I tried potato salad from Trader Joe's, Whole Foods, and Wegmans. One stood out as the clear winner.
To me, a good potato salad has a satisfying mix of textures, and enough flavor to liven up the potatoes without overpowering them.
With barbecue season upon us, I decided to try the house-brand potato salads from Wegmans, Trader Joe's, and Whole Foods to see how they compare. Here's how I ranked them, from worst to first.
Prices may vary by location.
Wegmans potato salad was the most expensive
A pound of Wegmans potato salad cost me $5.50, which was the most I paid at any of the stores.
This potato salad looked a bit soupier than the others I tried, with chunks of potato, celery, and pepper flakes floating in the mayo-heavy base.
The potatoes themselves turned out to be the mealiest of any I tried, but there was a nice bit of crunch to the celery and a bit of peppery spice that I liked. There was also an unexpected earthiness from the onions, and they tasted as if they'd been sautéed.
This potato salad wasn't bad, but it was my least favorite of the three I tried. In my opinion, it was a little heavy for a poolside barbecue side dish. Since it was also the most expensive, it was an easy choice for third place.
I would buy Trader Joe's potato salad again
Trader Joe's potato salad cost a little less than Wegmans, at $5 a pound. Of the three salads I tried, it was the most consistent in appearance.
It honestly looked and tasted more like egg salad to me, but the yolk-heavy creaminess was enjoyable, and I liked the nice hint of vinegary tang.
This was the sweetest of the three potato salads I tried, which isn't necessarily a selling point for me. I also thought it had the least texture. The potatoes were mushy, and the small bits of celery offered little to no crunch.
I didn't love it, but it was good enough that I'd buy it again if I were at Trader Joe's and needed potato salad.
The Whole Foods Red Bliss potato salad was the clear winner
Of the three stores I visited, Whole Foods was the only one that packed my potato salad fresh to order at the deli counter.
I can't say for sure if that makes a difference, but the Red Bliss potato salad was undoubtedly the most visually appealing of the three I tried. Red potato skins and green chives added plenty of color to the visibly creamy salad.
Although it typically costs $6, it was marked down to $4.50 per pound the day that I went. So, Whole Foods' potato salad was the least expensive of the three, and from the first bite, the clear winner in quality.
The potatoes had a nice, hearty texture, the celery was crunchy, and the salad packed a strong, delicious mustard flavor.
Since Whole Foods' entry was the least expensive, the best-looking, and the tastiest, its top ranking was a no-brainer. From now on, when the shopping list calls for potato salad, I'll steer toward Whole Foods.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Insider
a day ago
- Business Insider
I'm a dietitian who hates meal planning. Here are 12 things I buy at Trader Joe's to make feeding my family easier.
Trader Joe's spinach and ricotta raviolini can be ready in minutes. These are a lifesaver on busy nights — once the tiny spinach-and-ricotta-filled ravioli are in boiling water, they need just a few minutes to cook. I toss them with butter and salt or pesto, add fruit on the side, and dinner's done. I appreciate that the raviolini contain 7 grams of protein per one-cup serving — and get my kids to eat some spinach. At $3.50 per 10-ounce pack, these are a budget-friendly meal, too. The pollo asado works well in tacos, quesadillas, rice bowls, soups, salads, and more. With minimal meal planning, I don't budget time to marinate meat, so preseasoned proteins like this are convenient staples. Trader Joe's pollo asado is seasoned with paprika, garlic, onion, lemon juice, and peppers. I throw it in my Instant Pot for 20 minutes (so I can get other things done while it cooks) or grill it for five. The chicken also freezes well, so I always keep one pack on hand for busy weeks. The chain's frozen precooked rice is a mealtime hero in my house. Yes, I have a rice cooker — but some days I need rice ready now. My kids don't always want the carbs I prepare, so having rice that can be on the table within three minutes is good for my sanity. Trader Joe's offers jasmine, brown rice, and mixed-grain varieties in the frozen aisle — all are great for building up quick dinners or rounding out leftovers. I love the microwaveable asparagus from Trader Joe's. Vegetables usually take the longest for me to prep and cook — and after a full day, I often don't have the time or energy to do it. So, I love Trader Joe's microwavable asparagus, which steams right in its container for a few minutes. I pair the asparagus with salmon and rice for a simple, heart-healthy meal. Organic sprouted tofu is the perfect nut- and meat-free protein for lunches. Since my kids aren't big on sandwiches, I cut and microwave bite-sized pieces of sprouted tofu for them as an easy protein option for lunch. For an easy dinner, I'll sauté the tofu with garlic and soy sauce. It's a solid choice for the whole family, with 9 grams of protein per serving. The broccoli and kale slaw salad kit is a top pick when I'm pressed for time. I don't enjoy making salads from scratch, but salad kits from Trader Joe's come together easily. I like the broccoli and kale slaw option — with crunchy greens, nuts, seeds, dried fruit, and a