Cosatu critiques Finance Minister's Budget as insufficient for economic growth
Ashley Lechman | Published 7 hours ago
Trade union, The Congress of South African Trade Unions (Cosatu) said on Wednesday that it does not think Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana's third Budget attempt was enough to stimulate growth for the country's economy.
"We welcome government's decision to withdraw the proposed VAT hike as it would have been an unnecessary burden to workers struggling to cope with the rising costs of living. I t is a positive moment in our democratic evolution, when government led by the African National Congress, shows the political maturity and humility by responding positively to the concerns of Cosatu and society," Cosatu stated.
The union added that it cannot support tax hikes upon the working class and the poor who are already highly indebted.
"Whilst appreciating the scrapping of the VAT hike, we remain deeply distressed that for two years in a row, Personal Income Tax brackets have not been adjusted for inflation. This will see workers at the margins of the next tax bracket in danger of paying higher taxes when receiving their annual increases. This trend must be reversed. Whilst regretting the decision not to extend VAT exemptions for additional food items or provide further fuel price relief, we urge government to pursue additional measures to cushion indigent households from poverty, in particular expanding free electricity and water," Cosatu said.
"The Federation commends the R4 billion boost to the South African Revenue Service's tax and customs compliance efforts. SARS has shown that it has the capacity to deliver. The R7.5 billion allocated to it over the Medium-Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF) is an important step towards enabling it to ramp up collection of the R800 billion in owed taxes and improving tax compliance by at least R60 billion annually. It is critical that SARS be given every possible support to achieve these tax compliance targets. The tax regime must be reviewed to provide relief for low-income earners and ensure wealthy individuals and companies pay their fair share," Cosatu added.
Cosatu said that further discussions must take place on how the Reserve Bank's currency reserves can support the fiscus.
"We welcome government's acknowledgment that bleeding the public services working-class communities and businesses depend upon is reckless and harmful to the economy. The 5.4% increase in expenditure over the MTEF and allocations to frontline services, in particular including the rolling out of Early Childhood Education to 700 000 learners and tackling the school infrastructure backlog, refurbishing 660 health facilities, investing in Home Affairs' capacity, Defence and Correctional Services will be a step forward to repair damage inflicted by previous austerity budget cuts. However more must be done," Cosatu said.
The minister committed to hiring more teachers (1000 plus allocations to save 5500 existing posts), Home Affairs, police (4000), prosecutors (250) and border management officers, amongst other critical frontline personnel will boost public services.
"But we remain deeply dismayed by the reduced low allocations for doctors (800) and nurses. The implementation of the public service wage agreement will help public servants heal financial wounds. We are concerned about the impact the loss of valuable skills and experience by public servants who opt for early retirement, may have upon the state's ability to provide public services. Government must move with speed to identify any ghost posts in the state, as well as boost effort to tackle corruption and wasteful expenditure," Cosatu said.
The union said that it applauds the outstanding work done by Eskom and municipal workers to overcome load shedding.
"We are pleased that the debt relief package has provided Eskom breathing space to ramp up maintenance. It is critical that Eskom be given more support to tackle corruption, wasteful expenditure, cable theft and bring on board new generation capacity. The allocation of R219bn for energy infrastructure will be an invaluable boost as will the electrification of an additional 300 000 homes. These measures must translate into affordable electricity if the economy, in particular mining and industry are to survive and grow," Cosatu said in a statement.
"The turnaround of South African Airways is testimony that state-owned enterprises can be turned around to once again become enablers of economic growth. Whilst government is naturally reluctant to provide further debt relief to SOEs, Transnet should be assisted to settle its debt to free up capital for the modernisation of its port and railway network as these will unlock the mining, manufacturing and agricultural sectors, creating thousands of badly needed jobs and boosting state revenue. We are concerned by the reduction to R12.7 billion for Metro Rail's signal upgrades but hope its total R66 billion allocation will secure its efforts to return to full capacity, thus enabling 10 million workers and commuters travel quickly and save money on transport," the union added.
"Treasury needs to honour its court signed business rescue agreement to provide the Post Office with the long delayed R1.8 billion injection. This should not be delayed over the MTEF. We urge government to table the Road Accident Fund (RAF) and Benefits Scheme Bills at Parliament as part of a package of interventions to set the RAF on a sustainable path and ensure its funds are directed to the poor not the wealthy, let alone insatiable ambulance chasing lawyers," Cosatu added.
Cosatu said, "We welcome the various progressive provisions in the Budget, which Cosatu campaigned for, including allocating 61% for social wage expenditure. We are, however, disappointed by the failure to show any relief for the 8 million SRD Grants and government's continued shyness to drastically ramp up sufficient resources to support SMMEs, industrialisation and export sectors, as well as public employment programmes."
