Miracles Are Beyond Causality And Human Knowledge
Miracle, also known as 'chamatkar', is a complex phenomenon beyond human understanding in relation to causality and
human knowledge
. In philosophy and theology, it is often debated and generally understood as an event that defies natural laws or exceeds known powers of nature.
The survival of lone passenger,
Vishwash Kumar Ramesh
, in the recent
Air India plane tragedy
that took 241 lives, is a miracle. The survivor revealed, "I opened my eyes, unfastened seat belt, escaped through a small space on my left and walked up to an ambulance...don't know how I survived?"
A 10-minute delay due to a traffic jam made Bhoomi Chauhan miss the flight from Ahmedabad to London. She believed that the delay and missed flight were due to
divine intervention
and considers her survival a miracle.
Such tales defy or interrupt the standard chain of cause and effect that one typically expects in such a catastrophic event. It is a moment when the ordinary flow of events diverges and cannot be explained by physical factors or statistical probability. The incident compels one to ask a much deeper question: Is a miracle something entirely unknown and beyond the perception of the human mind?
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Giao dịch CFD với công nghệ và tốc độ tốt hơn
IC Markets
Đăng ký
Undo
The human mind, conditioned by habit, empirical observation, and specific situations, typically interprets events within a framework of cause and effect. However, the causal framework does not account for such an anomaly in catastrophic events where a lone survivor has emerged unscathed against all odds. Lone survivors: Juliane Koepcke (Dec 24, 1971), Vesna Vulovic (Jan 26, 1972), Cecelia Cichan (Aug 16, 1987), Bahia Bakari (June 30, 2009), Ruben Van Assouw (May 12, 2010), and now Vishwash Kumar Ramesh (June 12, 2025), underline limits of human knowledge and understanding pointing towards a hidden depth of reality yet to be fully comprehended by humans.
Philosophers have different perspectives. For example, Spinoza insists that nature operates according to eternal universal laws, a deterministic system. To him, 'miracle' would violate these natural laws, which is impossible because God and nature are the same - Deus sive Natura. David Hume is sceptical and views '
miracles
' as improbable, irrational or unknowable. However, Thomas Aquinas and Leibniz have different perspectives and view 'miracle' as a purposeful intervention by a higher principle, a manifestation of God's will.
This point is in accordance with traditional Hinduism, which views the universe not as a closed, mechanical system but as an expression of Brahmn, the ultimate reality. Naturally, the will of this Supreme principle can interrupt ordinary causality to produce what we call a chamatkar - an improbable event. Therefore, surviving a serious accident is a blessing in the ordinary sense.
Such phenomena consider the possibility of hidden causal orders, subtler than physical laws, which govern extraordinary events. The survival of the lone individual against all odds may be a manifestation of these hidden dimensions.This resonates that the ordinary world we experience is only a surface phenomenon, a visible ripple, while the true depth of reality lies in a more unified whole. Miracles, therefore, are not violations of nature but revelations of their greater potential than the physical, measurable world. Here, the Supreme principle can interrupt ordinary causality to produce a wonder beyond human knowledge and causal explanations.
