Vandals target the park at S.F.'s Upper Great Highway again. Here's the latest damage
An Outer Sunset resident who went to play the instrument, known colloquially as the 'wave piano' due to its proximity to the ocean, found that almost none of the keys worked early Saturday, said Lucas Lux, president of the volunteer nonprofit Friends of Sunset Dunes. Lux was also the campaign manager for Proposition K, the measure voters approved in November 2024 that closed the Upper Great Highway to cars and opened the park.
All the evidence points to someone 'very intentionally' damaging the piano, ripping off the felted hammers controlling all but 10 of its keys, political communications consultant Catie Stewart told the Chronicle. Piano maintenance experts have since confirmed the instrument is damaged beyond repair.
'It's such a thing that brought joy,' Stewart said. 'I don't know why anyone would ever do that.'
This is the latest in a series of acts of vandalism targeting Sunset Dunes since the 2-mile, 50-acre park opened in April, months after San Franciscans created it by voting to close a section of the Great Highway to cars. The measure has been highly controversial, and the supervisor who championed it, Joel Engardio, will face a recall election in September driven by groups opposed to the Upper Great Highway's closure.
The vandalism, Lux said, has largely occurred in two separate waves. The first occurred right after the Upper Great Highway closed on March 14, with murals and asphalt marred by graffiti, and the second began shortly after Engardio's recall qualified in late May.
On Thursday, just two days before the wave piano was found destroyed, park visitors discovered heavy damage to the nearby 'Ocean Calling' exhibit — a public art installation consisting of a phone booth that visitors can use to make symbolic phone calls to deceased loved ones. Someone had ripped the phone from its cord, tossed dirt and rocks into the booth and damaged its wooden frame, according to photos and videos taken shortly after the discovery.
While park rangers have not identified the perpetrators of the vandalism or definitively linked the acts, Lux and others suspect they are linked to the Upper Great Highway closure controversy. He said that while he understands that members of the community are split on their views about closure, they have plenty of ways to express that discontent without harming public artworks that bring joy and comfort to park-goers.
However, he added, 'most of the community regardless of their opinion treats the parks with respect.'
Phil Ginsburg, general manager of the San Francisco Recreation and Park Department, echoed Lux's sentiment.
'It's abhorrent that someone would try to destroy these sources of joy, connection, and healing," he said in a statement. 'But you can't break the spirit of a park, of public art, or of the people who cherish them.'
Soon after the piano was found destroyed, community members spent Saturday afternoon visiting and helping 'Ocean Calling' artists Jamae Tasker and Sarah McCarthy Grimm as they restored their installation. By Sunday morning, the piece had been fully repaired, Tasker posted on Instagram.
While the wave piano is irreparable, Lux said his group is looking for a new one to replace it. 'In the current world we live in, there are a lot of pianos that need homes. We'll have a wave piano back in place soon,' he said. Future pianos will have locks on their top guards to prevent similar acts of vandalism.
