logo
But What if 'Balloon Boy' Wasn't a Hoax?

But What if 'Balloon Boy' Wasn't a Hoax?

Yahoo18-07-2025
When filmmaker Gillian Pachter watched the 2009 'Balloon Boy' saga unfold live, she told The Hollywood Reporter, 'I couldn't take my eyes away.'
Same.
More from The Hollywood Reporter
First-Time Nominee Cooper Koch Is "Devastated" Over Emmy Snubs for Two of His 'Monsters' Co-Stars
Bela Bajaria on Which Emmy Nominee She Texted First and One Giant "Disappointment" of a Snub
Cristin Milioti, First-Time Emmy Nominee for 'The Penguin,' is "Ready to Get in There Again"
'I was scared, I but I was also very aware of how, like, special and strange it was that I was watching a livestream, you know?' the director of Trainwreck: Balloon Boy says about the next chapter in Netflix's excellent Trainwreck documentary, the anthology series that revisits headline-making events gone wrong. 'Livestreaming was new, and I just couldn't believe how clearly I could see it.'
After all, the streaming giant only just recently nailed that livestreaming thing itself.
On Oct. 15, 2009, Americans tuned in — however they could — to follow the insane and terrifying flight of Richard Heene's experimental weather balloon/flying saucer. Heene's 6-year-old son, Falcon Heene, was believed to be inside the contraption when it became untethered from the ground. As it turns out, Falcon was actually hiding in the garage attic and supposedly napped through the whole ordeal, which turned out to be no big ordeal at all — until later, when it was deemed a hoax perpetrated by inventor, amateur scientist and guy-who-acted-like-an-insane-asshole-once-on-an-episode-of-Wife Swap, Richard Heene.
Ultimately, Richard Heene pleaded guilty to a felony charge of attempting to influence a public servant; his wife Mayumi Heene pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor charge of false reporting to authorities. And then a decade later, weirdly and seemingly out of nowhere, the Heenes' crimes were pardoned by the governor of Colorado.
'And I thought, 'My God,'' Pachter recalled. 'You always wonder, when people get pardoned, like, does that mean we got it wrong? Why were they chosen [to be pardoned]? Because they were so vilified.'
Maybe… it wasn't a hoax?
'I also have a little boy who was about the same age, and I thought, 'What kind of dad even pretends that his son is maybe going to fall out of balloon and die?'' she continued. 'I mean, that's just such a bizarre thing to even think — if you're going to choose a hoax, why entertain the fantasy that your own child is in mortal danger?'
The Heenes now say they pleaded guilty out of concern that Mayumi could be deported if they didn't play ball.
'The more I talked to [Richard], the more I started wondering if my understanding of the story was everything there was to know, and if there weren't other truths behind it that I wasn't aware of,' Pachter told THR.
That phrase 'other truths' looms large in our 'fake news' era, 16 years removed from 'Balloon Boy.' Read our Q&A with Pachter below; the Balloon Boy installment of Trainwreck is available now on Netflix.
***
So do you believe it was a hoax, or do you think it was real?
Sorry to be coy but look, if I didn't think there was a very strong possibility that we got it wrong, and the thing wasn't actually a hoax but a real panicked call to the sheriff because these people thought their son was up there — if I didn't think that was a strong possibility, there would have been no point making the film, right? It's not just a documentary that looks back at a crazy day in our social history — it is looking back to see whether we got it right or whether we got it wrong.
There's a lot of evidence on both sides, and all the voices are in it. I guess I just feel really strongly that — I put everyone in there and I want people to look at it again, and I want people to hear from everybody. I want them to try to come to their own conclusion about who's right and who's wrong. Because the truth is in the heart of Richard Heene, right? It's kind of unprovable. The question is, 'What was in his heart when he called the sheriff? Was he lying or was he really panicked?' You're not going to be able to actually prove that, so you're going to have to just listen to people tell their truths and see who you believe.
The turning point in the public's perception was when Falcon, asked on a live CNN interview why he didn't come out of hiding if he heard his family calling for him, says, 'You guys said that we did this for the show.' The media took that as a clear admission of a hoax, but in hindsight — and now as a parent myself — he was also just a tuned-out little boy.
I have a very similar thought. 'What news story has ever flipped on 10 words uttered by a 6 year old?' I can't think of another. It wouldn't be admissible in court, it's not evidence. There's no way that could be taken seriously in any form of criminal process at all. And yet it completely flips the public's view and the sheriff's view. I was sort of dying. If only we had been able to turn back time and say, as a follow up question, 'Falcon, when you say, 'You said, we did this for the show' — which show are you talking about?' If there had been about five more sentences, even from a 6 year old, you might have been able to get to grips with it. But like, 10 words, which were 'You guys said we did this for the show' — I'm just astonished that people think they know what that means. Because I have no idea what that means.
