State pays Denis O'Brien €5.8m over legal costs related to Moriarty Tribunal
BILLIONAIRE BUSINESSMAN DENIS O'Brien has received €5.8m from the State Claims Agency for legal costs associated with the Moriarty Tribunal.
O'Brien, a mogul in Ireland's communications and media industries, gave evidence at the tribunal on nearly two dozen occasions between 2001 and 2010.
The
Irish Independent
has reported that the payment to settle O'Brien's costs application is the largest of its kind that has ever been given to a tribunal witness in the history of the State.
The State Claims Agency, which is administering the large payment to O'Brien, is responsible for managing claims for costs that are taken against the State.
A spokesperson for the agency said it 'does not comment on individual claims' when contacted today by
The Journal
.
The costs claim relates to the Moriarty Tribunal, known formally as the Tribunal of Inquiry into certain Payments to Politicians and Related Matters.
Advertisement
The tribunal was established in 1997 to examine payments made to former Taoiseach Charles Haughey and to Michael Lowry, a former Fine Gael Minister for Communications and current independent TD for Tipperary North.
It concluded that Lowry had an 'insidious and pervasive' influence over the awarding of Ireland's second mobile phone licence in the 1990s to O'Brien's company Esat Digifone.
The 2011 tribunal report said that Lowry gave 'substantive information' to O'Brien that was 'of significant value and assistance to him in securing the licence' and said that O'Brien made two secret payments to Lowry in 1996 and 1999 totalling £500,000 and supported a loan of £420,000 given to Lowry in 1999.
O'Brien rejected the findings of the tribunal, claiming it was grounded in 'opinions' and did not amount to findings of evidence, fact or law. Lowry claimed the tribunal's report was 'factually wrong and deliberately misleading'.
An investigation by gardaí in the Criminal Assets Bureau following the tribunal's findings, which were published in 2011, has been ongoing for years.
In January, gardaí confirmed that a
file has been sent to the Director of Public Prosecutions
on the matter.
O'Brien and the State are currently being sued by Persona Digital Telephony Limited and Sigma Wireless Networks limited, who were unsuccessful bidders for the phone licence in the 90s. In January, a High Court judge issued an order to O'Brien in relation to
document discovery in the case
.
With reporting from Jane Moore
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Irish households' €160bn in savings could be unlocked to fund new homes
The Government should establish a State-backed housing investment vehicle to allow households to invest their savings in housing development, the Society of Chartered Surveyors Ireland has said. The society said such an initiative, similar to schemes operating in countries such as France, would enable the Government to put long-term multi-annual housing plans in place while also facilitating investment in much-needed infrastructural projects. 'Irish households' bank deposits amount to nearly €160bn, mostly in low-interest current accounts,' said the society's new president, Gerard O'Toole. 'At the same time, access to finance remains a major barrier, especially for small and medium-sized developers.' Mr O'Toole pointed out that the State is by far the largest investor in Ireland's housing delivery — it allocated over €5bn to housing in 2024. However, he said that this level of public investment is not sustainable in the long term and the State needs to explore alternative and diversified funding streams. 'A savings fund of this nature would underpin long-term planning by providing the multi-annual funding commitments housing projects require,' he said. 'It could also support longer-term budgets for several state housing schemes, including help-to-buy and vacant property grants, which are often subject to annual funding reviews and decisions.' The Society of Chartered Surveyors Ireland (SCSI) also said the new Housing Activation Office needs to commence its work urgently on clearing the many blockages which are impeding the delivery of new housing. 'The SCSI is calling for reform of the utility connection processes and earlier engagement by Uisce Éireann and the ESB with home builders to reduce delays and prioritise essential connections for housing ready for occupation,' Mr O'Toole said. 'That is why we believe the terms of reference for the Housing Activation Office must facilitate greater collaboration and transparency. Regular and effective engagement with key industry stakeholders will be key to the success of this office.'