In the meantime, a second community piano at the park, this one intersecting with Judah Street, is still operable.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
a day ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
S.F. theater director resigns after anti-predator group posts alleged ‘catch' video
The executive director of Boxcar Theatre in San Francisco resigned Sunday, the organization said, after anonymous internet vigilantes accused him of attempting to meet up with someone who had posed online as a 14-year-old boy. The former executive director, Nick Olivero, did not immediately respond to the Chronicle's requests for comment on Monday. 'A private citizen's social media accounts personally accused Nick Olivero of sending inappropriate digital messages to someone who presented as a minor,' Boxcar Theatre said in a statement on its Facebook and Instagram accounts on Monday. 'We are shocked and appalled by these allegations and take them very seriously,' the statement said. 'Thankfully, we have expert leadership ready to assume executive duties and keep Boxcar Theatre's mission moving forward.' The social media account making the accusations, People v. Preds, had more than 67,000 followers on X and more than 24,000 on Facebook as of Monday. It referred to Olivero as 'Catch 540.' Around the country, a group of often unaffiliated groups has in recent years engaged in what is often called 'predator catching,' seeking to trick online targets into meeting with people pretending to be children and then filming the encounters. The phenomenon resembles the 20-year-old NBC show 'To Catch a Predator.' While these groups sometimes work with law enforcement and have prompted arrests, the methods are controversial, in part because the groups may be partially motivated by the prospect of making money or gaining online fame. Proving the cases in court can also be difficult. The Aug. 8 thread by People v. Preds contains a video showing a person strongly resembling Olivero walking out of a grocery store, into a parking garage and onto a street. The vigilante group said the store is in San Diego. A person holding a camera follows the man, saying, 'Yo, Nick, I have pictures of you, bro. I can turn it into the cops.' Then: 'You're here to meet a 14-year-old kid, dude,' and 'This ain't gonna look too good, dude.' Another video in the same thread shows what People v. Preds described as a text conversation with Olivero. One side identifies himself as Tim, who says he's 'bout to be 15' and that he 'can't put 14 on grindr :(.' David Oates, a spokesperson for Boxcar's board of directors, told the Chronicle that the board had planned to meet Monday to discuss Olivero's status with the company, but that Olivero resigned before they could do so. Managing Director Stefani Pelletier and Executive Producer Laura Drake Chambers will take over Olivero's duties. The conduct alleged in the vigilante group's posts appears to be unrelated to any activity by Boxcar Theatre. Boxcar Theatre was founded in 2005 and built a reputation for daring, gritty work. It had planned to mount the Halloween-themed show 'Nightmare: House on Franklin St.' at the Haas-Lilienthal House beginning in September, but that show has been canceled, Oates said. 'The company is working on a new haunted house production concept,' he said. The Chronicle last year investigated allegations of bullying, sexual harassment, racism, violence, wage theft, retaliation and more at the San Francisco theater company, which produced the long-running but troubled immersive, Prohibition-era show 'The Speakeasy.'
San Francisco Chronicle
a day ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Alameda County DA may seek to prosecute 16-year-old as adult in fatal shooting of Oakland teen
Alameda County District Attorney Ursula Jones Dickson will soon decide whether her office will attempt to prosecute a 16-year-old boy accused of fatally shooting another teenager during a botched robbery in Oakland as an adult. At the request of prosecutors Monday, Alameda County Superior Court Judge Scott Jackson, who presides over juvenile criminal cases, ordered the county probation department to file a report on the teen suspect's background by Oct. 7. The report is expected to inform Jones Dickson's decision on whether to push for the court to transfer the case to adult court. While prosecutors can request that teens be tried as adults, judges make the final decision. The victim, 15-year-old Derbing Alvarado Jr., was about to head to soccer practice when the assailant allegedly confronted him and tried to steal his pricey Sprayground backpack on 100th Avenue near International Boulevard the afternoon of March 17. Derbing placed his backpack on the ground, but when the assailant reached for it, Derbing tried to disarm him, police said in court records. As the pair struggled, the assailant shot Derbing. The teen suspect was arrested three days later and charged with murder and robbery in Juvenile Court. The Chronicle is not naming the teen because he is a minor. The case marked the first high-profile case for Jones Dickson, who was sworn in Feb. 18, and one of four murder cases filed in Juvenile Court since she took office, according to her office. Last month, Assistant District Attorney Sabrina Farrell told the Alameda County Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Commission, a state-mandated watchdog group, that under