'Skill and talent': NHL stats analysts with high praise for Oilers defencemen
Article content
Said Yost of the Oilers: 'The goaltending can terrify you on any given night but a key reason why the Oilers have emerged as perennial Stanley Cup contenders – OK, setting aside the two-headed monster of Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl – is a deepening of skill and talent on the blueline. You need puck movers capable of igniting an attack with this collection of forwards, and Edmonton has that in spades – now featuring one of the best trade deadline acquisitions of the 2024-25 season in Jake Walman.'
Article content
Article content
Other teams in Yost's Top Tier include Colorado, Carolina, Dallas and Ottawa.
Article content
Article content
Yost analysis follows the work of another strong stats analyst Dom Luszczyszyn of The Athletic, who recently did valuations of players on all 32 NHL teams (essentially translating each player's individual performance into a dollar amount) and found that the Oilers have the most high-performing and valuable d-man unit in the entire NHL.
Article content
Of the Top 60 highest performing d-men in the NHL, the Oilers had four, as per Luszczyszyn's model, with Evan Bouchard ranked seventh, Mattias Ekholm 16th, Jake Walman 29th and Darnell Nurse 52nd. Top ranked was Colorado's Cale Makar at $15.4 million.
Article content
Edmonton's Top 6 d-men were valued, on average at $7.2 million each, with the next most valuable d-men on Montreal, $6.7 million, Colorado, $6.5 million. (For the Habs, I had to estimate Lane Hutson's value, as Luszczyszyn does not rate Entry Level Contracts in this post on contract efficiency).
Article content
Article content
Luszczyszyn values Bouchard at $12.8 million, Ekholm, $9.8 million, Walman, $7.9 million, Nurse, $6.5 million, Kulak, $3.9 million and Ty Emberson at $2.5 million.
Article content
My take
Article content
1. For the many wretched years of the Decade of Darkness-plus, the Oilers defence was the blackest of holes, with iffy players like Mark Fayne, Corey Potter, Cam Barker, Theo Peckham, Martin Marincin, Kurtis Foster and Nikita Nikitin often thrust into Top 4 roles at even strength. Especially lacking during those darkest times were d-men who could move the puck. But now almost every Oilers d-man is above average-to-top tier when it comes to puck moving.
Article content
2. The Oilers d-men still make a significant number of mistakes on defence, but their passing ability has shot up since the last rancid season of that horrible decade, 2017-18.
Article content
As recently as the 2021-22 season, the d-men averaged as a group 0.9 major contributions to Grade A shots per 15 minutes of play. This past season, 2024-25, that average was at 1.3 major contributions per 15.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Edmonton Journal
6 hours ago
- Edmonton Journal
This fresh face on the Edmonton Oilers' Top Prospects list will attempt to buck long NHL odds
We will kick off our 2025 Cult of Hockey Prospect Series where we typically do, which is…at the bottom. Article content Today, I will cover all the forwards ranked 34-21. Tomorrow, David Staples will do the Defencemen and Goaltenders in that same range. Then, we will go from #20 to #1 between now and training camp. Who will garner top spot? Article content This series of articles has always strived to be a number of things, long before I was a member of the CoH staff. That includes being comprehensive. We intentionally cast a wide net. Players only fall off the list once they: Article content Article content -Make the NHL -Get dealt to a different organization -Age out, or… -Drop off the map. Article content Article content By their very definition, these guys are distant bells. At best, one of more of them may become a useful NHL Bottom-six regular. But most will never play actual NHL games, let alone have a significant role with the big club. And to be frank, some of these guys are rated as high as they are because the organization is not flush with prospects to begin with. Article content And look: When your club hockey is knocking on the door for a Stanley Cup, and have been in the final two years running, part of the price of that success is the spending of draft picks. Article content (Voters: David Staples, Kurt Leavins, Jim Matheson, Ira Cooper. The average of our four votes determined each prospect's standing). Article content Park (Unranked in 2024). Selected in Round 7 of the 2025 draft, #223 overall. Made an initial splash by sticking around in his hoodie on draft day as he lived just around the corner and was rewarded with the spotlight. The 19-year-old enjoyed a breakout year with the Green Bay Gamblers of the USHL. The 6'1, 188 LB right-shot Center put up 33-33-66 in 55 GP. Added 49 PIM. Scouts describe him as a tenacious, two-way forward who plays quick and smart. Our Cult of Hockey Draft Day summary can be found here. At just 19, Park would seem to be the one guy out of this lot with an outside shot. So, keep an eye out for him. But there is a long road to go. The numbers say that guys from Round 7 only have a 10% chance of playing 100+ NHL games. And three out of four will never see the ice. Park's Uncle is retired NHL forward Richard Park. Article content Article content Grubbe (Ranked 10 in 2024). Grubbe has toiled in the depths of the Oilers organization for a couple years now. The 6'3, 200LB Calgary native was drafted by the Rangers in Round 3, #65 overall in 2021. Worked himself up to a point per game player for the Red Deer Rebels by the time he graduated the WHL. Since being acquired by the Oilers, Grubbe has had two muted offensive seasons in Bakersfield, of 67-8-6-14 in 2-23-24 and 62-2-12-14 in 2024-25. Good friend of the CoH Ira Cooper who watches Bakersfield a great deal described Grubbe last Summer as 'A player the coach will play in tough situations at the AHL level, but questions arise regarding enough skill to translate for the NHL'. Outside shot at a Bottom-six role down the road a ways. Article content Copponi (19). A long shot selection by the Oilers in 2023, #216 overall in Round 7. After graduating from Hockey East (Merrimack for three years, Boston for one), the right shot Center got a productive cup of coffee with the Condors last season (3-0-2-2). Somewhat undersized at 5'11 180 LB, he was generally at or below a point per game in college. Recently signed a two-year AHL deal. Scouts say he is 'a high-energy player who definitely shows some good skill'. Projects as a middle-six AHL man.
