Umpire howler gifts Lachie Schultz first goal against Fremantle Dockers as Nick Riewoldt blows up
Amid a high-quality first half between finals fancies Fremantle and Collingwood at the home of footy, a bizarre umpiring decision stole the headlines.
Dockers defender Karl Worner was penalised for making high contact with Schultz during a tackle and dutifully stood the mark inside 50 despite clearly being bemused by the call.
Worner remained silent as he looked over his shoulder at the big screen, watching the replay of the incident with the crowd.
However, what he saw triggered his frustrations as he threw his head back and gestured towards the big screen.
It prompted umpire John Howorth to blow the whistle and pay a 50-metre penalty, stating '50 metres, point at scoreboard'.
Former St Kilda champion Nick Riewoldt exclaimed 'all my gosh' on the broadcast before scolding the call.
'That's just ridiculous and selective umpiring that,' he said on Channel 7.
'We saw a game last night, Clayton Oliver was way more demonstrative.'
Riewoldt made a further tongue-in-cheek remark later in the second term, suggesting Mason Cox should avoid looking towards the scoreboard after giving away a free kick in Fremantle's attacking half.
The umpire's decision marred an otherwise entertaining start to the mouth-watering contest, which included Pat Voss kicking four first-half goals while Pies small forward Jamie Elliott soccered a goal out of thin air as he chases Cat Jeremy Cameron for the Coleman Medal.
Scores were level minutes before the long break.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
7NEWS
5 hours ago
- 7NEWS
Kade Simpson chairs off Sam Docherty in Carlton veteran's emotional goodbye to footy
Sam Docherty has been reunited with a popular former teammate for an emotional goodbye to footy at the MCG on Thursday night. The Blues' 9.7 (61) to 13.7 (85) loss to Hawthorn sounded the final siren on the ex-Carlton skipper's AFL career following his retirement announcement earlier in the week. Despite the result Docherty's third-quarter goal proved a highlight before he was chaired off alongside Jacob Weitering, playing his 200th game, after the match. Blues great turned Hawthorn assistant coach Kade Simpson crossed the divide to carry Docherty alongside his other great mate Patrick Cripps. 'This is a pretty special moment,' Luke Hodge said in commentary for Channel 7. Docherty followed the farewell by immediately running back out onto the ground to thank the Carlton cheer squad one last time. He retires as one of the most admired players in the league after overcoming three ACL injuries and two bouts of testicular cancer. 'Strange feeling, to be honest. It's all I've done for 14 years — I don't really know how to sum it up at the moment,' Docherty told Channel 7. 'Amazing to have all my friends, family (here), share the game with Weiters, chair-off with Simmo, it's about as good as I could've felt other than getting the win. 'Strange feeling not coming in next week or having to do any recovery after this but I've had a career I'm pretty proud of, happy to go and relax and do some other stuff for a while.' Docherty was celebrated with a presentation in the rooms, surrounded by his wife, two children and their family. 'The finality of it — it's quite jarring,' AFL great Nick Riewoldt said post-game. 'That whole chapter of your life is over. In Sam's case you walk away with really an unprecedented level of respect because of the challenges that he's faced. 'Pretty special to be going home with your family to embark on that next chapter.' It took some time for Carlton to show some fight for the No.15 in his final game, with the playing group clearly limping to the end of the season after a horror campaign. The Blues had just one goal to their name and trailed by nearly 40 points early in the second quarter. Hawthorn's sixth win from seven outings strengthened their grip on a top-eight spot and kept them firmly in top-four contention with a 13-6 record. Jack Gunston (three goals), Calsher Dear, Mitch Lewis and Nick Watson (two each) shared the load in attack for Hawthorn. Will Day made a successful return from a foot injury with 15 disposals on limited minutes, and hauled in a spectacular mark over Lachie Fogarty. Fellow Hawks midfielder Jai Newcombe was subbed out in the third term — described as 'managed' by the club — after a second successive quiet performance. Dylan Moore (27 touches), Jarman Impey (25) and Josh Ward (22) were all busy.