" The Budget does not foresee growth rising beyond 2% over the next decade whilst we desperately need at least 3% growth if we are to turn the corner on unemployment. We dare not normalise a 43.1% unemployment rate. This is a ticking time bomb that will one day explode and the price of picking up the pieces will be far greater than we can afford," Cosatu added.
The union said it is calling upon Parliament and Government in the run up to the MTBPS and the 2026 Budget, to initiate a national dialogue on what are our expenditure priorities and what we can live without, and what are the acceptable and unacceptable revenue streams to fund these.
"We cannot afford to continue to stumble along a meek path of business as usual and expect better results. A bold and decisive Marshall Plan is needed if we are to capacitate the state, stimulate growth and slash unemployment. We do not have endless time to make the bold changes our many socio-economic crises demand. COSATU will be seeking further engagements with government on these burning matters," the union further stated.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
14 hours ago
- The Citizen
This is where we would be if SA sustained an economic growth rate of 4.5%
It is enough to make you weep when you read how much better off South Africa could have been with economic growth of 4.5%. If South Africa had sustained an economic growth rate of 4.5% per year, in line with its emerging market peers, its GDP would have been just under R12 trillion in 2024 instead of the actual R7.5 trillion. Government revenue could also have been around R800 billion higher than it is. Investment strategist at Investec Wealth and Investment International, Osagyefo Mazwai, notes that although South Africa has grown over the last 15 years, averaging economic growth around 1% a year, the population has grown at a higher rate of around 1.3%. He points out that there has been a structural break in South Africa's economic performance compared to the rest of the world, with a stark dislocation in gross domestic product (GDP) per capita. 'In essence, people are worse off than they were in 2010, suggesting that economic policy has been ineffectual in addressing poverty, unemployment and inequality. 'On a per capita basis, the rest of the world is 50% richer than the average South African. Growth of 1% will not lead to the envisaged goals of lifting people out of poverty and meaningfully addressing the problems of unemployment and inequality.' This chart compares nominal GDP over the period with what it would have been if the South African economy grew at 4.5% a year to illustrate the point on the opportunity cost of foregone growth in policy formation and execution: ALSO READ: Experts say no way SA can achieve economic growth of 3% this year How does economic growth of R12 trillion sound? Mazwai says if the economy grew at 4.5%, South Africa's nominal GDP would have been just below R12 trillion in 2024, a significant number, especially considering the benefits that could have been derived from a vastly larger GDP. He points out that South Africa's economic growth rates similarly had an effect on government revenue. 'Government revenue in 2024 alone could have been around R800 billion higher, while just a few weeks ago, South Africa faced a budget impasse due to a shortfall in funding, needing to raise R75 billion in the medium term to cover the shortfall. 'That shortfall is insignificant considering how much more could have been raised had the economy grown more in line with emerging market peers. 'The cumulative figure of revenue foregone is scary, at around R5 trillion over the last 15 years. 'That is material, considering the fiscal constraints facing South Africa and demonstrates the need to ensure economic growth to boost the fiscal war chest and further enable the capacity of the state to deliver services.' ALSO READ: IMF's bad news about economic growth for SA, thanks to Trump tariffs What economic growth of 4.5% could have meant Mazwai says these statistics put this into perspective: The R5 trillion lost would be enough to clear almost 90% of South Africa's gross national debt and bring the debt-to-GDP ratio down to just below 10%, compared to the currently expected 77% ratio this year. Eskom needs R390 billion over the next decade for transmission lines, a fundamental pillar of creating greater capacity in the energy sector. Electricity is the backbone of any structural improvement, especially considering the government's goals to build domestic manufacturing capacity and create meaningful employment opportunities. The R390 billion would be a drop in the ocean had growth been 4.5% over the last 15 years. Transnet needs R160 billion to upgrade rail and port infrastructure. Our logistics networks are key in connecting the economy across its internal nodes, but also key in building additional capacity to meet the demands of external markets. Again, R160 billion would have been a drop in the ocean had growth been in line with our peers. Eskom has debt of R400 billion. With economic growth at 4.5%, the government could have bailed Eskom out 12 times. Transnet has a debt of R140 billion, and the government could have bailed out Transnet many times, too. Social grants will cost the fiscus around R266 billion this year. With economic growth of 4.5%, these would have been more than affordable and potentially materially higher than what marginalised citizens receive now, also considering that many more people would have been absorbed into the labour market. ALSO READ: Fourth quarter GDP improved but economists say its still not great – here's why With higher economic growth, South Africa would have functioned better Mazwai says these statistics are significant because they show how South Africa could have been in a better position to address the prevailing needs of the state. 