creamy dressing, it pairs perfectly with leftover salmon or chicken for a quick, balanced meal. Plus, at only $3.49 per bag, it's a lot more budget-friendly than ordering takeout. The grilled chimichurri chicken thigh skewers are flavorful and ready in minutes. These frozen, fully-cooked skewers can be heated up with a grill, oven, or microwave. I serve the chicken thighs with a salad kit or microwaveable veggies and rice for a fast, complete dinner with minimal cleanup (always a perk). I rely on many of Trader Joe's frozen meals for my lunches. While I make my kids' lunches daily, I often forget mine. That's why I stock up on Trader Joe's frozen meals. My favorite is the channa masala — chickpeas stewed in a flavorful onion-y tomato sauce. Each two-serving container has 12 grams of protein and 12 grams of fiber, takes minutes to heat, and keeps me full for the afternoon. Some of the frozen meals come in handy for dinner — like the shiitake-mushroom chicken. Many of Trader Joe's frozen meals in a bag are an easy, affordable way to enjoy a dinner that tastes home-cooked but requires minimal prep. When the kids have leftovers and the adults still need dinner, I reach for the shiitake-mushroom chicken with edamame and green beans in a ginger soy sauce. It cooks in one pan, can be served on its own or with rice, and packs 20 grams of protein per cup — all for under $5. Red-lentil sedanini is a great pantry staple for no-fuss, balanced meals. With 15 grams of protein and 6 grams of fiber per serving, this lentil pasta is filling enough to enjoy on its own with no extra protein needed. I pair it with a sauce and veggies for a straightforward meal. Icelandic-style skyr is a thick, creamy, and satisfying high-protein yogurt. I keep a few in the fridge for a grab-and-go breakfast, snack, or even a last-minute dinner. Each single-serving container has about 15 grams of protein with only 5 grams of added sugar — less than what I've found in similar yogurts. At $1.19, it's quite affordable too. The freeze-dried mango tastes like candy but is 100% fruit. If I don't have time to pack fruit before heading out, I grab a bag of Trader Joe's unsweetened freeze-dried mango. The pieces are just fruit, making them a sweet, satisfying snack for both kids and adults. Plus, they're not a bad way to get extra fiber with about 2 grams per serving.
Business Insider
3 days ago
- Business Insider
I tried potato salad from Trader Joe's, Whole Foods, and Wegmans. One stood out as the clear winner.
No summertime barbecue or picnic is complete without a few good side dishes, and a scoop of potato salad makes a great addition to a juicy cheeseburger, a plate of smoky ribs, or a hearty deli sandwich. To me, a good potato salad has a satisfying mix of textures, and enough flavor to liven up the potatoes without overpowering them. With barbecue season upon us, I decided to try the house-brand potato salads from Wegmans, Trader Joe's, and Whole Foods to see how they compare. Here's how I ranked them, from worst to first. Prices may vary by location. Wegmans potato salad was the most expensive A pound of Wegmans potato salad cost me $5.50, which was the most I paid at any of the stores. This potato salad looked a bit soupier than the others I tried, with chunks of potato, celery, and pepper flakes floating in the mayo-heavy base. The potatoes themselves turned out to be the mealiest of any I tried, but there was a nice bit of crunch to the celery and a bit of peppery spice that I liked. There was also an unexpected earthiness from the onions, and they tasted as if they'd been sautéed. This potato salad wasn't bad, but it was my least favorite of the three I tried. In my opinion, it was a little heavy for a poolside barbecue side dish. Since it was also the most expensive, it was an easy choice for third place. I would buy Trader Joe's potato salad again Trader Joe's potato salad cost a little less than Wegmans, at $5 a pound. Of the three salads I tried, it was the most consistent in appearance. It honestly looked and tasted more like egg salad to me, but the yolk-heavy creaminess was enjoyable, and I liked the nice hint of vinegary tang. This was the sweetest of the three potato salads I tried, which isn't necessarily a selling point for me. I also thought it had the least texture. The potatoes were mushy, and the small bits of celery offered little to no crunch. I didn't love it, but it was good enough that I'd buy it again if I were at Trader Joe's and needed potato salad. The Whole Foods Red Bliss potato salad was the clear winner Of the three stores I visited, Whole Foods was the only one that packed my potato salad fresh to order at the deli counter. I can't say for sure if that makes a difference, but the Red Bliss potato salad was undoubtedly the most visually appealing of the three I tried. Red potato skins and green chives added plenty of color to the visibly creamy salad. Although it typically costs $6, it was marked down to $4.50 per pound the day that I went. So, Whole Foods' potato salad was the least expensive of the three, and from the first bite, the clear winner in quality. The potatoes had a nice, hearty texture, the celery was crunchy, and the salad packed a strong, delicious mustard flavor. Since Whole Foods' entry was the least expensive, the best-looking, and the tastiest, its top ranking was a no-brainer. From now on, when the shopping list calls for potato salad, I'll steer toward Whole Foods.