Jones Dickson, prosecutors automatically file transfer notices, which trigger steps that include probation reports for juvenile defendants, in murder cases. It's a practice that differs from the previous administration, Farrell said. The district attorney's office said prosecutors set the transfer process in motion in three of the four murder cases filed under Jones Dickson. In California, prosecutors can petition courts to prosecute teens ages 16 and 17 as adults for serious crimes like murder, although judges make the decision based in part on recommendations from probation departments and arguments from both prosecutors and defense attorneys. While some victims' families push for harsher punishment in adult court — Juvenile Court favors rehabilitation — advocates of rehabilitation point to research that shows human brains aren't fully developed until around mid-20s. The difference in punishment between adult court and juvenile court can be decades in prison versus a handful of years in a juvenile lockup. Former District Attorney Pamela Price filed murder charges against minors in six cases and triggered the transfer process to adult court in three cases, according to the office. Her second-in-command, Chief Assistant District Attorney Royl Roberts, who led the office for about two months after Price's recall, filed murder charges against minors in two cases and triggered the process in one case. The moves under the previous administrations came even after Price rolled out a policy aimed to keep children away from adult court. The policy generally prohibited prosecutors from initiating the transfer process unless supervisors gave them permission. The murder cases filed under the current and previous administrations remain pending in Juvenile Court, with no decisions made on whether to ask a judge to transfer the cases to adult court, according to Jones Dickson's office. During the brief hearing at the Juvenile Justice Center in San Leandro on Monday, the teen accused of killing Derbing sat at a table next to his attorney. His mother tuned in to the hearing via Zoom. Derbing's mother, who was seated in the gallery with other family members and friends, wept as soon as the hearing started, her arms wrapped around a framed photograph of her son. Before the hearing, Derbing's family and friends rallied outside, demanding that the teen suspect be tried as an adult. 'Adult crime, adult time,' read a sign in the crowd. Derbing's father said it was not fair to his family to keep the case in Juvenile Court. 'Our family fell apart,' Derbing Alvarado Sr. said in Spanish in an interview. 'There's no joy at all in our home. I tell my psychologist that I'm going crazy, because sometimes I think my son is on vacation and will return.' His family is afforded a small sense of comfort when his wife, 10-year-old daughter and him make their daily visit to the cemetery where Derbing was buried, Alvarado said.
San Francisco Chronicle
4 days ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
‘Danger to the public': Mission District residents say one man is causing chaos — exposing S.F. failures
It's a familiar story in San Francisco: A person living on the streets of a neighborhood spirals, bringing chaos while neighbors vent their frustration at how the city deals with those in crisis. In a small pocket of the Mission District, one unhoused man has been arrested at least four times over two months for allegedly assaulting people, damaging vehicles, vandalizing a bar and repeatedly violating restraining orders, according to jail and court records. In most of those instances, he spent a handful of days in jail before being released on the condition that he appear at a future court date. But he has remained in custody since his last arrest on Aug. 9. As a condition of his previous releases, he was enrolled in a program that required him to check in with staff from the San Francisco Pretrial Diversion Project several times a week and engage in some form of treatment. It's unclear whether he cooperated. Residents believe the 47-year-old man — whom the Chronicle is not naming under the newspaper's policies for crime coverage — set two recent fires in the neighborhood, though the causes remain under investigation by the police department, which says it is still working to identify potential suspects. The man is known to stay at an encampment on the sidewalk adjacent to Jose Coronado Playground, near the corner of 21st and Shotwell streets. A friend said he struggles with addiction and mental illness and deserves compassion. Residents say he is putting the community in danger and argue that the recent events were 'not only traumatic for our community but also preventable.' In a letter to Mayor Daniel Lurie, a group of about a half-dozen residents blames the city's 'permissive culture toward encampments' and an 'apparent breakdown in enforcement and accountability by city agencies.' Although a majority of San Franciscans approve of Lurie's performance thus far and are optimistic about the city's future, that sentiment is not shared evenly across the city. Many residents and merchants near the Mission's Jose Coronado Playground say serious problems continue to plague the neighborhood, including sex work, homelessness and public intoxication, and that the city needs to do more. Lurie's spokesperson Charles Lutvak said the mayor's office is working with city agencies to 'get dangerous people off the street' and to reduce homelessness. 