What does it mean to be South African? Navigating identity in a complex democracy
1. Defining South Africanness: A contested and plural concept
The webinar highlighted that defining 'South Africanness' is contested terrain, especially 30 years into democracy. Unlike monocultural countries, South Africa's identity is plural and layered, based on multiple identities and an acceptance of difference rather than a single shared culture, language or race.
2. The Constitution as a 'civic religion'
While South Africa boasts diverse cultures and languages, the Constitution and its democratic institutions serve as a common civic identity, a 'civic religion' that binds citizens together. It's seen as a crucial pillar for a country with a deeply divided past.
3. Beyond Western models of nationhood
Traditional Western models of nationhood, often based on shared culture or language, don't fully apply to South Africa. The country's identity must be more embracing, incorporating the best elements of its diverse past, present, histories and cultures.
4. Addressing xenophobia and exclusion
A critical concern raised is the potential for national identity to be used for exclusion, leading to xenophobia and other forms of discrimination. The discussion emphasised the need for a shared commitment and recognition of interdependence to foster a functional constitutional democracy.
5. The role of, and pressure on, the Constitution
The Constitution, with its core values of human dignity, equality and freedom, is an aspiration. However, it faces immense pressure as visible inequalities persist, leading some to question whether these values are truly shared or merely promises unfulfilled. The document itself cannot act; it is about how people and institutions behave.
6. Transforming individual identity towards a broader South Africanness
A significant challenge is to transform individual, narrow self-identities (e.g. based on race or ethnicity) into a broader South African identity. This requires more engagement in families, schools, workplaces and communities to foster a sense that one's specific group identity is just a piece of a larger South Africanness.
7. Cultivating empathy and solidarity across difference
A crucial missing element in South Africa's nation-building project is empathy and solidarity across different groups. People tend to have empathy for those similar to them, but extending this compassion to those who 'don't look like you' is vital for a stronger common South Africanness. This needs to be actively taught and nurtured, starting in schools.
8. The peril of politicised identity
The country's national identity is deeply intertwined with politics. When governance is poor, corrupt or incompetent, or when politicians exploit divisions for votes, it undermines the common South African project. There is a strong call for consequences for politicians who sow division.
9. Reimagining commemorations and recognising diverse contributions
Commemorative days and national memory-making need to move beyond focusing solely on politicians or political parties. There's a strong need to memorialise the diversity of South African society, including forgotten and excluded individuals, artists, institution builders and sports stars, celebrating a broader range of contributions to the nation.
10. The importance of recognising and refining indigenous identities
While recognising and bringing back indigenous identities erased by apartheid is crucial, it is equally important to critically evaluate and remove anti-democratic or anti-constitutional elements within these identities (e.g. patriarchy). The goal is to integrate the valuable aspects of indigenous identities with the constitutional value of equality.
The discussion highlighted the ongoing journey of defining and strengthening South Africa's identity, emphasising the complexities of diversity, the role of foundational values and the need for active engagement from all citizens. DM
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
36 minutes ago
- IOL News
South Africa eyes diversification as jobs exodus looms over 30% US import tariffs
Zane Dangor, the Director-General (DG) of the Department of International Relations and Cooperation (Dirco), speaking with Simphiwe Hamilton, the director-general of the Department of Trade, Industry and Competition (the dtic) during a press briefing led by Ministers Ronald Lamola and Parks Tau on the reciprocal US tariffs. Image: GCIS Banele Ginidza About 30 000 jobs in various sectors are likely to be impacted by the unilateral 30% import tariffs to be imposed by the United States on South African products, which is set to come into effect before the end of this week. This was announced on Monday as the government seeks to craft an export diversification strategy leaning heavily towards China's R20 billion market through the offered China-Africa Trade partnership and a special industrialisation memorandum of understanding exclusively with South Africa. Simphiwe Hamilton, the director-general of the Department of Trade, Industry and Competition (the dtic), confirmed that thousands of jobs were on the line in a variety of industries that export goods to the US market. 'We base this on the ongoing consultation that we have with all the sectors of the economy, from automotive to agriculture, and all the other sectors that are going to be affected, and at this stage, we are sitting at approximately 30 000 jobs that could be affected by this,' Hamilton said. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Next Stay Close ✕ The dtic and the Department of International Relations and Cooperation (Dirco) said the 20% increase on top of the basic 10% tariff may shave off 0.2% of South Africa's economic growth, with the reduction in growth depending on SA's ability to find alternative markets. Trade Minister Parks Tau said it was mildly comforting that 35% of SA exports remained exempted from the tariffs with the exceptions published in the previous US Executive Order to remain in force. The exceptions cover products such as copper, pharmaceuticals, semi-conductors, lumber articles, certain critical minerals, stainless steel scrap, energy and energy products. Tau said the impact of the tariff was still subject of scrutiny with various conclusions, citing AgriCulture South Africa reporting an understated impact than initially modelled. "Drawing a straight line is a mistake we all have been making over the past few months when we are saying the auto sector is going to be affected and can't export to the US market," Tau said. "But when you drill down to the detail, most of the Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) in