alleged abuse never occurred, accusing the victim of fabricating his claims for financial gain.
The allegations were also unreliable, having been infected by a controversial therapy called eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing which was known to create false memories, the court was told.
Judge Karen Robinson on Friday found the day student's memories regarding the rape were reliable even though he could not remember specific details of what happened.
"I have no difficulty finding the complainant to have been a forthright and honest witness," she said.
But Hughes was found not guilty of two further counts of indecent assault where he allegedly touched the boy's genitals between November 1982 and February 1984.
The judge found that this claimed abuse stemmed from memories "returning" to him in more detail during a breakdown in 2017.
She said she could not be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the memories were not a "repressed" memory which could be false.
The alleged indecent assault was said to have occurred in the school's teacher's lounge.
However, this lounge was officially opened in March 1984, after the period of the claimed abuse.
The victim watched silently in court as judgment was handed down and declined to comment afterwards.
Hughes did not say anything outside court but shielded his face with a green folder as he left flanked by his solicitor Greg Walsh and a support person.
The 82-year-old will face a sentence hearing on November 7.
1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732)
National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
2 days ago
- Perth Now
School principal's historical sexual abuse appeal fails
A former school principal and Catholic brother has been ordered to return to prison after his child sexual abuse conviction appeal was dismissed. Desmond Gregory Mackrell was convicted in March by a Queensland District Court jury of repeated sexual conduct with a child and two counts of carnal knowledge against a boy aged between 13 and 15. Mackrell was sentenced to seven years' imprisonment but was later granted bail after launching his appeal. The Queensland Court of Appeal on Tuesday dismissed Mackrell's bid to overturn his convictions. Mackrell committed the offences in his office and a school toilet in the early 1980s. In one of the incidents Mackrell held the boy down while he was sexually assaulted by another Catholic brother. Mackrell's convictions were unreasonable and could not be supported by the evidence, Appeal Justices Debra Mullins, Thomas Bradley and Philip Morrison were told at hearing in July. Barrister Tim Ryan, appearing for Mackrell, conceded that there was no issue as to the credibility of the evidence given by the man who testified he was abused as a child. He said the real issue was the reliability of that evidence. Mr Ryan said the man's various memories of sexual acts committed by Mackrell were no more than "just dreams and nightmares". At trial, the man agreed he "began having shards of memory that began to develop and piece together" following periods of worsening anxiety in 2019. Justice Morrison said, in a ruling supported by the other two justices, that there were reasons to doubt the reliability of the man's evidence but it was still open to the jury to find Mackrell guilty, "The jury's advantage in seeing and hearing the evidence is capable of resolving that doubt, and therefore no miscarriage of justice has occurred," Justice Morrison said. "The jury heard and saw the (victim) over two days of evidence, and under cross-examination about matters which, they would accept, were extremely painful for the (man) to recall and talk about." The justices issued a warrant for Mackrell's apprehension that would only be executed if necessary after five business days. 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028 Lifeline 13 11 14 Kids Helpline 1800 55 1800 (for people aged 5 to 25)
The Advertiser
5 days ago
- The Advertiser
Ex-Marist brother sexually abused pupil 40 years ago
A former high school student's recollection of historical molestation by a Catholic brother remained uninfected by a later mental breakdown, a judge has found. Cyril Alfred Hughes, 82, was found guilty on Friday of two counts of the since repealed legislation of homosexual intercourse between a teacher and a pupil. The alleged victim, who cannot be legally named, was sexually abused in Hughes' office at Marist Brothers College in western Sydney in 1985. Hughes - who was known as Brother Thomas - was found unfit to stand trial in the Parramatta District Court in April because of a constellation of health conditions including non-Hodgkin lymphoma, chronic back pain and kidney failure. At a three-week special hearing, crown prosecutor Heidi Cantor said the former teacher's conduct escalated from touching - including at a school sports carnival - to massaging the boy's intimate parts and more. Defence barrister Bill Neild SC said the alleged abuse never occurred, accusing the victim of fabricating his claims for financial gain. The allegations were also unreliable, having been infected by a controversial therapy called eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing which was known to create false memories, the court was told. Judge Karen Robinson on Friday found the day student's memories regarding the rape were reliable even though he could not remember specific details of what happened. "I have no difficulty finding the complainant to have been a forthright and honest witness," she said. But