Sabrina Carpenter's Songwriting Questioned by Popular YouTuber: ‘Maybe She Wrote One Line'
Sabrina Carpenter's Songwriting Questioned by Popular YouTuber: 'Maybe She Wrote One Line' originally appeared on Parade.
recently took heat for the controversial cover art for her forthcoming album Man's Best Friend.
Now the 'Espresso' hitmaker has found herself in the sights of popular music YouTuber , who is questioning the contributions to her own songs.
🎬 SIGN UP for Parade's Daily newsletter to get the latest pop culture news & celebrity interviews delivered right to your inbox 🎬
In a video titled 'How Do People NOT Know This About Pop Music?' posted on YouTube on June 24, Beato focuses on Carpenter's current hit single 'Manchild' and plays a clip of the video before letting loose on Carpenter and her fans.
'People are discussing the lyrics, and they are talking about them as if Sabrina Carpenter wrote these lyrics herself,' Beato says in his video. 'Now maybe Sabrina Carpenter wrote one line or changed a couple of words or something,' he adds, without providing evidence to back up this claim.
As of this writing, Beato's video has more than 1.2 million views, and his channel, which often features interviews with classic rock icons, has more than 5 million subscribers.
Beato goes on to mention that the song was co-written by Carpenter with songwriters and , who have worked with Carpenter in the past. Allen was one of the writers on Carpenter's massive breakout hit 'Espresso.' Carpenter, Allen and Antonoff also collaborated on her hit 'Please, Please, Please.'After noting Allen's and Antonoff's credits as writers on several hits by other artists, Beato again takes a shot at Carpenter's role in writing her songs. 'Yeah, she might be in the room for some of this stuff, but the fact of the matter is these same people are all over multiple hit songs.'
He also questions her role in the making of her videos. 'When I see people make videos on YouTube where they're about her lyrics, what this 'Manchild' thing means, it's like doesn't mean anything,' Beato says. 'Every bit of this video has been meticulously crafted. They do story boards. They do all this kind of stuff. They figure out what kind of outfits, what the vibe's going to be. The same thing with the album cover art. All of it is a completely calculated thing. She's a pop star. This is a thing that I guess a lot of people don't realize that this stuff is figured out by massive groups of people. These are not songs that are coming from Sabrina Carpenter's head.'
While Beato's video is seemingly designed to inform his followers about the making of pop records, some took it as an unwarranted attack on Carpenter.
'Something so unseemly about Rick Beato popping off on Sabrina Carpenter,' author/musician , host of The Record Store Day podcast, wrote on his Facebook page. 'Such a bitter Lefsetz-ian move,' he added, referring to music industry commentator .
Despite Myers' criticism, those who commented on Beato's YouTube video generally seemed to agree with Beato's thoughts on the matter.
'A few writers writing for everyone, a few producers producing everyone, mixed and mastered by the same people. Starts to feel like McMusic,' wrote one.
