Scandal-hit Queensland DNA lab repeats major testing error as rape victims wait over a year for results
The latest testing failure was revealed in a review into Forensic Services Queensland released on Monday, which also found that hundreds of rape victims were waiting 'over 12 months' for the lab to test rape kits, a process that should be completed 'ideally within five days'.
In 2022, the first of two inquiries into Forensic Services Queensland found that the laboratory's threshold for testing was set too low, calling into question DNA evidence used in thousands of criminal cases, including for crimes such as rape and murder.
Sign up: AU Breaking News email
On 19 November last year, the laboratory implemented a new threshold for testing for DNA.
But according to a review by forensic scientist Prof Kirsty Wright and former FBI expert Dr Bruce Budowle, tabled in parliament on Monday, the new limit was again incorrect.
'After introduction of the new DNA threshold, a Priority 1 crime scene sample from a violent unresolved crime was not fully tested because it fell below the threshold,' Wright's report found.
'[Queensland police] requested for it to be fully tested, and it provided a usable DNA profile that assisted the investigation.'
Priority 1 samples refer to evidence used in 'major crime cases', as opposed to 'volume crimes' like robbery.
The report also recommended the lab immediately stop testing all rape kits, due to concerns over the reliability of its results.
There were 511 untested rape kits in Queensland as of September 2024, it found.
The report describes the mismanagement of the then Queensland Health laboratory between 2007 and 2023 as 'one of the greatest failures of a justice system in the world', judging that 'many thousands of victims had been denied justice, and the communities' trust in forensic DNA services lost'.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
The review also found that the laboratory was 'a dirty lab' and was known to be contaminated.
The state government announced it would appoint a new expert team to overhaul forensic services led by former New South Wales police commissioner Mick Fuller, with the ongoing involvement of the review's authors.
More details soon …
In Australia, the national family violence counselling service is on 1800 737 732. In the UK, call the national domestic abuse helpline on 0808 2000 247, or visit Women's Aid. In the US, the domestic violence hotline is 1-800-799-SAFE (7233). Other international helplines may be found via www.befrienders.org
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
23 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Australian woman chained to her bed 'so she didn't sneak out to have sex with other men'
A man has been charged with a raft of domestic violence offences, accused of kidnapping and assaulted his partner who was allegedly chained to a bed. Zane Woodward, 34, appeared in court on Thursday, two days after Broadie McGugan, 32, finally escaped from him and fled to the local police station in the NSW Illawarra region. Harrowing details were laid bare in court, where police allege Ms McGugan was detained at an Oak Flats home and chained to the bed at night. She was only unlocked from the bed to eat and use the toilet, court documents allege. The court heard that Wodward's alleged torture began recently to prevent her from 'sneaking out' to have sex with other men. Woodward was charged with kidnap with intent to commit a serious indictable offence, two counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm – DV, take and detail a person with intent to obtain advantage, common assault and intimidation.
The Guardian
23 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Convicted rapist MP Gareth Ward argues it would be unfair to be expelled from NSW parliament
A lawyer for disgraced MP Gareth Ward has argued it would be unfair for his New South Wales parliamentary colleagues to vote on expelling him before he is sentenced for a rape conviction because Ward cannot oppose it. But chief justice Andrew Bell, one of the three judges who oversaw the matter in the state's court of appeal on Thursday, interjected to say Ward's inability to attend parliament and oppose his expulsion was 'driven entirely' by the fact he is remanded in custody for his crimes. Ward faced an urgent hearing on Thursday after he he sought an injunction against leader of the Legislative Assembly, Ron Hoenig, to stop his parliamentary colleagues expelling him. He commenced the proceedings on Monday night via his lawyers from Silverwater jail, where he has been remanded pending sentencing in September. Ward was found guilty in July of sexually abusing two young men in 2013 and 2015. He is appealing his convictions, which include three counts of indecent assault and one for sexual intercourse without consent. Ward's injunction triggered a potential constitutional showdown after Hoenig told reporters the government did not believe the court had the constitutional power to restrain the parliament or any member from moving a motion in the lower house. The hearing was then brought forward by a day after an urgent application by the parliament. The decision is expected to be handed down at 5pm on Thursday. During the hearing, Ward's lawyer, Peter King, accused the parliament of trying to conduct a 'kangaroo court' and said it was among a number of reasons why parliament's resolution to expel Ward was 'punitive in nature'. He further argued it was punitive because Ward's expulsion would trigger a by-election and 'he's further punished in that respect, by losing the opportunity to regain his seat'. King later compared Ward's absence from parliament to someone who has a 'serious malady or illness or cancer or something' and cannot attend parliament for nine months. King also told the court that Ward's convictions cannot alone be considered the 'unworthy conduct' needed as grounds to expel him from parliament. 'It's not, in our respectful submission, justice according to law to say to someone, 'well you've been convicted, we're now going to punish you by expelling you from the parliament',' he said. 'We submit that the [common law] privilege doesn't work that way.' Craig Lenehan SC, who appeared on behalf of Labor MP Ron Hoenig, disputed this. 'It's obviously open to a legislative body to form a view that a member convicted by a jury of a serious sex offence should be expelled,' he told the court. He also disputed that the motion to expel Ward was 'some sort of illicit punitive purpose', arguing there was no evidence of this. King told the court the parliament should at least hold off until after 19 September, when Ward is due to be sentenced. 'If he's acquitted,' he said, referring to the fact the matter is now under appeal, 'and he's lost all the rights that an innocent man would otherwise have, his career has been trashed.'
