Eddie O'Sullivan still not impressed by 'vulnerable' Munster defence
Eddie O'Sullivan believes Munster's knockout mentality means they're capable of causing chaos in the BKT URC play-offs, but says he remains unconvinced by their defence following last week's win against Benetton.
The province finished sixth overall in the URC table, and secured qualification for the Investec Champions Cup, with the 30-21 win against the Italian side, but needed a second-half rally to get over the line, coming from 14-10 behind at the break.
Two tries for Benetton full-back Rhyno Smith opened Munster up in what was a poor first half, but their own attacking flair prevailed after the break.
It was similar to their previous week's win against Ulster where they gave up two sloppy first-half tries, before an impressive third quarter saw them win 38-20.
"The defence is vulnerable. It seems like they're not settled in their defensive system," former Ireland head coach O'Sullivan said on the RTÉ Rugby podcast.
"They're not confident, and you have guys making bad reads, coming out of the line and getting carved.
"It seems to me there was confusion in the ranks as to who was doing what. There was a disconnect in their defensive line and that's a disaster area, when one guy is on one page and another guy is on another page.
"You can see that early in the season when you're kind of bedding in for the first few games, you can have big defensive screw-ups and you get caught, but at that this stage of the season everyone should be lockstep on D."
Munster thrive when the pressure is on, but @TheRealEddieOS still has big concerns about how easily they're giving up tries. ✖️
📺🎧 Full RTÉ Rugby podcast: https://t.co/qxEH4CFo55 pic.twitter.com/QnIa930w6C
— RTÉ Sport (@RTEsport) May 21, 2025
The province conceded an average of 24 points per game in their 18 matches in the regular season, the highest average of the eight teams that made it into the play-offs.
And O'Sullivan says similar leaks could be exposed badly against the Sharks, who they face in the quarter-finals in Durban next week.
He said: "South African teams bring two things to the URC as they always do. One is physicality. They're brutally physical.
"They will go toe to toe, pound the hell out of you. Sometimes you just run out of gas against them because you make so many big tackles. There's no easy tackles against South African teams. You taste your fillings every time you hit somebody.
"They have that and they always have serious gas on the edges, the outside channels.
"That's what makes South African teams so dangerous in the play-offs, they bring huge physicality and you know it's coming and there's not much you can do about it, and if they get free in the outside channels they can skin you alive and score from 50 or 60 metres. It's a lethal combination.
"Your defence has to be really buttoned down so that you're able to make two-man tackles, a tackler and an assist to at least slow the ruck ball and don't give up too many yards on the collision.
"To do that you have to commit more to the contact zone, and at the same time you can't leave edges with lots of space out there, because they have so much pace when they get out there."
If Munster are to win the title, they would likely have to win away in Durban, Pretoria and then against Leinster at Aviva Stadium, a path even tougher than the one they travelled to become champions two seasons ago.
And while O'Sullivan says he doesn't see enough evidence that they are capable of doing it, he's prepared to be proven wrong.
"They've always been able to pull out rescue results, when they're circling the pan and they get a result, and it rights the ship for a while," he said.
"They haven't got enough results through the season to really make them contenders.
"I'll probably get criticised for saying it because you don't know with Munster, they could go on and get to a semi-final or final because they're a knockout team, as we've seen in the last two games.
"Their form is not good, 50%, nine wins nine losses, average scoring 25 and conceding 24. That's about as bang average as you can get. Bang average shouldn't really win you the league.