'San Francisco does not tolerate violent behavior — if you put your neighbors at risk, you will be arrested,' Lutvak said in a statement. Evan Sernoffsky, a spokesperson for the San Francisco Police Department, said in a statement that officers are in constant communication with the community regarding the man. The department has distributed information packets to city supervisors and officers at Mission Station with a copy of the man's restraining orders and other documentation related to his cases, he said. 'This activity is unacceptable, and our officers will continue to make arrests and enforce the law in the Mission and every other neighborhood in the city,' Sernoffsky said. Supervisor Jackie Fielder's chief of staff, Sasha Gaona, said her office has elevated all of the constituent concerns it has received to the appropriate city agencies. It's unclear what kind of outreach or treatment city officials may have offered the man. Officials have a couple of newer avenues for pushing treatment on people experiencing mental illness or addiction, but they both have limitations and it's unclear the man would qualify. To take part in CARE Court, for instance, a person must be diagnosed with schizophrenia spectrum disorder or another psychotic disorder and voluntarily agree to participate. Officials could try to place the man in a court-ordered conservatorship, but they must prove he is unable to care for himself and find an appropriate placement amid a shortage of locked beds. At a hearing Tuesday, the man faced an allegation that he violated a restraining order preventing him from coming within 150 yards of where he allegedly committed assault and battery two months earlier. He was assisted by a Spanish interpreter and barely spoke. His attorney argued for his release from jail, contending that the man may not have known he was sitting in the prohibited area, but the judge ruled against him. 'He is thumbing his nose at the court,' Superior Court Judge Gail Dekreon said of the man's alleged breach of repeated court orders, 'and he is a danger to the public.' All of the incidents reported to police have occurred within a couple of square blocks of Jose Coronado Playground — between Folsom, Van Ness, 20th and 21st streets. A friend who identified himself as Pedro said the man was originally from Nicaragua and that he has been unhoused in San Francisco for several years. 'I think he was using too many different drugs,' Pedro said recently while hanging out near the park. 'Mental illness is a very, very difficult thing to deal with.' Residents said they had filed several 311 complaints in June regarding the man's sidewalk encampment, but saw little response. Then, on June 17, a small fire ignited outside a garage on the edge of the playground. The building owner, Ayman Farahat, said he saw the man and a second person leaving the area moments before smoke became visible. Three days later, police arrested the man in connection with incidents in the same area. Prosecutors charged him with assaulting two people with glass bottles and vandalizing two vehicles parked on the street, one of which belonged to longtime Mission resident Pablo Carbajol. Carbajol, 66, said the man broke the windshield of his 1982 Datsun pickup, stole the vehicle's battery and damaged the ignition switch, making the vehicle inoperable. Carbajol, who is disabled, does not have the $3,000 required to repair his truck and said he's worried his car will be impounded if he can't move it for upcoming street cleanings. As part of the legal proceedings in that case, a judge ordered the man to refrain from coming within 150 yards of where the alleged assault occurred adjacent to the playground. But neighbors said he quickly returned — and that police initially ignored their reports of his violations. In late July, another fire broke out in the neighborhood. Near the corner of 20th and Shotwell streets, a car erupted in flames in the middle of the night. It's unclear how the blaze started, but residents said a person matching the man's description was captured on surveillance footage nearby and shortly before the fire broke out. The next evening, the man entered Shotwell's Saloon on the same block. It was around closing time, and he began yelling at staff when they asked him to leave, said the bar's owner, David Hall. He shouted profanities and threatened to break a window, Hall said. The next morning, Hall said he woke up to a text from another merchant informing him that the man had thrown a rock through the bar's front door. 'It's just ridiculous,' Hall said. 'He's a threat to the community and yet he was still walking around.' Later that morning, officers apprehended the man, who was charged with felony vandalism. A judge issued another restraining order to prevent him from coming within 150 yards of the bar. Since then, officers have arrested the man twice for allegedly violating his restraining orders, which prevent him from returning to the encampment he frequented. The man is expected to remain in custody until his next court hearing, scheduled for Sept. 4. Farahat, one of the residents voicing concerns about the situation, said the possibility of the man getting released from custody again next month makes the community 'very uncomfortable.' 'All of us want to be safe,' he said, 'and he's demonstrated what he can do on multiple occasions.'
