Company supplying critical EV metal ‘did not disclose' Erin Brockovich pollutant in drinking water
One of Indonesia's largest nickel-mining companies, which supplies a mineral critical to the global electric car industry, did not tell the public that local drinking water was polluted, according to documents seen by the Guardian.
Indonesia has become the world's biggest producer of nickel, used in the production of wind turbines, solar panels and electric vehicle batteries. But observers have voiced concerns that regulatory oversight in the country has failed to keep up with the rush to develop mines to satisfy booming global demand.
Leaked documents seen by the Guardian suggest a source of drinking water close to a $1bn (£800m) mining project owned by the Indonesia-based Harita Group on remote Obi Island, was contaminated with unsafe levels of hexavalent chromium (Cr6), the cancer-causing chemical more widely known for its role in the Erin Brockovich story and film.
Cr6 can cause liver damage, reproductive problems and developmental harm when ingested or inhaled. Long-term exposure through drinking water has also been linked to stomach cancer. Evidence has shown that Cr6 in drinking water can be a result of industrial processes.
The leak comes after a Guardian investigation into pollution at the site in 2022 was disputed by the mining company, which extracts and processes nickel for use in EV batteries.
For the 2022 investigation, water samples collected from a spring in the village of Kawasi, less than 200 metres from the mining site, were tested at government-certified laboratories and suggested high levels of contamination from carcinogenic Cr6 of 60 parts per billion (ppb). The maximum contaminant level allowed by law in Indonesia is 50ppb.
In response to the Guardian's original investigation, a Harita company said its own results had shown that the spring water was suitable for consumption and met the quality standards set by the Indonesian government.
However, the leaked documents and emails suggest a Harita company found the Cr6 values in Kawasi spring, used as drinking water by villagers, in excess of Indonesian quality standards just one day after its statement to the contrary. It then found even higher values in subsequent days. It does not appear to have made this data public.
The Guardian was given a chance to review the material by the Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (OCCRP) in a joint investigation with the Gecko Project, an environmental organisation.
The material suggests tests of Kawasi's spring water undertaken by a Harita company found Cr6 concentrations of 70ppb on 1 February 2022, one day after the Harita company provided its statement to the Guardian. On 7 February 2022 a value of 128ppb was recorded.
A weekly environment report from December 2022 reported that values of 140ppb had been recorded at the spring.
Harita has not responded to requests for comment on the leaked material and test results but in a press release published on its website this month, the company said it conducts periodic monitoring of the water at Kawasi spring to ensure it is safe and uncontaminated.
Environmental health experts have said the test results suggest a significant issue with pollution.
Matthew Baird, an environmental lawyer based in south-east Asia, said: 'These are figures that need to be taken into account not just by the company, but also the Indonesian government.'
'Nickel is meant to be one of the transition metals [to move to a green, low-carbon economy] and we require a just transition to ensure the protection of the environment, human rights and the community,' he said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
17 hours ago
- NBC News
Crushed by Israeli missile strikes, Gaza's hospitals are barely functioning
Israeli military assaults on the Gaza Strip's hospitals have ramped up in recent weeks to the highest level so far this year, bringing a health system already weakened by 19 months of war to a breaking point. NBC News has analyzed 27 videos and images from the last two months taken by civilians and our own journalists on the ground to piece together a picture of the full extent of the destruction of a health system engulfed in war. In footage from a surveillance camera, men, women and children could be seen crossing the entrance to Khan Younis' European Hospital moments before a missile hit, blasting people into the air as others scattered in panic. Another video, posted to social media and verified by NBC News, showed the fiery aftermath of an explosion at a medical warehouse near Al-Awda Hospital, in northern Gaza, which has been attacked repeatedly, including on May 22 and again on May 24. 'Nearly all hospitals in Gaza are now damaged or destroyed, and half of them are no longer operational,' Jens Laerke, spokesperson for the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, or OCHA, told NBC News. During the war, Gaza's hospitals have eked back services, only to be repeatedly struck or besieged again. Hospitals are protected under international humanitarian law, butIsrael has maintained that Hamas uses hospitals and medical centers for military activities, opening them to attack. Hamas has denied doing so. Humanitarian groups, including the United Nations, havesaid Israel has not provided sufficient information to substantiate many of its claims and have called for independent investigations of Israel's attacks and Hamas' alleged misuse of the facilities. Earlier this week, however, the Israeli military gave a small group of reporters a tour of a tunnel that was uncovered beneath the European Hospital, where it said it had recovered the body of Hamas' military chief Mohammed Sinwar. 