News.com.au
6 hours ago
- News.com.au
Retiring star Sam Docherty ‘put on a poster' in huge Calsher Dear grab
Calsher Dear clearly didn't get the memo about cherished Carlton star Sam Docherty's last game in the AFL. Docherty had tears flowing across the footy world earlier this week as the man who beat cancer twice announced Thursday night's clash with Hawthorn would be his 184th and last for the Blues. The 31-year-old was a huge part of the pre-game build-up on Fox Footy and was mentioned on the Carlton banner alongside Jacob Weitering in his 200th game. But once the game got underway, 19-year-old Dear did all he could to steal the show. The rangy 195cm youngster, pick 56 in the 2023 draft who is the son of Norm Smith medallist and premiership winner Paul Dear, was playing just his 21st game for the Hawks. Watch Calsher Dear's mark in the video player above With 30 seconds remaining in a dominant first quarter for Hawthorn, Dear put his stamp on the contest – and his legs on poor Docherty's shoulders – in a sensational grab in the goalsquare. Another veteran in Jack Gunston had a shot on goal from right on the 50m arc fall short and Dear read it best, soaring through the air to take the mark at full stretch as the commentators lost their minds. 'Gunston from on 50. Right to the top of goal, oh Calsher Dear!' Mark Howard said on Fox Footy. 'A young man with a big fly!' Jack Riewoldt added: 'Ah, that was a hanger. That was huge.' From the sideline, Brad Johnson referenced the commentary from Alex Jesaulenko's famous mark when he said: 'You beauty guys. How good was that?' Dear had a strong rookie campaign last season, making 17 appearances for the Hawks and kicking 25 goals, picking up a Rising Star nomination along the way. He was featuring in just his fourth game of 2025 against the Blues, missing the first four months of the season due to a back issue. The club has carefully managed the young forward, who had an extended stint in the VFL and is now playing his third straight AFL game as the finals loom. He took the term 'rising star' to a whole new level on Thursday night and David King was glowing about the youngster's future as the Hawks took a five-goal lead into halftime. 'He's the wildcard,' King said. 'He's the one, I mentioned in the pre-game I just think he's got a big game in him. 'Whether it's tonight or the next couple of weeks, it's been two weeks back in this line-up, he's kicked 5.2 coming into tonight and he just looks lively. 'This is a big hang. A big hang.' Riewoldt then spared a thought for Docherty, who was the unfortunate step ladder to help Dear pull off the superb mark. 'Sam Docherty, in his last game, has been put on a poster by Calsher Dear in what, game 21,' the Richmond great said. 'It's a weird and wonderful game footy.' Dear's name was quickly trending on social media, with many commenting on the mark. The official AFL account tweeted a video with the caption: 'Calsher Dear said it was time to fly.' An account called @whinacooperrr wrote: 'Just give Calsher Dear (mark of the year) now omfg.' Fox Footy said: 'Calsher Dear with a HUGE HANG ... on the retiring Sam Docherty.' 7AFL wrote in all caps: 'Calsher Dear might never come down.' Leo Barry got a reference when @dazzb65 tweeted: 'Calsher Dear. You Star.' A Hawthorn fan quipped: 'How's the weather up there Calsher Dear?? WOW.' X account Americans Watching The Footy was feeling for the retiring Carlton star, writing: ''See, that's why I'm retiring' – Sam Docherty.'
The Australian
8 hours ago
- The Australian
AFL: Suns seeking QClash redemption after heavy loss to Crows
Sick of hearing 'how crap' they are, the Gold Coast Suns have the perfect chance to 'change the narrative' by beating premiers Brisbane in Saturday's QClash. While the Suns have won 11 of their 17 matches to remain on track to play finals football for the first time in the club's history, an embarrassing 61-point loss to Adelaide last Sunday has raised doubts about their ability to finish the season in the top eight. Gold Coast coach Damien Hardwick believes the ideal way to respond is with a win over the second-placed Lions this weekend at People First Stadium. Gold Coast coach Damien Hardwick wants the Suns to lift against Brisbane. Picture: James Elsby/AFL Photos via Getty Images 'We're still in the race for something that we have never achieved, so we're really looking forward to that challenge,' Hardwick said on Thursday. 'As a coaching group and as a playing group, we've got a big step this week. We've got to take care of this step, then we'll sit there and take the next one this week. 'There's no greater test than the mob we're playing this week. The way they play the game is a great style of footy – combative, high pressure, high contest. 'What's really improved over the last six weeks is their handball game. Those Ashcroft boys (Will and Levi), (Jaspa) Fletcher and all those sorts of players have certainly helped with that, Lachie Neale's always been a star at it. The challenge is firmly set for our midfielders to respond. 'We get to test how far we've come in six days. The great thing about the very best sides is you know exactly how they play. 'Stopping them is the next part of the equation and we're looking forward to that challenge.' Despite having only taken charge of the Suns last year, Hardwick is well aware of how the Gold Coast has been portrayed since joining the AFL competition in 2011. Suns star Matt Rowell (front) is tackled by Brisbane co-captain Lachie Neale during the Lions' QClash win in May. Picture:'Everyone, for a long period of time, has told us how crap we are, (that) we're no good, (that we) don't deserve to be here,' the former Richmond three-time premiership-winning coach said. 'You know what? We're about changing that narrative. It's not the same old Suns, it's the brand new Suns.' Hardwick said the top-eight was now 'probably 90 per cent a race in nine', with the ninth-placed Western Bulldogs trailing the Suns – who have played one game less – by four points. 'We've got a game in hand which is the challenging thing with the ladder and the swings and roundabouts that we have … (but) we've just got to keep ticking off as many wins as we can to make sure that we aim for that first finals campaign,' he said. Hardwick also addressed speculation that Carlton forward Charlie Curnow wanted to join the Suns next season, 'We can understand that people hopefully want to come here and want to join in on this journey. We're looking to bring the very best players to our footy club,' he said. Marco Monteverde Sports reporter Marco Monteverde is a Brisbane-based sports reporter for NCA Newswire. He worked in a similar role for The Courier-Mail from 2007 to 2020. During a journalism career of more than 25 years, he has also worked for The Queensland Times, The Sunshine Coast Daily, The Fraser Coast Chronicle and The North West Star. He has covered three FIFA World Cups and the 2000 Sydney Olympics, as well as a host of other major sporting events in Australia and around the world. @marcothejourno Marco Monteverde
