Opinion: Asian Students' Test Scores Are Often High. Our Success Is Complicated
Few observers were probably surprised when Asian students outscored other students on test scores released by California state this fall.
Statewide, and here in Los Angeles, Asian students who completed California's 2024 assessments showed higher levels of proficiency in reading and math, compared to other racial groups.
Asian kids' dominance of California's state tests echoes the results of national exams, where the same, long-standing trend of academic achievement by these students holds true in other cities and states across the country.
Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter
So, why do Asian kids do so well on those exams? In my experience, the reasons are complicated.
I grew up in L.A.'s San Gabriel Valley, where I attended high-performing public schools that enrolled a lot of Asian students like me. We consistently outperformed other schools and student groups across the state.
But here's what the high test scores didn't show. Many of us poured countless hours into our studies and extracurriculars. Many of us were also privileged enough to have tutors.
Growing up, I had classmates who started their academic after-school programs in elementary school. And although not every family in the neighborhood had a tutor, education was definitely one of the top priorities for the majority in my community.
We were in a high-pressure environment, and assimilation meant performing well. In high school, students engaged in afterschool activities, such as sports and academic clubs. Some parents paid tens of thousands on college counselors.
All this pressure, however difficult at times, created 'success,' which ultimately meant being accepted to reputable universities. Our graduating class had around 250 students. One of our most notable statistics for college admissions was 26 confirmed acceptances to U.C. Berkeley.
However, a highly competitive atmosphere like this can exact psychological and social costs.
Many students around me growing up were constantly stressed. It felt like college admissions were the be-all end-all. It shouldn't be that way.
My mom and dad immigrated from China, and I am forever grateful for their dedication and sacrifices. One way to show my appreciation and that their efforts weren't wasted was through my academic and professional achievements.
It's all part of the American Dream.
However, that pressure to succeed can also hold a dark side.
A University of Michigan research project called Deconstructing the Model Minorityfound Asian students 'often experience extreme pressure and stress.' We may also feel 'the responsibility and guilt […] for [our] parents' sacrifices.'
This is what academic achievement costs for some Asian students, and also probably what it costs some other kids from other ethnic groups.
However, not every student has access to the same opportunities as me. And not everyone's experience was like mine.
While my school growing up provided structure, support, and community, many other students in L.A. are navigating underfunded schools. And often those students also have less academic support and face greater socio-economic instability.
I've worked as a tutor in South Central L.A., so I've seen some of these issues first-hand.
I've worked with fourth graders struggling to read. It's not that those students lacked the ability to learn. It's that they've been disadvantaged by systematic issues and other external factors they can't control.
But I believe that education is the great equalizer. And I think that we are making progress on fulfilling that potential. Organizations such as Teach for America, Khan Academy, Head Start, and PeerForward are excellent starting points in the ultimate goal of closing the achievement gap.
It sounds simple, but it's not. Educators and policymakers everywhere need to ensure every student has an equal opportunity to a quality education. It's a multifaceted issue.