'Granted, if the economy was growing at 4.5% the assumption is that Transnet and Eskom and some of the other structural enablers of the economy would have been functioning properly. 'The numbers indicate the potential for vastly greater capacity to invest in the productive elements of the South African economy, such as in infrastructure, education, healthcare and the salaries of teachers, nurses and doctors.' He also notes that business confidence has been unusually correlated with the performance of state-owned enterprises (SOEs) in the post-pandemic environment, and therefore, SOE reform momentum must be sustained or increased. 'Business confidence is the key leading indicator of economic growth and employment creation. The unemployment rate would be closer to around 20% compared to the current 32.9% had the economy been growing at 4.5%. 'In other words, a third of those presently unemployed, according to the narrow definition of unemployment, would have jobs.' ALSO READ: Absa foresees economic growth of 2.1%, but Trump and budget can disrupt it But there have been some victories so far for the economy However, Mazwai says none of this should detract from some of the victories seen of late, such as: The formation of the government of national unity (GNU) and subsequent political stability and increased policy certainty, although the recent budget impasse showed that these are nonetheless fragile. The increased momentum of Operation Vulindlela in addressing the various structural impediments in the economy. The next steps are critical for addressing water infrastructure and local government inefficiencies. Improvements in the electricity supply and logistics network. Mazwai says there has been some stagnation in the recovery of SOEs, which may be cause for concern, although the worst of SOE performance appears to be behind us. However, he says a reacceleration in trend improvement is important for business confidence to grow. ALSO READ: Economic activity still moving sideways but optimism increases Recovery in PMI could mean higher economic growth 'We recently saw a modest recovery in the S&P Global Purchasing Managers Index (PMI), to a neutral level of 50. There must be a trend improvement in PMIs, which are typically linked to economic outcomes. 'Should PMIs continue to improve, the economy should continue on its path of recovery. This will likely be driven by the continued success of Operation Vulindlela.' Looking at GDP projections, Mazwai says data released so far suggest that while growth was likely weak in the first quarter, a persistent upward trend in PMIs can result in a marked acceleration in growth outcomes. 'PMI improvement will largely be a function of continued improvement in SOE performance. At present, the economy, by our estimates, is tracking at 1.3% for the year, which is well above the 0.6% seen in 2024 and 0.8% in 2023. 'This can then lead to more meaningful employment creation and a trend reversal in GDP per capita from the pattern of decline since 2011.' ALSO READ: World Bank has simple answer to improve South Africa's economic growth What SA can do to keep momentum going to grow He suggests that South Africa follow these steps to keep the momentum going and put South Africa on a firmer growth trajectory:
The Citizen
17 hours ago
- The Citizen
The hidden costs of gambling
South Africans place over R1 trillion in bets annually, with R700 billion spent on sports betting alone. For many, particularly those with limited financial resources, the appeal of a big win can be incredibly tempting. However, the reality is often more complex. Instead of earning easy money, those who indulge in excessive gambling frequently face financial strain, says John Manyike, Head of Financial Education at Old Mutual. In March, an online betting platform shared a story of someone turning a R4 wager into an astounding R83,701.54. While stories like this grab attention, the rise in online sports betting also brings important considerations. According to the National Gambling Board's 2022/23 gambling statistics, sports betting in South Africa has expanded significantly over the past decade, growing from under 10% of the gambling sector in 2009/10 to over half in 2022/23. 'What stands out is that 36% of those who gamble do so to pay off debts or cover expenses,' explains Manyike, referring to the 2024 Old Mutual Savings and Investment Monitor. Among low-income earners (those earning between R8,000 and R15,000 per month), this figure rises to 41%, highlighting a concerning trend. Understanding the risks Despite rising costs of living and economic pressures, gambling has gained popularity, particularly due to the widespread use of mobile phones and internet access. This is especially evident among young African men. Advertising from betting companies further fuels this trend, increasing participation within this demographic. 'This can be risky, particularly for young people and low-income earners, who may see gambling as a way to improve their financial situation,' says Manyike. However, he notes that losses can add up quickly, sometimes leading to financial stress. 'In a country already facing high unemployment and economic challenges, it's important to be aware of the potential financial pitfalls of gambling.' A game of chance, not strategy Unlike investing, gambling is based purely on luck, yet many believe they can develop a winning approach. The truth is that the house edge ensures that bookmakers maintain a profit over time. For instance, when odds are at -110 on both sides of a bet, a bettor must risk R110 to win R100, meaning even skilled bettors face a statistical disadvantage in the long run. The belief that that the system can be beaten can lead to risky financial decisions. 