Most over-rated Edmonton Oilers still plugging along elsewhere in pro hockey
Article content
Who are they? Bottom-pairing d-men in Edmonton, players who as young pros ere held up by large and vocal factions of the Oilers fanbase as budding NHL stars, surefire Top 4 defencemen-to-be, with all the fancy statistics you'd ever want to back up the claim.
Article content
Article content
But one after another failed to in his Oilers audition, then have struggled as well in other NHL organizations.
Article content
Article content
This list has many similar players, mostly smaller d-men with NHL average-to-good puck-moving skills. None of them were high draft picks, but their lack of pedigree and inconsistent skill profile didn't stop many fans from adoring them, promoting them, and gnashing their teeth at the presumed incompetence of the Oilers organization when they crashed in Edmonton and eventually were traded away after a few seasons.
Article content
The fact that not one of them stuck as a Top 4 d-man in another NHL city suggests maybe the Oilers were right to move on, and that the faction that so believed in each player simply had it wrong. I had it wrong on a few of them, I admit.
Article content
Article content
It's a bold statement to say these are the most over-rated Oilers of all, especially given how so many fans have fallen for high pedigree offensive players like Rob Schremp, Nail Yakupov, Magnus Paajarvi and Jesse Puljujarvi.
Article content
But I'll suggest there's a special intensity to the hope invested in these bottom-end d-men, one similar to the optimism of the gold prospector scratching for decades for the one big find, the ego-driven aspect that rises high inthose who hope to have that rare ability to spot a diamond-in-the-rough.
Article content
These d-men tended to be most beloved by fans who put a lot of weight in modern era hockey analytics and fancy stats, the team-based on-ice numbers that attempt to rank individual players. The one exception to that is big Desharnais, who was adored by the old school, Rock 'Em, Sock 'Em faction of fans. They loved the size and aggression he brought to the team. But after two playoff seasons where Desharnais struggled to move the puck, it was time for him to go, at least when he was offered a major raise by Vancouver. But the Canucks quickly moved on from Desharnais as well.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Edmonton Journal
an hour ago
- Edmonton Journal
'Skill and talent': NHL stats analysts with high praise for Oilers defencemen
This in from TSN stats analyst and hockey writer Travis Yost, his ranking of NHL defences, where he places the Edmonton Oilers in the top tier. Article content Said Yost of the Oilers: 'The goaltending can terrify you on any given night but a key reason why the Oilers have emerged as perennial Stanley Cup contenders – OK, setting aside the two-headed monster of Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl – is a deepening of skill and talent on the blueline. You need puck movers capable of igniting an attack with this collection of forwards, and Edmonton has that in spades – now featuring one of the best trade deadline acquisitions of the 2024-25 season in Jake Walman.' Article content Article content Other teams in Yost's Top Tier include Colorado, Carolina, Dallas and Ottawa. Article content Article content Yost analysis follows the work of another strong stats analyst Dom Luszczyszyn of The Athletic, who recently did valuations of players on all 32 NHL teams (essentially translating each player's individual performance into a dollar amount) and found that the Oilers have the most high-performing and valuable d-man unit in the entire NHL. Article content Of the Top 60 highest performing d-men in the NHL, the Oilers had four, as per Luszczyszyn's model, with Evan Bouchard ranked seventh, Mattias Ekholm 16th, Jake Walman 29th and Darnell Nurse 52nd. Top ranked was Colorado's Cale Makar at $15.4 million. Article content Edmonton's Top 6 d-men were valued, on average at $7.2 million each, with the next most valuable d-men on Montreal, $6.7 million, Colorado, $6.5 million. (For the Habs, I had to estimate Lane Hutson's value, as Luszczyszyn does not rate Entry Level Contracts in this post on contract efficiency). Article content Article content Luszczyszyn values Bouchard at $12.8 million, Ekholm, $9.8 million, Walman, $7.9 million, Nurse, $6.5 million, Kulak, $3.9 million and Ty Emberson at $2.5 million. Article content My take Article content 1. For the many wretched years of the Decade of Darkness-plus, the Oilers defence was the blackest of holes, with iffy players like Mark Fayne, Corey Potter, Cam Barker, Theo Peckham, Martin Marincin, Kurtis Foster and Nikita Nikitin often thrust into Top 4 roles at even strength. Especially lacking during those darkest times were d-men who could move the puck. But now almost every Oilers d-man is above average-to-top tier when it comes to puck moving. Article content 2. The Oilers d-men still make a significant number of mistakes on defence, but their passing ability has shot up since the last rancid season of that horrible decade, 2017-18. Article content As recently as the 2021-22 season, the d-men averaged as a group 0.9 major contributions to Grade A shots per 15 minutes of play. This past season, 2024-25, that average was at 1.3 major contributions per 15.
CTV News
3 hours ago
- CTV News
Peguis First Nation celebrates draft pick Carter Bear
Winnipeg Watch Peguis First Nation honoured NHL First Round Draft Pick Carter Bear with a community celebration.
CTV News
11 hours ago
- CTV News
‘An immense amount of pride': Peguis First Nation celebrates Carter Bear's NHL achievement
Carter Bear signs Detroit Red Wings jerseys bearing his name during a community celebration in Peguis First Nation. Uploaded Aug. 10, 2025. (Peguis First Nation) An Interlake First Nation celebrated one of its own on Saturday. Peguis First Nation hosted a community event honouring Carter Bear, an 18-year-old winger with the Everett Silvertips of the Western Hockey League. Bear was selected 13th overall by the Detroit Red Wings in the first round of the 2025 NHL entry draft. He was born in Winnipeg, but his family is from the Peguis First Nation. 'Just an immense amount of pride. We haven't stopped telling people where he's from, and what our connections are to the community,' said Chief Stan Bird of Peguis First Nation. 'It's a real positive thing for our youth to see – to be part of history. '18-year-old Indigenous person being drafted by the Detroit Red Wings. That's history itself.' Chief Bird said he initially didn't expect Bear to have the time to sign individual autographs and take pictures, but Bear made it happen on Saturday. 'We're very pleased that he'll take a few hours of his time, just to drive to Peguis, to meet with the people of Peguis. 'There's a lot of pride here, and for him to come back and to interact with the people, I think it's a really positive, uplifting experience for all of us.' To mark Bear's selection by the Red Wings, organizers served free hot wings at the event.