"Their form doesn't say to me that they're going to win the URC. I might take that back in a few weeks, because Munster are Munster."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Leinster have point to prove as the doubters circle ahead of URC semi-final
Leinster will have to avoid the pressure-trap against Glasgow Warriors in the URC semi-final at The Aviva this afternoon. Notwithstanding, they lost last year's Champions Cup final in extra-time, lost this year's semi-final by three points and have lost three consecutive URC semi-finals by a point, a point and five respectively. But it is surely fair to suggest a squad with 12 Lions, three highly rated foreigners and another dozen chosen to tour with Ireland this summer have little to fear - but themselves. But that's not the full story as Leo Cullen finds himself dealing with the growing 'noises off' as much as what's happening centre stage. As for the main actors Hugo Keenan has pulled out with a calf-strain which sees Jimmy O'Brien move no15 and a fit-again Tommy O'Brien brought onto the right-wing while Scott Penny deputising for Josh van der Flier as he did for the last hour last week. Tommy O'Brien had been their in-form late-in-the-season back while spare a thought for Penny who was the glaring overlook when the Ireland squad was named midweek. Penny will hardly lack motivation. "To be honest I was more focussed on trying to prepare the group, no offence, Scott," said Cullen of a player who will be seeing 15 Leinster players touring this summer - and it would have been 17 but for Will Connors and Caelan Doris's injuries. "Scott has 86 appearances for Leinster and I hope he goes well, and he just needs to be ready and play well and focus on that. "Selection (for Ireland) is one of those things that are out of your control, injury is out of your control, those are the frustrating things about being a professional sportsman. "The only thing you can control is preparation and performance. If he plays well enough, hopefully he won't be too far away in the future." Meanwhile Cullen is for reminding the sceptics, growing day by day this week it seemed, that Leinster don't lose ALL their play-off/knockout games - they have won 14 of the last 17 played in Dublin in the last four seasons. "We've had positive play-off games where we've racked up big scores on dry days and conceded no points but it didn't ultimately help (win anything), do you know what I mean? So, you'd prefer, what, two 6-3 wins if it meant you were going to win semi-finals." But then knockout rugby is, by its nature, hard to predict. 'None of us know exactly what way it will unfold. That's the pressure of knock-out games and all the rest. 'I was looking at the Champions League final in the football and a lot of the pundits were saying that the other team were going to win, that lost. They got steamrollered in the end. "That's the beauty of sport isn't it? We think we might know what's going to happen but it's two teams going at it and we'll wait and see." Former Scotland captain and Premier Sport TV commentator John Barclay has been one for putting up a case for Warriors and, even then, he is worried about sounding 'daft'. 'There's a lot of talk about a vulnerability to Leinster after what Saints did to them in the Champions Cup but it feels a bit daft, given they finished top of the league, we may be losing sight of that," he says. 'There's a template of how to beat Leinster from the Scarlets and Northampton games, the key message being that Leinster are not unbeatable, but you have to be disruptive, really go after them. "There's lots to admire and learn from what the Scarlets did last weekend, they were brave, they attacked well and they didn't just sit back. 'If you are Leinster you are probably quite liking people writing you off as well. They topped the URC, got to the semi-finals of Europe. Yes there will be bits of their game they will be wanting to sharpen up – but I think they will also be pretty confident. The Scots need to be able to consistently shut Leinster's playmakers. 'For Glasgow, it's about disrupting the flow of the game that quality players like Jamison Gibson-Park, Jordie Barrett, James Lowe dictate, the guys that determine where and how they play the game. 'The up front battle will also be huge but how good will that contest be between the likes of Tom Jordan, Sione Tuipulotu and Jordie Barrett? "Tom Jordan will be even more motivated with the prospect that it could be his last game for the club.' Warriors finished fourth in the league-proper and come to the game as outsiders to make the final but they shouldn't be written off. Continues Barclay: "Glasgow are looking good, looking sharp and are peaking at the right time, I think they will be confident going over there. 'They dominated the Stormers up front last weekend which surprised a few people given the size of them, but the Warriors are so well coached now, they know how to do that. 