Hughes was found not guilty of two further counts of indecent assault where he allegedly touched the boy's genitals between November 1982 and February 1984. The judge found that this claimed abuse stemmed from memories "returning" to him in more detail during a breakdown in 2017. She said she could not be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the memories were not a "repressed" memory which could be false. The alleged indecent assault was said to have occurred in the school's teacher's lounge. However, this lounge was officially opened in March 1984, after the period of the claimed abuse. The victim watched silently in court as judgment was handed down and declined to comment afterwards. Hughes did not say anything outside court but shielded his face with a green folder as he left flanked by his solicitor Greg Walsh and a support person. The 82-year-old will face a sentence hearing on November 7. 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028 A former high school student's recollection of historical molestation by a Catholic brother remained uninfected by a later mental breakdown, a judge has found. Cyril Alfred Hughes, 82, was found guilty on Friday of two counts of the since repealed legislation of homosexual intercourse between a teacher and a pupil. The alleged victim, who cannot be legally named, was sexually abused in Hughes' office at Marist Brothers College in western Sydney in 1985. Hughes - who was known as Brother Thomas - was found unfit to stand trial in the Parramatta District Court in April because of a constellation of health conditions including non-Hodgkin lymphoma, chronic back pain and kidney failure. At a three-week special hearing, crown prosecutor Heidi Cantor said the former teacher's conduct escalated from touching - including at a school sports carnival - to massaging the boy's intimate parts and more. Defence barrister Bill Neild SC said the alleged abuse never occurred, accusing the victim of fabricating his claims for financial gain. The allegations were also unreliable, having been infected by a controversial therapy called eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing which was known to create false memories, the court was told. Judge Karen Robinson on Friday found the day student's memories regarding the rape were reliable even though he could not remember specific details of what happened. "I have no difficulty finding the complainant to have been a forthright and honest witness," she said. But Hughes was found not guilty of two further counts of indecent assault where he allegedly touched the boy's genitals between November 1982 and February 1984. The judge found that this claimed abuse stemmed from memories "returning" to him in more detail during a breakdown in 2017. She said she could not be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the memories were not a "repressed" memory which could be false. The alleged indecent assault was said to have occurred in the school's teacher's lounge. However, this lounge was officially opened in March 1984, after the period of the claimed abuse. The victim watched silently in court as judgment was handed down and declined to comment afterwards. Hughes did not say anything outside court but shielded his face with a green folder as he left flanked by his solicitor Greg Walsh and a support person. The 82-year-old will face a sentence hearing on November 7. 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028 A former high school student's recollection of historical molestation by a Catholic brother remained uninfected by a later mental breakdown, a judge has found. Cyril Alfred Hughes, 82, was found guilty on Friday of two counts of the since repealed legislation of homosexual intercourse between a teacher and a pupil. The alleged victim, who cannot be legally named, was sexually abused in Hughes' office at Marist Brothers College in western Sydney in 1985. Hughes - who was known as Brother Thomas - was found unfit to stand trial in the Parramatta District Court in April because of a constellation of health conditions including non-Hodgkin lymphoma, chronic back pain and kidney failure. At a three-week special hearing, crown prosecutor Heidi Cantor said the former teacher's conduct escalated from touching - including at a school sports carnival - to massaging the boy's intimate parts and more. Defence barrister Bill Neild SC said the alleged abuse never occurred, accusing the victim of fabricating his claims for financial gain. The allegations were also unreliable, having been infected by a controversial therapy called eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing which was known to create false memories, the court was told. Judge Karen Robinson on Friday found the day student's memories regarding the rape were reliable even though he could not remember specific details of what happened. "I have no difficulty finding the complainant to have been a forthright and honest witness," she said. But Hughes was found not guilty of two further counts of indecent assault where he allegedly touched the boy's genitals between November 1982 and February 1984. The judge found that this claimed abuse stemmed from memories "returning" to him in more detail during a breakdown in 2017. She said she could not be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the memories were not a "repressed" memory which could be false. The alleged indecent assault was said to have occurred in the school's teacher's lounge. However, this lounge was officially opened in March 1984, after the period of the claimed abuse. The victim watched silently in court as judgment was handed down and declined to comment afterwards. Hughes did not say anything outside court but shielded his face with a green folder as he left flanked by his solicitor Greg Walsh and a support person. The 82-year-old will face a sentence hearing on November 7. 