Social media companies not liable for 2022 Buffalo mass shooting, New York court rules
Reversing a lower court ruling, the state Appellate Division in Rochester said defendants including Meta Platforms' Facebook and Instagram, Google's YouTube, and Reddit were entitled to immunity under a federal law that protects online platforms from liability over user content.
The case arose from Payton Gendron's racially motivated mass shooting at Tops Friendly Markets on May 14, 2022.
Relatives and representatives of victims, as well as store employees and customers who witnessed the attack, claimed the defendants' platforms were defective because they were designed to addict and radicalise users like Gendron.
Lawyers for the plaintiffs did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Other defendants included Alphabet, Amazon.com, Discord, 4chan, Snap and Twitch, all of which Gendron used, the mid-level state appeals court said.
Writing for a 3-2 majority, Justice Stephen Lindley said holding social media companies liable would undermine the intent behind Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act, to promote development of and competition on the internet while keeping government interference to a minimum.
While condemning Gendron's conduct and "the vile content that motivated him to assassinate Black people simply because of the color of their skin," Lindley said a liability finding would "result in the end of the Internet as we know it."
"Because social media companies that sort and display content would be subject to liability for every untruthful statement made on their platforms, the Internet would over time devolve into mere message boards," he wrote.
Justices Tracey Bannister and Henry Nowak dissented, saying the defendants force-fed targeted content to keep users engaged, be it videos about cooking or puppies, or white nationalist vitriol.
"Such conduct does not maintain the robust nature of Internet communication or preserve the vibrant and competitive free market that presently exists for the Internet contemplated by the protections of immunity," the judges wrote.
Gendron pleaded guilty to state charges including murder and terrorism motivated by hate, and was sentenced in February 2023 to life in prison without parole.
He faces related federal charges that could lead to the death penalty. Questioning of potential jurors in that case is scheduled to begin in August 2026, court records show.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
33 minutes ago
- India Today
Huge crowd gathers after German influencer spotted, detained for unauthorised shoot
A large crowd gathered on Church Street on Monday evening after popular German influencer Younes Zarou was spotted filming a video without prior police permission, prompting concerns over public safety and law and order. The influencer was initially detained by the police but was let off with a warning to police sources, an emergency call was received on 112 reporting a huge gathering and alleging that a celebrity was creating a public nuisance in the busy commercial arrival, Cubbon Park police found Zarou in the middle of a video shoot that had drawn a huge crowd. Officers informed him of the complaint and explained that sudden public appearances by high-profile individuals without prior intimation to authorities could escalate into law and order situations. A video shared by the influencer on his Instagram account shows the police taking him with them after detention. The caption of the video says, "Free Younes." "We received a phone call on 112 stating that there was a huge gathering on Church Street and that a celebrity was creating public nuisance," a police source said. "We went to the location and explained the nature of the complaint to him. We also informed him that any untoward incident might occur if a celebrity suddenly appears in a public place without obtaining prior permission from the police, as it could lead to a law and order situation."After a discussion that lasted nearly 30 minutes, Zarou acknowledged the police's concerns and agreed to vacate the location. No formal complaint was registered, and he was let off with a warning.- Ends
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Bengaluru woman spread radical content for AQIS: Gujarat ATS
Ahmedabad: A day after the Gujarat ATS arrested a 30-year-old woman from Bengaluru, Shama Parveen Ansari, the agency officers on Wednesday claimed that she operated social media accounts used to spread 'al-Qaida in the Indian subcontinent' (AQIS) propaganda and incite jihad. Officials said Parveen was a key digital propagandist who disseminated radical content calling for armed revolt and religious violence. Shama Parveen was arrested from her rented house in RT Nagar, Bengaluru, on Tuesday. According to Gujarat ATS, she operated key social media handles disseminating jihadi content. "This arrest is a part of an ongoing investigation into AQIS-linked radicalisation of Indian youth. We have evidence that Shama Parveen was the user behind Instagram account 'strangers_nation02' and Facebook pages 'Strangers of The Nation' and 'Strangers of The Nation 2'," said Gujarat ATS in an official statement. The agency added, "These accounts were used to post videos and speeches of AQIS leader Maulana Asim Umar and Imam Anwar al Awlaki calling for armed revolution against the Indian govt, promotion of Ghazwa-e-Hind, and inciting violence against non-believers." by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Explore the 18 Most Stunning Hotel Pools Only the Rich and Famous Get to Swim In! Click Here Undo "She also circulated video messages of Maulana Abdul Aziz of Lal Masjid, Lahore, calling upon Muslims to wage armed struggle against the Indian state," ATS said. You Can Also Check: Ahmedabad AQI | Weather in