the country do not go into the US market. So you have to go to the OEM that goes into the US market to determine what percentage of products [is exported to the US] to then determine impact. Last month, US President Donald Trump stated that the 30% tariff was "necessary to correct the many years of South Africa's Tariff, and Non Tariff, Policies and Trade Barriers," blaming Pretoria for what he called "unsustainable Trade Deficits against the United States." However, Tau and Dirco Minister Ronald Lamola said the calculation of US-SA "trade deficit" ignored the substantial US trade surplus in services, as well as the complementary nature of the bilateral trade and investment relations between the two countries. "South African exports do not compete with US producers and do not pose a threat to the US industry," they said in a joint statement. As a result, the government has embarked on the diversification of markets and strengthening trade and investment partnerships with various trade partners, targeting markets across Africa, as well as in Asia, Europe, Middle East, and Americas. "Our announcement on the Clean Trade and Investment Partnership with the European Union in March has unlocked a R90 Billion Investment Package that has been initially committed," read the statement. "This Clean Trade and Investment Partnership also aims to unlock new market access opportunities for South Africa, including the export of Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF) by Sasol and the exports of hybrids and Electric Vehicles. "While facing global trade challenges, South Africa is proactively building a more resilient agricultural sector. We've made significant progress in opening up vast new markets like China and Thailand, securing vital protocols for products like citrus and others." The government said that with China alone being a $200bn market, South Africa was confidently expanding its reach and creating new opportunities for agricultural producers. "We're making significant inroads into new, high-growth markets across Asia and the Middle East, including the UAE, Qatar, and Saudi Arabia. We have also developed a number of Trade and Investment Packages with a number of countries, including Japan that aim to unlock new market access opportunities," it said. "While the current measures present challenges, it also presents opportunities to build and accelerate the implementation of the African Continental Free Trade Agreement and to develop new partnerships in markets that have remained untapped, including ASEAN and Turkiye." BUSINESS REPORT
Daily Maverick
4 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
What does it mean to be South African? Navigating identity in a complex democracy
In a Daily Maverick webinar asking 'What does it mean to be South African?', professors William Gumede and Pierre de Vos joined Zukiswa Pikoli to delve into identity, citizenship and inclusion 30 years into South Africa's democracy. Here are 10 takeaways. 1. Defining South Africanness: A contested and plural concept The webinar highlighted that defining 'South Africanness' is contested terrain, especially 30 years into democracy. Unlike monocultural countries, South Africa's identity is plural and layered, based on multiple identities and an acceptance of difference rather than a single shared culture, language or race. 2. The Constitution as a 'civic religion' While South Africa boasts diverse cultures and languages, the Constitution and its democratic institutions serve as a common civic identity, a 'civic religion' that binds citizens together. It's seen as a crucial pillar for a country with a deeply divided past. 3. Beyond Western models of nationhood Traditional Western models of nationhood, often based on shared culture or language, don't fully apply to South Africa. The country's identity must be more embracing, incorporating the best elements of its diverse past, present, histories and cultures. 4. Addressing xenophobia and exclusion A critical concern raised is the potential for national identity to be used for exclusion, leading to xenophobia and other forms of discrimination. The discussion emphasised the need for a shared commitment and recognition of interdependence to foster a functional constitutional democracy. 5. The role of, and pressure on, the Constitution The Constitution, with its core values of human dignity, equality and freedom, is an aspiration. However, it faces immense pressure as visible inequalities persist, leading some to question whether these values are truly shared or merely promises unfulfilled. The document itself cannot act; it is about how people and institutions behave. 6. Transforming individual identity towards a broader South Africanness A significant challenge is to transform individual, narrow self-identities (e.g. based on race or ethnicity) into a broader South African identity. This requires more engagement in families, schools, workplaces and communities to foster a sense that one's specific group identity is just a piece of a larger South Africanness. 7. Cultivating empathy and solidarity across difference A crucial missing element in South Africa's nation-building project is empathy and solidarity across different groups. People tend to have empathy for those similar to them, but extending this compassion to those who 'don't look like you' is vital for a stronger common South Africanness. This needs to be actively taught and nurtured, starting in schools. 8. The peril of politicised identity The country's national identity is deeply intertwined with politics. When governance is poor, corrupt or incompetent, or when politicians exploit divisions for votes, it undermines the common South African project. There is a strong call for consequences for politicians who sow division. 9. Reimagining commemorations and recognising diverse contributions Commemorative days and national memory-making need to move beyond focusing solely on politicians or political parties. There's a strong need to memorialise the diversity of South African society, including forgotten and excluded individuals, artists, institution builders and sports stars, celebrating a broader range of contributions to the nation. 10. The importance of recognising and refining indigenous identities While recognising and bringing back indigenous identities erased by apartheid is crucial, it is equally important to critically evaluate and remove anti-democratic or anti-constitutional elements within these identities (e.g. patriarchy). The goal is to integrate the valuable aspects of indigenous identities with the constitutional value of equality. The discussion highlighted the ongoing journey of defining and strengthening South Africa's identity, emphasising the complexities of diversity, the role of foundational values and the need for active engagement from all citizens. DM
