Mathematicians Thought This Algebra Problem Was Impossible. Two Geniuses May Have Found a Solution.
In this paper, however, the authors posit that they can use a metric from geometry called a Catalan number, or Catalan series, to find exact solutions to higher degree polynomials.
The Catalan numbers are a natural observed consequence of a bunch of different mathematical scenarios, and can be found by engaging in such efforts as distilling Pascal's triangle of polynomial coefficients. They help graph theorists and computer scientists to plan data structures called trees by showing how many different tree arrangements can be made within certain parameters. In this case, they also quantify how many ways you can divide a polygon of any size into a particular number of triangles.
The leading mind behind this work, mathematician Norman 'N.J.' Wildberger, is an honorary professor at the University of New South Wales in Australia—a term likely reflecting the fact that he retired in 2021 after teaching at the university since 1990. Wildberger also self identifies as a 'heretic' of certain mathematical foundations, exemplified in part by his longtime belief that we should stop using infinity or infinite concepts in some parts of math.
That opposition to infinite or irrational numbers is key to this research. For many, many years now, people studying algebra have known that we simply 'can't' solve certain polynomials. They can't be taken apart into a mathematical term that fits under a square root (a.k.a. radical) sign at all. But, in Wildberger's view, focusing on this divide and dwelling inside the radical is a hindrance. We should 'sidestep' it altogether.
To make this argument, Wildberger teamed up with Dean Rubine, a computer scientist who has worked for Bell Labs and Carnegie Mellon University. However, for decades now, Rubine has helped to lead the number-crunching at a secretive hedge fund that focuses on algorithms (more later on his role in this publication).
The paper has a teacherly quality, reading somewhat like a chapter from a good textbook. The authors lay out and define their terms, then build their arguments one by one into a complete picture. What results is the 'hyper-Catalan' array, which contains the classic Catalan numbers as well as an extension that includes other numbers that satisfy the conditions to solve polynomials. (Remember, the hyper-Catalan number series doesn't need to line up with all the other uses of the Catalan numbers—rather, the Catalans are a basis from which to begin building a unique set that solves the polynomial problem.) This all wrapped up in an array called the Geode, which encompasses the entirety of the hyper-Catalan number series.
After stepping through the work leading up to and including the Geode array, Wildberger gets in one last jab:
[F]ormal power series give algebraic and combinatorially explicit alternatives to functions which cannot actually be concretely evaluated (such as nth root functions). Hence they ought to assume a more central position. This is a solid, logical way of removing many of the infinities which currently abound in our mathematical landscape.
Having been authored by an aging iconoclast and a longtime quantitative executive, this work may have more of an uphill climb to be broadly recognized. It's also published in the peer reviewed American Mathematical Monthly—a broad interest journal associated with the Mathematical Association of America. The journal accepts advertisers, offers paid editing services, and offers an option where authors can pay to make their articles open access—often a few thousand dollars or more. (The latter is, unfortunately, the normalized model and cost of open access publishing.) In this case, this less-orthodox approach could be a result of the subject matter simply not being on most people's radar anymore. But it also fits right into Wildberger's lifelong quest to trim the mathematical fat and present clear, simple ideas for as many people as possible.
On the tech forum Hacker News (from startup incubator Y Combinator), Rubine explained in a post that he'd closely followed Wildberger's work on this problem since 2021, when Wildberger declared he was going to solve this problem on his YouTube channel.
'[H]e was doing a series where he'd teach amateurs how to do math research,' Rubine said. 'For the first problem, he said he'd solve the general polynomial. I thought it was a joke, because everybody 'knows' that we can't go beyond degree four. But no, 41 videos later, he had done it. Two years after that he still hadn't written it up, so I wrote a draft and sent it to him, which evolved into this paper.'
With that kind of determination, Wildberger may, after all, be an apt opponent for infinity itself. His democratic, open-door approach to mathematical thinking is really admirable. And in the paper, he and Rubine point out a number of questions that this theory opens up. We'll see if others in the mathematics community pick up some of these questions. I, for one, hope so, because 41 more videos is a long time to wait for the next breakthrough.
You Might Also Like
The Do's and Don'ts of Using Painter's Tape
The Best Portable BBQ Grills for Cooking Anywhere
Can a Smart Watch Prolong Your Life?