'If you look at the coaching ticket that Glasgow have, the way they evolve and have a plan for every week, I think they'll be pretty comfortable in what they have to do as a team on Saturday. 'It's fascinating that a Glasgow team that can get beaten 52-0 points over there a few weeks ago and actually people say they have a reasonable chance." Leinster: Jimmy O'Brien, Tommy O'Brien, Jamie Osborne, Jordie Barrett, James Lowe, Sam Prendergast, Jamison Gibson-Park, Andrew Porter, Dan Sheehan, Thomas Clarkson, Joe McCarthy, James Ryan, Ryan Baird, Scott Penny, Jack Conan (CAPT) Replacements: Rónan Kelleher, Jack Boyle, Rabah Slimani, RG Snyman, Max Deegan, Luke McGrath, Ross Byrne, Ciarán Frawley Glasgow Warriors: Josh McKay, Kyle Steyn (CAPT), Sione Tuipulotu, Tom Jordan, Kyle Rowe, Adam Hastings, George Horne, Jamie Bhatti, Gregor Hiddleston, Fin Richardson, Alex Samuel, Scott Cummings, Euan Ferrie, Rory Darge, Henco Venter Replacements: Johnny Matthews, Rory Sutherland, Sam Talakai, Max Williamson, Jack Mann, Macenzzie Duncan, Stafford McDowall, Jamie Dobie Referee: Andrea Piardi (Italy)
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Arsenal star Jorginho completes Flamengo transfer and set to become second Chelsea icon to face Blues at Club World Cup
JORGINHO has completed his move to Flamengo - just hours after leaving Arsenal. The Brazilian midfielder, 33, was released from his contract early by the Gunners. 3 Jorginho has completed his Arsenal exit and has joined Flamengo Credit: Getty 3 The 33-year-old will face off against ex-club Chelsea in the Club World Cup Credit: Getty Jorginho joined Arsenal in January 2023 from The 33-year-old made 78 appearances for Mikel Arteta's side, but mostly featured off the bench this season. But the club arranged for him to be released early so he could play for Flamengo in the Club World Cup. READ MORE ON FOOTBALL He has penned a three-year deal with the Brazilian side. The Gunners described Jorginho as a "valuable and integral part of the club" in a statement confirming his early release. It added: "Everyone at Arsenal Football Club would like to thank Jorgi for his contribution to the club. "We wish him and his family all the best for the future." Most read in Football BEST ONLINE CASINOS - TOP SITES IN THE UK Flamengo's It means Jorginho will face his former club on June 20 at Philadelphia's Lincoln Financial Field. £67M Real Madrid Star Rodrygo on Gunners Hit List | From The Sports Desk | Sun Sport A familiar face to Blues fans will also play against Chelsea in the tournament opener. Olivier Giroud, who played for both the Blues and Arsenal, currently leads the line for Los Angeles FC. The MLS club booked their place in the competition with a 3 The winner-takes-all tie came about after Mexico's Club Leon Leon were due to be in Group D alongside Chelsea. But they were booted due to a violation of Fifa's rules on multi-club ownership. The 32-team tournament starts later this month. Manchester City, among the favourites for the crown, face Italian giants Juventus, Morocco's Wydad AC and Al Ain of the UAE in the group stages.
The 42
2 hours ago
- The 42
Leinster want excitement but Glasgow can make it a nervy day at the Aviva
IT'S STRANGE TO watch a team come through a high-stakes knock-out game where much of the post-match focuses on the perceived sense of apathy around it all. This was the experience of covering Leinster's URC quarter-final defeat of Scarlets seven days ago. The sticking point was the attendance figure of 12,879 – by no means a miserable crowd, but certainly one which feels miserable when housed inside a near-52,000 capacity stadium. Leo Cullen's post-match pleas for the club to collectively feel 'excitement' about reaching another semi-final today [v Glasgow, KO 2.45pm, RTÉ 2/Premier Sports/URC TV] and for fans to 'please turn out in force' at the Aviva Stadium brought a somewhat bizarre end to the occasion. It's an unusual place for a club to find themselves when two games out from potentially lifting a trophy. But how excited should those Leinster fans actually feel? On the face of it this should be sizing up as a massive few weeks. Leinster have not won the URC since the competition was rebranded and their last trophy came four years ago – a Pro14 final win over Munster, played behind closed doors at the RDS due to the pandemic. The opportunity to see this group of players lift silverware should be all the excitement needed, with the bonus of potentially watching them do that on home soil in Dublin an added incentive. Yet there is no escaping the feeling the URC is very much a secondary prize to the Champions Cup, a competition Leinster have become increasingly obsessed with capturing again since last doing so in 2018. Advertisement Less than 13,000 were in attendance for last week's quarter-final. Billy Stickland / INPHO Billy Stickland / INPHO / INPHO The province themselves have played a central part in this. Players have spoken about