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028 A former high school student's recollection of historical molestation by a Catholic brother remained uninfected by a later mental breakdown, a judge has found. Cyril Alfred Hughes, 82, was found guilty on Friday of two counts of the since repealed legislation of homosexual intercourse between a teacher and a pupil. The alleged victim, who cannot be legally named, was sexually abused in Hughes' office at Marist Brothers College in western Sydney in 1985. Hughes - who was known as Brother Thomas - was found unfit to stand trial in the Parramatta District Court in April because of a constellation of health conditions including non-Hodgkin lymphoma, chronic back pain and kidney failure. At a three-week special hearing, crown prosecutor Heidi Cantor said the former teacher's conduct escalated from touching - including at a school sports carnival - to massaging the boy's intimate parts and more. Defence barrister Bill Neild SC said the alleged abuse never occurred, accusing the victim of fabricating his claims for financial gain. The allegations were also unreliable, having been infected by a controversial therapy called eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing which was known to create false memories, the court was told. Judge Karen Robinson on Friday found the day student's memories regarding the rape were reliable even though he could not remember specific details of what happened. "I have no difficulty finding the complainant to have been a forthright and honest witness," she said. But Hughes was found not guilty of two further counts of indecent assault where he allegedly touched the boy's genitals between November 1982 and February 1984. The judge found that this claimed abuse stemmed from memories "returning" to him in more detail during a breakdown in 2017. She said she could not be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the memories were not a "repressed" memory which could be false. The alleged indecent assault was said to have occurred in the school's teacher's lounge. However, this lounge was officially opened in March 1984, after the period of the claimed abuse. The victim watched silently in court as judgment was handed down and declined to comment afterwards. Hughes did not say anything outside court but shielded his face with a green folder as he left flanked by his solicitor Greg Walsh and a support person. The 82-year-old will face a sentence hearing on November 7. 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) National Sexual Abuse and Redress Support Service 1800 211 028
7NEWS
5 days ago
- 7NEWS
Marist brother Cyril Alfred Hughes found guilty of sexually abusing pupil 40 years ago at Marist Brothers College in Western Sydney
A former high school student's recollection of historical molestation by a Catholic brother remained uninfected by a later mental breakdown, a judge has found. Cyril Alfred Hughes, 82, was found guilty on Friday of two counts of the since repealed legislation of homosexual intercourse between a teacher and a pupil. The alleged victim, who cannot be legally named, was sexually abused in Hughes' office at Marist Brothers College in Western Sydney in 1985. Hughes — who was known as Brother Thomas — was found unfit to stand trial in the Parramatta District Court in April because of a constellation of health conditions including non-Hodgkin lymphoma, chronic back pain and kidney failure. At a three-week special hearing, crown prosecutor Heidi Cantor said the former teacher's conduct escalated from touching — including at a school sports carnival — to massaging the boy's intimate parts and more. Defence barrister Bill Neild SC said the alleged abuse never occurred, accusing the victim of fabricating his claims for financial gain. The allegations were also unreliable, having been infected by a controversial therapy called eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing which was known to create false memories, the court was told. Judge Karen Robinson on Friday found the day student's memories regarding the rape were reliable, even though he could not remember specific details of what happened. 'I have no difficulty finding the complainant to have been a forthright and honest witness,' she said. But Hughes was found not guilty of two further counts of indecent assault, where he allegedly touched the boy's genitals between November 1982 and February 1984. The judge found that this claimed abuse stemmed from memories 'returning' to him in more detail during a breakdown in 2017. She said she could not be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the memories were not a 'repressed' memory, which could be false. The alleged indecent assault was said to have occurred in the school's teacher's lounge. However, this lounge was officially opened in March 1984, after the period of the claimed abuse. The victim watched silently in court as judgment was handed down and declined to comment afterwards. Hughes did not say anything outside court but shielded his face with a green folder as he left flanked by his solicitor Greg Walsh and a support person. The 82-year-old will face a sentence hearing on November 7.