Daily Mail
23 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Tears flow in court in VERY emotional scenes at the Outback Wrangler trial - as wife, widow and witness all weep for beloved Willow killed in tragic chopper crash amid new revelations
The first witness in Outback Wrangler Matt Wright 's trial wept in court after he was quizzed about the dead man at the centre of the case, Chris 'Willow' Wilson. NT Crocodile King Michael 'Mick' Burns broke down in tears after prosecutor Jason Gullaci asked if he had been close to the daredevil crocodile egg-collector. Willow's widow Dani, who has been a regular at court, also wiped tears from her face as Mr Burns sobbed in the witness box. Wright, who has pleaded not guilty to three counts of attempting to pervert the course of justice, bowed his head to his knees and looked straight down. Wright's wife Kaia also needed tissues during the emotional courtroom scenes. Mr Wilson was suspended in a 30m sling beneath a Robinson R44 helicopter to pluck the eggs from croc nests when it crashed on February 28, 2022. The helicopter, referred to as 'IDW' in the trial, crashed in a paperbark swamp near King River, a remote part of West Arnhem Land, 500km east of Darwin. The father-of-two allegedly fell more than 5m to his death in the tragedy. Wright, 45, denies accusations he attempted to meddle with the investigation in the aftermath of the horror tragedy which left pilot Seb Robinson, who the jury was told was a 'recreational cocaine user', a paraplegic. The jury was earlier told the former Netflix croc celebrity was caught discussing a plot to destroy the character and reputation of Mr Robinson. Mr Gullaci said a covert recording between Wright and associate Jai Tomlinson where they discussed a plot to tarnish the former pilot will be played to the jury. The Victorian-based silk read excerpts of the recording made in September 2025, in which Mr Tomlinson and Wright discus the paraplegic pilot. 'I'll just say he's a s*** pilot,' Wright allegedly said. 'Yeah, work on his character,' Mr Tomlinson allegedly responded. In a previous conversation covertly recorded at Wright's Queensland home on September 23, 2022, the wrangler and Tomlinson discussed the investigation. 'Oh, yeah, now, but now everyone's f***ing now they are starting to put the pressure on everyone,' Wright allegedly said. 'You know, they would start squealing.' Tomlinson allegedly responded: 'One's word against another.' The jury previously heard allegations Wright visited Mr Robinson at a Queensland hospital on March 11 and March 13 2022 to pressure his former pilot into altering flight hour records. Mr Gullaci alleged Wright brought a Maintenance Release (MR) document for Mr Robinson's helicopter known as 'ZXZ'. At the first visit on March 11, Wright asked Mr Robinson to take some hours of the crashed 'IDW' and put them onto his 'ZXZ' helicopter. Kaia and Mr Robinson's mother Noelene Chellingworth and brother Zac Chellingworth were also present during the first visit. The court heard Wright left the document at the hospital for Mr Robinson to sign before he returned on March 13. Mr Gullaci told the jury Mr Robinson's uncle James Carew partially recorded the conversation between Wright and the paraplegic pilot. 'He wanted him to falsely take those hours,' Mr Gullaci said. Mr Gullaci repeated his reference from yesterday that Wright was 'no Robinson Crusoe' before adding a lot of helicopter operators had lax flight hour recording practises. The 14-person jury was told Mr Chellingworth heard Wright say during a hospital visit that he needed Mr Robinson 'to take 1520 hours off IDW and put them on ZXZ because they were hours unaccounted for'. 'I just need those hours from that machine... just as long as Sebby signs, Sebby has to sign for that, where does he sign,' Wright was allegedly captured on the recording. The prosecution also alleged Wright 'never produced' the original Maintenance Release document for IDW despite being requested by authorities to do so. It's also alleged Wright ordered Mr Tomlinson to destroy the MR with those orders allegedly caught on a covert recording. The court heard Wright allegedly told Mr Tomlinson he would likely find the MR in a box marked 'office' at his company base in the NT. 'Just torch it, I don't know where it is,' Wright allegedly told Mr Tomlinson. 