Business Insider
06-08-2025
- Business Insider
I walk to Trader Joe's every week to shop for my family of 4. These 10 items always make it into my cart.
My kids go crazy for Trader Joe's butternut-squash ravioli, and it's a dinner I can prepare in minutes. It's always helpful to have a few tried-and-true dinners on hand for nights when the kids get fussy. When I want to make sure I get some food in them, I take a couple of minutes to prepare these thin pasta triangles with butternut-squash filling inside. My kids have yet to turn the pasta down, and this dish allows me to rationalize that I've fed the children a fruit — squashes have seeds! Cosmic Crisp apples are great to pack as snacks. My local Trader Joe's often stocks Cosmic Crisp apples, a cross between Enterprise and Honeycrisp apples. They come in two distinct sizes: small ones, which are in a 2-pound bag, and huge ones, which customers can buy individually. I especially like the latter. Cosmic Crisps tend to brown more slowly than most other apples because they have higher levels of acidity and sugar, so if I cut one up and pack it as a snack for both kids, I know the slices will look fresh and appetizing all day. And in my experience, Cosmic Crisps don't seem to bruise easily. I throw one in my bag whenever I anticipate the need for a healthy afternoon snack. Trader Joe's jalapeño sauce has plenty of flavor and mixes well with other condiments. Trader Joe's jalapeño sauce stays true to the taste of its namesake pepper, though I'd say it carries more of the jalapeño's flavor than its heat. Like all hot sauces, this product has a wide range of potential uses. However, I didn't discover its true purpose until I put it on a salami sandwich in place of mustard. It brought out the very best of cured meat. I eat a lot of burgers at home, so I play around with condiments to keep things interesting. I found that combining this jalapeño sauce with mayonnaise, barbecue sauce, and Worcestershire sauce makes an excellent burger topping. The elote corn-chip dippers barely make it back to my apartment. These might be my favorite chips of all time, which is no small accomplishment. They taste quite a bit like Cool Ranch Doritos, just with an extra little kick of heat. The chips' hearty texture is phenomenal, and they remind me of higher-caliber Fritos. The bag suggests dipping these chips in guacamole, but that seems unnecessarily indulgent. They carry enough flavor on their own. I sometimes fantasize about crushing them up and using them to bread chicken, but in truth, I usually just eat half the bag on my walk home. The store's organic Bolivian coffee blend makes some of my favorite cold brew. I drink an alarming amount of coffee. Ever since I started making cold brew at home about 10 years ago, I estimate I've saved thousands of dollars in coffee-shop purchases. I've experimented with various roasts, origins, and preparations and have yet to find a high-quality coffee in the same price range as Trader Joe's organic Bolivian blend. It produces cold brew exactly as I want it: strong but smooth, with subtle, caramel-tinged sweetness. Thanks to Trader Joe's, we never have to settle for carrots of just one color. I could say I buy multicolored carrots because my kids think they're fun, but in truth, the novelty hasn't yet worn off on me either. Now our crudités look like a beautiful autumnal cornucopia. The purple ones are especially popular in my house, and it doesn't hurt that they're also very tasty. Reusable lavender dryer bags make my whole home smell fresh. I have sensitive skin and can't handle most fabric softeners, so I always keep a stock of these dryer bags, which have lavender as their only ingredient, to help my clothes smell nice. I also like that they don't have harsh chemicals. The lavender is enough to add a pleasant, floral fragrance to my laundry and freshen up the air in my apartment. Pretzel nuggets filled with peanut butter are the ultimate blend of sweet and salty. I'm old enough to remember a time when stuffed pretzels seemed rare and felt reserved for special occasions. Now they're widely available — especially at Trader Joe's — and you can choose from multiple different nut-butter fillings and coatings. I favor the classic ones with peanut butter on the inside. They're crunchy, salty, sweet, and satisfying. When I think of a Venn diagram representing all the different ways I want my snacks to taste, these treats land smack-dab in the middle. All I need to make a delicious homemade pizza is Trader Joe's plain dough, a mozzarella log, and jarred sauce. After trying a variety of Trader Joe's frozen pizzas, I've found I often prefer to make my own. I pair ready-to-bake plain pizza dough with a jar of fat-free pizza sauce and a fresh mozzarella log. The jar of sauce and the cheese are enough for at least two pizzas — assuming no one snacks on the cheese — and the dough is easier to work with than other supermarket ones I've used in the past. My kids won't eat spicy food, but I jazz up my slices with Trader Joe's version of Sriracha. The jerk-chicken burritos are too spicy for my kids, meaning I get them all to myself. It's always important to stock up on foods my kids will eat, but it's equally important to keep some on hand that my kids won't touch. I want to know that I have lunch options that won't descend upon like vultures, and the jerk-chicken burrito is one of them. It's delicious and has enough Caribbean spices that my children, who can't handle spice, stay away from it. Like most burritos, these are great with a little sour cream. Although I haven't found it in stores in a while, I hope Trader Joe's brings it back as it often does with products.