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
06-08-2025
- Yahoo
Study Reveals How Many IVF Babies Have Been Born Worldwide
More than 13 million people worldwide owe their lives to in vitro fertilization (IVF), according to the first estimates of their kind. Since the original 'test tube' baby was born in 1978, the number of children brought into the world by IVF technologies – collectively known as assisted reproductive technology (ART) – has exploded into the millions. Today, an ART-conceived baby is born every 35 seconds, and IVF, where an egg is fertilized by sperm in a test tube, is the most commonly used method. To figure out how many ART babies have been born since the technology's infancy, an international team of researchers compiled health data from 101 different nations. Related: As of 2018, the team estimates between 10 and 13 million babies have been born via ART, while preliminary data from 2018 to 2023 adds another 3 to 4 million children. "Every year we estimate how many babies were born in the previous 12 months – but we've never actually gone back and used a consistent methodology and extrapolation for missing data to estimate the total number of babies born in the world," says lead author Georgina Chambers, an epidemiologist from the University of New South Wales. The estimates are not perfect, but Chambers and her colleagues argue they are "a reasonable and sound approximation" based on the "most robust data available in the literature." The information comes from the International Committee Monitoring Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ICMART), of which Chambers is the data custodian. Back in the early 1980s, Australia became the first country in the world to establish an IVF registry. While many high-income nations have since followed suit, some countries, like Singapore,either lack formal registries that report to ICMART or the registries have been delayed for many years, as in China. Even when formal lists are kept, some regional clinics do not report to ICMART, as in the United States, India, and some African countries. To make up for these gaps in knowledge, researchers tallied the number of clinics within a nation, using that coverage rate to predict ART rates. They also accounted for miscarriage rates where only ART pregnancies were reported. Their findings reveal that in the 40 years since the dawn of ART, between 9.4 million and 12.4 million infants from 101 countries were born using reproductive technology, with an exponential increase starting around the turn of the century. Europe tops the charts with 3.6 to 4.5 million infants born via IVF, followed by Asia with 3 to 4 million IVF infants, and North America with 1.4 to 1.6 million IVF infants. In the last two decades, IVF technology has come a long way, providing cheaper, safer, and more successful routes to parenthood. The chances of IVF succeeding are far from guaranteed, but health data from the UK show that the average IVF pregnancy rate using frozen embryos has gone from 7 percent in the 1990s to 36 percent in 2021. No longer is it necessary to transfer several fertilized eggs to increase the odds of pregnancy. As a result, the number of IVF twins and triplets being born is on a steep downward trend. "Today, more than 93 percent of IVF cycles involve a single embryo transfer, resulting in a multiple birth rate of below 3 percent," says Chambers. "Most IVF babies in Australia now come from frozen embryos." "As more babies are born through IVF," Chambers adds, "we hope access to safe, high quality care will become more equitable – and based on human rights – across the world." The study was published in Fertility and Sterility. Related News Image on The Shroud of Turin May Not Belong to a Real Human Venting Doesn't Reduce Anger, But Something Else Does, Says Study Playing Video Games Has an Unexpected Effect on Kids' IQ, Study Discovers Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
01-08-2025
- Yahoo
The Bright Side: Leopard seal love songs structured like nursery rhymes, study finds
Male leopard seals compose and sing their own songs to woo potential mating partners, scientists in Australia have found. The songs are structured much like nursery rhymes, making them easy to remember. "It kind of sounds like sound effects from an '80s sci-fi" movie, the lead author of the study said. When male leopard seals dive down into icy Antarctic waters, they sing songs structured like nursery rhymes in performances that can last up to 13 hours, scientists said Thursday. The Australian-led team of researchers compared the complexity of the songs composed by the big blubbery mammals to those of other animals -- as well as human musicians like the Beatles and Mozart. Lucinda Chambers, a bioacoustics PhD student at Australia's University of New South Wales, told AFP that people are often surprised when they hear the "otherworldly" hoots and trills sung by leopard seals. "It kind of sounds like sound effects from an '80s sci-fi" movie, said the lead author of a new study in the journal Scientific Reports. During the spring breeding season, male leopard seals dive underwater and perform their songs for two minutes before returning to the surface for air. They then repeat this performance for up to 13 hours a day, according to the study. The researchers determined that all leopard seals share the same set of five "notes" which are impossible to distinguish between individuals. However each seal arranges these notes in a unique way to compose their own personal song. "We theorise that they're using that structure as a way to broadcast their individual identity, kind of like shouting their name out into the void," Chambers said. The researchers believe the males use these songs to woo potential female mates -- and ward off rivals. 