'Beyond financial losses, gambling can also take a psychological toll,' says Manyike. 'It can lead to stress, anxiety, and even a cycle of chasing previous bets in the hope of recovering losses.' A 2016 study by the University of Cape Town's Department of Psychiatry and Mental Health noted a significant association between suicidality and pathological gambling. It found that pathological gamblers were five to ten times more likely to have a history of suicide attempts than non-gamblers. Furthermore, gambling doesn't just affect individuals—it can have ripple effects on families, sometimes resulting in financial strain for loved ones. 'While gambling is legal,' Manyike points out, 'many people don't fully understand the long-term risks involved due to a lack of financial education.' For those who feel their gambling habits might be affecting their financial well-being, Manyike advises seeking support. 'The South African Responsible Gambling Foundation offers free and confidential counselling services,' he says. Additionally, professional counsellors who specialise in gambling addiction can provide guidance. 'Gambling is not a reliable source of income, and without careful management, it can lead to serious financial setbacks,' concludes Manyike. 'By increasing financial awareness and promoting responsible gambling, we can help people make informed decisions and avoid unnecessary financial risks.' At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
IOL News
18 hours ago
- IOL News
Cabinet approves National Labour Migration Policy to regulate foreign employment
Cosatu has welcomed the Cabinet approving the National Labour Migration Policy (NLMP) White Paper 2025 for implementation. The paper will mark a significant step in regulating the movement and employment of foreign nationals in South Africa. Minister in the Presidency Khumbudzo Ntshavheni said that the policy seeks to provide a framework to enforce proper and orderly movement and employment of foreign nationals in the country. 'It aims to achieve a balance across several areas, including addressing South Africans' expectations for job prospects, in light of rising unemployment and the perception that foreign nationals restrict labour market access.' Cabinet said that the NLMP introduces quotas on the total number of documented foreign nationals with work visas that can be employed in major economic sectors such as agriculture, hospitality and tourism, as well as construction, among others. 'The policy complements other interventions such as enforcement of a list of sectors where foreign nationals cannot be allocated business visas and amendments to the National Small Enterprise Act, 1996 (Act 102 of 1996), as amended, to limit foreign nationals establishing small, medium and micro enterprises, and trading in some sectors of the economy.' Cabinet added that the NLMP is the first comprehensive National Labour Migration Policy aimed at managing labour migration both into and out of the country. 'The policy is designed to promote a 'brain gain' by attracting skilled workers to South Africa, while also addressing the 'brain drain' caused by the emigration of skilled professionals. The Employment Services Amendment Bill goes hand-in-hand with the NLMP and has been created to make it legal for the government to regulate the employment of immigrants in South African businesses.' One of the bill's more contentious features is the potential introduction of employment quotas, which would limit the number of immigrants that businesses can hire and require employers to prioritise the hiring of South African citizens, the Cabinet said. Matthew Parks, Parliamentary Coordinator for Cosatu, said that he welcomes Cabinet's approval of the National Labour Migration Policy and the Employment Services Amendment Bill. 'Cosatu extensively engaged on both the Policy and the Bill at Nedlac and looks forward to the Bill's processing and adoption by Parliament and their implementation. The Bill and the Policy provide a long overdue response to the flood of undocumented migrant labour into the economy over the past decade.' Parks said this will enable the Minister for Employment and Labour to set limits on the number of documented migrant workers that can be employed in a workplace and an economic sector. 'These limits are critical for an economy battling dangerously high and rising unemployment levels of 43.1% overall and 72% among youth. We have seen countless unscrupulous employers in certain sectors, in particular agriculture, petrol stations, restaurants, and construction, among others; preferring to employ undocumented migrant labour as their vulnerability opens them to wildly abusive exploitation." Parks said they hope that the Department of Employment and Labour's recruitment drive for an additional 20 000 labour inspectors will provide a decisive boost to efforts to crack down on such violations of workers' hard-won labour rights. It is crucial that the Critical Skills List be continuously assessed by government with business and labour at Nedlac to ensure that it is positioned to attract scarce skills to South Africa, to upskill local workers and to ensure unemployed South Africans with such needed skills are prioritised, he said. 'Whilst migration is ingrained with history and South Africa is no exception, the current levels into South Africa are unsustainable, more so given the high levels of unemployment. The Bill and Policy seek to find the correct balance and to ensure the state is better capacitated to set limits and protect the needs of workers. These are badly needed, and their implementation must be expedited,' Parks said. BUSINESS REPORT Visit:
