State pays Denis O'Brien €5.8m over legal costs related to Moriarty Tribunal
O'Brien, a mogul in Ireland's communications and media industries, gave evidence at the tribunal on nearly two dozen occasions between 2001 and 2010.
The
Irish Independent
has reported that the payment to settle O'Brien's costs application is the largest of its kind that has ever been given to a tribunal witness in the history of the State.
The State Claims Agency, which is administering the large payment to O'Brien, is responsible for managing claims for costs that are taken against the State.
A spokesperson for the agency said it 'does not comment on individual claims' when contacted today by
The Journal
.
The costs claim relates to the Moriarty Tribunal, known formally as the Tribunal of Inquiry into certain Payments to Politicians and Related Matters.
Advertisement
The tribunal was established in 1997 to examine payments made to former Taoiseach Charles Haughey and to Michael Lowry, a former Fine Gael Minister for Communications and current independent TD for Tipperary North.
It concluded that Lowry had an 'insidious and pervasive' influence over the awarding of Ireland's second mobile phone licence in the 1990s to O'Brien's company Esat Digifone.
The 2011 tribunal report said that Lowry gave 'substantive information' to O'Brien that was 'of significant value and assistance to him in securing the licence' and said that O'Brien made two secret payments to Lowry in 1996 and 1999 totalling £500,000 and supported a loan of £420,000 given to Lowry in 1999.
O'Brien rejected the findings of the tribunal, claiming it was grounded in 'opinions' and did not amount to findings of evidence, fact or law. Lowry claimed the tribunal's report was 'factually wrong and deliberately misleading'.
An investigation by gardaí in the Criminal Assets Bureau following the tribunal's findings, which were published in 2011, has been ongoing for years.
In January, gardaí confirmed that a
file has been sent to the Director of Public Prosecutions
on the matter.
O'Brien and the State are currently being sued by Persona Digital Telephony Limited and Sigma Wireless Networks limited, who were unsuccessful bidders for the phone licence in the 90s. In January, a High Court judge issued an order to O'Brien in relation to
document discovery in the case
.
With reporting from Jane Moore
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Colin Sheridan: I'd be the perfect president — I wouldn't interfere in anything
It is with deep humility, mild vanity, and a complete lack of preparation that I announce my intention to succeed Michael D Higgins as the next president of Ireland. This is not a decision I arrived at lightly. No, this is the result of careful reflection, at least two long runs in the Phoenix Park, and a chance encounter with a sika deer who looked at me as if to say: 'Colin, your time is now.' Some will wonder what qualifies me for the highest office in the land. Well, 26 years' service as an officer of the State and peacekeeper with the United Nations. That's longer than Netflix has existed, longer than we've had the euro, and longer than Michael D's hair has been blowing in the breeze on Áras lawns. For over a quarter of a century, I stood between opposing forces, negotiating tense stand-offs, all the while wearing a beret and looking calm in the face of unimaginable chaos. Do you know how hard it is to look good wearing a beret? This makes me uniquely suited to the presidency, where my role will be to stand between warring government factions, look concerned for the cameras, then drift off toward the canapé table without saying anything incendiary. I have no intention of interfering in anything. This is not apathy. This is strategy. Interference is the enemy of peace — I learned that in Lebanon, Liberia, and Kabul. When you've seen men point rifles at each other over an imaginary line in the sand, you learn that sometimes the greatest intervention is no intervention at all My presidency will be a masterclass in dignified, studied inaction. I will be genocide-indifferent, a welcome break from our current president, who seems to prioritise principles over politics. Such nonsense! Unlike my rival Catherine Connolly, I am, in fact, a man. This