Extra.ie
7 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Plumbers' exam springs a leak as apprentices share questions
A state exam for plumbers was leaked, complete with answers, and widely circulated online just days before apprentices sat the test, has learned. Solas, the agency that took over State apprenticeships from Fás in 2013, expressed 'great concern' about the leak and said it is 'taking this matter very seriously'. However, a union for tradespeople this weekend said there are 'a lot of questions about the delivery of apprenticeships and standard of quality assurance' from Solas. An apprentice plumber who sat the leaked test in March told 'This is a QQI Level 6 exam – a State exam higher than the Leaving Cert – and we had questions and answers going in.' He said he was aware of the paper being shared before the exam in WhatsApp groups in at least four technological universities, where the courses are delivered, nationwide. He said he was aware of the paper being shared before the exam in WhatsApp groups in at least four technological universities, where the courses are delivered, nationwide. Pic: DenPhotos/Shutterstock 'There were lads in the class who did not turn up [for classes during the year], did not know the content, and they were getting merits and distinctions, and now they're going out into the world and plumbing,' he said. 'If you put a valve on an uncontrolled heat source, that's a bomb. Pressure builds, it explodes. People have been killed in Ireland in recent years with that. 'If you pipe gas wrong, that can lead to explosions, death. Carbon monoxide, [that can lead to] death.' The apprentice said the exact same theory exam – the final of three taken along with four 'on the job' tests for plumbing – had been used for the previous group, and that lecturers had already 'been complaining' at how 'easy' the papers are. 'The exact words were, 'A monkey would have passed the last one',' he said. 'There were three thick folders of notes, and they prepared us as best they could, covered the entire syllabus, only for the same exam to come up again, word for word. Then a few days before the exam, we got a leaked copy. 'I worked my a**e off. I spent 11 weeks studying, and then there was no need.' Asked if it was aware of the leak, Solas told 'We note this and the details from your query with great concern and are taking this matter very seriously.' Pic: Shutterstock The spokeswoman confirmed 224 people took the two-part exam on the same days in March as the apprentice who spoke to Asked what the pass rate for the exam was, and if the agency has safety concerns about potentially unskilled plumbers passing the leaked exam, the spokeswoman said: 'We are examining the matters raised in your query. Craft apprentices undergo continuous and multiple practical and written assessments throughout the seven phases of their apprenticeship to ensure that they are competent, working safely in the workplace and that their skills levels are up to date and in line with industry standards.' Assistant general secretary with Connect trade union, Brian Nolan, said he was aware of 'accusations of things that compromise the standard', including exam papers being posted on social media. He told the 'In our opinion, there's a lot of questions about the delivery of apprenticeships and the standard of quality assurance, off the job and on the job. 'We represent the workerlearners in the apprenticeships. We taught apprentices before we ever had Fás or AnCO [An Chomhairle Oiliúna, which oversaw apprenticeships until 1987]. We taught them in the workplace. 'And there's a fear here that as quality assurance is slipping, you could have these exam issues.' Mr Nolan said the course was also in danger of 'being led as academic and not vocational'. Pic: Getty Images He said he 'recently raised' the union's concerns about the exams to the Department of Higher Education. Solas said that in March, 'eight different phase 6 plumbing apprenticeship assessments were delivered, each of which was drawn from a range of different papers'. It added: 'Solas is working with its partners in the Technological Universities to identify if the assessment paper you had provided was one of the assessments delivered and if this was the case, we will agree the urgent actions needed to ensure the integrity of the assessment process.' Solas said new apprenticeship curricula 'are being implemented across all craft apprenticeship programmes' this year. 'Alongside this, new question banks for assessments are being developed and rolled out across the system. This is part of our ongoing efforts to enhance the quality and integrity of our apprenticeship programmes and ensure that they meet the highest standards,' it said. The apprentice who spoke to said plenty of apprentices fail their practical exams 'if they aren't up to scratch'. He said: 'It's not that people are just being slapped through. Lecturers are trying their best to train the next generation. 'And it's also not a plumbing issue alone – it's across all the trades. I know there was an audit into some of the electrical papers being leaked [in his institute].' There are 29,347 apprentices across 77 different Solas apprenticeship programme types.