Winnipeg Free Press
a day ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Legends from 1976 Canada Cup team to reunite at Serge Savard invitational
TERREBONNE – The 1976 Canadian men's hockey team is reuniting almost 50 years after winning the inaugural Canada Cup. Bobby Orr, Darryl Sittler, Bobby Clarke and head coach Scotty Bowman are among the 16 team members expected to gather this morning at Le Mirage Golf Club for the Invitation Serge Savard. Sittler scored the overtime winner that sealed Canada's 5-4 victory over Czechoslovakia in the second game of the best-of-three final on Sept. 15, 1976, at the Montreal Forum. Orr was named the tournament's MVP after tallying two goals and seven assists in seven games. The legendary defenceman, and two-time Stanley Cup champion, later called the Canada Cup title the highlight of his career because it was the only time he wore the red and white Maple Leaf in an international tournament. The 1976 Canada Cup was the first of five such events, and a precursor for best-on-best play at the world championships and Olympics. The Soviet Union, Sweden, the United States and Finland also competed in the inaugural tournament, with games held in Montreal, Ottawa, Toronto, Winnipeg, Quebec City and Philadelphia. Thursdays Keep up to date on sports with Mike McIntyre's weekly newsletter. Several former members of the Montreal Canadiens will also take part in today's invitational, organized to raise funds for student-athletes at the University of Sherbrooke. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 12, 2025.
Edmonton Journal
a day ago
- Edmonton Journal
'Worst feeling in the world': Have Edmonton Oilers run out of key ingredient to chase Stanley Cup?
Do the Edmonton Oilers have the juice, the motivation, the burning desire to fight through and win the Stanley Cup in 2026? I wonder. Article content In a 32-team National Hockey League, it takes a lot going right for any one team to win the Stanley Cup, especially with a salary cap in place. For example, the Florida Panthers were given a huge boost when Matthew Tkachuk suffered a major injury in the Four Nations tournament one that sidelined him for the rest of the regular season and gave them the cap space to bring in Seth Jones and Brad Marchand. Without that injury, would Florida have had the juice for a second Cup run? I doubt it. Article content Article content The Edmonton Oilers have come close two years running, going to Game Seven against Florida two years ago and two Game Six this past June. It's been a monumental achievement for the Oilers, but to get back there a third time, and this time win against Florida and whichever other teams gets there seems like a brutal ask to make of the Edmonton squad. Article content Article content They almost came back in miraculous fashion in the 2024 playoffs, which evidently filled the Oilers with hope and fighting spirit for the 2025 playoff campaign, when the Oil looked like world-beaters in dispatching excellent Vegas and Dallas teams. But their Stanley Cup Final against Florida was a disaster. They lose their cool in the face of poor refereeing. They failed to impose their speed on Florida, who got stronger as the series whent along. The Oilers essentially caved in the final two games. It was a dispiriting, discouraging, embittering loss, and it has me and others wondering if the Oil have now run Cup in 2026. Article content Article content Los Angeles podcaster Dan Powers recently addressed this same issue on his Empty Netters, harkening back to the famous clip from the Oilers dressing room after the team lost in 2024 to Florida, and Zach Hyman promised the team they'd get back to the Final in 2025. Article content 'There's that clip,' Powers said. 'I don't know if you've seen it. They kept playing it this year of Hyman in the locker room after the last year where he's like, 'bBys, this is the worst feeling in the world. I'm telling you, we're going to be right back here.' And they did get back to the Cup and they lost in one less game.' Article content Powers where the Oilers would now find the motivation to fight their way back. 'It's like, 'Yeah, we were right back here. And you wonder if you're that team, how do you sit there right now and go, 'We're going to be right back here.'' Article content Former NHLer James Wisniewski agreed with Powers, noting the Oilers must be physically drained with so much hockey the past two ywears. 'We're talking about rest, too. Like, don't forget, like, these guys played the f*cking balls out until June something. And then (they're) not riding in the high. The Florida Panthers are (getting) $500,000 (bar) tabs picked up. These guys are like, 'Oh no. Lost again.''