is not an attack — merely a biographical detail. She, presumably, will run on the radical ticket of 'having opinions'. I, however, will run on the far safer platform of 'not upsetting anyone'. In this increasingly polarised climate, that is no small feat. And while Catherine might speak eloquently in the Dáil, I bring something no other candidate can match: The ability to run 10km through the Phoenix Park without looking like I'm being chased. I have spent countless mornings pounding those paths, nodding at other joggers in that silent fraternity of the slightly unhinged. Running there has taught me many things about endurance, resilience, and which bushes contain ... um ... adult adventurers. Independent TD Catherine Connolly, presumably, will run on the radical ticket of 'having opinions', but Colin Sheridan doesn't want to upset anyone. Picture: Brian Lawless/PA It's also where I refine my thoughts on the central issues of my campaign: The canapés. The Irish presidency has been crying out for someone to take the State's finger food seriously. Too often have visiting dignitaries been fobbed off with a stale vol-au-vent or a micro-quiche that tastes like ambition left out in the rain. Under my leadership, the Áras will be a fortress of hors d'oeuvres excellence. There will be smoked salmon blinis that make French ambassadors weep, sausage rolls of substance, and prawn skewers that actually contain prawn. Food diplomacy is real diplomacy. I know this because I have seen ceasefires tentatively agreed over tabbouleh I have watched suspicious men in camouflage soften at the sight of a decent mini-spring roll. My canapé doctrine is simple: Feed them well and they will listen to you, or at least stop shouting long enough for the band to finish Amhrán na bhFiann. Some of you might be wondering about my 'vision' for Ireland. Here it is: To be exactly the kind of president you forget is there until you see them on the news shaking hands with someone important, at which point you think: 'Fair play, he's still going.' That's the job. This is not America. We don't want a president who interferes with policy, only with the placement of the Laphroaig at New Year's. My years with the UN have equipped me perfectly for ceremonial life. I can stand very still while being photographed. I can nod meaningfully during speeches I don't understand. I can smile politely while someone tells me their entire family history in a language I do not speak. I am also capable of remembering the names of at least three people at any given reception — a skill honed under fire, both literal and metaphorical. The Phoenix Park will, of course, remain central to my presidency. It is both my training ground and my metaphor. Just as the park contains majestic beauty, occasional chaos, and the faint smell of shit, so too will my term in office. I will invite foreign leaders to join me on runs there, at a pace slow enough to preserve diplomacy but fast enough to discourage overly long conversations about trade deficits. Critics may accuse me of lacking substance. They are correct. Most exes agree. Substance is for the Government The president's role is to be the oil painting in the nation's living room — always there, rarely the subject of an argument. I will be that oil painting, but one with excellent cardio and an eye for a decent canapé spread. Michael D Higgins has set the bar high. He is learned, articulate, and capable of quoting obscure poets at a moment's notice. I will not attempt to compete in that arena. Instead, I will focus on making guests feel welcome through my flagrant mediocrity. In summary, 26 years of peace-keeping have prepared me to maintain harmony in the Áras without lifting more than an eyebrow. I promise to interfere in absolutely nothing, unless the smoked salmon runs out, in which case all bets are off. Ireland, I stand ready. Ready to host, to smile, to run, to nod, and to preside over the greatest finger-food renaissance our Republic has ever known. If you elect me, I will bring dignity, calm, and a discreet but determined focus on the important things, chiefly, remaining indifferent in the face of global entropy. Now, if you'll excuse me, I must train. Not for the campaign trail — for the canapé table.