'Songbirds of the ocean' The team studied recordings of 26 seals captured by study co-author Tracey Rogers off the coast of Eastern Antarctica throughout the 1990s. "They're like the songbirds of the Southern Ocean," Rogers, who is also from the University of New South Wales, said in a statement. "During the breeding season, if you drop a hydrophone into the water anywhere in the region, you'll hear them singing." The team analysed how random the seals' sequences of notes were, finding that their songs were less predictable than the calls of humpback whales or the whistles of dolphins. But they were still more predictable than the more complex music of the Beatles or Mozart. "They fall into the ballpark of human nursery rhymes," Chambers said. This made sense, because the songs need to be simple enough so that each seal can remember their composition to perform it every day, she explained. She compared it to how "nursery rhymes have to be predictable enough that a child can memorise them". But each seal song also needs to be unpredictable enough to stand out from those of the other males. Leopard seals, which are the apex predator in Antarctic waters, swim alone and cover vast distances. They likely evolved their particular kind of song so that their message travels long distances, the researchers theorised. Varying pitch or frequency might not travel as far in their environment, Chambers said. Female seals also sing sometimes, though the scientists do not know why. Chambers suggested it could be to teach their pups how to sing -- exactly how this talent is passed down is also a mystery. But she added that this behaviour has never been observed in the wild. The females could also just be communicating with each other, she said. (FRANCE 24 with AFP)
Yahoo
01-08-2025
- Yahoo
Seals sing 'otherworldly' songs structured like nursery rhymes
When male leopard seals dive down into icy Antarctic waters, they sing songs structured like nursery rhymes in performances that can last up to 13 hours, scientists said Thursday. The Australian-led team of researchers compared the complexity of the songs composed by the big blubbery mammals to those of other animals -- as well as human musicians like the Beatles and Mozart. Lucinda Chambers, a bioacoustics PhD student at Australia's University of New South Wales, told AFP that people are often surprised when they hear the "otherworldly" hoots and trills sung by leopard seals. "It kind of sounds like sound effects from an '80s sci-fi" movie, said the lead author of a new study in the journal Scientific Reports. During the spring breeding season, male leopard seals dive underwater and perform their songs for two minutes before returning to the surface for air. They then repeat this performance for up to 13 hours a day, according to the study. The researchers determined that all leopard seals share the same set of five "notes" which are impossible to distinguish between individuals. However each seal arranges these notes in a unique way to compose their own personal song. "We theorise that they're using that structure as a way to broadcast their individual identity, kind of like shouting their name out into the void," Chambers said. The researchers believe the males use these songs to woo potential female mates -- and ward off rivals. - 'Songbirds of the ocean' - The team studied recordings of 26 seals captured by study co-author Tracey Rogers off the coast of Eastern Antarctica throughout the 1990s. "They're like the songbirds of the Southern Ocean," Rogers, who is also from the University of New South Wales, said in a statement. "During the breeding season, if you drop a hydrophone into the water anywhere in the region, you'll hear them singing." The team analysed how random the seals' sequences of notes were, finding that their songs were less predictable than the calls of humpback whales or the whistles of dolphins. But they were still more predictable than the more complex music of the Beatles or Mozart. "They fall into the ballpark of human nursery rhymes," Chambers said. This made sense, because the songs need to be simple enough so that each seal can remember their composition to perform it every day, she explained. She compared it to how "nursery rhymes have to be predictable enough that a child can memorise them". But each seal song also needs to be unpredictable enough to stand out from those of the other males. Leopard seals, which are the apex predator in Antarctic waters, swim alone and cover vast distances. They likely evolved their particular kind of song so that their message travels long distances, the researchers theorised. Varying pitch or frequency might not travel as far in their environment, Chambers said. Female seals also sing sometimes, though the scientists do not know why. Chambers suggested it could be to teach their pups how to sing -- exactly how this talent is passed down is also a mystery. But she added that this behaviour has never been observed in the wild. The females could also just be communicating with each other, she said. dl/ach