the Champions Cup being the competition they judge themselves off. It's also been illustrated in how Leinster have managed their seasons. Think back to the 2023 URC semi-final, where a Munster side desperate for a trophy capitalised as Leinster kept a host of frontliners on ice, given the game fell a week before their Champions Cup final date with La Rochelle. Even this season, where there has appeared to be a greater desire to get over the line in the URC, the big hitters have been largely held back for European Cup action. The real prize. Captain Caelan Doris featured in four URC games before injury ended his season last month. Before last weekend, Jamison Gibson-Park had started four URC games across the campaign, the most recent of which came back in October. Sam Prendergast started five of the 18 regular-season URC games. Andrew Porter had featured in eight, starting three. Hugo Keenan played in five (all starts), Josh van der Flier six (five starts). The list goes on. Leinster are right to be aiming high and being clear in their desire to win the Champions Cup, but perhaps a better balance could be struck. The timing of the two competitions' run-ins is also damaging, with the Champions Cup semi-final loss to Northampton Saints always going to take the enthusiasm out of the URC knock-outs. Leinster will have an improved crowd at the Aviva today, hoping to hit the 15,000 mark, but the upper tier will remain closed (as was always the plan). It should also be noted this is not too far off what Leinster typically attract for these games: 9,346 for a 2022 quarter-final v Glasgow at the RDS, 11,565 for the resulting semi-final v the Bulls, 14,642 for the May 2023 quarter against the Sharks at the Aviva, over 26,000 for the Aviva semi-final loss to Munster, and 18,000 for a June 2024 quarter-final against Ulster at the Aviva. Yet it all comes in the context of the massive crowds Leinster have been able to attract over recent seasons. The province have typically been excellent at generating interest in their big home games – selling out Croke Park twice over the last year, bringing 55,000 fans there for the Champions Cup clash with Harlequins and regularly drawing large crowds to the Aviva for European games. Tommy O'Brien returns to the Leinster team today. Laszlo Geczo / INPHO Laszlo Geczo / INPHO / INPHO The elongated rugby season doesn't help, but it will be interesting to see what type of numbers Leinster could attract should they reach the URC final, which would be held in Croke Park against South African opposition (either the Bulls or Sharks) this day next week. Not that their passage to that final is by any means a given. Leinster cannot expect to face the Glasgow team so comprehensively dismissed in their Champions Cup meeting earlier this year, nor the one that came up short at the Aviva just a few weeks ago. The defending URC champions will come to Dublin sensing opportunity and carrying the momentum of their impressive last-eight win against the Stormers. With only 34% of the territory, Glasgow hit for five tries and a total of 36 points, clocking up 17 clean breaks and 40 defenders beaten. They are punchy, incisive and inventive in attack. This is best epitomised in their brilliant centre Sione Tuipulotu, who shifts to the 13 jersey today, and is hitting form right in time for the Lions tour after an injury-disrupted season. And Leinster are clearly not firing on all cylinders. Their defence was sloppy against Scarlets and their attack struggled for cohesion, while still piecing together some wonderfully-worked tries. Garry Ringrose remains absent, Josh van der Flier misses out with injury while Hugo Keenan also drops out of the 23. The knock-on effect is three changes to the starting XV: Tommy O'Brien on the wing as Jimmy O'Brien moves to fullback, Dan Sheehan coming in at hooker following his game-changing impact off the bench, and Scott Penny replacing Van der Flier at openside. Throw in the absences of Caelan Doris, Tadhg Furlong and Robbie Henshaw, and there's a core of senior players watching this one from the sidelines. Leinster should still have enough to book their place in next week's final, but the margin for error has narrowed again. LEINSTER: Jimmy O'Brien; Tommy O'Brien, Jamie Osborne, Jordie Barrett, James Lowe; Sam Prendergast, Jamison Gibson-Park; Andrew Porter, Dan Sheehan, Thomas Clarkson; Joe McCarthy, James Ryan; Ryan Baird, Scott Penny, Jack Conan (capt). Replacements: Rónan Kelleher, Jack Boyle, Rabah Slimani, RG Snyman, Max Deegan, Luke McGrath, Ross Byrne, Ciarán Frawley. GLASGOW: Josh McKay; Kyle Steyn (capt), Sione Tuipulotu, Tom Jordan, Kyle Rowe, Adam Hastings, George Horne; Jamie Bhatti, Gregor Hiddleston, Fin Richardson; Alex Samuel, Scott Cummings; Euan Ferrie, Rory Darge, Henco Venter. Replacements: Johnny Matthews, Rory Sutherland, Sam Talakai, Max Williamson, Jack Mann, Macenzzie Duncan, Stafford McDowall, Jamie Dobie. Referee: Andrea Piardi [FIR]