That's why our conversation should not center solely on why Asian students score higher than other kids. We should also be talking about how to ensure that all students have all the resources they need to succeed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
8 hours ago
Chinese ship runs aground off Philippines-occupied island in the disputed South China Sea
PUERTO PRINCESA, Philippines -- A Chinese ship ran aground in stormy weather in shallow waters off a Philippines-occupied island in the disputed South China Sea, prompting Filipino forces to go on alert, Philippine military officials said Sunday. When Filipino forces assessed that the Chinese fishing vessel appeared to have run aground in the shallows east of Thitu Island on Saturday because of bad weather, Philippine military and coast guard personnel deployed to provide help but later saw that the ship had been extricated, regional navy spokesperson Ellaine Rose Collado said. No other details were immediately available, including if there were injuries among the crewmembers or if the ship was damaged, Collado said. Confrontations have spiked between Chinese and Philippine coast guard and navy ships in the disputed waters in recent years. "The alertness of our troops is always there,' Col. Xerxes Trinidad of the Armed Forces of the Philippines told reporters. But when they saw that a probable accident had happened, 'we tried to provide assistance as professionals' in accordance with international law on helping distressed vessels at sea. "We're always following international law,' Trinidad said. Filipino villagers living in a fishing village on Thitu, which they call Pagasa island, immediately informed the Philippine military and coast guard after seeing the Chinese ship lying in the shallows about 1.5 nautical miles (2.7 kilometers) from their village, said MP Albayda, a local Filipino official, told The Associated Press. 'They got worried because the Chinese were so close but it was really the strong wind and waves that caused the ship to run aground," said Albayda, adding that other Chinese ships pulled the stricken vessel away. The stricken ship resembled what the Philippine military had repeatedly said were suspected Chinese militia ships, which had backed the Chinese coast guard and navy in blocking and harassing Philippine coast guard and military vessels in the disputed waters, a busy conduit for global trade and commerce. Thitu Island is home to a Philippine fishing village and Filipino forces and is the largest of nine islands and islets occupied by the Philippines. It lies about 26 kilometers (16 miles) from Subi Reef, which China transformed into an island base along with six other barren reefs to reinforce its claim to virtually the entire South China Sea. Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei and Taiwan are also involved in the long-simmering territorial standoffs, an Asian flashpoint that many fear could pit China and the United States in a major conflict. The U.S. does not lay any claim to the South China Sea but has repeatedly warned that it's obligated to defend the Philippines, it's longtime treaty ally, if Filipino forces, ships and aircraft come under an armed attack, including in the South China Sea.
Eater
2 days ago
- Eater
The Chefs' Guide to Chicago's Farmers Markets
It's springtime in Chicago. Not only have we survived the cold, but farmers market season is in full swing. Many neighborhoods have weekday and weekend markets highlighting the work of independent farmers and culinary artisans, whose vegetable, meat, dairy, and seafood quality can outstrip what you can find at a big grocery store. The difference is partly seasonality. If it's not in season, small farms aren't going to force it; there's no need for winter tomatoes in Chicago. The farmers market is a visual education for urbanites into what the seasons look like and the food each season yields. Ramp and chive blossom season in early spring brings opportunities for cooking pastas and light soups with bright alliums, tomato season in summer is best enjoyed with thick slices of heirlooms and flaky salt. Sweet cherries are eaten whole in summer's hottest peak; the spit-out pits should always be composted or replanted, of course. The frantic dog days of summer bring us the gifts of okra: fried, stewed, sauteed with South Asian spices. And fall, when the chill begins to set in, brings the luxury of figs and pomegranate with baked desserts, along with the heartiness of root vegetables and hardy greens like kale, collards, and mustard greens. The temporality of farmers markets is what makes them so beloved by the city's best chefs, who frequent them — and sometimes have stalls there, like Daisies and Verzenay — to find superior products for their customers. Quality comes at a higher price than convenience, but farmers markets are also working on making themselves more accessible and convenient; many, including Green City Market in Lincoln Park, take SNAP/Link cards and triple-match credit so customers can stretch their dollar, and some farms have delivery services if rolling out of bed at 7 a.m. on a Saturday isn't your jam. Markets in the South Side, like 61st Street Market, the El Paseo Community Market, Hyde Park Farmers Market, and Plant Chicago's