Authored by: Vijay Hashia
Why Arjun Was Chosen: The Untold Secret of Bhagavad Gita Chapter 4, Verse 3
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
10 minutes ago
- India Today
I wasn't on Air India Flight 171, but I haven't stopped reliving the horror
Based on true eventsIt was 12 am when I got a call from my father, a very unlikely time for someone who is usually in bed by 11 pm.'Hello, your mother and sister's phones are still switched off. Have they landed?' a restless voice asked from the other end. 'It's raining in Mumbai, probably that's the reason for the delay,' I tried to pacify him, though I was equally worried about their well-being. 'Don't worry, they'll probably land any moment.'advertisementI was just about to check the flight status when my sister messaged: 'LANDED.'I let out a sigh of relief, called dad, told him they had landed, and went to incident I'm talking about is from June 16, just four days after Air India Flight 171 crashed in the Meghaninagar neighbourhood of Ahmedabad, killing 241 out of 242 passengers on hasn't been the sameIt's been just about six months, but the year has brought more bad news than feels like we've been moving from one bad dream to another, without even getting time to recoup from the trauma each incident leaves behind — be it the terrorist attack on unarmed tourists in Baisaran Valley, Kashmir, that killed 26 civilians, or the Air India crash that sent shivers down our weren't there when these incidents happened, and I'm sure many of us thanked our stars for that, but we've relived every moment of those horrific events, every single day, through social media and news coverage. And it's far from a good Air India crash has reignited my lingering fears as a flier.I know a neighbour who changed her Air India tickets to Dubai and made sure she booked a different airline. If that meant no refund, so be it.I've always been an anxious flier (the anxiety comes from the fear of a crash itself), and this felt like my worst nightmare come true. Once you're onboard, your life depends entirely on the pilot, and of course, on the aircraft, which we mostly assume is in perfect all, who would allow a faulty aircraft to fly, right? It's human life we're talking the allegations seem to suggest haunting storiesI wasn't on that fateful flight, but every story I read about the passengers onboard makes me feel closer to their will happen now that they're gone? For some, it was a journey that promised the joy of a new beginning; for others, just a reunion with loved ones. All of it, silenced in one even worse is thinking about their last must have happened? How did they react? Was it painful?These questions may sound insensitive, but they come from one quiet, persistent fear: if I were ever in that situation, what exactly would happen?After all, these were just regular passengers, just like you and me, who boarded a flight one fine afternoon, only to see everything come to an end in a few media makes it worseSocial media hasn't been helpful either. While several influencers are busy suggesting which flights to avoid (Airbus or Boeing), conspiracy theorists are sharing their own dissected versions of the there are astrologers, warning people not to fly on certain dates because of Mercury Retrograde. I don't usually believe in astrology, but this time, I gave in. And right now, I'm genuinely rethinking whether I should travel at all this the crash, there's been a steady stream of updates about flights being diverted, sometimes due to technical snags, sometimes bomb threats, and somehow, Air India seems to be at the centre of every bad news.A fear shared by manyadvertisementJust when I thought I was alone in feeling this way, the persistent dread, the intrusive what-ifs, I realised this isn't just a personal battle with fear. I'm not the only one avoiding booking tickets or googling 'safest airlines 2025' at 2 out, and you'll see it's not just a few nervous fliers grappling with post-crash jitters. The collective mental health toll of such tragedies runs deeper and wider than we like to admit.'When a crash of this scale happens, something so unprecedented in recent aviation history, it jolts people's sense of safety,' explains Dr Vishnu Gade, Consultant Psychiatrist at Arete Hospital. 'Even if you're not directly involved, the mind doesn't always make that distinction. You're still processing trauma, just second-hand (vicarious trauma).'According to Dr Gade, this isn't just a vague unease. What many of us are feeling can show up as a very real phobia, fear of flying (aviophobia), heightened anxiety, even panic attacks, especially when these events are followed obsessively through the news or social remedy, Dr Gade stresses, is the importance of support systems - family, friends, and yes, therapy if needed - especially if the anxiety lingers beyond a few weeks, starts affecting sleep, or disrupts daily something else that he said seemed true yet heartbreaking:'In another month, people will move on. That's the world we live in. But for some, especially those who were affected, even indirectly, the fear doesn't leave. It lingers quietly, in our choices, our habits, our hesitation to book that next ticket.'(Views expressed in this piece are those of the author)Tune InMust Watch
Time of India
13 minutes ago
- Time of India
'U.S.' Bunker Buster Bombs...': Israeli Journalist Reveals IDF's Big Plan; Khamenei's Nuclear Game