'We cannot stress this enough: Hospitals must never be militarized or targeted. If they are, it may constitute a war crime,' Laerke said. Of Gaza's 36 hospitals, none are fully functioning; 17 are providing partial services, and 19 are not functioning at all, according to World Health Organization data from Monday. The wider health system, including ambulances, field hospitals and clinics, has been attacked more than 700 times since the start of the war, killing at least 900 people and injuring more than 1,000. (The death toll across Gaza is more than 55,000, according to the health ministry.) After a ceasefire was called in January, Israeli military attacks on Gaza's health system had abated. The truce fell apart in March, and WHO data shows a ramping up of attacks in recent weeks. While the organization tallied five attacks on Gaza's health system in April, after the first three weeks of May, the number of attacks had quadrupled to 21, with at least three more attacks since, including on the vicinity of a dialysis center at the Indonesian Hospital on June 1 and strikes on Al-Aqsa and Al-Ahli Hospitals on June 4 and 5. In addition, hostilities near Al-Amal Hospital have rendered it 'out of service,' the WHO said Monday. The earliest attack recorded by NBC News during that two-month period was on April 2, when an Israeli airstrike hit a UNRWA clinic in Jabalia, north of Gaza City, that was housing displaced people. Video captured by NBC News on the ground documented the chaotic aftermath: walls crushed to rubble, charred mattresses, furniture blasted into shards. A child's small, shrouded body was loaded onto a donkey cart to be taken to the morgue. In another case, the Israel Defense Forces struck two hospitals on the same day, May 13, both in Khan Younis. Video verified by NBC News shows several large plumes of smoke rising from the grounds of the European Hospital. Palestinian health officials said at least 16 people were killed and dozens more injured. The WHO said the facility had been forced to suspend services. Also struck that day was the Nasser Medical Complex. Video posted by the U.N. showed scattered debris, twisted hospital beds and damaged equipment. It was the fourth time Nasser had been hit during the war, according to the U.N., with the latest strike killing two people and injuring a dozen others. In a statement in response to those attacks, the IDF said its forces had targeted a command and control center located at Nasser Hospital and 'a Hamas underground terrorist infrastructure site' underneath the European Hospital. The IDF provided evidence of what it said was a Hamas tunnel beneath the European Hospital. It did not, however, provide evidence for the command and control center at Nasser, or for the following cases, but broadly said: 'The Hamas terrorist organization continues to use hospitals in the Gaza Strip for terrorist activity.' NBC News is not able to independently verify the IDF's statements.
Scotsman
2 days ago
- Scotsman
Over 1,000 yogis set to downward dog at Emirates Arena for largest event of its kind
In just one week over 1,000 yoga enthusiasts will be namaste-ing at the Emirates Arena in Glasgow as part of a World Yoga Day event with renowned PYPT practitioner, Sadhvi Devaditi. Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Tickets for the event – believed to be the biggest of its kind - are being snapped up quickly with over 900 already reserved, and organisers are encouraging others to secure their spot now and join the movement. The clincher, tickets are completely free. This year's event promises to be the biggest and most dynamic yet, with a live international broadcast from the Emirates Arena. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The event is a major part of Scotland's contribution to World Yoga Day, recognised globally on 21 June. Sunita Poddar, Chairperson of the Patanjali Yog Peeth (Scotland) Trust In the lead-up to the big day, the city is embracing yoga like never before. Free yoga classes will be offered to offices, schools, and community groups across Glasgow and Edinburgh from 16 to 23 June, helping people of all backgrounds experience the physical and mental health benefits of yoga. This special event is hosted by the Consulate General of India, Edinburgh, and Patanjali Yog Peeth (UK) Trust, with support from Glasgow Indians Association The events are designed to introduce people to yoga, celebrate the community spirit of new and experienced yogis across Glasgow, and supports the bringing together of from across Glasgow to celebrate the benefit of yoga. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Sunita Poddar, Chairperson of the Patanjali Yog Peeth (Scotland) Trust, said: 'Yoga is for everyone - it transcends age, background, and ability. 'At PYPT, we are committed to promoting holistic health and wellbeing by reconnecting communities with the ancient wisdom of yoga. Our aim is to inspire positive change, both physically and mentally, and empower individuals to take control of their own wellbeing. 'This celebration at the Emirates Arena is a chance to come together and experience the transformative power of yoga - we welcome everyone to be part of this special day.' Sunita Poddar is the founder and chief executive of Glasgow-based care home group, Oakminster Healthcare. Part of her mission to root her businesses and approach to person-centred resident care in health and wellbeing will see the team of care home wellbeing enablers trained to deliver low-impact yoga sessions for residents across the five care homes in Govan, Kinning Park, Pollokshields, St George's Cross and Knightswood. The PYPT Yoga Event is free, but registration is essential via Eventbrite.