Mercado De Intercambio are also expanding access to fresh, quality produce to under-served communities. We spoke to chefs around Chicago about their most beloved farmers market items and what they cook with them, and farmers whose work they love: Mick Klüg, Nichols Farm, and Froggy Meadows are classics, while Oriana's (Asian pears, pawpaws, and quince), Joe's Blues (blueberries), and Seedling are known for more specialty items. Latinx-owned Los Rodriguez Farms, Black-owned Growing Home, and Willowbrook Farms are also opportunities to support farmers of color, who are underrepresented. Lamar Moore of Etc. Farmers Market Move: Apples from Growing Home Right now, I'm looking for apples. I love apples in the fall. I used to grow up just eating apples. My grandmother was selling them all the time. In Illinois, we're so close to Michigan, so you get a lot of those farmers that are bringing up those amazing apples, from Pink Lady apples down to the Fujis. We have duck ravioli on the menu, and I do pickled apples on there and apple sorrel ... It gives the ravioli this citrus flavor. I'll make apple compote for our biscuits too. Obviously, Green City has everything. But I try to stick close to South Loop Market because I do find a lot of Black-owned farms that are coming through that way. And 61st Street Market is another good one for that. Justin Lerias of Del Sur Farmers Market Move: Baby corn from Nichols Farm Every summer, Nichols has these tiny little baby corns that I just love to use and bake. It's so soft and you can just eat it with the cob. I think it's more subtle than regular corn, and it's the perfect canvas. Baby corn is so easy to saute and grill to make something exciting. Nichols has lots of miniature versions of vegetables so they have like a baby vegetable art show. I also love their baby eggplants and baby artichokes. Ryan Fakih of Beity Farmers Market Move: Ramps and garlic from Mick Klüg and Froggy Meadows Farm, blueberries and fresh blueberry juice from Joe's Blues I'm excited to start seeing the different colors come out. I'm excited to see life come back from winter to summer. Especially with Lebanese and Arab cuisine, it relies heavily on summer-y produce. That can get difficult because how do you make muhammara, a red pepper dish, if you want it outside of pepper season? Right now, ramps are almost over, but I've been enjoying them. I get mine from Mick Klüg and Four Star Mushroom. I'm excited for anything that comes out of Froggy Meadows; any mushrooms or shallots that Jerry gets, I love. I love Joe's Blues. They're a blueberry farm and they have freshly squeezed blueberry juice. Every visit, I get one. Before I even start the whole walk around the market, I go straight there and get a juice. It shoots up through your blood and wakes you up for the whole trip. For me, the most important part of the farmers market is making sure you're fermenting and pickling the ingredients so it lasts you throughout the year. In Lebanon, we call it mouneh, this fermenting and pickling of items for the winter so you make it through the winter. It's a means of survival and a way that we cherish our plants. In my world, it's beautiful to carry on that history. It's also very sustainable; you're saving food instead of buying more than you can cook and throwing it away. And if you buy garlic from the market, you can plop the bulbs in the soil to grow your own. If you have a garden, you better be gardening. Even when I was living in France and I was in my studio, I'd still grow a bunch of things out of windows and share them with everyone. When we know how to make things for ourselves and share it with others. I think it's a beautiful thing. Diana Dávila of Mi Tocaya Antojeria Farmers Market Move: Melons from Geneva Lakes Produce We get ours from Geneva Lakes Produce — a lovely, hardworking family at Logan Square Farmers Market. We hosted them during the pandemic on our patio. And Los Rodriguez Farm is another lovely family. I also love Seedling and Nichols Farm at Green City. I put onions in everything, so I'd say I'm excited about the allium family. Chiles are also my favorites to get at the farmers market. But I think one of the special things that the Midwest has that doesn't get enough attention is melons. It's one of the only tropical-ish flavors that you can really have here. And I always get them all, but especially rare varietals. Pharaohs in Egypt loved melons, you know? They have pictures of melons, and I think that's so cool. I love watching people's faces when they have actual melons that are grown by small farmers because so much of the fruit that people get at the store is just complete bastards, you know what I mean? Like, some people didn't even know that melons are supposed to have seeds because they make these seedless melons for mass consumption, and that makes other melons have less and less seeds in general. I also buy heritage chicken from farmers markets because I can't stand bullshit chicken, where they rob them of the molecular part of their ingredients with all these chemicals and unnatural practices. But back to melons, once you take them home, you can make agua fresca. It's such a cultural thing for us back in Mexico, making a beautiful, fresh fruit water. You don't need to add sweetener, but you can. I don't really like regular sugar because it's not the best for you. You could use agave or honey. You could use sorghum, you could use beet sugar, you could use maple syrup if you want. The real stuff. And melon is also really good for ceviches. It has all this beautiful water content that lends itself really well to aguachiles. And whatever you get from the market, try pickling it. Erick Williams of Virtue Farmers Market Move: Sorrel, torpedo onions, and root vegetables from Nichols Farm, the South Shore Market, and Bronzeville Boxville Market I love sourcing from Nichols Farm. They consistently offer a wide variety of high-quality, seasonal produce. I also keep an eye out for small-batch growers at the South Shore Market and the Bronzeville Boxville Market, where you often find gems that reflect the flavor and soul of the South Side. Supporting South Side farmers markets is about equity and community investment. These markets not only bring fresh, nutritious food to neighborhoods that need it, but they also support local growers and food entrepreneurs who often don't have the same access to visibility or resources. The produce is just as beautiful, the stories behind the vendors are powerful, and the impact is deeper when we circulate our dollars locally. We need to uplift all of Chicago, not just the parts that already get attention. What I'm excited about … sorrel has this beautiful, bright citrusy flavor — try blending it into a pesto with sunflower seeds and olive oil, or stir it into scrambled eggs or warm grains like farro or couscous to bring some acidity and freshness. With torpedo onions, I love grilling them whole until tender, then drizzling with olive oil and vinegar for a simple side. They also make a fantastic onion jam when slow-cooked — a great addition to burgers, sandwiches, or even a roasted veggie plate. Beets, turnips, and rutabagas are staples for us. Beets can be roasted with a bit of honey and thyme, or shaved raw into salads for texture. Turnips, especially the small Hakurei variety, can be sautéed with garlic and finished with lemon zest. And rutabagas are underrated; mash them like potatoes with butter and herbs, or cut them into wedges and roast until crisp. They're hearty and grounding, perfect for both comfort food and creative dishes. Paul Virant of Gaijin , Vistro Prime , and Petite Vie Farmers Market Move: Endive from Nichols Farm and Mick Klüg For me, it's pretty easy. I'm always most excited about the things you can't get at the grocery store. In the springtime, it's ramps and other spring alliums that are hard to find in the store. As you move into the summertime, it's really hard to find really good fruit in the grocery store. And the fruit that we do see comes from pretty far away, but there's a cost to that. Strawberries are picked under-ripe, and they turn red on their travels out to Chicago. I also love shelling beans, like cranberry beans, lima beans, or fresh black-eyed peas. Even regular kinds of lettuce, arugula, spinach — all that stuff is just more beautiful at the farmers market. If you're buying heartier greens in the fall from some of the local farmers, like spinach or kale, because they can handle the colder weather, that's the stuff that's been nipped by a frost, so it gets better and gets sweeter. Some of those greens, they've kept them in the ground, and they get sweeter as the nights get colder. Then they have interesting greens, like all the radicchios and the endives, the treviso — the bitter greens. Surprisingly, they have a kind of sweetness to them as well, so they're nice raw in a salad. I also like endives quickly charred in a hot pan, maybe with some garlic. I like them slowly braised in the oven with some orange halves and zest, maybe a little wine. If you have dandelion greens or kale, I like doing a conserva-style where you're slowly cooking them with garlic and anchovies in olive oil, maybe some chile flakes, and then finish them with a splash of vinegar or lemon juice. And they'll keep longer because of all the oil. And at Gaijin, we do a lot of Japanese-inspired pickles, and one is like a quick kind of ferment of mustard greens or chrysanthemum greens. The farms that have been pretty consistent in my world would be the Nichols Farm, Mick Klüg Farm, Ellis Family Farms, Iron Creek Farm, and there are a lot of others too. I like River Valley Ranch's mushrooms, Finn's Ranch for meat and eggs (they have duck eggs too). I love Jake's Country Meats. When they're at the market, I make sure to bring my Yeti strap cooler and buy a whole chicken, get some pork, good stuff I can make at home. Oliver Poilevey of Mariscos San Pedro , Le Bouchon , Obelix , and Taqueria Chingon Farmers Market Move: Summer tomatoes from Froggy Meadows I'm most excited for the summer tomatoes. I'll put them on everything. The really good ones are only here for a little while, and I don't really use the other ones that much. Nothing ruins a February sandwich more than a hard tomato. My friend Jerry at Green City Farmers Market in Lincoln Park, from Froggy Meadows, he's the tomato whisperer. Put tomatoes in everything you can think of, but definitely salads. And make sauces and salsas with them. You can also just slice them and eat them with salt and pepper. Leigh Omilinsky of Daisies Farmers Market Move: Strawberries, sweet black cherries, and sugar cube melons from Mick Klüg Farms, Quince from Oriana Orchard and Nursery We wait six months or however long for strawberries. Those are always the best. They're always the highlight for me. Because I have my strawberry items planned in my head in March, when I'm actually ready for them. But we don't get them until the first week of June. We get the majority of our fruit from Mick Klüg. I love them. I've worked with them for more than 15 years. I watched Abby's kids grow up. So it's cool to go and see how they've expanded. But I always look forward to the first strawberries. Then everything happens in rapid succession. All of a sudden, everything is here, at least fruit-wise. Sweet cherries are always fun for me because the season can be like two weeks. And then it's done, so I need to find something that really showcases them. Those sweet black cherries are so fleeting. And black raspberries, too, are so fleeting. I used to know in the city where there are some secret spots where you can pick them. I think generally speaking, with produce that is so special, we know our farmers, we know where they come from, we know what it takes to get there. The less we muck it up, the better. So we are jamming and preserving, and pickling all summer. Then, always like in August, the sugar cube melons I love. The little teeny yellow cantaloupe-looking ones. Those are great. I always make a sous vide out of those because, like it's two ingredients and that's it. And that's just perfect as is. Later into fall, I always want to do something with quince from Oriana. Bring a bag. Take your time. Talk to your farmers. These are the people that put everything they have into this. And for the most part, I can't think of a single one that's not willing to answer any questions. Ask them what's coming up next. Ask them what they're excited about. Ask them what they would do with it. They want to educate you. They want to have you enjoy their product as well. Jenner Tomaska of Esme and The Alston Farmers Market Move: Medlar and a strawberry smoothie from Seedling Fruit Peter from Seedling Fruit is amazing. He's been a long-time supporter of me, and he's an avid diner; he really stays in touch with the chef community. He's able to curate and plan for the following year if there's something special or unique you want to do. His stand at Green City Market also makes smoothies; my favorite is strawberry when they're in season. Right now, I'm looking forward to rhubarb. It's such a small season and small window, so we usually bulk up on it. But he also does medlar, which is just kind of an out-of-the-norm fruit that people don't really buy because it's kind of a pain in the ass to process. Medlar is a small brown fruit, like three times the size of a blueberry. It's dark in complexion, and when you press the innards out of it, it almost tastes already cooked and caramelized. It's almost like a roasted apple pawpaw flavor. It does have some of the slightest astringency to it. You can turn it into ice cream, adding it to a vinaigrette or dressing to make it slightly more savory. Esme is like a block away from Green City in Lincoln Park, so I usually go with my kid, and he goes up to Seedling Fruit, and he'll eat a flat of blackberries in like 30 seconds. Arshiya Farheen of Verzenay Farmers Market Move: Strawberries, gold and black raspberries, and Jupiter grapes from Mick Klüg and Ellis Family Farms, pawpaws from Oriana's Our booth is very close to Nichols Farm, and soon as the ramps get done, you start getting garlic scapes, which is very fun. They have different varieties of allium that you can never see in a grocery store. But we are a bakery and I really believe that strawberries from the Midwest, especially Michigan, are the best in the entire country. If you try Mick Klüg farms or Ellis Family Farms or any other farm from Michigan, their strawberries are a whole different level. It's red through and through, it tastes amazing. They're the closest I have seen to the gariguettes, these tiny French strawberries that grow around spring. The strong flavor profile that a strawberry should have, unfortunately, gets lost in other conventional farming. I also love getting the apples, the peaches, and the pawpaws from Oriana's. Jupiter grapes from Mick Klüg, they're a good alternative to Concord grapes, but they have a deep muscat flavor, and I love to make open-faced tarts with them. Ireland tomatoes from Nichols and sungold tomatoes from Jerry [Boone at Froggy Meadow]. Black raspberries and gold raspberries from Ellis; they are really fragile, so you have to get them right when they bring it out and eat them soon. Oriana's pawpaws and the Asian pears she has are so good. I didn't know what a pawpaw was 10 years ago before we started going to the market. They remind me of some of the fruits back in India; they have a custardy flavor profile, and you don't have to do anything but scoop it out and eat it with a spoon. You can also do something savory with strawberries if you want to try something new. Get the green strawberries and pickle them. These interviews have been edited and condensed for clarity. Sign up for our newsletter.