'I reckon CASA [Civil Aviation Safety Authority] are chasing the original to set us up, I don't remember signing it... just burn the c***.' Mr Burns commenced giving evidence shortly after the prosecution completed its trial opening and lead defence barrister David Edwardson KC gave a brief response. The experienced croc farmer and egg collector known locally as NT's Crocodile King told the jury how he flew to the crash site with Wright and former NT cop Neill Melon as soon as heard about the accident. Mr Burns said he had flown to Darwin on the morning of the crash but returned as fast as he could to the scene. He said the first thing he did when he arrived was to see his 'great mate Willow'. The emotionally-charged courtroom heard how Mr Burns flew in a CareFlight with Mr Wilson's body then spoke to his parents. The court heard on Wednesday that Wright was probed for his alleged actions following the crash, between March and September 2022, in Darwin and other locations. At the centre of the case is the allegation that Wright impeded the investigation in the months following the fatal crash. Prosecutors allege Wright did not properly follow maintenance rules for his helicopters and had attempted to conceal this after the crash. On Wednesday, Mr Gullaci told the jury that multiple conversations Wright had with his wife were covertly recorded, including one discussion which occurred on September 22, 2022. The jury heard Kaia asked her husband that if he was being honest, how many hours did he believe IDW had been overflown? Mr Gullaci explained the model of helicopter involved in the crash needed to be scrapped, or undertake a $400,000 overhaul, once it reached 2,200 recorded flight hours. The jury also heard the helicopter needed to be serviced every 50 hours, according to Australian aviation regulations. In the recording, the jury heard Wright said: 'A couple of hundred, I think, ten percent… I think 200.' Mr Gullaci also said Wright and his wife discussed how he didn't properly log hours, and he didn't even own a 'f***ing book', which the jury heard was meant to mean a helicopter flight hours logbook. Wright also feared video footage of his helicopters taken during TV production and other times could lead investigators to conclude the recorded flight times did not correlate. Mr Gullaci said Wright, in his role as owner and chief pilot of Helibrook, was motivated to cover his tracks because he hadn't kept proper records. The jury heard allegations Helibrook pilots regularly failed to record flight hours and Wright ordered pilots not to record to flight hours. Mr Gullaci said it was the prosecution case Wright had a motivation to 'actively' meddle with the investigation because he believed if his under-recording of hours was uncovered could be considered a reason for the deadly crash. The jury heard IDW was registered to fly with Helibrook in 2020 and a company owned by Wright purchased when it had 1,594 hours on the clock and when it crashed it had 2,070 recorded hours – 130 hours under the threshold. The prosecution alleged the helicopter had flown more than 2,200 hours and Wright had attempted to cover the bogus numbers up. Mr Gullaci acknowledged slinging for croc eggs was 'incredibly brave and risky and dangerous due to the remote nature of the job. Mr Gullaci also stressed that Wright was not responsible for the death of Mr Wilson or Mr Robinson's serious injury. The court also heard Wright and the other men including Mr Burns who rushed to the accident scene in another helicopter was also 'incredibly brave'. Mr Gullaci acknowledged slinging for croc eggs was 'incredibly brave and risky and dangerous due to the remote nature of the job. Mr Gullaci also stressed that Wright was not responsible for the death of Mr Wilson or Mr Robinson's serious injury. The court also heard Wright and two other men rushed to the accident scene in another helicopter which was also 'incredibly brave'. Other witnesses in the trial will include the pilots, as well as fellow TV crew members, major Top End business figures and crocodile egg collectors. Wright's lead role in Outback Wrangler - before launching his Netflix and Channel Nine spin-off - was believed to have earned him at least $250,000 per season. Wild Croc Territory featured Wright as both the main star and executive producer, working alongside his agent, Nick Fordham, further boosting his income. However, the first season of the show, which co-starred Mr Wilson, was derailed by the tragic crash that led to his death. After the accident, Netflix continued to stream the first season of Wild Croc Territory despite a request from Ms Wilson to cease, but a planned second season for 2023 has never aired. Wright previously had endorsement deals with Ariat, Yokohama Tyres Australia and Otis Eyewear. Tourism Australia also dropped him as a 'Friends of Australia' ambassador. The trial at the Northern Territory Supreme Court in Darwin continues.