When I was asking the Heenes about it, they have various explanations, but their initial one is, 'I have no idea why he said that.' Everybody needs them to have this . And they did sort of search for and find — according to them — this explanation of Falcon getting confused with the reporters that were around in the aftermath. But actually, it seemed like the most genuine response for them was, like, 'He said dumb shit all the time. We had no idea what he was talking about or why he would be under that impression.' That, to me, is very realistic. As somebody who has had a 6-year-old boy, I just don't understand why people were so sure they knew what that meant. Because I'm not.
You told me Richard wasn't hard to find — in general, is it easier to get access to your documentary subjects these days than it used to be?
I think it's actually gotten harder. It's not like the Heene family was particularly naive about the media. They were really hard-nosed and really suspicious, and they were really not interested in getting involved with anybody that was in the media. So it was actually years of talking to each other.
People aren't stupid, and they can tell whether you're sincere or not. I was sincerely open to them in a way that people who had approached them before were not. I wasn't faking it, and they knew that. At the end of the day, it's not a documentary about me and my opinions, it's a platform [on which] they tell their full story, and so does everybody else. But I did think there was cause to give them that opportunity.
Are you friends with Richard at this point?
Richard and I are incredibly different. I really like him. He's not a straightforward person, he's not an easy person. He's not even a consistent person. I wouldn't have sunk all this time into that family if I didn't find them massively engaging and fascinating, and if I didn't actually like them. I don't think I've ever made a program about anybody I didn't like. [I'm] very drawn to getting to know somebody who maybe a lot of people don't like, and seeing what they dislike in them. So I think there's a lot to like in him — and the boys are great — charming, smart. It's really funny to have met them as adults when I saw this home-video stuff of them when they were crazy little kids.
Richard was an asshole , but that may not be the best format to judge anybody. He's a really smart guy, maybe a bit tortured…
The sort of essence that I found really engaging is a classic American archetype. He's a dreamer, right? Some people would see him as a con man, which is another classic American archetype. But I see him as a dreamer. Here's this guy who was not formally educated to be a scientist — [he's] incredibly inventive, crazy out-of-the-box thinking. The whole flying saucer thing was that it was going to be this dirigible that was going to replace cars, and we're going to be like The Jetsons and be commuting to work on these things. You have to just love that totally outrageous, outsized imagination. And everything with that family was so outsized, and that is wonderful. And it all went wrong, but it's still wonderful to have done the crazy things, which is what that family has always done.
They're a crazy family, but they also seem like a lovely family that does everything together.
And they still do. They're really, really tight. They're very uniquely bonded.
Did Richard have any -esque blowups with you?
No. He did pull out on the morning of filming, but that's less uncommon than you would think in my line of work. He's very moody… you never totally know where you [stand]. So I didn't even know until the cameras were rolling that we were going to really be able to make this. But no, if he had ever shouted at me, I wouldn't have stood for that — but I felt that we were very familiar with each other by that point.
He did have these incredibly fierce dogs that kept on throwing themselves at me, which was distracting. So I was not being attacked by Richard Heene, but I was definitely being attacked by his dogs.
Dangerous dogs or yappy dogs?
I'm not a great judge — I'm not a dog person. I feel like, if it has fangs and it's taller than I am on its hind legs and it's coming at me [in a way that's] not like a hug… but I don't really know dogs.
***
Trainwreck: Balloon Boy is now streaming on Netflix.
Best of The Hollywood Reporter
'The Studio': 30 Famous Faces Who Play (a Version of) Themselves in the Hollywood-Based Series
22 of the Most Shocking Character Deaths in Television History
A 'Star Wars' Timeline: All the Movies and TV Shows in the Franchise
Solve the daily Crossword
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Amazon MGM Studio's James Bond film names ‘Peaky Blinders' writer
Amazon MGM Studio's James Bond film names ‘Peaky Blinders' writer

USA Today

time25 minutes ago

  • USA Today

Amazon MGM Studio's James Bond film names ‘Peaky Blinders' writer

The upcoming James Bond movie now has a writer attached to the project. Steven Knight, who has penned projects like Eastern Promises, Apple TV+'s See, Locke and Netflix's wildly popular Peaky Blinders series, was announced as the script writer on Thursday afternoon. He will join director Denis Villeneuve on the highly-anticipated project. David Heyman and Amy Pascal have signed on to produce the project, the first Bond movie in its new home at Amazon MGM Studios. Amazon acquired MGM in 20212, taking control of the extensive collection of 007 movies. It wasn't until February of 2025, however, that the studio was able to negotiate a deal for the rights to the creative control of the character. There has not been a new James Bond announced yet, but the search is apparently on. That hasn't stopped fans from coming up with their own theories on who could take over the mantle from Daniel Craig. Names like Idris Elba, Damson Idris, Callum Turner, Aaron Taylor-Johnson, Theo James, Tom Holland, Jacob Elordi and Harris Dickinson have all been in the online conversation. Craig became Bond in 2006's Casino Royale and went on to star in five total movies as 007. His final outing as the dapper spy was in 2021 with No Time To Die.

Chaos, comedy, and chemistry: Seth Rogen and Rose Byrne ready to take Apple TV+'s ‘Platonic' to a new level in Season 2
Chaos, comedy, and chemistry: Seth Rogen and Rose Byrne ready to take Apple TV+'s ‘Platonic' to a new level in Season 2

Yahoo

time26 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Chaos, comedy, and chemistry: Seth Rogen and Rose Byrne ready to take Apple TV+'s ‘Platonic' to a new level in Season 2

Seth Rogen is taking a timeout from promoting his Emmy-contending The Studio to moonlight on his other Apple TV+ comedy series. Rogen and costar Rose Byrne headlined Wednesday's premiere of Season 2 of Platonic. The streamer transformed the Hammer Museum in Los Angeles into a celebration of the show, which follows Will (Rogen) and Sylvia (Byrne) as they rekindle their friendship later in life. The series abides by its title and shows what a non-romantic relationship can look like in adulthood, when partners, children and careers often take center stage. More from Gold Derby Who is Lynette Howell Taylor? 5 fun facts about the new Academy president 'Spinal Tap II: The End Continues': Everything to know about the mockumentary sequel and its soundtrack as new 'Stonehenge' drops Rogen says he's grateful for having two vastly different projects occupying his time. 'To me, it does create a lovely balance,' he tells Gold Derby. 'I love doing this type of comedy, which is a little more slice of life, a little more improvisationally based, and a little more casual in some ways. But to that point, it's much more relatable to the average person than The Studio is, I think, in a lot of ways. 'Honestly, I conceived of The Studio knowing I was also doing Platonic. The ability to do something that's highly regimented and planned and blocked within an inch of its life, and is about precision [like The Studio], to then something like [Platonic], which is about comedians and finding the scenes, and improvising. … To me, doing both is a really lovely gift.' Byrne, whose character Sylvia dealt with marital struggles in Season 1 thanks to her friendship with Will, credits Rogen with helping her hone her comedic chops. 'Seth is funny on a molecular level,' she said. 'He breathes and lives and walks comedy in a way. I didn't come from standup or improv or Groundlings, so to have chemistry with someone who comes from that world is so fun and exciting. I'm always kind of in that orbit, in his gravitational comedic pull. We have a really fun time and it's an unusual coupling, obviously, but it's kind of not too, if you really know us. We're pretty low-key. We're both from the Commonwealth [of Canada] and we like to work, and we work well together. But comedy's so hard, so when you do have that chemistry, you really do go back to that source.' Directors, cocreators and cowriters Nick Stoller and Francesca Delbanco think that Platonic Season 2 showcases how Rogen, Byrne, and the ensemble can turn tough shoots into comedy gold. 'We cross-board the season because we direct everything, so it's totally out of order when we shoot stuff,' Stoller says. 'We shot one of the scenes that's towards the very end of the season in the first week and it didn't matter because everyone knows their characters and what kind of stories they're telling.' Delbanco agreed, saying, 'We really felt like we hit the ground running this season. Everybody knew what they wanted to do and how they wanted to approach it.' Luke Macfarlane, who plays Sylvia's lawyer husband, Charlie, got the chance to live out a dream this season thanks to his character's participation on a beloved quiz show that might or might not have been famously hosted by the late Alex Trebek. Does Macfarlane think he could successfully compete on the television staple? 'We all watch the unnamed, very popular game show,' he said. 'I think I would do pretty well on it, but we all watch this show and think we have the answers when we would flounder in real life.' As the ensemble made its way along the carpet and was asked to describe the new season in one word, there was one incredibly popular response: 'Chaotic.' Season 2 of Platonic airs Aug. 6 on Apple TV+. Best of Gold Derby 'Five new life forms from distant planets': Everything to know about 'Alien: Earth' as new trailer drops Everything to know about 'The Pitt' Season 2, including the departure of Tracy Ifeachor's Dr. Collins Everything to know about 'Too Much,' Lena Dunham's Netflix TV show starring Megan Stalter that's kinda, sorta 'based on a true story' Click here to read the full article. Solve the daily Crossword

10 Best Fake Songs From Fake Movie Bands
10 Best Fake Songs From Fake Movie Bands

Gizmodo

timean hour ago

  • Gizmodo

10 Best Fake Songs From Fake Movie Bands

This summer has seen some pretty catchy needle drops in movies, from Superman's Mighty Crabjoys to KPop Demon Hunters flash mob fandoms for Huntr/x and the Saja Boys. The latter Netflix release has reached not only Billboard music charts but also become the most streamed animated feature ever. With that in mind, we look back at our favorite fake bands' best songs of the past 30 years. While half the list includes incredible recent music from hit movies, the other half (and our number one slot) nod at the songs that really propelled this particular niche in movies—think A Goofy Movie. So, if you notice some of your favorites missing, simmer down because we excluded musicals and kept to genre movies that had original songs featured in them. Like Superman, we can't help but think this song is for the cool kids. No matter how hard we tried, we could not get 'Try Everything' out of our heads, and Gazelle (voiced by Shakira) might be back in Zootopia 2. Finally, the full single from Freaky Friday has been released for Freakier Friday sung by Pink Slip's in-universe lead singer Christina Vidal Mitchell. Josie and the Pussycats was such an underrated gem when it came out but was formative for millennials. We know there are so many songs, and it was hard to narrow it to one, so we went with 'Three Small Words' (featuring Kay Hanley as the voice of lead singer Josie), which encompasses the moment in time this movie embodies for a generation. Sammie (Miles Caton) in the Sinners universe went on to become a blues legend, but the night that changed his life was when he first performed 'I Lied to You.' The scene is hands down one of Ryan Coogler's masterpieces, and the music sizzles off the celluloid fever dream… just watch. It took a few years, but the Envy Adams (Brie Larson) on-screen performance of the Clash at Demonhead's 'Black Sheep' was finally released on Spotify and other platforms to enjoy. We love Metric's version, but the angst in the movie version is top tier. The Billie Eilish and Finneas-produced songs from Pixar's Turning Red are all so good. This one was also hard to narrow down, but the chorus of 'Nobody Like U' is never not on my mind. The KPop Demon Hunters soundtrack also has too many killer songs from each band to pick from. While I particularly love 'Soda Pop,' we have to give the Saja Boys props for 'Your Idol' for charting on Billboard. In 'Golden,' we get lyricist Ejae's heart and soul shining through. The powerful anthem is coming for 'Let It Go''s crown in replayability among young animation fans. Powerline is the blueprint, the O.G. of modern fake music pop stars thanks to A Goofy Movie. Vocalist Tevin Campbell made an icon so scene-stealing we're still waiting for a full Powerline album 30 years later… or at least a sequel with more fake music to dance to. Want more io9 news? Check out when to expect the latest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what's next for the DC Universe on film and TV, and everything you need to know about the future of Doctor Who.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store