Irish Examiner
9 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
'Preferred bidder' found for MV Matthew berthed in Cork Harbour
Drug trafficking cargo ship the MV Matthew has cost the State almost €10m in maintenance, crewing, and berthing fees since it was intercepted in 2023. A buyer has been found for the drug trafficking ship, and the Revenue Commissioners are engaging with Panamanian authorities to ensure legal and regulatory compliance. The MV Matthew, a Panamanian-registered ship, was at the centre of the largest cocaine seizure in the history of the State. Eight men were sentenced to a combined 129 years in prison in July for their role in the drug trafficking operation in which some €157m worth of cocaine was seized. The MV Matthew, owned by a Dubai-based company, was boarded at gunpoint by Ireland's elite army ranger wing in rough seas off the Cork coast in September 2023. Eight men from the 21-person crew were ultimately charged with drug trafficking offences. The ship, which has since been berthed in Cork Harbour, has been costing an average of €120,000 each week to maintain. However, Revenue has confirmed that 'a preferred bidder has been identified' for the MV Matthew. 'Revenue is engaging with the Panamanian authorities to ensure compliance with maritime legislation and regulations that govern the disposal of the MV Matthew, and has received confirmation from them that it is receiving attention,' a statement said. 'Revenue hopes to have these matters finalised shortly. Revenue is required to ensure that all regulations and legal obligations are fully complied with throughout the disposal and removal process.' 'Far too long' Berthing the ship, which includes costs for unberthing and moving the vessel when necessary, has cost €2,187,950. Maintenance of the ship — including fuel costs, waste removal, and repairs — has cost €3,784,050. Crewing has cost 3,762,054. More than €9,734,054 has been spent on the ship in total. These costs were paid by the Revenue Commissioners to maintain and manage the MV Matthew from September 2023 to the end of July 2025. Fianna Fáil TD for Cork South Central Séamus McGrath said that the disposal of the MV Matthew is taking 'far too long'. 'The cost of keeping it on a weekly basis is extremely high,' he said. 'I doubt very much at this stage if the State will actually be any net better off as a result of the sale, given the amount of cost that was incurred in terms of the storage and maintenance of the ship.' The ship had been maintained to allow access for defence legal teams as it was at the centre of a major criminal trial. The Special Criminal Court authorised its release on December 2. It was only possible to dispose of the ship from that date. Mr McGrath said that it should have been ready for sale as soon as it was released by the courts. He said he has raised his concerns both with Revenue and with the Public Accounts Committee, and has requested further information on the sales process.
Irish Post
9 hours ago
- Irish Post
Personal loans in Ireland hit record high especially for car payments
PEOPLE taking out personal loans in Ireland hit record highs in the first quarter of 2025. Personal loans were up across all fields, particularly in car financing, according to new figures from the Banking & Payments Federation Ireland (BPFI). The newest BPFI Personal Loans Report reveals that the number of car loans increased by 20% year-on-year to 19,552, while the total value of such loans surged by 25% to €259 million. This is the highest level of car loans since the BPFI began collecting this data in 2020. The average car loan rose by €366 over the year, reaching €13,267. BPFI's Head of Sector Research & Analysis, Anthony O'Brien, attributed the continued growth in car loans to rising demand for electric and plug-in hybrid vehicles, along with ongoing financing for second-hand cars. In total, over 60,000 personal loans were taken out in the first quarter of the year , valued at nearly €700 million. This represents an annual increase of 22% in volume and 24% in value. The average personal loan increased by €177 compared to the same period last year, now standing at €11,239. The report also shows major growth in green loans, which rose 26% in volume to 1,531 loans. Their total value climbed 29.3% to €35.1 million. The average green loan reached €22,906, which was more than double the average across all personal loan types. Home improvement loans also saw a sharp increase, with 15,372 loans drawn down in the first quarter, an 18% increase from last year. These loans were valued at €198 million, 19% higher than the same period in 2024. The average home improvement loan increased by €116 to €12,886. O'Brien said that these numbers show a big start to the year for consumer borrowing, with Q1 setting new records for personal loan drawdowns both in terms of volume and value. Separately, in Britain, a Supreme Court ruling brought relief to lenders facing possible payouts related to motor finance commissions. The court overturned a previous decision that could have forced banks to compensate borrowers for undisclosed commissions paid to car dealerships. While the judgement reduces the potential financial burden on lenders, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) is moving forward with a redress scheme covering deals dating back to 2007. Bank of Ireland, which holds around 2% of the British motor finance market, had already allocated £143 million for possible compensation. Following the ruling, the bank said it would fully review the judgement but made no further comment. See More: BPFI, FCA, Loans