Ahmedabad | Bank Holidays in Ahmedabad | Public Holidays in Ahmedabad Earlier, on July 22, Gujarat ATS arrested four men from Ahmedabad, Modasa, Delhi, and Noida for promoting similar content. The agency said, "We digitally tracked the origin of this propaganda to the accounts operated by Shama Parveen." "She was apprehended with the help of central agencies and local police. Her mobile phone was seized and examined, and prima-facie evidence confirmed her role in radicalisation," said ATS. "Parveen has been brought to Gujarat on a transit remand. A case under Sections 13, 18, 38, and 39 of the UAPA has been registered against her. Her electronic devices and communication records are under forensic analysis," the agency added. Gujarat ATS concluded, "The woman established digital links with foreign entities, including those in Pakistan. Her involvement in recruiting or influencing others is part of a broader probe now underway. " Shama Parveen sent to police remand for 14 days Ahmedabad: Shama Parveen Ansari, who was arrested from Bengaluru allegedly for spreading al-Qaida ideology through social media, was sent to 14-day custodial interrogation on Wednesday. Ansari was produced before judicial magistrate of first-class, M D Virani, at Ahmedabad rural court after being arrested by the ATS. Seeking her remand for 14 days, assistant public prosecutor Sandeep Gautam submitted before the court that she had been operating an Instagram ID since 2022, several Facebook pages, and was accused of uploading jihadist speeches by al-Qaida in Indian Subcontinent (AQIS) leader Maulana Assim Umar. The content called for armed revolution against the govt of India, Ghazwa-e-Hind, religious hatred, and terrorist attacks. Ansari was accused of posting jihadi speeches by AQIS's Imam Anwar al Awlaki and Lahore's Lal Masjid's Maulana Abdul Aziz on these social media accounts, thereby inciting Indian Muslim youth to carry out violence on religious grounds against members of other religions, the ATS stated in its remand application. The probe agency wanted to question her in custody also to know more about the earlier arrest of other alleged AQIS supporters. Fardeen Shaikh, a resident of Ahmedabad; Mohd Faiq, a resident of Delhi; Zeeshan Ali, a resident of Noida in Uttar Pradesh; and Saifullah Qureshi, a resident of Modasa in Gujarat's Aravalli district, were arrested last week on allegations of being involved in propagating AQIS ideology. They were booked under the provisions of Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act (UAPA).
Economic Times
an hour ago
- Economic Times
Kanye West and Bianca Censori 'unusual and troubling' social media posts raise concerns. Here's what they said
Agencies Kanye West and Bianca Censori have triggered concern on social media. Kanye West and Bianca Censori have triggered concern on social media following a sequence of unusual and troubling posts. Kanye's masked photo and Bianca's hacking alert have fueled new speculation. Their actions have drawn attention, especially as the rapper faces serious accusations and divorce rumors West, aged 48, posted a photo on Instagram showing himself wearing a hooded sweatshirt and a mask. The photo appeared in his Instagram Story. Other posts included artwork and images from a recent visit to South Korea. These posts were cryptic and raised concerns among his followers. Shortly after Kanye's post, his wife Bianca Censori, aged 30, updated her Instagram Story. She wrote that her account had experienced repeated hacking. She told followers that 'anything weird is not me.' This marked one of the few times she directly addressed her followers in a message. Also Read: Baba Vanga's 2025 Predictions: World War 3 possibility, natural disasters rise, biological experiment going wrong, alien discovery, shift in technology and AI. Here's complete list Bianca had earlier deleted several posts from her Instagram profile. Only a few photos remained. These included images from a hotel suite in Japan, taken during an October 2024 trip with Kanye. This sudden cleanup of her feed added to the mystery surrounding her current message. Just before Kanye's upcoming concert in China, his former personal assistant, Lauren Pisciotta, filed a lawsuit. The lawsuit includes multiple allegations, such as sexual assault, physical assault, harassment, sex trafficking and false imprisonment. The case adds to the artist's public controversies and ongoing legal couple was recently spotted at the airport in Seoul, South Korea. They wore matching black outfits. Kanye wore his usual streetwear. Bianca wore a bodysuit with a sheer top and knee-high boots. She also carried a Hermès Birkin Read: Ozzy Osbourne Funeral Tributes: Family Visits Black Sabbath Bench on Broad Street Kanye followed his masked post with more images. These included a masked man in a green hoodie, smoke on a concert stage, and fireworks. Bianca's recent photos showed her in sheer lingerie with a blonde wig. These were reportedly taken by Kanye couple married in December 2022. However, they have often been the subject of divorce rumors. Page Six reported in March that Bianca had considered leaving Kanye. Sources claimed she feared his control over many parts of her life.A source told the outlet that Bianca once left for another hotel. Kanye allegedly found out and sent security to retrieve her. The source added that Kanye would not leave her alone and stayed close to her location. Why did Bianca Censori issue a hacking warning on Instagram? Bianca said her account was hacked repeatedly and warned followers that any strange content should not be seen as coming from her. What are the recent legal issues involving Kanye West? Kanye West's former assistant has filed a lawsuit alleging serious claims including assault, trafficking, and false imprisonment.