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
Opinion: What Employers Want, Project-based Learning Can Deliver
Dear high school and college students, Are you a good communicator? Can you effectively lead a team of your peers? Can you think critically about issues, ask questions, and find solutions to complex problems? If so, we're looking for you. Apply now if you can show evidence of teamwork, creativity, and a strong work ethic. We don't need 'good test-takers' or the highest GPA. No experience? No problem. We will train you. We want employees who know how to learn, think, and lead. We want employees with the skills to help our company succeed both now and in the future. Are you up for the challenge? Sincerely, Every Industry in America Today's education system fails to adequately prepare many students for college and the workforce. One survey found less than a quarter of high school graduates believe their schooling prepared them for life after graduation. Meanwhile, employers want candidates with '21st Century Skills,' but are coming up short. In recent years, however, there has been a promising shift as many states re-evaluate how to prepare students for the world. Twenty states and hundreds of districts have created 'Portraits of a Graduate' outlining the skills students should have by graduation such as communication, problem-solving, critical thinking and collaboration. Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter Meanwhile, the landscape of K-12 assessments is also shifting. Last year when New York set a timeline to eliminate the requirement that students pass the Regents Exam in order to graduate, it joined a growing number of states that have ended reliance solely on exit exams as a condition of graduation. Instead, states are increasingly embracing measures such as performance-based assessments which measure both what students know and whether they can apply that knowledge. These students demonstrate their skills through completing a project or performing a certain activity, which can include. essays, portfolios or research papers. With the right support, these changes can effectively prepare students for the workforce of tomorrow. We have seen this happen in schools that have taken a project-based learning approach to instruction and assessment. For instance, the rural Adair County School District in Kentucky launched an initiative to help students build skills outlined in the state's portrait of a graduate and create a 'culture of inquiry.' In one project, high school English and business classes, led by teachers Amy South and JR Thompson, worked together to research local industries and community businesses, interview business owners, analyze marketing strategies and develop comprehensive plans for promoting the community and its local businesses to outsiders. As part of the process, students were introduced to the concept of a 'strong hook' to capture interest and then divided into two teams. Each team worked collaboratively to propose a value proposition and refine their marketing strategies. They were then required to pitch their ideas and plans, ultimately narrowing down their focus to two distinct community projects. They presented their final pitches live to a jury, which selected one — a Marketing Day Vendor Fair — to be implemented in the community. The project culminated in students hosting an event at the high school showcasing local businesses The Thomas Edison CTE High School in Queens, New York, is currently a mentor school for the New York State Department of Education, training other schools to develop performance-based assessments. It uses a project-based learning model in which students engage in real-world and personally meaningful projects. It developed a framework and 'essential skills' rubric that assesses both how well students know the content and whether they can demonstrate essential skills of communication, collaboration, feedback and reflection, design thinking and professionalism. Related These are just two examples of schools that are leading the way in making sure students are prepared for the world by the time they graduate. We need more stories like this. Instead of focusing on cuts to education, we need to continue the momentum happening in New York and elsewhere by supporting and growing these innovative programs. We call on parents, caregivers, students, schools, districts, boards of education, policy makers and government agencies to focus on these key areas to ensure the momentum continues and the changes last Professional development and capacity building: Institutions must ensure all teachers have ample time for professional development around performance-based curriculum and assessments as well as ongoing professional support. Buy-in at all levels is required in order to strengthen the system and build the capacity needed to make the shift toward building and measuring real-world skills. Funding: Re-defining student success — and how to assess it — will require investment. State leaders must ensure that there is funding to provide the staffing, training, curriculum and resources to support implementing performance-based assessments. Stakeholder alignment: K-12 schools, local industries and higher education institutions must be aligned on which skills are important for career and college readiness. Communications: Some students may resist performance-based assessments because they have learned how to navigate the current system and do well on tests. Communicating effectively to students and families will help to shift mindsets and make the process smoother. Change is slow, but worth it. It will take persistence. There must be a willingness from all involved to hold the line and know it might take 10 years for this new way of assessing student learning to fully take hold. We are experiencing a rare opportunity to change education and improve student success. This work must be intentional, evidence-based, and supported at all levels. We implore education leaders, policy makers, schools, districts and communities to lay the groundwork now to ensure students have a successful future and can respond to the 'letter to high school and college graduates' with a resounding 'Yes.'