Sunday World
12 hours ago
- Sunday World
Addict was on bail for burglary at time of alleged shoplifting spree, court told
'I stole yeah, but do you not think I need professional help?' Charles Reilly admitted he had stolen in the past to feed a persistent drug habit. A father of two and 'chronic drug user' has been remanded in custody accused of carrying out a shoplifting spree in a midlands town while on bail for burglary and theft related incidents, a court has heard. Thirty-three-year-old Charles Reilly, of River Court, Great Water Street, Longford was brought before a sitting of Longford District Court charged with stealing over €600 worth of clothes and food items from three shops in Longford town over the course of a six week period. Two of those allegedly took place on the same day, on April 11, when Mr Reilly was accused of walking into Durkins, along the town's Ballymahon Street and exiting moments later with €280 worth of men's clothing. Charles Reilly admitted he had stolen in the past to feed a persistent drug habit. Later that same day, Garda Maeve Daly said it will be the alleged Mr Reilly entered Dealz, Market Square to steal almost €50 of food items. The same discount store was allegedly targeted by the accused on May 20, she added, in an incident that resulted in the theft of almost €130 of clothes. Nine days later, Judge Deirdre Gearty was told how Mr Reilly was positively identified on CCTV selecting a number of bedding items before concealing them in a bag and covering the goods with a jacket. In all of the alleged thefts, Mr Reilly was adjudged to have passed all points of payment without making any effort to pay for the near €650 worth of goods which were taken, the contents of which remain outstanding. In a contested bail hearing, the court heard of garda objections to bail under both section 2 of the Bail Act 1997 and O'Callaghan Rules. Garda Daly said despite there being no CCTV available for the second theft which Mr Reilly stood accused of in April, he was found sporting the same attire in both incidents. The court heard how the State's rationale in registering its objection to bail being afforded to Mr Reilly was predicated on fears the sum of goods taken in the alleged thefts may be disposed of by the Longford man. Garda Daly said gardaí likewise harboured fears of possible witness intimidation, a concern which was based on the close proximity of Mr Reilly's home to the shops which had fallen foul of the alleged thefts. Judge Gearty was similarly informed of how Mr Reilly was a 'chronic drug user' and heroin addict who gardaí believed, if granted bail, had the propensity to go on and commit further crimes to feed his addiction. Charles Reilly outside Longford Courthouse. Equally, Garda Daly said the accused was on bail for an alleged burglary in Longford town in early March, in addition to bail which had been sanctioned at the end of February for an alleged theft incident. Part of those conditions, it was added, had obligated Mr Reilly to abide by daily sign on conditions, in an order he had failed to comply with since April 9. John Quinn, defending, contended those anxieties could be suitably addressed by the tabling of a 'substantial' cash lodgement in a vow which would provide the necessary incentive for his client to abide by whatever terms thee court chose to implement. Taking the stand himself, Mr Reilly pledged to adhere to those measures as he came under cross-examination from court presenter for the State, Sgt Enda Daly. 'Your health isn't good,' observed Sgt Daly, as he looked directly at Mr Reilly as he sat in the witness box. 'I know you a long time and I just don't think you look that well at the moment.' The accused, for his part agreed as he revealed how he had recently spent a period of time in hospital. In conceding the addictive challenges he was attempting to curb, Mr Reilly admitted that while he had resorted to crime in the past to feed his drug habit, he was no longer under the influence of heroin. Charles Reilly, the court heard, was already on bail in connection to separate burglary and theft incidents when he was arrested in connection to a string of thefts from retail outlets in Longford town. 'I am taking drugs, but not heroin,' he said. I ran out of money and I did steal, but thank God I am on a methadone programme now.' Sgt Daly, however, said the very fact Mr Reilly was back before the courts facing four separate theft charges indicated otherwise. 'I stole yeah, but do you not think I need professional help?' Mr Reilly snapped in response. 'Prison is not the place for me and I need help.' Judge Gearty, in delivering her verdict, said the State had been 'fully justified' in raising its objections to bail. She said despite Mr Reilly's medical ailments, for which the court empathised with, there were no meaningful conditions which could be applied in order to allay the fears which had been outlined by the State. As such, she stressed the court's decision to refuse bail was grounded on the seriousness of the charges, the strength of evidence presented, the possible intimidation of witnesses, risk of reoffending and addiction issues. He was consequently remanded in custody to appear back via video link at a sitting of Longford District Court next Tuesday (June 10). In making that order, Judge Gearty directed Mr Reilly to receive all appropriate medical attention as part of his remand. Charles Reilly admitted he had stolen in the past to feed a persistent drug habit. Today's News in 90 Seconds - 08 June 2025
