Daulton Varsho reveals how Blue Jays teammate stole his jersey number

National Post

2 days ago

Daulton Varsho is known to rob opposing players of hits with his stellar play in the outfield, but it was the Gold Glover who fell victim to a bit of locker-room theft.
Article content
It wasn't a valuable possession that went missing this past spring, however. It was his jersey number.
Article content
Article content
During an appearance on Wednesday's episode of the 6ix Inning Stretch podcast, Varsho shared the story between his impromptu number switch from No. 25 – which he wore for his first two years in Toronto – to No. 5 this season and how it all went down.
Article content
Article content
Varsho told co-hosts Lindsay Dunn and Whit Merrifield – a former Blue Jays all-star – that Anthony Santander surprised him with the news on the day of the slugger's introductory press conference, after having assured him the day before that every was cool.
Article content
Article content
'He came up to me and was like, 'Hey, like I'm not going to take 25, I'm going to take this number,'' Varsho said, adding that he told Santander, 'If you want it, like you can take it, but obviously we'll figure out something for it.'
Article content
Article content
Article content
However, it turned out that Santander was pretty quick to change his mind.
Article content
Article content
'The next day, he had his press conference, he's like, 'Hey, I'm taking your number.' I was like, 'Oh … OK,'' Varsho explained. 'The clubhouse manager, he's like, 'Hey, we need to figure out what your number is, Tony's going to take 25.''
Article content
Caught off guard by the situation, Varsho told him, 'OK, like I guess I'll take No. 5.'
Article content
Varsho did share that Santander has been asking him since then what the outfielder would like in return for the number.
Article content
'He got me something the week before I got back (from injury). He was down in Florida, and he said he got me something,' Varsho said. 'I don't know what it is yet, but we'll see.'
Article content
Merrifield then joked about what he would have given the native of Marshfield, Wisc., in return for the digits.
Article content
'If that was me, I'd have got you either a big wheel of cheese or I'd have bought you, because the (Green Bay) Packers are a publicly traded company … you'd have been a part-owner of the Packers.
Article content
'Give me Tony's number. I'll tell him to buy you some shares of the Packers.'
Article content
While many players are very superstitious about their jersey numbers, the switch seems to be working out well for Varsho.
Article content
Daulton Varsho since returning from the IL:
🔹.357 AVG
🔹1.276 OPS
🔹4 HR
🔹11 RBI
🔹245 wRC+
BEAST🔥 pic.twitter.com/tCkbH9yHTe
— SleeperBlueJays (@SleeperBlueJays) August 13, 2025