Daily Maverick
4 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
GNU must take blame for not acting to avert imposition of Trump's exorbitant tariffs
The recent decision by US President Donald Trump to increase tariffs from 10% to 30% on most South African imports, effective this past Friday, 1 August 2025, is a damning indictment of our foreign policy shortcomings. At the heart of this unfolding crisis is the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa), which for nearly 25 years has given South African goods duty-free access to US markets. In 2023, more than $3-billion worth of exports flowed to the US under Agoa, sustaining jobs and livelihoods in key industries such as automotive manufacturing, agriculture, and mining. It's difficult to overstate just how beneficial Agoa has been. The US is South Africa's second-largest export market, and Agoa alone accounts for more than $2-billion in exports annually. Entire value chains are built on this preferential access. This has resulted in tens of thousands of jobs created and maintained in export-related industries, especially in the automotive and agricultural sectors. Yet, what once felt like abstract diplomatic tensions have now resulted in exorbitant tariff hikes that could wipe out margins for exporters and put thousands of jobs at risk across key sectors — from citrus and wine to auto manufacturing and metals. While some may point fingers at an increasingly protectionist White House, the Government of National Unity (GNU) must accept responsibility for what is in most parts a self-inflicted wound. Those in the GNU say that jobs and the economy are their number one priority. But when it came to protecting one of our largest export markets and tens of thousands of South African jobs, they sat on their hands and watched the tariffs roll in. This diplomatic misstep will be measured in job losses, declining export revenue, and dwindling investor confidence. Instead of strategic engagement, disarray ensued. Civil society organisations like AfriForum and Solidarity secured high-level meetings in Washington, while our official diplomatic presence remained directionless. Undermining national trade posture Even the Democratic Alliance was accused of undermining our national trade posture through uncoordinated political freelancing, a move that seemingly cost MP Emma Powell her role as the DA's International Relations spokesperson. At the core of Washington's growing frustration is South Africa's erratic and often contradictory foreign policy. Despite claiming to be non-aligned, our government has taken deliberate steps that signal the opposite. The ANC's hosting of senior Hamas representatives in Pretoria, Minister Naledi Pandor's infamous meeting with then Iranian president Ebrahim Raisi, and South Africa's ambiguous stance on Russia's war in Ukraine have all sent provocative messages that clash with global democratic norms. These actions carry real-world consequences, as this latest tariff decision makes painfully clear. Even under the more diplomatic Biden administration, South Africa failed to rebuild trust. We did not use the opportunity to engage, negotiate or reassure. And now, under a more transactional Trump presidency, patience has run out. What is clear is that South Africa urgently needs a foreign policy rooted in clear principles and strategic interests, instead of nostalgia and ideology. Our diplomacy must be led by the state, above party politics, and laser focused on three core objectives: expanding trade and economic growth, defending human rights, and advancing democracy on the continent and beyond. The current bipolar approach, with mixed signals from different actors, is unsustainable and deeply damaging. A government-led, coherent strategy to stabilise and grow our trade relationship with the US is now mission-critical. This strategy must include five immediate actions: South Africa must reassert official leadership in managing our engagement with Washington. Splinter groups and political parties must refrain from back-channelling for narrow political gain. Trade policy is national policy. South Africa must speak with one clear, credible, and united voice. Our government must directly engage with the US Congress, which holds immense sway over trade legislation. Lawmakers on Capitol Hill need to hear not just about Agoa's benefits for South Africa, but for the US too. More than 500,000 American jobs are tied to trade with us. We should use that as leverage. South Africa must table a credible trade and investment plan that showcases the mutual benefits of partnership. Priority sectors like automotive exports (valued at more than $1.2-billion annually), citrus, wine, metals and green technology must be at the forefront. We must position ourselves as a reliable partner for US capital, technology, and innovation as America eyes new partners in the global energy transition. A full economic risk assessment must be urgently commissioned to measure the impact of the proposed tariffs on jobs and industry. Such a study would not only quantify the damage, but guide our negotiating position and enable smarter policy responses, including sector-specific relief or adjustment mechanisms. Perhaps most urgently, we must appoint a capable and credible ambassador to Washington. This needs to be someone who understands both diplomacy and economics. The job now requires high-stakes negotiations to restore market confidence and protect jobs. That seat has remained vacant or ineffective for far too long. The truth is that South Africa's foreign policy has long lacked a future-focused economic dimension. It is too often discussed not in terms of trade, growth or a digital future, but in the context of how liberation movements can remain in power. This mindset has locked us into outdated alliances, including with authoritarian regimes that are neither democratic nor innovative. Meanwhile, we've neglected crucial relationships with long-standing partners like the US, and failed to appoint ambassadors, attend key forums or secure investment guarantees. What is clear is that we cannot afford to respond with more muddled messages, delayed decisions and ideological posturing. If we do not act with clarity, urgency and humility, we risk permanently losing one of our most important trade relationships. Now more than ever, our foreign policy must serve South Africa's economic interests. Jobs, industries and future growth hang in the balance. DM