Press and Journal
2 days ago
- Press and Journal
Nappies cut ruled out as London-based experts drafted in to help NHS Grampian save millions
Health bosses have voted against plans to slash spending on newborn tots amid fears scrapping hospital nappies 'would do more harm than good'. A shock dossier earlier this week revealed a range of services across the north-east could be axed or reduced to save the health board £23 million. This included halting cancer treatment and elective surgeries on public holidays and even stopping giving out disposable nappies for most newborn babies. The proposed cost-cutting measures would have impacted expectant mums at maternity wards in Aberdeen, Inverurie, Peterhead and Elgin. It comes as NHS Grampian bosses scramble to recoup millions of pounds after officially becoming the most broke health board in Scotland. They currently have a staggering £68m overspend that they aim to reduce to £45m in the next 12 months. And now, external experts have been drafted in to help them balance the books. Government officials haven hired London-based advisors KPMG to crunch the numbers and help NHS Grampian come up with an expansive savings plan. They say the cash crisis within the health board has escalated to the point where there is a need for experts to intervene amid concerns over failing to improve services. Adam Coldwells reassured board members that NHS Grampian will still be 'absolutely in charge' of the recovery plan and the changes they implement further down the line. However, the external body will be there to monitor their progress, give advice on possible additional savings the board might have missed and 'hold them to account'. The interim chief executive said this is a necessary measure to turn the health board's fortunes around as 'the scale of the [financial] challenge is significant'. And he stressed this would be a good opportunity to learn and improve. He added: 'Clearly it's an extremely serious issue and relates primarily to our financial position, which as a board we've been working on for the last two years. 'We've certainly struggled to find the scale of savings that we need to. 'I'm optimistic this external support from an organisation, who has done this lots of times, will be able to find things that we've simply not been able to identify ourselves.' Members of the NHS Grampian board were later presented with a detailed report outlining 79 cost-cutting measures which will be implemented within the next year. Health bosses admit about a dozen of those could have direct impact on vulnerable patients – with a range of medical services no longer taking place on public holidays. This would affect non-emergency surgeries and diagnostic tests, as well as cancer treatments such as chemotherapy and radiation therapy. Routine test results will also be given by phone or letter, with face-to-face appointments taking place only when essential. The aim is to cut down on overtime pay. Board member Derick Murray questioned whether they are not 'taking a step back' by reducing these services. But interim director of people and culture, Philip Shipman, said running services on public holidays is 'incredibly expensive' so that's a good place to make a saving. Dr Colette Backwell later also reminded fellow board members that the recovery plan they have been presented with is a necessity rather than a choice. 'The Scottish Government is asking us to find more savings so we have to go along with that,' she said. Staff at pharmacies will also be taking a day off on public holidays from now on. Members raised concerns this could result in people not getting the treatment they need in a timely manner or being missed altogether. Area clinical forum chairman Mark Burrell admitted other health committees have had similar worries too. However, he reassured that there is a 'robust evaluation' under way so that 'patients do not suffer' at the hands of the proposed changes. 'This is kept under very close review,' Mr Burrell added. One of the proposed measures was, however, scratched from the plans amid fears it 'would not be supportive of vulnerable parents'. Board chairwoman Alison Evison raised concerns that if they stop giving out nappies at hospitals, parents might end up without any supplies at an already stressful time. This option would have essentially saved them around £8,000 per year. But Mrs Evison didn't think 'such a small' amount would justify the impact of going ahead with the proposals. She said: 'This saving has huge implications for certain people who are in need of that kind of support when they're coming to hospital. 'And yet, the saving associated with it is actually relatively small. 'Sometimes people will be coming to a hospital to have a baby when they are not expecting it at that point in time. It's a case of just not being prepared. 'So I think we are actually trying to make a saving which is going to be more negative than supportive.' All of the other proposals were given the green light, however, with a more detailed report being presented to the board in October.