New Videos Show Students Jumping Off Hostel Balcony As Air India Plane Crashes Into Building A new video has surfaced showing students leaping from a building at a medical college in Ahmedabad, Gujarat, where an Air India plane crashed on June 12. In the latest video, students are seen climbing over balcony railings and attempting to descend as flames engulf the lower floors of the BJ Medical College hostel, believed to have been caused by the impact of the crashing aircraft. The Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner, carrying 242 people, crashed into the BJ Medical College complex shortly after taking off from Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport at 1:39pm. Of the 242 people on board the London-bound flight, 241 lost their lives. Miraculously, one passenger survived. The crash also claimed the lives of 29 people on the ground, including five MBBS students.#ahmedabadplanecrash #airindiacrash #bjmedicalcollege #studentvideo #buildingfire #hostelfire #boeing787 #svpi #fatalcrash #planesurvivor #groundfatalities #mbbsstudents #planeimpact #flames #balconyjump #desperateescape #aviationtragedy #airindia171 #june12crash #ahmedabad #medicalcollege #toi #toibharat 10.4K views | 1 hour ago
Time of India
26 minutes ago
- Time of India
The other side of fatherhood: waiting, hoping, becoming
As Father's Day just went by, our timelines were filled with smiling dads and their little ones, photos full of laughter, gratitude, and love. Every year, this day becomes a beautiful reminder of what it means to be a father. But there's another kind of dad out there. One who doesn't have a handmade card waiting on the breakfast table. One who quietly walks through baby aisles, heart tugging at the thought of 'someday.' One who's still trying, still waiting, still hoping. To that man, this day belongs to you, too. The father no one talks about You might not be the one unwrapping a tie or receiving hand-drawn cards. Your moments are different. They happen in waiting rooms, in long conversations with doctors, in silent car rides home, in unspoken prayers that are sometimes too tender to say out loud. You are a man who wants to be a father. And that, in itself, is something powerful. But the world doesn't always see that side. Because your story doesn't come with a due date. There are no balloons, no baby showers. Just the quiet courage of showing up. Again and again. In reality, the journey to fatherhood isn't always about cribs and lullabies; it often starts much earlier. In the heart. In the intention. In the commitment to becoming someone's safe place, even if that 'someone' hasn't arrived yet. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Trading CFD dengan Teknologi dan Kecepatan Lebih Baik IC Markets Mendaftar Undo The weight of silence There's an unspoken rule that men are expected to carry their struggles in silence, especially those that touch their sense of identity. Fertility is one of those tender topics. While science tells us that nearly 4 out of 10 infertility cases are due to male factors, conversations around male fertility still carry a certain stigma. And for many men, facing fertility challenges can quietly unravel their sense of self-worth. But here's what needs to be said louder: Struggling with fertility does not make you any less of a man. Your ability to nurture, love, and protect isn't measured by a lab report. Manhood is not proven by perfection; it's shaped by presence, by love, and by willingness to grow. It takes tremendous emotional strength to admit when something's wrong. To ask questions. To sit in vulnerability. To keep showing up for yourself and your partner, even when the road is uncertain. That's not a weakness. That's grace. Because taking action matters Some say parenthood begins at the birth of your little one. But for many, it begins much earlier… It's in the quiet decision to seek answers. In the willingness to understand your body, not as a source of shame, but as a source of possibility. In booking that first consultation, even if your heart is full of questions. In walking into a clinic, not because you've failed, but because you still believe. Today, fertility care has changed. It's not cold or clinical. It's human. It's grounded in science, yes - but also in compassion, confidentiality, and understanding. A simple test, sometimes as straightforward as a semen analysis , can uncover information you didn't know you were missing. And with that knowledge comes power: to explore treatments tailored for you, to make informed choices, to take a step forward. This journey isn't just about biology. It's about emotional resilience. And that's why more men today are choosing to take charge of their reproductive health, not just for themselves, but for their partners, for their future families, and for the dream they still hold close. You're not walking this path alone. There are experts who see you, not just your numbers, but your doubts, your fears, your questions. There's no shame in asking or taking a second opinion. No weakness in checking. No 'too late' in trying. It's time to expand the circle While the world raises a toast to dads who are already in their role, let's also make room at the table for you. The ones who are still in the process. Still on the path. Still holding a father's heart patiently, lovingly, while life catches up. You may not have the traditional milestones to show just yet. But your emotional journey, your effort, and your heart make you every bit a father in spirit. There's no timeline on love. There's no expiration date on dreams. And there's certainly no one way to become a dad. Dear future fathers, take a moment to honour yourself. For the ways you've shown up. For the dreams you're still holding onto. For the family you're building in your heart. From the Doctor's Desk If you are still waiting to be called 'dad,' know this: you are not alone, and there are answers. Male infertility is a real problem, but today, we have advanced diagnostics and treatments that can offer effective solutions. From semen analysis to tailored treatment plans, there are ways forward. Reaching out is not a weakness. It's the first step toward possibility. We are here to guide you with All Heart. All Science. Dr Prachi Benara, Birla Fertility & IVF, Gurgaon The above is non-editorial content and TIL does not guarantee, vouch or endorse any of it. Please take all steps necessary to ascertain that any information and content provided is correct, updated, and verified.