Sabrina Carpenter's Songwriting Questioned by Popular YouTuber: 'Maybe She Wrote One Line' first appeared on Parade on Jun 26, 2025
This story was originally reported by Parade on Jun 26, 2025, where it first appeared.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fast Company
24 minutes ago
- Fast Company
Why Gen Z is ditching popular emojis for unexpected alternatives
Not all emojis are created equal. The sparkle emoji or red heart emoji are staples of text conversations and social media captions. But how often are you using the baggage claim icon or the non-potable water symbol? Recently, a new trend has emerged: mainstream emojis are being passed over in favor of more creative alternatives. The broken heart emoji? Tired. Predictable. The wilted rose emoji? Aesthetic. Unexpected. The trend began earlier this year when a video from one TikTok user went viral. The caption read: ''💔' lowkey starting to become too mainstream / i might just start using '🥀'.' Others quickly joined in. 'How it feels using '💔' in the '🥀' era,' one TikTok user posted, cutting to a photo of someone's grandpa. As David Doochin explained for Emojipedia: 'One of the most typical memes gaining traction among the TikTok contingent is the 'X has gone mainstream / we now use Y' format that declares a given meme, emoji, or cultural symbol as out of date or past its prime and offers a replacement, usually a derivative of the original symbol in some way but sometimes totally arbitrary.' The most commonly used emojis include faces, hearts, and hand gestures—ones that slip seamlessly into texts to convey emotion. 'Loudly Crying Face' was the most-used emoji of 2024, followed by 'Face with Tears of Joy' and the 'Fire' emoji. Now, among younger generations and the chronically online, certain emojis have taken on entirely new meanings—with lesser-used icons pulled from obscurity. YouTuber John Casterline posted a video last month encouraging people to adopt the aerial tramway emoji—once the least-used emoji in the world —as a replacement for the common 'Crying Laughing Face.' 'I came up with a plan where we can make this emoji one of the most used emojis, at least on YouTube,' he explained. 'Instead of using laughing emojis from now on, replace it with this. And if someone doesn't know why you're doing it, don't tell them.' This isn't the first time the aerial tramway has been thrust into the spotlight. Back in 2018, the now-defunct X account @leastUsedEmoji reported that the aerial tramway held the title of least-used emoji for 11 weeks straight. Responding to the call, public transportation advocates rallied around the underappreciated emoji, spamming Twitter/X with strings of the aerial tramway. The plan worked. After 77 days, the tram climbed the ranks and was replaced in last place by input symbol for latin capital letters. As of the account's last post on August 3, 2020, input symbol for symbols had been the least-used emoji for 264 days. Perhaps it's time it gets the same treatment.
CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
Remember Anna Wintour's shocking first Vogue cover?
By today's standards, the front cover of American Vogue's November 1988 edition seems typical enough. Beside the text 'the real cost of looking good,' Israeli model Michaela Bercu gazes past the camera, her windswept hair brushing across the shoulders of a bejeweled $10,000 Christian Lacroix couture jacket. Yet, the cover signaled a revolution at the storied fashion bible. It also marked two important — and related — firsts: This was the first Vogue cover produced by editor-in-chief Anna Wintour and the first ever to feature a pair of jeans. London-born Wintour, who on Thursday stepped down from the role after 37 years (she will remain as Vogue's global editorial director and publisher Condé Nast's global chief content officer), had been hired to shake things up. The magazine's previous editor, Grace Mirabella, oversaw a surge in readership but was, by her own admission, increasingly out of step with the 1980s zeitgeist. Condé Nast executives were reportedly worried the title was losing its edge. Mirabella had famously repainted former editor Diana Vreeland's red office a shade of beige, which became a metaphor for her reputation as being too unadventurous. Practically every American Vogue cover from 1980 to 1988 had been taken by Richard Avedon, a fashion photographer known for his stark, minimalist style. Models were usually shot against plain studio backgrounds in heavy makeup and statement jewelry. The covers were self-consciously elegant, standing aloof from the more mainstream women's weeklies they shared newsstands with. By contrast, Wintour's debut was warm and easygoing. German photographer Peter Lindbergh held the shoot outdoors rather than in a controlled studio; Bercu's eyes were neither fully open nor looking directly at the camera. As a result, she came across as a glamorous everywoman. Wintour's unpretentious approach was seemingly epitomized by another coverline on that first issue: 'Paris couture: haut but not haughty.' 'It looked easy, casual, a moment that had been snapped on the street, which it had been, and which was the whole point,' Wintour recalled in a Vogue feature marking publication's 120th anniversary. Then there were the jeans. These were not a high-fashion label's take on Americana, they were stonewashed denim pants straight from Guess. Having launched less than a decade earlier, the denim brand's highest-profile moment at that point had come courtesy of Michael J. Fox, who wore a pair of Guess jeans as Marty McFly in 1985's 'Back to the Future.' As such, both in style and styling, Wintour's first cover was a major statement — one that set the tone for hundreds of issues to follow. She went on to forge an editorial identity her predecessors might have looked down on, from spotlighting pop culture icons to featuring a man on the cover (Richard Gere, who appeared alongside then-wife Cindy Crawford). But there was an element of luck behind her debut issue, too. Wintour has since revealed that the jeans were a last-minute decision forced upon the shoot's stylist, Carlyne Cerf de Dudzeele, by unforeseen circumstances. Bercu was initially wearing a full Christian Lacroix suit comprising the beaded jacket (which Wintour described as 'all very 'Like a Prayer'') and a skirt, but the latter didn't fit properly. '(Bercu) had been on vacation back home in Israel and had gained a little weight,' Wintour recounted in the 2012 Vogue feature, before qualifying: 'Not that that mattered. In fact, it only served to reinforce the idea to take couture's haughty grandeur and playfully throw it headlong into real life and see what happened.' Wintour has since recalled that the magazine's printers were so surprised by the front cover that they called to see whether it had been sent in error. The veteran editor also played down the intention behind the image, though she surely knew, better than most, that magazines are judged by their covers. 'Afterwards, in the way that these things can happen, people applied all sorts of interpretations: It was about mixing high and low, Michaela was pregnant, it was a religious statement. But none of these things was true,' she said. 'I had just looked at that picture and sensed the winds of change. And you can't ask for more from a cover image than that.'
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
After Her Stepfather's Death, She Set Out to Skateboard Across America in His Honor (Exclusive)
A few years ago, Brooke Johnson set out on a personal mission: skateboarding 178 miles from Los Angeles to Mexico The trek sparked a bigger idea: what if she skated across the entire country? For a while, it remained just a dream — until her stepfather, Roger, suffered a devastating fall, breaking his C5 vertebra and becoming a quadriplegic. Inspired by his strength, Brooke decided to skateboard across America in his honorA few years ago, Brooke Johnson set out on a personal adventure: skateboarding from Los Angeles to Mexico. The 178-mile trek sparked a realization — if she could go that far, why not farther? As her confidence and skills grew, the idea of skating across the entire country began to take shape. It felt like a natural next step. For a while, though, it remained just that: an idea, tucked away in the back of her mind without a clear purpose. Then everything changed. Her stepfather, Roger, suffered a devastating fall, breaking his C5 vertebra and becoming a quadriplegic. 'Suddenly, I had a reason,' says Johnson, who began skateboarding at age 13. 'I told him, 'I'll skate across the country and raise money for your recovery.' ' The original plan was simple but powerful: she would skate across the United States and, at the end, push Roger in his wheelchair across the finish line. At the time, she had relocated from New York City back to her hometown of Seattle to help support her family. But before the journey could begin, Roger died while recovering from surgery. It was devastating, but Johnson had made him a promise, and she was determined to keep it. She began reaching out to sponsors, eventually partnering with Playtex to bring her vision to life, all while setting her sights on a history-making goal. This summer, she officially hit the road, aiming to become the first woman to skateboard across America — a 3,000-mile journey from Santa Monica to New York City. She's accompanied by a small crew in a support van, which doubles as their mobile home. The team usually sleeps in the van, but every four or five days they splurge on a budget hotel — a Days Inn or Super 8 — to shower, reset and rest before heading back out the next morning. 'I just told myself, I'll keep going until my body gives out, and I'll find out what my limits are,' she says. 'We've had angels show up in the craziest parts of the desert," she adds. "You think, 'There's no way anyone's going to help us out here.' But then someone always shows up. And I don't think that's a coincidence — that's Roger.' Leading up to the journey, Johnson purchased a skateboard specifically for the adventure. It has a lower drop-through deck that sits closer to the ground, so it doesn't hurt her thighs as much when she's pushing. But along the way, she says the skateboard has developed its own personality. 'It's my chariot," she says. "She takes me where I need to go, and oftentimes it's just her and me skating through. I've put stickers on it. The meaning is it's just the thing that gets me where I'm going. She's my seat when I need to cry. She's my transportation when I need to move. She's just a part of me now.' 'We did leave her once by accident at a stopping spot, and I freaked out," Johnson adds. "I was like, 'Oh no!' But the thing is, to get a world record, I have to finish the entire trip on the same board — so I can't get another one. She's very important.' Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. One of Johnson's favorite questions from people she meets is whether they can see her route. She laughs every time. 'I wish I could see it too,' she says. 'It's constantly changing.' Before she set off, she mapped out a route on Google Maps that seemed manageable. Surprisingly, she and her crew have stuck fairly close to it, reassessing the plan every 100 miles — the rough segments they use to break down the trip. She mostly sticks to car-accessible roads, always steering clear of highways when possible. Each stretch brings new challenges, but Johnson keeps pushing forward — one mile, one promise, one purpose at a time. Some of the toughest moments aren't physical. While long uphills and rough roads take their toll, she says the biggest challenge is mental. 'It's not even the road conditions — it's the act of starting,' she says. 'Every motivational speaker says it, but it's true: starting is the hardest part. And I have to do it every single day. Getting out of bed when all you want to do is sleep ... that's the hardest part for me.' In desert regions, where the daytime heat is brutal, Johnson often chooses to skate at night — something she's grown to love. 'I really like night skating. It's colder, quieter. Honestly, it feels like you're in a simulation,' she says. 'The van follows behind me, and because you can't see very far ahead, you lose your sense of distance. You just keep going. It's peaceful.' 'During the day, you're dodging cars constantly, and that's exhausting — not physically, but mentally. Making sure I don't get hit wears me down more than the skating itself,' she adds. 'I'm constantly jumping off the road for semis, waiting, then starting again. It breaks your rhythm.' Her routine has become a dance with the desert: skating at night, resting during the day. On a typical afternoon in New Mexico, for example, she'd rest when the heat peaked around 5 p.m. She'd sleep for about two-and-a-half hours, then take a 5-Hour Energy, pop three ibuprofen and skate as far into the night as she could. It's a physically brutal journey but more than anything, it's a test of will. And so far, she's meeting that test one determined push at a time, fueled by cheers from the community on social media, where she's amassed more than 200,000 followers across TikTok and Instagram. 'The people in my comment section are so kind,' she says. 'They're hyping me up. They're like, 'Keep going, girl.' ' 'I'm doing this to inspire a generation of women to know that they are capable, that they can do anything they put their minds to, even if it's hard,' she adds. 'We're constantly in this space of social media that's really tough — showcasing only the best of people, and comparison is a problem. But here I am, in a helmet and a highlighter vest. I want girls to know you can do this and still look pretty on days like this. I am who I am, but then I have to go on a date with my boyfriend and want to feel pretty. You can get dirty and still be pretty.' Along the way, Johnson and her team have met countless people in every town — people who feel nothing short of magical. Just a few days before her PEOPLE interview, while skating up a highway, Johnson stopped at a small honey farm that looked a bit run-down at first glance. But it turned out to be part of an Earthship community — homes built sustainably from natural and recycled materials, completely off the grid. There, Johnson met a woman who shared her life story: how she runs a shelter for the unhoused and dedicates herself to helping others. The woman could tell Johnson was feeling low, and before she left, she gifted the crew jars of honey, muscle rub and other thoughtful supplies. 'She asked if she could donate or help in any way,' Johnson recalls. 'I told her I was fine, but she insisted on leaving us with those gifts.' 'We also went through this town called Pi Town, and they gave me free pie," she adds. "I showed up at the top of Pi Town, which is at the top of a hill, and I was so tired — crying, exhausted. They just gave me pie, and I was like, 'All I want is a strawberry rhubarb pie right now.' And they happened to have that. People are just kind.' Most recently, Johnson has found herself in Hereford, Texas, steadily closing in on her goal. She hopes to finish the journey in July. What started as a race against the clock has transformed into a lesson in presence: learning to live fully in each moment, mile by mile. But when she finally crosses that finish line, she has one simple but powerful request. 'I've decided the theme of the rest of my life is going to be buoyancy,' she says. 'After pushing so hard against gravity, wind and heat, I want to feel weightless. I want to be in the water — free, floating and light. My celebration? Swimming with dolphins and snorkeling, letting the ocean carry me instead of fighting against it. It sounds kind of wild, but to me, it's the perfect way to mark this journey.' Read the original article on People
